- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Deepak v. State Of M.P.
Structured Summary of the Opinion (S.K. Awasthi, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
On 9.8.2017 at around 1:00 p.m., Jyoti (also referred to as Jiya), daughter of Rajendra Prasad Sharma, committed suicide at her residence in Piplichowk, Neemuch. The police registered a report and, during the enquiry, found that the deceased worked at the Central Bank, Jeeran Branch, Neemuch, alongside the petitioner. The allegations in the investigation were that the petitioner had entered the deceased's house and assaulted her with an intention to outrage her modesty; the deceased lodged a report about that incident and a criminal case was registered. It was further alleged that the petitioner harassed the deceased, caused her to lose her job at the bank, and, by instigation, caused the landlord to evict her from a rented house. In these circumstances the deceased committed suicide. Following investigation, offences under Section 306 of the IPC and Section 3(2)(v) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act were registered and a charge-sheet was filed. The Special Judge, Neemuch framed charges against the petitioner on 13.10.2017. The petitioner challenged the framing of charges by preferring the present revision petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, upon accepting the entire material available on record as true for the purpose of prima facie consideration, an offence punishable under Section 306 of the IPC and under Section 3(2)(v) of the SC & ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act would be made out against the petitioner?
- Whether the facts and material satisfy the ingredients of abetment as defined in Section 107 of the IPC (i.e., instigation, conspiracy, or intentional aid) necessary to sustain a charge under Section 306 IPC?
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The deceased had obtained a loan of Rs. 5,00,000 from the Central Bank of India, Jeeran Branch, and her inability to repay that loan led to her suicide.
- There is no material on record indicating any intention or acts by the petitioner that would have stressed the deceased into committing suicide.
- The dying declaration does not reflect any positive or overt act by the petitioner that caused the deceased to commit suicide.
- Mere allegations of harassment are insufficient to attract Section 306 IPC unless there is clinching evidence that the harassment was of such an extent as to force the deceased to commit suicide.
- An assault alone cannot be equated with instigation to commit suicide; absent ingredients of abetment (Section 107 IPC), framing charge under Section 306 IPC and Section 3(2)(v) of the Act was erroneous.
State / Public Prosecutor's Arguments
- The deceased committed suicide because the petitioner harassed her, forced her to lose her job, and thereby created the circumstances that led to her suicide.
- Given the deceased's suicide resulting from the petitioner's conduct, the trial court did not err in framing charges under Section 306 IPC.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| S.S. Cheena v. Vijay Kumar Mahajan, (2010) 12 SCC 190 | Abetment requires a mental process of instigating or intentionally aiding; without a positive act by accused to instigate or aid in suicide, conviction cannot be sustained; conviction requires clear mens rea and an active or direct act intended to push the deceased to suicide. | The court relied on this precedent to emphasize that mere harassment or allegations, absent a positive instigation or mens rea, are insufficient for sustaining a charge under Section 306 IPC; used to support overturning framing of charge. |
| State of West Bengal v. Orilal Jaiswal, (1994) 1 SCC 73 | Caution that courts must carefully assess whether cruelty alleged actually induced suicide; if the victim was hypersensitive to ordinary petulance, ordinary domestic discord should not ground a finding of abetment. | The court invoked this principle to observe that if the deceased was hypersensitive to ordinary grievances, such conduct would not ordinarily be expected to induce a similarly circumstanced person to commit suicide; hence the facts did not support abetment. |
| Gangula Mohan Reddy v. State of A.P., (2010) 1 SCC 750 | Reiteration that abetment involves instigation or intentional aiding; conviction under Section 306 IPC requires clear mens rea and an active/direct act intended to push the deceased into committing suicide; hypersensitivity caution reiterated. | The court cited the case to reinforce that none of the ingredients necessary for Section 306 were made out on the facts and thus framing of charge was unsustainable. |
| M. Mohan v. State represented by Deputy Superintendent of Police, (2011) 3 SCC 626 (AIR 2011 SC 1238) | Affirmation that abetment requires positive act of instigation or intentional aid; conviction under Section 306 IPC requires clear mens rea and an act intended to push the deceased to suicide. | The court relied on this authority to support the conclusion that absence of evidence of provocation, incitement or encouragement meant the charge under Section 306 could not stand at the stage of framing. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court framed the principal legal question as whether, accepting all material on record as true for prima facie consideration, an offence under Section 306 IPC and Section 3(2)(v) of the SC/ST Act was made out. The court proceeded by:
- Setting out the factual matrix: a prior criminal case was pending against the petitioner for assaulting the deceased with intent to outrage modesty; the dying declaration indicated the deceased lost her job and believed she could not secure another job because of difficulties allegedly created by the petitioner, and that she therefore decided to end her life.
