Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Appaswamy Real Estates Limited v. Puducherry Environment Protection Association

Madras High Court
Mar 14, 2018
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Puducherry Environment Protection Association (referred to as ‘PIL petitioner’) filed a Public Interest Litigation (W.P. No. 11189 of 2017) challenging a notification dated 14.03.2017 issued by the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MOEF). The PIL petitioner alleged that the impugned notification was arbitrary, illegal, and violated Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India as well as the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986. The main writ petition was fully heard and disposed of by judgment dated 13.10.2017. Subsequently, three miscellaneous petitions (W.M.P. Nos. 3361, 3362, and 3721 of 2018) were filed by Appaswamy Real Estates Limited (AREL), Ambattur Reality Private Limited (ARPL), and MOEF respectively. AREL and ARPL sought clarification of the court’s earlier order regarding the applicability of public hearing requirements under the impugned notification. MOEF sought an extension of time for submission of proposals under the impugned notification. The court consolidated and addressed these petitions by a common order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the public hearing requirement contained in sub-paragraph 5 of paragraph 13 of the impugned notification applies only to those project categories for which ‘public consultation’ was mandated under the parent notification dated 14.09.2006 (S.O. No. 1533).
  2. Whether projects exempted from ‘public consultation’ under the parent notification remain exempt under the impugned notification and the court’s earlier order.
  3. Whether an extension of time should be granted to project proponents for submission of proposals under the impugned notification.
  4. The scope and effect of the court’s earlier order dated 13.10.2017 on the applicability of public hearing requirements to various categories of projects.

Arguments of the Parties

Appaswamy Real Estates Limited (AREL) and Ambattur Reality Private Limited (ARPL)

  • They fall under the category of building/construction projects exempted from public consultation under the parent notification (specifically item 8(a) for projects between 20,000 and 1,50,000 sq.m built-up area).
  • They sought clarification that the public hearing requirement in the impugned notification and the court’s order applies only to categories where public consultation was necessary under the parent notification.
  • They argued that the letter dated 28.02.2018 from MOEF imposing a public hearing condition (Terms of Reference) on their project was a new condition introduced solely due to the court’s order, which they contested.
  • They emphasized the adverse impact of further delay on the viability of their residential apartment projects and the interests of purchasers.

Puducherry Environment Protection Association (PIL Petitioner)

  • Opposed the plea that AREL and ARPL’s projects are exempt from public consultation under the impugned notification.
  • Submitted that AREL and ARPL represent entities violating the parent notification by commencing projects without prior environment clearance.
  • Argued that violators of the parent notification cannot claim exemption from public consultation requirements under the impugned notification, which provides a reprieve only to violators but requires adherence to the impugned notification as a whole.

Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MOEF)

  • Clarified that the Terms of Reference letter dated 28.02.2018 was issued as a matter of abundant caution to avoid breach of the court’s order.
  • Requested an extension of time for submission of proposals under the impugned notification.
  • Agreed to upload Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) and Environment Management Plan (EMP) reports on the official website within three working days of clearance or related orders for projects under the relevant category.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the scope of the public hearing requirement in sub-paragraph 5 of paragraph 13 of the impugned notification in light of the parent notification dated 14.09.2006. It recognized that the parent notification mandated public consultation, including public hearing, only for certain categories of projects, explicitly exempting some categories such as building/construction projects under item 8(a) of the Schedule. AREL and ARPL’s projects fall within this exempted category.

The court clarified that the public consultation clause of the parent notification applies only to those categories specified therein, and projects falling under the exempted category (item 8(a)) shall continue to be governed by that exemption despite the impugned notification and the court’s earlier order. The court further noted the consensus among the parties that EIA/EMP documents and clearances for such projects should be uploaded on the MOEF website within three working days of clearance.

Regarding the extension of time requested by MOEF for submission of proposals, the court found merit in granting a limited extension of thirty days from the date of the order to serve the ends of justice. The court also appreciated MOEF’s caution in issuing Terms of Reference that included public hearing as per the court’s order to avoid non-compliance.

Holding and Implications

The court clarified that the public consultation requirements under the parent notification apply only to the specified categories of projects and that projects exempted under the parent notification (such as building/construction projects under item 8(a)) are not subject to public consultation or public hearing requirements imposed by the impugned notification or the court’s earlier order.

The court granted an extension of thirty days for submission of proposals under the impugned notification.

