- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Nareshbhai Bhagubhai v. Union Of India
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Akil Kureshi, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
These petitions were filed by agriculturist land-owners whose lands in Surat district were subject to proposed acquisition by Railway Authorities for construction of a Dedicated Freight Corridor. An initial notification of intention to acquire land was published on 29.09.2008 but did not include the petitioners' lands. After reconsideration of alignment options, a fresh notification under section 20A of the Railways Act, 1989 was issued on 08.02.2011 and the petitioners' lands were included in its schedule. Some petitioners lodged objections around 06.04.2011, alleging inter alia that the Railways lacked power to acquire the lands, that the proposed line was impractical and would leave fragmented holdings, and suggesting alternative alignments; they also asserted that a prior preliminary notification (dated 28.10.2008) had allegedly been abandoned under pressure from land owners. The Special Land Acquisition Officer (LAO) replied on 15.07.2011 giving brief reasons rejecting the objections and offered a personal hearing; a hearing was scheduled and held on 30.07.2011. A declaration under section 20E was published by the Ministry of Railways on 06.02.2012 that the lands would vest in the Central Government, recording that 59 objections were received and were considered and disallowed. The petitioners challenged the acquisition, principally alleging defects in the acquisition proceedings and that the change in proposed line was motivated by pressure from landowners.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the competent authority complied with the procedural requirements of Chapter IV-A of the Railways Act, 1989—in particular whether objections under section 20D were properly considered and disposed of after affording a personal hearing before the declaration under section 20E was made.
- Whether the decision to adopt a fresh railway alignment (as opposed to the earlier proposed line) was impermissible, impractical, or tainted by mala fides such that the Court should interfere with the administrative/technical decision.
- Whether an incorrect reply given by the LAO to RTI queries (stating that no separate order was passed after the hearing) affected the legality of the acquisition or required remedial action.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- Reliance on Chapter IV-A of the Railways Act (special railway project provisions): counsel asserted the competent authority did not consider and dispose of all objections, thereby violating the statutory right to be heard.
- Personal hearing is a statutorily granted valuable right; petitioners alleged they were deprived of that right because no order disposing their objections was passed following the hearing of 30.07.2011.
- They relied on a reply dated 05.09.2013 from the Information Officer (who was also the LAO) under the RTI Act which stated that objections had already been replied to and that no order was passed after the hearing; this was relied on as evidence that their objections were not properly disposed of.
- They contended the earlier proposed acquisition had been abandoned to benefit certain landowners and implied that the change of alignment was suspect.
Respondents' Arguments
- After thorough examination, feasibility studies and engineering considerations, Railway authorities validly proposed a fresh railway line; a prior suggested alternative does not preclude reconsideration and adoption of a new alignment.
- All objections raised at hearings (including on 30.07.2011) were considered and rejected by the competent authority; any RTI reply stating otherwise was an error or oversight.
- Documentary notings in office files showed objections had been rejected, and the Railway administration produced an additional affidavit dated 17.07.2018 together with documents recording LAO's remarks (endorsed 20.08.2011) and a report of hearings reflecting consideration and disallowance of objections.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded in two main strands: first addressing challenges to the feasibility or advisability of the fresh railway alignment, and second examining whether the objections had been properly considered and disposed of in accordance with the statutory scheme of Chapter IV-A.
On the question of feasibility and change of alignment: The Court emphasised deference to administrative and technical decision-making in matters involving complex engineering, topology, geology and economic considerations. It stated that courts are "extremely slow" to overrule government decisions in highly technical subjects unless it is shown that relevant considerations were not weighed or the decision was "blatantly mala fide." The mere fact that the present line differed from a previously proposed line, resulting in a "considerable shifting and shuffling" of lands to be acquired, was not by itself sufficient to infer mala fides. The petitioners had not placed further material on record to demonstrate that the present line was impractical or unjustified.