- Explaining the legal standard: the court emphasised that the reason for suicide and abetment cannot be equated; for a conviction under Section 306 IPC, the ingredients of abetment as defined in Section 107 IPC must be satisfied. The court reproduced Section 107 and defined 'instigate' as actively goading, urging, provoking, inciting or encouraging by word or conduct.
- Applying the law to facts: on examination of the record, the court found no evidence that the accused goaded, urged, provoked, incited or otherwise encouraged the deceased to commit suicide. The court noted that the deceased's impression that she could not get a new job because of the petitioner did not establish an intention on the petitioner's part that the deceased should commit suicide.
- Relying on precedent: the court drew on several Supreme Court authorities (S.S. Cheena; State of West Bengal v. Orilal Jaiswal; Gangula Mohan Reddy; M. Mohan) which collectively stress that abetment involves a mental process and a positive act, that mens rea is required, and that courts must be cautious where the victim may have been hypersensitive to ordinary petulance or domestic discord.
- Concluding analysis: the court accepted that the alleged harassment may have contributed to the deceased's state of mind but held that this did not, on the available material, amount to abetment as defined by Section 107 IPC. The court therefore found the trial court erred in framing charges under Section 306 IPC and the corresponding provision of the SC/ST Act.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The revision petition was allowed. The impugned order of the trial court framing charges dated 13.10.2017 was set aside and the petitioner, Deepak, was discharged from the commission of the offence under Section 306 of the IPC and under Section 3(2)(v) of the SC & ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act.
Implications:
- Direct effect: The petitioner is discharged of the offences charged in the impugned order; the framing of charge for Section 306 IPC (and Section 3(2)(v) of the Act) was held to be erroneous on the material before the court at the stage of framing.
- Broader implications: The court applied existing Supreme Court authorities reaffirming the requirement of a positive act or clear mens rea for abetment under Section 306 IPC and cautioned against equating harassment or loss of employment with abetment absent evidence of instigation, incitement or intentional aiding. The opinion itself does not purport to establish a new legal precedent beyond applying those authorities.
S.K. Awasthi, J.:— This revision petition takes exception to the order dated 13.10.2017 passed by the Special Judge, Neemuch under Prevention of Atrocities Act in Special Case No. 51/2017, whereby the charge under Section 306 of the IPC and under Section 3(2)(v) of SC & ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act (in short the Act) have been framed against the petitioner.
2. Briefly stated the facts of the case are that, on 9.8.2017 at around 1.00 p.m., one Jyoti @ Jiya daughter of Rajendra Prasad Sharma has committed suicide at her residence situated at Piplichowk, Neemuch. The Police registered merg report and during the enquiry, it was found that the deceased was working in the Central Bank Jeeran along with the applicant. During that period, the petitioner entered into the house of the deceased and assaulted her with an intention to outrage her modesty. She lodged a report regarding the incidence and the Police registered a criminal case against the petitioner. On that account, the petitioner harassed her and got rid of her job from the Bank. It is further alleged that on the instigation of the petitioner, the landlord evicted the deceased from the rented house. In these circumstances, she committed suicide. Therefore, offence under Section 306 of the IPC and under Section 3(2)(v) of the Act has been registered against the petitioner and after due investigation, charge sheet has been filed.
