Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

Employees Provident Fund Organization Petitioner v. Indore Composite (P) Ltd.

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Aug 1, 2017

1. Heard on the question of admission.

2. By this writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, the petitioner is praying for setting aside of order dated 6/09/2016 passed by the Employees Provident Fund Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi in ATA No. 214(8)2015.

3. As per the case of the Department the establishment M/s. Indore Composite Pvt. Ltd. has paid the provident fund contribution in the year 2005-2006 on the wages lesser than the minimum wages prescribed for the employees under the category of semiskilled. Accordingly, a summon dated 19/05/2008 was issued to the establishment under Section 7A of the Employees Provident Fund & Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 (herein after referred to as “the Act”).

4. The representative of the respondent/establishment attended the enquiry and submitted that the department has not considered non-working days of employees already furnished in form-3A for the year 2005-06. It is also pointed out that there are some employees under the category of unskilled, whereras the department has treated all of them as semi-skilled. The petitioner after considering the aforesaid, directed the establishment to deposit Rs. 87,024/- within 15 days from the receipt of order dated 4/05/2010

5. The aforesaid order was challenged by the respondent by filing appeal under Section 7-I of the Act.

6. The learned Tribunal considering the fact that admittedly vide order dated 15/04/2010, amount of Rs. 87,204/- as assessed by the petitioner under Section 7A of the Act was deposited within the stipulated period by the respondent and as per the opinion of the learned Tribunal there was no delay in remittance of dues and paying the amount of Rs. 87,204/-.

7. The representative of the appellant/establishment made a statement before the learned Tribunal that the establishment is ready to pay damages as assessed by the petitioner for the period April 2010 onwards and, therefore, the learned Tribunal allowed the appeal and set aside the order dated 21/01/2015 and directed the respondent/establishment to pay the damages assessed by the petitioner for the period from April 2010 - May 2010. As per Annexure-A/3, it is this order which has been impugned in the present writ petition..

8. Learned counsel for the petitioner filed number of documents on 19/07/2017 vide Annexure-P/6 to P/8. These documents and proceedings were not part of the record of the learned Tribunal and considering the fact that no objection was made before the learned Tribunal when the respondent made statement that he is ready to pay damages for the period April 2010 - May 2010, the learned Authority allowed the appeal and passed the following order which reads as under:—

3. It is contended on behalf of appellant that previously vide order dated 15.04.2010, respondent assessed amount of Rs. 87,2014/- u/s 7-A of the Act and appellant establishment was directed to deposit that amount within 15 days of receipt of that order. It is further contended on behalf of appellant that after receiving copy of order dated 15.04.2015, appellant without wasting any time deposited amount of Rs. 87,2014/- with the respondent on 15.04.2010, on the same day of passing of impugned order dated 15.04.2010, so there was no delay in remittance of dues for the period Feb. 2006. It is further contended on behalf of appellant that there is delay in remittance of dues on behalf of appellant establishment from April 2010 onwards for which appellant establishment is ready to pay damages as assessed on behalf of respondent so accordingly present appeal may kindly be allowed.

4. On the other hand, it is contended on behalf of respondent that respondent passed impugned order dated 21.01.2015 by following the provisions of law and as there as delay in remittance of dues which was attributed to appellant establishment so respondent was having no option but to pass such order so present appeal may kindly be dismissed.

5. Admittedly vide order dated 15.04.2010, amount of Rs. 87,204/- was assessed by respondent u/s 7-A of the Act. Amount of Rs. 87,204/- was deposited within stipulated period fixed by respondent so this Tribunal reached at a considered opinion that there was no delay in remittance of amount of Rs. 87204/-. As pleaded and argued on behalf of appellant that appellant Establishment is ready to pay damages as assessed by respondent for the period 04/2010 on wards so by allowing present appeal, impugned order dated 21.01.2015 set aside. Appellant establishment is supposed to pay damages assessed by respondent for the period 4/2010 to 05/2013(calculation sheet “Annexure-A/3, page 20 of the appeal). Copy of the order be sent to the parties as per law. File be consigned to the record room after due compliance.

9. On due consideration of the aforesaid on the basis of the fresh documents and affidavit for taking additional documents on record, we cannot direct the establishment to pay damages for the period from March 2006 - April 2010 when all these objections were not taken before the learned Tribunal.

10. Considering the aforesaid, we are of the view that the order passed by the learned Tribunal is just and proper and no case for interference with the impugned order is warranted.

11. The writ petition filed by the petitioner has no merit and is accordingly dismissed.