On the question of statutory procedure for objections and personal hearing: The Court set out the relevant statutory provisions in Chapter IV-A of the Railways Act: - Section 20A: Central Government may declare intention to acquire land for a special railway project by notification; notification must give a brief description of land and project. - Section 20D(1)-(3): Persons interested may object within thirty days; objections must be in writing; the competent authority must give the objector an opportunity of being heard (in person or by a legal practitioner); the competent authority may, after hearing and making such enquiry as it thinks necessary, by order allow or disallow objections; orders under sub-section (2) are final. - Section 20E(1)-(4): Where no objection is made or objections are disallowed, the competent authority reports to Central Government and the Central Government may declare acquisition by notification; on publication, the land vests absolutely in Central Government; a declaration is not to be called into question in any court. The Court explained that publication under section 20E(1) can follow only when there were no objections within prescribed time or when the competent authority has disallowed objections; hence, if objections had not been disallowed, the Central Government could not validly publish the declaration.
The Court then addressed the factual question whether objections had in fact been considered and disallowed. The RTI reply dated 05.09.2013 (from the Information Officer who was the LAO) stated that objections were already replied to and that no order was passed after the hearing of 30.07.2011, which created confusion and suggested non-disposal of objections. The Railway authorities initially explained this as an error or oversight and later produced additional material.
The Court examined original files and documents and discovered a report dated 03.01.2012 from the LAO addressed to the Chief Project Manager, DFCCIL, which recorded publication details, tabulated the number of objections received, listed hearing dates (including hearings beginning 30.07.2011 and continuing through various dates), and expressly stated that "all the 59(59) objection were disallowed by order by the undersigned" with a request to declare the notification under section 20E at the earliest. The LAO had also submitted summaries showing objections, responses of DFCCIL and LAO remarks indicating agreement with the acquiring body or not with objectors.
On the basis of these documents, the Court concluded that the objections received and orally presented on 30.07.2011 were in fact considered and disposed of by the LAO, and that the RTI reply was inaccurate. Accordingly, the Court rejected the petitioners' contention that the objections had remained undecided and that the declaration under section 20E was therefore invalid for want of disposal.
Nevertheless, the Court strongly criticized the manner in which the matter was handled: the LAO had given an incorrect RTI reply that conveyed a materially wrong position to the affected landowners, thereby misleading them about the status of their objections and the legality of the acquisition. The Court described the RTI reply as "an act of utter carelessness" with serious ramifications and observed that this miscommunication may have prompted the petitioners to file the petitions.
Balancing the legal outcome (that objections had been considered and disallowed and that the Court should not interfere with technical decisions absent mala fides) with the procedural lapse (the erroneous RTI reply), the Court dismissed the petitions but imposed a cost on the LAO.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court DISMISSED the petitions challenging the acquisition.
Direct consequences and directions: - The Court found that the objections under section 20D were considered and disallowed by the competent authority (as evidenced in the LAO's report dated 03.01.2012 and related summaries), and therefore the declaration under section 20E was not vitiated on the ground that objections remained undecided. - The Court accepted the respondents' position that the administrative decision to adopt a fresh alignment after technical and feasibility studies is a matter calling for deference, and the petitioners failed to establish mala fides or other grounds to impugn the alignment decision. - The Court was critical of the LAO's incorrect RTI reply and, while dismissing the petitions, directed the Special Land Acquisition Officer to pay costs of Rs. 50,000 (rupees fifty thousand only) in each petition.
Broader implications: The opinion does not purport to lay down any new legal precedent; its immediate effect is the dismissal of the petitions and the imposition of costs on the LAO for giving an inaccurate RTI reply.
Disposition
All petitions were disposed of accordingly, with the direction that the respondent-Special Land Acquisition Officer pay costs of Rs. 50,000 in each petition.
Akil Kureshi, J.:— These petitions are filed by the agriculturists-land owners whose lands are under acquisition by the Railway Authorities for the construction of Dedicated Freight Corridor. The lands are situated in Surat district. They oppose the acquisition on various grounds.
