- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bank of Baroda v. Mandhana Industries Limited
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion concerns applications filed under the Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) for approval of a final resolution plan in respect of a Corporate Debtor undergoing Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP). The CIRP was initiated following admission of a company petition under Section 7 of the IBC on 29 September 2017. The Resolution Professional, Ms. Charu Desai, was appointed to oversee the process, including managing claims of creditors and conducting the resolution plan bidding. The Committee of Creditors (CoC) initially comprised 15 financial creditors, later revised to 16. The Resolution Professional received multiple resolution plans, with Formation Textiles LLC ultimately declared the highest bidder after an outbidding process. The CoC approved the resolution plan of Formation Textiles LLC with 80.92% voting share. A dissenting secured financial creditor, Axis Bank Limited, filed an application challenging aspects of the resolution plan, particularly regarding priority of payments and liquidation value.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Resolution Plan submitted by Formation Textiles LLC complies with the requirements of Section 30(2) and Section 31(1) of the IBC and relevant regulations under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI) CIRP Regulations, 2016.
- Whether the order of moratorium should cease to have effect consequent to approval of the resolution plan under Section 31(3)(a) of the IBC.
- Whether the dissenting financial creditor, Axis Bank Limited, is entitled to receive liquidation value in priority to other financial creditors under the approved resolution plan.
- The validity and legality of clauses in the resolution plan relating to waiver of claims arising during CIRP, payment of liquidation value to dissenting financial creditors, and concessions granted therein.
- The appropriate modifications required to the resolution plan to ensure compliance with amended regulations and applicable laws, including priority of payments and management control.
Arguments of the Parties
Assenting Financial Creditors' Arguments
- Once a resolution plan is approved, all assets of the Corporate Debtor form a common pool; no preferential treatment based on security or creditor status is permissible.
- Reliance on Central Bank of India v. Resolution Professional of Sirpur Paper Mills Ltd. to assert that no discrimination among financial creditors is allowed in a resolution plan and liquidation value provisions apply only during liquidation, not CIRP.
- Reference to deletion of relevant regulation by the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI) in October 2018, removing the obligation to pay liquidation value to dissenting financial creditors.
- Priority payment claims by dissenting creditors would defeat the statutory intent of the resolution process under the IBC.
Axis Bank Limited's Arguments (Dissenting Financial Creditor)
- Axis Bank, holding exclusive charge on Baramati land, contends it should receive proceeds from sale of that security in priority to other financial creditors to protect its secured creditor rights.
- Argued that failure to prioritize payment to Axis Bank risks loss of its security interest if the resolution plan fails and liquidation follows.
- Claimed that priority payment to Axis Bank is just and legal and does not amount to preferential treatment since interest continues to accrue on balance payments for all financial creditors.
- Prayed for deletion of references to payment of liquidation value to dissenting financial creditors in the resolution plan, in light of changed law and NCLAT ruling.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Central Bank of India v. Resolution Professional of Sirpur Paper Mills Ltd. | (a) No discrimination between financial creditors in a resolution plan; (b) Liquidation value provisions apply only at liquidation stage, not during CIRP. | The Court relied on this precedent to reject claims for liquidation value payments to dissenting financial creditors during CIRP and to uphold the principle of equal treatment among financial creditors in the resolution plan. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the resolution plan's compliance with Section 30(2) of the IBC and relevant CIRP regulations, including provisions on payment priority, management control, implementation, and supervision. The plan was found largely compliant, subject to certain modifications. The Court noted the increase in the resolution amount due to an outbidding process, which enhanced the value for stakeholders.
Regarding the dissenting creditor's claim for liquidation value priority, the Court analyzed the legal framework and relied on the NCLAT ruling in Central Bank of India v. Resolution Professional of Sirpur Paper Mills Ltd., as well as the deletion of corresponding regulatory provisions by the IBBI. Consequently, the Court held that liquidation value payments to dissenting financial creditors during CIRP are not permissible and that all financial creditors should be treated equally.
However, the Court acknowledged the secured creditor status of Axis Bank with an exclusive charge on Baramati land and reasoned that priority payment from the sale proceeds of that security to Axis Bank is justified to protect its rights and prevent loss of security. This was distinguished from preferential treatment among financial creditors generally.
The Court directed deletion of clauses in the resolution plan that waived claims arising during CIRP, granted concessions inconsistent with law, or provided for liquidation value payments to dissenting creditors. It also mandated modifications to ensure priority payment to operational creditors as per amended regulations, compliance with applicable laws governing employee rationalization, SEBI approvals, external commercial borrowings, and statutory dues.
Holding and Implications
MA 692/2018 and MA 811/2018 are disposed of.
The Court approved the resolution plan of Formation Textiles LLC under Section 31(1) of the IBC, subject to specified modifications ensuring compliance with statutory provisions and regulations. The order declares the cessation of moratorium as per Section 31(3)(a) of the IBC, making the approved resolution plan binding on the Corporate Debtor, its employees, members, creditors, guarantors, and other stakeholders.
