- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Lalta Prasad v. U.P. State Public Service Tribunal Lucknow And Others
1. Heard Sri. Saurabh Lavania, learned counsel for petitioner, learned State counsel and perused the record.
2. By means of the present writ petition, the petitioner has challenged the impugned order dated 18.09.2002 passed by State Public Service Tribunal in Claim Petition No. 154 of 1997 (Lalta Prasad v. State of U.P.).
3. Facts in brief of the present case as submitted by learned counsel for petitioner are that initially petitioner by an order dated 24.06.1987 (Annexure No. 2) passed by respondent No. 5/Superintendent of Police, Rajya Police Motor Vahan Adhikari, Sitapur has been appointed on the post of Constable Technical Electrician on temporary basis. Thereafter, by order dated 17.06.1988, his services had been terminated by invoking the provisions as provided under U.P. Temporary Government Servants (Termination of Services) Rules, 1975 (hereinafter referred to as the Rules, 1975).
4. Aggrieved by the order dated 17.06.1988, petitioner filed an appeal before the appellate authority which was dismissed by an order dated 23.08.1997. Thereafter petitioner for redressal of his grievances, filed a Claim Petition No. 154 of 1997 (Lalta Prasad v. State of U.P.) before U.P. Public Service Tribunal, Lucknow/respondent No. 1. After exchange of the pleadings, the same was dismissed by an order dated 18.09.2002.
5. In view of the abovesaid factual background, present writ petition has been filed by the petitioner thereby challenging the order dated 18.09.2002 passed by U.P. Public Service Tribunal, Lucknow/respondent No. 1, order dated 23.08.1997 by which the appeal of the petitioner has been dismissed as well as order dated 17.06.1988 passed by respondent No. 5 by which the petitioner has been terminated from services.
6. Learned counsel for petitioner while challenging the impugned orders submits that even if the petitioner has entered into the services by furnishing forged document in respect to the age, reasonable opportunity of hearing before passing of the termination order should be given to him. As the same has not been done, so the impugned order of termination is contrary to the law as laid down by Hon'ble the Apex Court in the case of Avtar Singh v. Union of India, (2016) 8 SCC 471.
7. Second limb of argument of learned counsel for petitioner is to the effect that the action on the part of respondents thereby terminating the services of the petitioner by invoking the provisions as provided under Rules, 1975 is wholly incorrect as the very basis of passing of the order of termination of the services is to the effect that he has submitted forged document while entering into the services, that is to say, it is a foundation of passing of the impugned order, so in view of the abovesaid facts, before passing of the same, opportunity should be given to the petitioner, in support of the his argument he has placed reliance on the judgment given by Hon'ble the Apex Court in the case of State Bank of India v. Palak Modi, (2013) 3 SCC 607 and the said plea has been categorically brought before the appellate authority as well as U.P. Public Service Tribunal, Lucknow/respondent No. 1, however, ignoring the said plea, the impugned orders have been passed, so the same are liable to be set aside and the writ petition be allowed.
8. Learned State counsel while opposing the prayer as made by learned counsel for petitioner submits that in the present case, from the material on record, it is clearly evident that the petitioner has entered into the services by furnishing forged document in respect to the age, so keeping in view the said facts, no opportunity of hearing is necessary in the matter in question and the petitioner's services were rightly terminated by invoking the provisions of Rule, 1975, hence, there is no illegality or infirmity in the impugned, writ petition is liable to be dismissed.
9. We have heard learned counsel for parties and gone through the record.
10. As per admitted facts of the case, by means of order dated 24.06.1987, petitioner was selected and appointed on the post of Constable Technical Electrician on temporary post, thereafter it was found that while entering into the services, he has submitted a certificate in respect to the age which is a forged one, so his services has been terminated by order dated 17.06.1988 passed by respondent No. 5/Superintendent of Police, Rajya Police Motor Vahan Adhikari, Sitapur, against which the petitioner filed an appeal, dismissed by appellate authority/respondent No. 4 by order dated 23.08.1997, thereafter the claim petition filed by the petitioner was also dismissed by order dated 18.09.2002 passed U.P. Public Service Tribunal, Lucknow/respondent No. 1.
