Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

The Indian Performin... v. Union Of India Throu...

Bombay High Court
Feb 27, 2018
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Petitioner, a society registered under Section 33 of the Copyright Act, 1957, challenged initiation of enforcement proceedings under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 ("PML Act"). The impugned notice under the PML Act was issued on the basis of FIR No. 321 of 2014 (for offences under Sections 420, 471 read with 120(B) IPC) lodged by Surendra Sathi against Hasan Kamaal and Omprakash Sonik alleging non-payment of royalty. The Agra FIR by Surendra Sathi was previously quashed with the consent of parties by the Allahabad High Court on 7 November 2017. The Court heard senior counsel for the parties on the question of grant of interim relief and reserved the matter to 1 March 2018, meanwhile granting an ad-interim stay of further proceedings against the Petitioner.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether interim relief should be granted to stay further proceedings under the PML Act against the Petitioner.
  2. Whether offences alleged (Sections 420, 471 and 120(B) IPC), which require mens rea, permit initiation of enforcement proceedings against a juristic person (the Petitioner society).

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Natural Sugar and Allied Industries Ltd. v. Razzak s/o Hazi Gaffar 2006 All M.R. (Cri.) 2822 Juristic person cannot be prosecuted for offences which require mens rea. The court relied on this authority to observe that offences under Sections 420, 471 and 120(B) IPC require mens rea, making prosecution of the Petitioner society problematic.
Motorola Incorporated v. Union of India 2004 Cri.L.JJ. 1576 Juristic person cannot be prosecuted for offences which require mens rea. The court cited this decision for the same principle and applied it in assessing the propriety of proceedings against the Petitioner.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court heard senior counsel on the issue of interim relief. It noted that the Petitioner is a registered copyright society governed by statutory provisions providing a complete code for its functioning and possible cancellation by the Central Government. The impugned PML notice stems from an FIR alleging non-payment of royalty and offences under Sections 420, 471 and 120(B) IPC. The Court observed that mens rea is an essential element of those offences and relied on precedents holding that juristic persons cannot be prosecuted for offences requiring mens rea. The Court further recorded that the Agra FIR had been quashed by the Allahabad High Court with consent on 7 November 2017. Considering these factors, and that the PML proceedings were initiated on the basis of a solitary complaint by a member against erstwhile office bearers, the Court concluded that the initiation of PML proceedings was, at least prima facie, an abuse of process of law, warranting interim protection.

Holding and Implications

Interim stay granted.

Direct effect: All further proceedings insofar as they relate to the present Petitioner are stayed by way of ad-interim order. The matter was stood over to 1 March 2018.

No broader implications or new precedent were articulated in the opinion; the decision provides interim relief to the parties without establishing new law.

Show all summary ...

1. Rule.

2. Heard Mr. Ravi Kadam, learned senior counsel on behalf of the Petitioner and Mr. Shyam Mehta, learned senior counsel on behalf of Respondent No. 1 on the question of grant of interim relief.

3. The Petitioner has approached this Court being aggrieved with initiation of the enforcement case under the provisions of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (for short “PML Act”).

4. The Petitioner is a society duly registered under Section 33 of the Copyright Act, 1957. Perusal of Chapter VII of the Copyright Act, 1957 as well as Chapter XI of the Copyright Rules, 2013 would reveal that a complete code is provided for the functioning of the copyright society. It could further be seen that Central Government, if finds that the society is being managed in a manner detrimental to the interest of the authors and other owners of the right concerned, it is also empowered to cancel the registration of the said society.

5. Perusal of the impugned notice issued under the provisions of the PML Act would reveal that the very basis for proceeding against the present Petitioner is FIR No. 321 of 2014 registered for offences punishable under Section 420, 471 r/w 120(B) of the Penal Code, 1860 (for short “IPC”). The said FIR is placed on record. The said FIR is lodged by one Surendra Sathi against one Hasan Kamaal and Omprakash Sonik stating therein that the said persons had not paid royalty, which was due to the said complainant.

6. For the offences under Section 420, 471 as well as 120(B), mens rea is a necessary ingredient. As held by the this Court in Natural Sugar and Allied Industries Ltd. v. Razzak s/o Hazi Gaffar 2006 All M.R. (Cri.) 2822 and Motorola Incorporated v. Union of India 2004 Cri.L.JJ. 1576 juristic person cannot be prosecuted for offences which require mens rea.

7. Apart from that, it would reveal that in so far as the FIR lodged at Agra by said Surendra Sathi is concerned, the same is already quashed with consent of the parties by the judgment and order dated 7 November 2017, passed by the Allahabad High Court.

8. In any event, we find that on the basis of solitary complaint by one of the members of the Petitioner society against the erstwhile office bearers of the society, a drastic step of initiation of proceedings under the PML Act, is at least, prima-facie, an abuse of process of law.

9. In that view of the matter, by way of ad-interim order, there shall be stay to all the further proceedings qua the present Petitioner. Stand over to 1 March 2018.