The court directed that EIA/EMP reports and related clearances for the exempted category of projects be uploaded on the MOEF website within three working days of clearance. This decision directly affects the parties by clarifying the scope of public consultation requirements and providing procedural timelines but does not establish new legal precedent beyond the interpretation of the notifications and the court’s earlier order.

Show all summary ...

M. Sundar, J.:— We propose to dispose of the aforesaid three miscellaneous petitions, i.e., W.M.P. Nos. 3361 of 2018, 3362 of 2018 and 3721 of 2018 by this common order.

2. One Puducherry Environment Protection Association had filed a Public Interest Litigation which is the main writ petition, i.e., W.P. No. 11189 of 2017. In this common order, Puducherry Environment Protection Association is referred to as ‘PIL petitioner’ for the sake of brevity, clarity and convenience. In the main suit, Union of India, represented by Secretary to Government, Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change was arrayed as lone respondent. For the sake of convenience and clarity, lone respondent in the main writ petition is hereinafter referred to as ‘MOEF’.

3. Of the three miscellaneous petitions here, W.M.P. Nos. 3361 and 3362 of 2018 have been taken out by one public limited and one private limited companies, which go by name ‘Appaswamy Real Estates Limited’ and ‘Ambattur Reality Private Limited’, which are hereinafter referred to as ‘AREL’ and ‘ARPL’ respectively also for the sake of brevity, clarity and convenience.

4. PIL petitioner filed the main writ petition assailing a notification dated 14.03.2017 bearing No.S.O.804(E) issued by MOEF. This notification is hereinafter referred to as ‘impugned notification’ for the sake of brevity. The prayer of PIL petitioner was for a declaration that the impugned notification is arbitrary, illegal and violative of Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India as also the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986.

5. The main writ petition was heard out fully and was disposed of by us by a judgment dated 13.10.2017. As paragraph 5 of the said judgment captioned ‘Conclusion’ (authored by M. Sundar, J.) is pivotal for disposal of the present petitions, it is deemed necessary to extract the same which reads as follows:

“5. We record the submissions of the learned Additional Solicitor General that (a) public hearing can be read into paragraph 5 of the impugned notification and (b) this shall certainly and clearly be a one time measure.”

6. Before proceeding further, it is necessary to note that in the conclusion paragraph of our judgment, which has been extracted supra, paragraph 5 of the impugned notification should be read as sub-paragraph 5 of paragraph 13 of the impugned notification. There is no dispute or disagreement between parties before us on this aspect of the matter.

7. Though the prayers in the petitions filed by AREL and ARPL seek leave to permit AREL and ARPL to file petitions for clarification in the aforesaid 13.10.2017 order of this court, we deem it appropriate to hear out the clarification sought and dispose of the petitions.

8. To understand what is the clarification that has been sought by AREL and ARPL, it may be necessary to go back to the factual matrix of the main writ petition very briefly.

9. On factual matrix of the main writ petition, it has to be noticed that originally, an EIA notification dated 14.09.2006 bearing S.O. No. 1533 was issued by MOEF. For the sake of convenience and clarity, this 14.09.2006 notification of MOEF bearing S.O. No. 1533 is referred to as ‘parent notification’.

10. Many project proponents had commenced work without obtaining prior environment clearance as required under the parent notification. Therefore, a question arose as to whether they can be given ex post facto clearance. It is in this regard that the impugned notification came to be issued. There are several other facts and events between the parent notification and the impugned notification. Considering the limited scope of these miscellaneous petitions and the very short and narrow compass on which this order turns, we refrain from elaboration on those aspects of the matter. Suffice to record that there have been several proceedings, notifications and events between the parent notification and impugned notification.

11. In the parent notification, ‘public hearing’ has been referred to as ‘public consultation’. ‘Public consultation’ is contained in ‘III. Stage (3)’ which is part of paragraph 7(i) of parent notification. We deem it appropriate to extract ‘public consultation’ as contained in the parent notification. The same reads as follows:

““III. Stage (3)- Public Consultation:

(i) “Public Consultation” refers to the process by which the concerns of local affected persons and others who have plausible stake in the environmental impacts of the project or activity are ascertained with a view to taking into account all the material concerns in the project or activity design as appropriate. All Category ‘A’ and Category B1 projects or activities shall undertake Public Consultation, except the following:—

(a) Modernization of irrigation projects (item 1(c)(ii) of the Schedule).

(b) All projects or activities located within industrial estates or parks (item 7(c) of the Schedule) approved by the concerned authorities, and which are not disallowed in such approvals.

(c) Expansion of Roads and Highways (item 7 (f) of the Schedule) which do not involve any further acquisition of land.