2. At the outset, we may record brief facts.
3. For the said purpose, the notification for acquisition of land was issued on 29.09.2008 declaring intention of the Railways to acquire land. This notification contained a schedule of lands under proposed acquisition which did not contain the lands of the present petitioners. However, this proposal did not go through. There was rethinking at the level of the Railway administration itself to construct such corridor at the proposed place or parallel to the existing railway lines so as to save private lands. Eventually, a fresh notification came to be issued by the Railways on 08.02.2011 under section 20A of the Railways Act, 1989 (hereinafter to be referred to as ‘the Act’ for short) declaring the intention for acquisition of private lands for the said purpose. Schedule to this notification contained details of the lands under acquisition. The lands of the petitioners were mentioned therein. Some of the petitioners raised objections on or around 06.04.2011. Various grounds taken in the objections were that the Railway authorities have no power to acquire the lands, that, the proposed railway line is impractical and unscientific; that, the acquisition of the lands would leave the remaining lands in the hands of the farmers in small fragments. They also suggested the alternative line, which according to them, was more suitable. They also pointed out that previous preliminary notification was published on 28.10.2008, and alleged that such acquisition was abandoned under pressure from the concerned land owners.
4. On 15.07.2011, the Special Land Acquisition Officer (‘LAO’ for short) responded to such objections by citing his brief reasons why he did not agree with any of the grounds raised by the objectors. In particular, he pointed out that feasibility of the project was decided after thorough study and calculations by the Railway authorities. The lay out plan is decided independently without any pressure. He nevertheless, pointed out to the objectors that a personal hearing will be fixed on which date they may remain present with necessary documents. The date of the personal hearing would be communicated shortly. Under further communication dated 19.07.2011, the LAO conveyed the hearing date of 30.07.2011 at 12:30 afternoon. It is not in dispute that personal hearing did take place on such date. The Ministry of Railways issued a further notification dated 06.02.2012 under section 20E of the Act providing that the lands specified under the schedule shall vest under the Central Government free from all encumbrances. Said notification also records that objections from 59 members were received. The same were considered and disallowed by the competent authority. Under this notification thus, the lands of the present petitioners along with other neighboring lands came to be acquired. Petitioners have challenged such acquisition notification on various grounds. Principally, they allege defect in the acquisition proceedings and of the change of previously proposed railway line under pressure from the owners whose lands were then under acquisition.
5. In the context of the proper procedure not being followed, counsel for the petitioners placed heavy reliance on the provisions contained in Chapter IV-A of the Act, in which, provisions have been made for acquisition of land for a Special Railway Project. He contended that the competent authority had not considered and disposed of all the objections of the petitioners which was a major defect. The land owners have a valuable right to be heard. The competent authority deprived the petitioners of such valuable right. In this context, he referred to certain documents on record. It was pointed out that some of the petitioners had raised a query to the Information Officer under the Right to Information Act (‘RTI’ for short) on 13.08.2013 inquiring about the outcome of the objections raised by them. In reply to such query, the Information Officer who was also the LAO himself, conveyed on 05.09.2013 that the objections raised by the petitioners to the preliminary notification issued under section 20A of the Act were already replied. Thereafter, hearing had taken place, in which, no order was passed since previous objections were already declined. Counsel for the petitioners would therefore vehemently contend that the competent authority did not deal with and dispose of the objections raised by the land owners during the hearing of 30.07.2011. Personal hearing is a statutorily granted right. They were deprived of such right of hearing. The counsel had also raised the ground that previous acquisition was abandoned by the Railway authorities to benefit the land owners whose land would have been acquired.
6. The respondents however opposed the petitions contending that after thorough examination of all relevant aspects of the matter, detailed feasibility study and engineering aspects, fresh railway line was proposed, which culminated into the notification dated 06.02.2012 issued under section 20A of the Act. Merely because previously an alternative line was suggested, would not prevent the Railway administration from taking a fresh look at all relevant aspects of the matter.