11. After hearing learned counsel for parties and going through the record, the first and foremost question which is to be considered in the present case is to the effect that if a person enters into the services by producing a forged document then in that circumstances, whether it is incumbent upon the appointing authority to give a reasonable opportunity to the petitioner to defend his case and satisfy the appointing authority that the document which was given by him is not forged one. Answer to the said question find place in the judgment given by Hon'ble the Apex Court in the case of Avtar Singh v. Union of India, (2016) 8 SCC 471, relevant paragraph quoted as under:—
“. This Court while referring the matter had expressed the opinion that in case an appointment order has been secured fraudulently, the appointment is voidable at the option of the employer and the employee cannot get any equity in his favour and no estoppel is created against the employer only by the fact that the employee has continued in service for a number of years. It has been further observed that if appointment is secured on forged documents, it would amount to misrepresentation and fraud. The employer has a right to terminate the services on suppression of important information or giving false information, having regard to nature of employment. Verification of character and antecedents is important if the employer has found an incumbent to be undesirable for appointment to a disciplined force. It cannot be said to be unwarranted. The Court thus further opined that suppression of material information necessary for verification of character/antecedents will have a clear bearing on character and antecedents of a candidate in relation to his continuity in service and such a person cannot claim a right for appointment or continuity in service. The Bench was of the view that in uniformed service, suppression or false information can be viewed seriously as it requires higher level of integrity and the employer is supposed to find out before an appointment is made that criminal case has come to an end and pendency of a case would serve as a bar for appointment and in such cases of suppression whether different yardsticks can be applied as noted in the various decisions of this Court. The question which has been referred to arises frequently and there are catena of decisions taking one view or the other on the facts of the case. It would be appropriate to refer to the various decisions rendered by this Court; some of them have been referred to in the impugned order.”
12. And Hon'ble the Apex Court in the case of Vikram Singh v. Commissioner Of Police . of Police, (2018) 1 SCC 308 and after placing reliance on the said judgment held as under:—
“4. Though the learned counsel appearing for the appellant made strenuous submissions to contend for the position that the lapses, if any, are only to be condoned since everything occurred prior to the filing of the application and the appellant had already been acquitted also even before filing of the application. As rightly pointed by Ms. Kiran Suri, learned senior counsel, appearing for the respondent, if at all anything is to be done it can only be on consideration by the respondent of all the relevant aspects, in the light of the judgment referred to above.
5. Accordingly, this appeal is disposed of as follows:—
The appellant is permitted to file a detailed representation before the respondent, within a period of one month from today. In the event of filing of such a representation, the respondent will consider the same in the light of the judgment referred to above and pass a reasoned order after affording an opportunity of hearing to the appellant, within a period of four months thereafter.
We make it clear that the judgment of the High Court shall not stand in the way of the respondent/Commissioner of Police passing orders, as above.
6. Pending applications, if any, shall stand disposed of.
7. There shall be no orders as to costs.” (See also. Avtar Singh v. Union of India, (2018) 1 SCC 268).
13. Further, in the present case, the very basis of terminating the services of the petitioner by an order dated 17.06.1988 passed by respondent No. 5 is that he has submitted a forged document in respect to the age while enering into services, so the said action on the part of respondent No. 5 comes within the ambit of foundation for passing of the termination order, it is also incumbent upon the said authority to give an opportunity to the petitioner to defence his case as per the law laid down by Hon'ble the Apex court in the case of State Bank of India v. Palak Modi, (2013) 3 SCC 607 while terminating the services of the petitioner invoking the provisions of Rule, 1975.
14. For the foregoing reasons, the impugned order of termination dated dated 17.06.1988 passed by respondent No. 5/Superintendent of Police, Rajya Police Motor Vahan Adhikari, Sitapur, order dated 23.08.1997 passed by appellate authority/respondent No. 4 in appeal filed by the petitioner as well as order dated 18.09.2002 passed by State Public Service Tribunal in Claim Petition No. 154 of 1997 (Lalta Prasad v. State of U.P.) are set aside.
15. Further, respondent No. 5 is directed to issue a show cause notice to the petitioner keeping in view the law as laid down by Hon'ble the Apex Court in the case of Avatar Singh (Supra) within a period of four weeks from the date of receiving certified copy of this order, thereafter the petitioner shall submit his defence within a further period of four weeks and after taking into consideration the defence of the petitioner and affording opportunity of hearing to him pass a reasonable order within a further period of four weeks thereafter.
16. So far as the service benefits which are amenable to the petitioner for the intervening period after termination of his served by order dated 17.06.1988 passed by respondent No. 5 is concerned, the same shall be subject to outcome of the decision taken by respondent No. 5.
17. With the above observations, writ petition is allowed.
Alert