(d) All Building/Construction projects/Area Development projects and Townships (item 8).

(e) All Category ‘B2’ projects and activities.

(f) All projects or activities concerning national defence and security or involving other strategic considerations as determined by the Central Government.

(ii) The Public Consultation shall ordinarily have two components comprising of:—

(a) A public hearing at the site or in its close proximity-district wise, to be carried out in the manner prescribed in Appendix IV, for ascertaining concerns of local affected persons;

(b) Obtain responses in writing from other concerned persons having a plausible stake in the environmental aspects of the project or activity.

(iii) the public hearing at, or in close proximity to, the site(s) in all cases shall be conducted by the State Pollution Control Board (SPCB) or the Union territory Pollution Control Committee (UTPCC) concerned in the specified manner and forward the proceedings to the regulatory authority concerned within 45 (forty five) of a request to the effect from the applicant.

(iv) in case the State Pollution Control Board or the Union territory Pollution Control Committee concerned does not undertake and complete the public hearing within the specified period, and/or does not convey the proceedings of the public hearing within the prescribed period directly to the regulatory authority concerned as above, the regulatory authority shall engage another public agency or authority which is not subordinate to the regulatory authority, to complete the process within a further period of forty five days.

(v) If the public agency or authority nominated under the sub paragraph (iii) above reports to the regulatory authority concerned that owing to the local situation, it is not possible to conduct the public hearing in a manner which will enable the views of the concerned local persons to be freely expressed, it shall report the facts in detail to the concerned regulatory authority, which may, after due consideration of the report and other reliable information that it may have, decide that the public consultation in the case need not include the public hearing.

(vi) For obtaining responses in writing from other concerned persons having a plausible stake in the environmental aspects of the project or activity, the concerned regulatory authority and the State Pollution Control Board (SPCB) or the Union territory Pollution Control Committee (UTPCC) shall invite responses from such concerned persons by placing on their website the Summary EIA report prepared in the format given in Appendix IIIA by the applicant along with a copy of the application in the prescribed form, within seven days of the receipt of a written request for arranging the public hearing. Confidential information including non-disclosable or legally privileged information involving Intellectual Property Right, source specified in the application shall not be placed on the web site. The regulatory authority concerned may also use other appropriate media for ensuring wide publicity about the project or activity. The regulatory authority shall, however, make available on a written request from any concerned person the Draft EIA report for inspection at a notified place during normal office hours till the date of the public hearing. All the responses received as part of this public consultation process shall be forwarded to the applicant through the quickest available means.

(vii) After completion of the public consultation, the applicant shall address all the material environmental concerns expressed during this process, and make appropriate changes in the draft EIA and EMP. The final EIA report, so prepared, shall be submitted by the applicant to the concerned regulatory authority for appraisal. The applicant may alternatively submit a supplementary report to draft EIA and EMP addressing all the concerns expressed during the public consultation.”

12. The case of AREL and ARPL is that they fall under clause (d) supra, i.e., ‘all building/construction projects/Area development projects and townships (item 8) [item 8(a) to be precise]. Item No. 8(a) is contained in the schedule to the parent notification and we deem it appropriate to extract item No. 8(a) of the Schedule, which is as follows:

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) 8 Building/Construction projects/Area Development projects and Townships 8(a) Building and Construction projects >20000 sq.mtrs and < 1,50,000 sq.mtrs. of built-up area# #(built up area for covered construction; in the case of facilities open to the sky, it will be the activity area)

13. On the above basis, AREL and ARPL have sought a clarification of our order in the main writ petition dated 13.10.2017 saying that public hearing contained in sub paragraph 5 of paragraph 13 of the impugned notification will apply only to categories for which ‘public consultation’ was necessary under the parent notification. In other words, it is the specific case of AREL and ARPL that six categories of projects have been exempt from ‘pubic consultation’ in the parent notification and they need not now be subjected to ‘public consultation’ because of our order.

14. To be noted, when the clarification petition was filed and first heard on 26.2.2018, it was in the nature of a mere apprehension. However, when it was next listed (a day later) on 01.03.2018, AREL and ARPL produced a letter dated 28.02.2018 from MOEF, which according to them is terms of reference (TOR).