3. The Trial Court, on perusal of the charge-sheet, concluded that the material available on record is enough for framing charges punishable for offence under Section 306 of the IPC and under Section 3(2)(v) of the Act against the petitioner/accused. Feeling aggrieved by the order of framing the charges, the petitioner has preferred this revision petition.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the deceased had obtained a loan for a sum of Rs. 5,00,000/- from the Central Bank of India, Jeeran Branch, Neemuch. She was unable to pay the loan amount and due to which, she has committed suicide. He further submitted that there is no material available on record, which indicates the intention or acts of the petitioner to stress the deceased to commit suicide. The dying declaration of the deceased does not reflect that any positive or overt act was done by the present petitioner, due to which, the deceased has committed suicide. Merely on the allegation that the deceased was being harassed by the petitioner does not attract the provisions of Section 306 of IPC unless and until there is clinching evidence available on record that the harassment was of such an extent that can force the deceased to commit suicide. Only because the petitioner had assaulted the deceased, it cannot be said that he instigated her to commit suicide. Since no ingredient of abatement is borne out from the facts of the prosecution case, learned trial Court committed error in framing charge under Section 306 of the IPC against the petitioner and under Section 3(2)(v) of the Act.
5. Learned Public Prosecutor for the State, on the other hand, has submitted that the deceased had committed suicide because the petitioner to stress the deceased and got rid of her job, due to which, she committed suicide. Since the deceased had committed suicide due to the conduct of the petitioner, the trial Court did not commit any error in framing charges under Section 306 of the IPC.
6. I have considered the facts of the case and rival contentions of the parties.
7. The question in the present revision as to whether considering and accepting the entire material available on record, is absolutely true, prima-facie case and commission of offence punishable under Section 306 of the IPC and under Section 3(2)(v) of the Act would be made out against the petitioner?
8. Before adverting to the contentions raised by the parties, it is appropriate to observe factual background in which the entire incident in question has taken place. It is alleged that one criminal case was pending against the petitioner for assaulting the deceased with intention to outrage her modesty and for this reason, he started harassing her. From the dying declaration of the deceased, it reveals that she loses her job and she was unable to get a new job because the petitioner creates hazardous for getting new job. Therefore, she decided to end her life.
9. The aforesaid facts failed to satisfy the ingredients of Section 306 of the IPC because the reason to commit suicide and abetement to commit suicide cannot be equated and for the purpose of Section 306 of the IPC it can be used simultaneously or interchangeably. The fact that the deceased committed suicide under apprehension that she did not get any new job, is not enough to prosecute a person for offence under Section 306 of IPC unless the ingredients of Section 107 of the IPC is to be satisfied, which are reproduced as under:—
“107. Abetment of a thing - A person abets the doing of a thing, who -
First - Instigates any person to do that thing;
Secondly, - Engages with one or more other person or persons in any conspiracy for the doing of that thing, if an act or illegal omission takes place in pursuance of that conspiracy, and in order to the doing of that thing;
Thirdly - Intentionally aids, by any act or illegal omission, the doing of that thing.”
10. A person is said to be instigated another to an act, when he actively or stimulates him to the act by means of language, direct or indirect, whether it takes the form of express solicitation, or of hints, insinuation or encouragement. The word ‘instigate’ means to goad or urge forward or to provoke, incite, urge or encourage to do an act.
11. On examination of the facts and circumstances of the present case, as they are, it appears that the accused never goaded or urged forward, provoked, incited or urged or encouraged the deceased to commit suicide. Merely the deceased was feeling to get any job and she is under impression that the petitioner is creating burden and hence she did not get any new job. He never intended that deceased should commit suicide.
12. Learned counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance on the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of S.S. Cheena v. Vijay Kumar Mahajan, reported in (2010) 12 SCC 190, the allegations levelled were as under:
“An enquiry was conducted by the Security Officer of the University, the appellant herein, regarding the theft of a mobile phone. A dispute arose between the deceased and H. The deceased committed suicide during the course of enquiry, by jumping in from of a train, leaving a suicide note. In the suicide note it is stated that he did not commit the theft and he had committed suicide because he was falsely implicated in the theft case of a mobile phone.”
