- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Moti Lal v. U.P. State Road Transport Corporation Thru M.D. And Others .
Attau Rahman Masoodi, J.:— The benefit of appointment on the post of Mechanic is claimed in the backdrop of facts stated in paragraph-14 of the rejoinder affidavit, that too when the certificate as mentioned in paragraph-8 of the writ petition filed by the petitioner was disputed by the respondents alleging the same to have been obtained without permission.
2. To substantiate the plea in reply to the stand adopted in the counter affidavit, the petitioner has taken a stand as under:—
“That in reply to the contents of Para-16 of the counter affidavit it is stated that it is absolutely wrong to say that the deponent got the ITI Training in Motor Mechanic in the year 1989 without prior permission from the competent authority and after Training also he did not give information of the said training. In this connection it is stated that the deponent with prior permission from the competent authority completed his ITI Training in the year 1989 and his leave of the said examination period were also granted and the salary etc. Of the said period has also been paid to the deponent. It is further submitted that the opposite parties raised this pleas first time in this petition and the said pleas had not been raised before the learned Labour Court nor in the previous writ petitions filed by the deponent before this Hon'ble Court.”
3. It is clear from the averments made in the paragraph extracted above that the petitioner has stated about grant of prior permission and it is also averred that he was sanctioned leave for the said examination, however, the plea raised is not supported by any documentary proof. The court would have declined to grant any permission for filing additional document at this stage but looking to the interest of justice last opportunity is granted to the petitioner for placing on record the permission granted to him for being sent for training as well as the leave sanctioned for the period of training, if any.
4. This Court may further note that the creation of posts and strength of the services is provided under Regulation-10 of U.P. State Road Transport Corporation Employees (Other Than Officers) Service Regulations, 1981.
5. According to Regulation-10, it is the Board which is competent to create the posts or any other authority to whom the power is vested in this behalf. The power so conferred is subject to the directions as may be given by the State. The appointing authorities are defined in the U.P. State Road Transport Corporation Employees (Other Than Officers) (Appointing Authorities) Act, 1987. According to Section 2 of the aforesaid Act the appointing authority of the employees of UPSRTC is vested in the Board of Directors or any Officer authorised by the Board. Regulation-11 of the Statutory Regulations mentioned above contemplates the sources of recruitment and the same for ready reference is reproduced below:—
“11.Sources of recruitment-(1) Recruitment to various categories of posts in the service shall be made from one or more of the following sources as decided by the Board from time to time-
(a) by direct recruitment;
(b) by promotion from amongst such Corporation employees as have put in at least 3 years service in the next lower post through a departmental test or interview or in any other manner prescribed by the Board from time to time;
(c) by deputation or on contract.
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-regulation(1) the recruitment may be made from any other source approved by the Board.
(3) Subject to such directions as may be given by the Board, employees possessing requisite qualifications shall also be entitled to compete in direct recruitment.”
6. The aforesaid Regulation is reproduced for ready reference so that the claim as has been setup by the petitioner is tested in the light of statutory regulations applicable in this behalf. The criteria for appointment by promotion is provided under Regulation 21 and 22.
7. List/put up on 06.02.2019.
8. On the next date of listing, learned counsel for the parties may also address the Court in the light of aforesaid provisions.
Alert