15. Paragraph 6 of TOR is relevant and we deem it appropriate to extract the same, which reads as follows :

“6. Based on recommendations of the EAC, the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change, in pursuance of the provisions of its Notification dated 14 March, 2017, hereby accords approval to the Terms of Reference for Residential building ‘Greensville’ at Sholinganallur village, Sholinganallur Taluk, Kanchipuram District (Tamil Nadu) by M/s. Appaswamy Real Estates for undertaking Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) and preparation of Environment Management Plan (EMP) as enumerated in Annexure, along with public hearing (As per the Order dated 13.10.2017) by the Hon'ble High Court of Judicature at Madras in W.P. No. 11189 of 2017) for consideration of the proposal of Environmental Clearance to the project.”

16. It is the specific case of Mr. P.S. Raman, learned senior counsel appearing for counsel on record for AREL and ARPL that the aforesaid paragraph 6 is a new condition that has been introduced by virtue of/owing to our order in the main writ petition. Mr. Yogeswaran, learned counsel on record for PIL petitioner vehemently opposed this plea and submitted that this argument is untenable. It was submitted by learned counsel for PIL petitioner that AREL and ARPL represent several entities which are violators of parent notification. It was his specific submission that only those who have violated the parent notification will come under the impugned notification and it was vehemently submitted that violators who had not adhered to the parent notification cannot now take umbrage under the parent notification with regard to public consultation alone. In other words, it is his specific submission that one should adhere to the notification in its entirety. The moment somebody has violated the notification, when a reprieve is given by way of the impugned notification, they have to go only by the impugned notification. The reprieve itself is given because of violation of the parent notification.

17. We heard learned Additional Solicitor General Mr. G. Rajagopalan on this.

18. Learned Additional Solicitor General's simple submission is that MOEF had issued the aforementioned TOR dated 28.02.2018 as a matter of abundant caution as they do not want to be seen in breach of orders of this court. In short, his submission was that MOEF preferred to err on the right side.

19. We place on record our appreciation of this fair and forthright submission made by learned Additional Solicitor General. Learned Additional Solicitor General also impressed upon us the need to extend the time for submission of proposals as sought for in W.M.P. No. 3721 of 2018 which has been taken out by MOEF.

20. In response to the request of extension of time for submission of proposals under the impugned notification, Mr. Yogeswaran, learned counsel submitted that MOEF has been receiving and processing applications even when this court was in seizin of the matter. Learned Additional Solicitor General pointed out that there are many who may not have applied because of this court was in seizin of the matter and because of the interim order which was operating.

21. To this, Mr. Yogeswaran, learned counsel also fairly submitted that extension of time if any may not be for 129 days as sought for and a lesser time frame at the discretion of the court may be granted. In view of this consensual approach on this aspect of the matter, we are of the view that elaboration on how 129 days was computed is unnecessary.

22. In the light of aforesaid submissions and backdrop, we examine both prayers.

23. With regard to the first prayer made by AREL and ARPL, it was highlighted by Mr. P.S. Raman, learned senior counsel that constructions made by AREL and ARPL are residential apartments and middle income group of citizens have put their hard earned money. It is his specific plea that further delay will make the entire exercise not viable not only for the project proponents, but also for purchasers.

24. In this view of the matter, considering that sub-clause (i)(d) of Stage III of paragraph 7(i) of parent notification as contained in item No. 8(a) of the Schedule being housing projects, we deem it necessary to clarify that projects and project proponents falling under this category alone shall be governed by the ‘public consultation’ clause in the parent notification.

25. With regard to the prayer of MOEF for extension of time for submission of proposals by project proponents, we are of the view that it will serve the ends of justice if time is extended by 30 (thirty) days from the date of delivery of this order in open court.

26. There is one other aspect of the matter on which there was unanimity and consensus amongst all three counsel before us. With regard to projects falling under sub clause (i)(d) of Stage III of paragraph 7(i) of parent notification alone we have given this clarification qua public consultation. The same is contained in item No. 8(a) of the Schedule to parent notification which has already been extracted supra. This is hereinafter referred to as ‘said category’ for the sake of convenience and clarity. We are informed that projects falling under the said category are those in which EIA/Environment Management Plan (‘EMP’ for brevity) will be done by accredited consultants. The clearance which is based on EIA/EMP is granted by MOEF. The consensus amongst three counsel was that EIA/EMP of project proponents and clearance based on EIA/EMP should be uploaded in the official website of MOEF. It was also agreed that EIA/EMA will be uploaded within three days from the date of clearance or any other order based on EIA/EMP by the MOEF. MOEF agreed that such uploading will be done within three working days from the date of such clearance or order.

27. With this, we dispose of these miscellaneous petitions by this common order on the above terms. No costs.