25. Abetment involves a mental process of instigating a person or intentionally aiding a person in doing of a thing. Without a positive act on the part of the accused to instigate or aid in committing suicide, conviction cannot be sustained. The intention of the legislature and the ratio of the cases decided by this Court is clear that in order to convict a person under Section 306 IPC there has to be a clear mens rea to commit the offence. It also requires an active act or direct act which led the deceased to commit suicide seeing no option and that act must have been intended to push the deceased into such a position that he committed suicide. When the appellant was in no manner connected with this case and there was no credible material to connect the appellant with the crime, it would be a futile exercise to compel him to undergo a criminal trial.
13. In the case of State of West Bengal v. Orilal Jaiswal: reported in (1994) 1 SCC 73, Hon'ble Supreme Court has held as under:
This Court has cautioned that the Court should be extremely careful in assessing the facts and circumstances of each case and the evidence adduced in the trial for the purpose of finding whether the cruelty meted out to the. victim had in fact induced her to end the life by committing suicide. If it transpires to the Court that a victim committing suicide was hypersensitive to ordinary petulance, discord and differences in domestic life quite common to the society to which the victim belonged and such petulance, discord and differences were not expected to induce a similarly circumstanced individual in a given society to commit suicide, the conscience of the Court should not be satisfied for basing a finding that the accused charged of abetting the offence of suicide should be found guilty.
14. In the case of Gangula Mohan Reddy v. State of A.P: reported in (2010) 1 SCC 750, whereby Hon'ble Supreme Court has held thus:
Abetment involves a mental process of instigating a person or intentionally aiding a person in doing of a thing. Without a positive act on the part of the accused to instigate or aid in committing suicide, conviction cannot be sustained - In order to convict a person under section 306 IPC there has to be a clear mens rea to commit the offence. It also requires an active act or direct act which led the deceased to commit suicide seeing no option and this act must have been intended to push the deceased into such a position that he commits suicide. - Also, reiterated, if it appears to the Court that a victim committing suicide was hypersensitive to ordinary petulance, discord and difference in domestic life quite common to the society to which the victim belonged and such petulance, discord and difference were not expected to induce a similarly circumstanced individual in a given society to commit suicide, the conscience of the Court should not be satisfied for basing a finding that the accused charged of abetting the offence of suicide should be found guilty. - Herein, the deceased was undoubtedly hyper sensitive to ordinary petulance, discord circumstances of case, none of the ingredients of offence under Section 306 made out - Hence, appellant's conviction, held unsustainable.”
15. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of M. Mohan v. State represented by the Deputy Superintendent of Police reported in (2011) 3 SCC 626 : AIR 2011 SC 1238 has observed thus:—
Abetment involves a mental process of instigating a person or intentionally aiding a person in doing of a thing. Without a positive act on the part of the accused to instigate or aid in committing suicide, conviction cannot be sustained. The intention of the legislature and the ratio of the cases decided by this Court is clear that in order to convict a person under Section 306 IPC there has to be a clear mens rea to commit the offence. It also requires an active act or direct act which led the deceased to commit suicide seeing no option and that act must have been intended to push the deceased into such a position that he/she commits suicide.
16. Looking to the facts of the case, it is found that the alleged harassment may be caused for committing suicide, but would not amount to abetment to commit the same as defined in Section 107 of IPC and in the facts and circumstances of the present case, there is no evidence with regard to provocation, incitement or encouragement for commitment of suicide by the deceased. Therefore, the trial Court has committed error in framing charge against charge against the present petitioner for an offence punishable under Section 306 of the IPC.
17. Taking this view of the matter, the present revision petition is allowed. The impugned order of the trial Court is hereby set aside and the petitioner Deepak is discharged from the commission of offence under Section 306 of the IPC and under Section 3(2)(v) of SC & ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act.
18. Certified copy, as per rules.
Alert