7. With respect to the objections of the petitioners raised in the personal hearing of 30.07.2011, it was contended that all such objections were considered and rejected by the authority. It was submitted that the reply given by the Information Officer to the query raised under the RTI was a pure error and oversight. In fact, in the office files, proper notings were made rejecting the objections. This was also placed before the acquiring body in a summary form since number of objections received from various villages were heard on different dates and disposed of by the competent authority.
8. We will first dispose of the petitioners objections to the feasibility or advisability of the fresh proposed railway line. It is well settled that in highly technical subjects involving scientific and technical fields, the Court would be extremely slow in overruling the decision taken by the Government after due deliberations. Laying the railway line through a certain region would require consideration of range of factors including the engineering aspect, the topology and geology of the region, as well as the economic considerations. Unless and until it is pointed out that relevant considerations were not properly weighed or that the decision was blatantly mala fide, the Court would not attempt to substitute its understanding of such complex subject for that of the Government who would have been advised by the experts in the fields. It is undoubtedly true that previously the railway line proposed was somewhat different from the present line and as a result of which, there has been a considerable shifting and shuffling of the agricultural lands which would come under acquisition. This by itself however would not be sufficient to jump to the conclusion that the entire decision was either mala-fide or without proper justification. Except for pressing this ground of shift of railway line as compared to the previously proposed line, the petitioners have not brought any further materials on record in support of their objections and contentions that the present line is not advisable.
9. Coming to the more complex issue of disposal of the objections of the petitioners, we will first refer to the statutory provisions. Chapter IV-A of the Act, as noted, pertains to land acquisition for a special railway project. Section 20A contained in the said chapter empowers the Central Government upon being satisfied that for a public purpose, any land is required for execution of a special railway project, to declare its intention to acquire such land by issuing a notification. Sub-section (2) of section 20A provides that every notification under sub-section (1) shall give a brief description of the land and of the special railway project for which the land is intended to be acquired. Section 20D pertains to hearing of the objections and reads as under:
20D. Hearing of objections, etc. -
(1) Any person interested in the land may, within a period of thirty days from the date of publication of the notification under subsection (1) of section 20A, object to the acquisition of land for the purpose mentioned in that sub-section.
(2) Every objection under sub-section (1), shall be made to the competent authority in writing, and shall set out the grounds thereof and the competent authority shall give the objector an opportunity of being heard, either in person or by a legal practitioner, and may, after hearing all such objections and after making such further enquiry, if any, as the competent authority thinks necessary, by order, either allow or disallow the objections.
Explanation.- For the purposes of this subsection, “legal practitioner” has the same meaning as in clause (i) of sub-section (1) of section 2 of the Advocates Act, 1961 (25 of 1961).
(3) Any order made by the competent authority under sub-section (2) shall be final.
10. Section 20E pertains to declaration of acquisition and reads as under:
20E Declaration of acquisition. -
(1) Where no objection under sub-section (1) of section 20D has been made to the competent authority within the period specified therein or where the competent authority has disallowed the objections under sub-section (2) of that section, the competent authority shall, as soon as may be, submit a report accordingly to the Central Government and on receipt of such report, the Central Government shall declare, by notification, that the land should be acquired for the purpose mentioned in sub-section (1) of section 20A.
(2) On the publication of the declaration under sub-section (1), the land shall vest absolutely in the Central Government free from all encumbrances.
(3) Where in respect of any land, a notification has been published under subsection (1) of section 20A for its acquisition, but no declaration under sub-section (1) of this section has been published within a period of one year from the date of publication of that notification, the said notification shall cease to have any effect:
Provided that in computing the said period of one year, the period during which any action or proceedings to be taken in pursuance of the notification issued under sub-section (1) of section 20A is stayed by an order of a court shall be excluded.
(4) A declaration made by the Central Government under sub-section (1) shall not be called in question in any court or by any other authority.
