Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Union Of India And Another v. Tarsem Singh And Others

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Nov 12, 2018
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judicial Opinion Summary — Ajay Tewari, J. (Oral)

Factual and Procedural Background

This matter proceeded on a notice of motion hearing. Counsel for respondents Nos. 1 to 3 entered appearance. On 25.10.2018 the court directed learned counsel to place on record information about the award under the relevant acquisition, details of payments made, and information about other related cases; the matter was adjourned to 12.11.2018. At the subsequent hearing, counsel had not placed the requested information on record.

The dispute arises from acquisition by the National Highways Authority of India (NH Authority) of a stretch of N.H. 1-A (Km. 26.00 to Km. 117.20). Respondents' counsel drew attention to an adjoining award (MA 471/2009, Lekh Raj v. UOI, decided 25.1.2011) in which the NH Authority did not file objections and satisfied the award. The appellant (NH Authority) contended that non-filing in that case was an administrative error and asked that the case be decided on merits.

The court considered these facts, identified errors in the award under challenge (specifically with respect to a grant for severance and an 18% conditional interest clause), applied pertinent legal authorities, and issued the operative directions set out below. The appeal was disposed of in the terms recorded by the court and any pending civil miscellaneous application was also disposed of.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the National Highways Authority of India, being an entity covered by the expression "State" under Article 12 of the Constitution, can selectively challenge some awards and not others arising from the same acquisition notification.
  2. Whether the award's grant of severance compensation was appropriate where "there is no severance."
  3. Whether the stipulation of conditional interest at the rate of 18% per annum (if the awarded amount is not paid within six months) was legally sustainable.
  4. Whether, if the appellant relies upon principles from the Division Bench judgment in Golden Iron and Steel Forging v. Union of India (2011 (4) RCR (Civil) 375), the respondents (or landowners) are entitled to solatium at the rate laid down in that decision.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents' Arguments

  • Pointed out that in an adjoining award (MA 471/2009 — Lekh Raj v. UOI, decided 25.1.2011) the National Highway Authority of India did not file objections and instead satisfied the award, implying inconsistent institutional conduct by the Authority.
  • Contended that if the appellant relies on the principles enunciated in Golden Iron (supra), then, in fairness, solatium should be paid at the same rate as laid down in that decision.

Appellant's Arguments

  • Contended that the non-filing of objections in the Lekh Raj matter was an "administrative goof-up" and urged the court to decide the case on its merits rather than penalize the Authority for that omission.
  • Argued that the landowners (who would benefit from solatium) were not parties to the appeal—an argument advanced in opposition to the respondents' call for solatium payments where Golden Iron principles were invoked.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Article 12 of the Constitution To classify the National Highways Authority of India as an entity covered by the expression "State". The court held that because the NH Authority is covered by Article 12, it cannot be permitted to "pick and choose" in which cases it challenges compensation; this reasoning supported rejection of the appeal against valuation.
Golden Iron and Steel Forging v. Union of India, 2011 (4) RCR (Civil) 375 Referenced for the principles governing payment of interest and solatium applicable to awards under acquisition. The court noted that interest had to be paid in terms of Golden Iron (as admitted). The court directed payment of solatium at 30% as laid down in Golden Iron. At the same time, the court set aside the award's stipulation of conditional interest at 18% per annum as not justifiable in the circumstances of this case.
Lekh Raj v. Union of India (MA 471/2009), decided 25.1.2011 Used to demonstrate the NH Authority's prior conduct in an adjacent award where it did not file objections and satisfied the award. The court relied on this instance of the Authority's conduct to underscore inconsistency and to support the conclusion that the Authority could not selectively challenge awards; this influenced the decision to reject the appeal against valuation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through a sequence of factual observations and legal conclusions, applying the authorities cited above as follows:

  1. Non-compliance with directions: The court began by noting that counsel for the appellant had failed to place on record the information the court had directed at the previous hearing (details of the award, payments, and related cases). This procedural lapse framed the context for scrutiny of the appellant's conduct.
  2. Inconsistent conduct of the NH Authority: The court relied on the example of the adjoining award (Lekh Raj) where the NH Authority did not file objections and satisfied the award. The court treated that behaviour as material to assessing whether the Authority could be permitted to challenge valuation in the present case.
  3. Application of Article 12: By treating the NH Authority as a "State" under Article 12, the court applied the principle that a State entity cannot "pick and choose" which awards to challenge. This principle was used to reject the appeal against the valuation of the land.
  4. Identification of specific errors in the award: The court identified two "glaring errors" in the award: (a) an award of severance compensation where, on the court's finding, "there is no severance"; and (b) a stipulation of conditional interest at the rate of 18% per annum if the award is not paid within six months.
  5. Relationship to Golden Iron: The court noted that interest issues were governed by the Division Bench judgment in Golden Iron (admitted by counsel). While recognising that interest must be paid in accordance with Golden Iron, the court found that respondents' counsel could not justify payment of severance where no severance existed, nor justify the 18% conditional interest. Consequently, the court set aside the awarded amounts relating to severance and the stipulation of 18% per annum conditional interest.
  6. Equitable application of precedent: The court considered the respondents' submission that if the appellant invoked Golden Iron principles, it could not selectively adopt favourable portions of that decision. Accepting this equitable argument, the court directed payment of solatium at 30% as laid down in Golden Iron.
  7. Disposition: Taking these conclusions together, the court disposed of the appeal "in the above terms" and disposed of any pending civil miscellaneous application since the main case was decided.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The appeal is disposed of in the terms recorded by the court. More specifically:

  • The appeal against the valuation of the land is rejected.
  • The award's grant of severance compensation is set aside on the finding that there is no severance.
  • The stipulation of conditional interest at the rate of 18% per annum (if the awarded amount is not paid within six months) is set aside.
  • The court directed payment of solatium at the rate of 30% as laid down in Golden Iron and Steel Forging v. Union of India.
  • Any pending civil miscellaneous application connected to the main case stands disposed of.

Implications:

The direct effect of the decision is to (a) reject the appellant authority's challenge to valuation, (b) remove severance and the conditional 18% interest component from the award, and (c) require payment of solatium at 30% per the cited Division Bench authority. The court's reasoning emphasises that a State entity (here, the NH Authority) must act consistently and cannot selectively accept or contest awards arising from the same acquisition notification. The opinion does not purport to announce any novel principle beyond the application of the identified authorities to the facts of this case.

Show all summary ...

Ajay Tewari, J. (Oral):— Notice of motion.

2. Mr. Satbir Rathore, Advocate and Mr. Harish Mahajan, Advocate has entered appearance on behalf of the respondents No. 1 to 3.

3. On 25.10.2018 the following order was passed:—

“This dispute arises out of the acquisition carried out by the National highways for stretch of roads from Km. 26.00 to Km.117.20 of N.H. 1-A. The authority has taken seven years to challenge the Award. Learned counsel is directed to place on record information regarding the Award passed under this acquisition; the details of payments which may have been made; the details of other cases which may have been filed and the details of other cases which have been filed against this acquisition.

Adjourned to 12.11.2018.”

4. Even today learned counsel has not placed on record any information on the different points which was required on the last date of hearing.

5. Counsel for the respondents No. 1 to 3 state that in one award of the adjoining land in Harshi Pind Tehsil Dausya, District Hoshiarpur, passed in MA 471/2009 Lekh Raj v. UOI decided on 25.1.2011, the National Highway Authority of India has not even bothered to file objections and rather satisfied the award. The contention of counsel for the appellant is that non filing of the objections in that case was an administrative goof-up and prays that this case be decided on merits. I am afraid that this argument cannot cut much ice. The National Highway Authority of India is one of the entities which would be covered by the expression ‘State’ under Article 12 of the Constitution and it cannot be permitted to pick and choose in which case it would challenge the compensation and in which case it would not challenge the compensation, specially when adjoining land was acquired vide same notification by the same authority for the same purpose. Resultantly, the appeal against valuation of the land is rejected.

6. There are however two glaring errors. One, grant of severance and second, grant of 18% interest if the awarded amount is not paid within six months. Admittedly, there is no severance and admittedly, the interest had to be paid in terms of the Division Bench Judgment of this Court passed in Golden Iron and Steel Forging v. Union of India, 2011 (4) RCR (Civil) 375. Counsel for the respondents are not in a position to justify how the severance amount could be paid when there is actually no severance or how 18% interest per annum could be awarded. In the circumstances, the awarded amount under severance and the stipulation of conditional interest @ 18% per annum is set aside.

7. Counsel for the respondents however states that if the counsel for the appellants is relying upon the principles enunciated in the judgment of Golden Iron (supra) then they should in all fairness pay solatium at the same rate. Counsel for the appellants has then countered by arguing that land owners are not in appeal. Be that as it may. It cannot be lost sight of that compensation for acquired land is beneficial legislation and if the appellants-authority is relying upon a particular decision and contending that that decision is the basis for computing the compensation then it cannot cherry-pick those portions of the decision which are in its favour and ignore those portions which are not in its favour.

8. In the circumstances, I also direct payment of solatium @ 30% as laid down in Golden Iron' case (supra).

9. Consequently, the appeal is disposed of in the above terms.

10. Since the main case has been decided, the pending civil miscellaneous application, if any, also stands disposed of.