11. Thus, under sub-section (1) of section 20D, any person interested in the land would have a right to object to the acquisition of such land within thirty days from the date of publication of the notification under sub-section (1) of section 20A of the Act. Under sub-section (2) of section 20D, upon such objection being raised, the competent authority would give the objector an opportunity of being heard either in person or by legal practitioner and after hearing such objections and making such enquiry as the competent authority thinks necessary, pass an order either allowing or disallowing the objections. An order made by the competent authority under subsection (2) achieves finality under sub-section (3) of section 20D.
12. Section 20D of the Act thus recognizes the valuable right of a person interested in the land which is under acquisition, to raise objections and be heard on such objections. Sub-section (2) of section 20D in fact, provides for a right of personal hearing through the objector himself or his legal practitioner. The right of hearing is thus not confined to raising of objections but extends to a personal hearing as well. By all means thus, this is a valuable right. When the private land is thus being considered for acquisition for public purpose, any objection raised by the person interested in such land has to be considered and disposed of after hearing by the competent authority.
13. Sub-section (1) of section 20E of the Act provides that where no objection under sub-section (1) of section 20D has been made within the prescribed period or where he competent authority has disallowed the objections under sub-section (2), he shall as soon as may be, submit a report to the Central Government and on receipt of such report, the Central Government may declare by way of notification that the land is acquired for the purpose mentioned in sub-section (1) of section 20A. As per sub-section (2) of section 20E, on publication of notification under sub-section (1), the land would vests absolutely with the Central Government free from all encumbrances. Thus, publication of notification under sub-section (1) of section 20E can take place only under two circumstances viz; where no objections are received within the time prescribed or where the objections so received have been rejected by the competent authority. If therefore the objections received by the persons interested have not been disallowed by the competent authority, it would simply not be open for the Central Government to proceed to issue the notification of acquisition of land under sub-section (1) of section 20E of the Act.
14. In context of such statutory provisions and contentions raised before us, we had minutely examined this aspect of the matter. We were further compelled to look deep into the matter since, as noted in reply to the query raised by some of the objectors under the RTI, the reply given was that since previously the objections were already disposed of, no separate order was passed pursuant to hearing of 30.07.2011, simply confounded this confusion. Simply going by this communication, it would appear that after 30.07.2011 hearing, the competent authority did not pass any order on the objections of the concerned objectors. This situation was compounded since the Railway authorities in their earlier replies had not dealt with these specific contentions of the petitioners or independently clarified the position emerging from the such reply dated 05.09.2013 issued by the LAO as the Information Officer. The LAO himself had not filed any reply. At a subsequent stage, the Railway administration had filed an additional affidavit dated 17.07.2018 along with which, a document was produced which contained the reference to the personal hearing which took place before the LAO on various dates and on which, he put his remarks that objections are not accepted with an endorsement dated 20.08.2011. The Railway administration and now even the Assistant Government Pleader appearing for the LAO would therefore argue that the objections discussed on 30.07.2011 were in fact considered and disposed of by the LAO. We were not entirely satisfied with this cursory explanation. Even when the learned AGP orally stated that the reply to the RTI query was inaccurate, we had, called for the original file. After rummaging through several files and documents, we eventually chanced upon a report dated 03.01.2012 made by the LAO to the Chief Project Manager, Dedicated Freight Corridor Corporation of India Limited. He had stated as under:
“Dear Sir,
With the reference to the above mentioned subject and reference the above mentioned notifications were published in two local newspapers namely “Times of india” on dt.12.03.2011 and in “Sandesh” (in vernacular language) on dated 12.03.2011 and objection were called from various villages of Choryasi, Kamrej & Palsana talukas. The number of objections received therein are tabulated below. On receipt of Objections all the peasants/complainants were issued notice regarding section 20(A) hearing and were called for hearing at LAQ Office Branch-4, 5th Floor, Multi Storage Building, Nanpura Surat. Of the respective villages as tabulated below. All the peasant/complainants were heard at length and amicable replied in according with law were orally answered in the presence of the representative of DFCCIL Surat.
Sr. No Taluka Village Total Nos. of Complaints Total Nos. of Complaints heard Hearing held on Hearing Place 1 City Unn 1 1 21.10.2011 CA & LAQ Office Branch-4, Surat. 2 Bhestan 4 4 15.09.2011 CA & LAQ Office Branch-4, Surat. 3 Bhedwad 3 3 18.08.2011 CA & LAQ Office Branch-4, Surat. 4 Dindoli 0 0 ------------ CA & LAQ Office Branch-4, Surat. 5 Godadara 2 2 18.08.2011 to 24.08.2011 CA & LAQ Office Branch-4, Surat. 6 Choryasi Devagadh 3 3 30.07.2011 to 18.08.2011 CA & LAQ Office Branch-4, Surat. 7 Dakkhanwada 10 10 30.07.2011 CA & LAQ Office Branch-4, Surat. 8 Kamrej Valak 16 16 29.08.2011 to 03.01.2012 CA & LAQ Office Branch-4, Surat. 9 Laskana 3 3 29.08.2011 CA & LAQ Office Branch-4, Surat. 10 Bhada 11 11 29.08.2011 to 03.01.2012 CA & LAQ Office Branch-4, Surat. 11 Palsana Shedhav 6 6 03.07.2011 to 03.01.2012 CA & LAQ Office Branch-4, Surat. 59 59
Finally after due consideration and taking in to view, the nationwide infrastructure, long lifetime permanent utility and hence public utility is greater than that of personal, all the 59(59) objection were disallowed by order by the undersigned and their applications for objection were filed at this end.
I do submit humbly to declare the notification for 20(E) at the earliest.”
15. Along with his report, he had also submitted the summary of objections of various objectors from various villages. His summary contains briefly the objections of the land owners, the response of Dedicated Freight Corridor Corporation and the remarks of the LAO himself whether he agrees with the acquiring body or with the objectors. This would therefore show that the objections received by the LAO on 30.07.2011 and orally presented before him by the objectors or their representatives were considered and disposed of. Clearly the answer to the RTI query was carrying inaccurate information. Under the circumstances, the second contention of the petitioners also cannot be accepted.
16. However, we are extremely perturbed by the manner in which this entire litigation was handled by the respondents. The farmers whose lands were under acquisition and who had at the outset raised objections to the preliminary notification under section 20A of the Act were informed that their all objections were not valid. This was even before granting them personal hearing. The Special Land Acquisition Officer conveyed his brief reasons for his conclusions but simultaneously also granted a personal hearing which even otherwise was a statutory requirement. When the hearing took place on 30.07.2011 and now as it appears, he disposed of the objections, the same was never conveyed to the objectors. When the objectors asked him under RTI Act about the outcome of their objections, he conveyed that since previously response was already made, no fresh order was necessary and therefore he cannot supply copy of the order which was never passed. This probably was one of the main reasons which prompted the petitioners to move these petitions. Going by such reply dated 05.09.2013, the competent authoity had not fulfilled an important stage of disposal of the objections before which, as noted, final declaration of acquisition could not have been made. He, thus gave a completely wrong reply under the RTI Act on an issue which was most vital to the land owners and to the very acquisition. The legality of the acquisition rested entirely on the question whether the objections were disposed of after personal hearing. He gave wrong answer to this most important issue and there by mislead the land owners on the strength of their legal position vis-a-vis the challenge to the acquisition. Had he not given this wrong answer, perhaps the petitioners may not have filed these petitions. His act of giving wrong answer under the RTI Act has no explanation. It was an act of utter carelessness and which had serious ramifications. Under the circumstances, while dismissing the petitions, we direct the respondent-Special Land Acquisition Officer to pay a cost of Rs. 50,000/- (rupees fifty thousand only) in each petition.
17. All petitions disposed of accordingly.
Alert