The Court's decision clarifies that liquidation value payments to dissenting financial creditors are not permissible during CIRP, reinforcing equal treatment among financial creditors, except where secured creditor rights are involved, as in the case of Axis Bank's exclusive charge. The ruling emphasizes adherence to amended regulatory priorities, including payment preference to operational creditors and compliance with applicable laws governing corporate management and financial transactions.
No new legal precedent beyond the application of existing law and regulations was established; the decision's effect is limited to the parties and the specific resolution plan before the Court.
MA 692/2018
1. It is an application filed under Section 30(6) read with Section 31(1) of the Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code, 2016 read with Regulation 39(4) of Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Insolvency Resolution Process of Corporate Persons) Regulations, 2016 for the approval of the final resolution plan by this Adjudicating Authority with the reliefs as mentioned below: IN THE NATIONAL COMPANY LAW TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI BENCH MA 692/2018, MA 811/2018 in CP(IB)1399(MB)/2017 (a) Allow the present Application and approve the Resolution Plan of Formation Textiles LLC (Successful Resolution Plan) in terms of Section 31(1) of the Code; (b) Declare that the order of moratorium dated 29 September 2017 shall cease to have effect in terms of Section 31(3)(a) of the Code, consequent to the approval/sanction of the Successful Resolution Plan as prayed hereinabove; (c) Direct that the Successful Resolution Plan approved/sanctioned by this Honble Adjudicating Authority shall be binding on the Corporate Debtor, its employees, members/shareholders, creditors, guarantors and other stakeholders involved in the Successful Resolution Plan; (d) Pass such order or further relief(s) as this Honble Adjudicating Authority may deem fit and proper in facts and circumstances of the case.
2. The applicant herein is a Resolution Professional appointed in this case to carry out the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process in respect to this Corporate Debtor against which a company petition filed under Section 7 of the IBC was admitted on 29.9.2017. The Applicant, Ms. Charu Desai was initially appointed as Interim Resolution Professional and was subsequently confirmed as Resolution Professional. The 180 days time period was expiring on 27.3.2018, so MA 193/2018 was filed for seeking extension of 90 days of Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process. The extension was allowed vide order dated 23.3.2018.
3. The total amount of claims admitted by the Applicant, Resolution Professional in the CIRP of the Corporate Debtor is Rs. 1,183.17 crores details of which are set out herein below: Creditors Claims filed (in Rs.) Amount of claims admitted (in Rs.) Financial Creditors 1,180.95 1,180.95 Operational Creditors: Suppliers 17.38 0.63 Operations Creditors: Workmen & Employees 1.59 1.59 Total 1,199.92 1,183.17 IN THE NATIONAL COMPANY LAW TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI BENCH MA 692/2018, MA 811/2018 in CP(IB)1399(MB)/2017
4. The CoC constituted of 15 financial creditors initially and the composition was revised to 16 financial creditors.
5. The Resolution Professional determined the liquidation value of the company as Rs. 305 crores.
6. Initially, the Resolution Professional received three resolution plans from three applicants namely Finquest Financial Services Limited, Formation Textile LLC and GBTL Limited. Thereafter revised resolution plans were received from Finquest Financial Services Limited and Formation Textile LLC. In the 19th CoC meeting, Finquest Financial Services Limited was declared as highest bidder. A miscellaneous application 651 of 2018 was filed by the Formation Textiles LLC before this Bench challenging the declaration of Finquest Financial Services Limited as the highest bidder. This bench vide its order dated 3.7.2018, directed, inter-alia, Formation Textiles LLC and Finquest Financial Services Limited to outbid each other in the presence of the Resolution Professional and the CoC. As a result of the outbidding, Formation Textiles LLC emerged as the highest bidder. This outbidding process led to maximization of assets of the Corporate Debtor as the money to be brought into the account of Corporate Debtor increased from Rs. 424.48 crores to Rs. 537 crores which translates into 26.5% increase from the original bid value. Initial bid Final bid Finquest Financial Services Limited Rs. 433 crores Rs. 473 crores Formation Textiles LLC Rs 424.48 crores Rs. 537.22 crores
7. The present application has been filed pursuant to the voting held on 06-07 July 2018 whereby the CoC of the Corporate Debtor approved the resolution plan of Formation Textiles LLC by 80.92% voting share. Creditors constituting 17.61% voting share voted against the resolution and 1.46% voting share abstained from voting.
8. The Resolution Applicant Formation Textiles LLC has two shareholders namely Mr. Piyush Viradia and Mr. Jiten Parikh with 80% and 20% shareholding respectively.
9. A resolution plan needs to meet the criteria laid down in Section 30(2) of the IBC along with the regulations 38 and 39 of the IBBI IN THE NATIONAL COMPANY LAW TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI BENCH MA 692/2018, MA 811/2018 in CP(IB)1399(MB)/2017 (Insolvency Resolution Process for Corporate Persons) Regulations, 2016 (hereinafter CIRP Regulations). The table below ascertains the compliance: Sub- clause of S. 30(2) Requirement How dealt with in the Plan (a) Plan must provide for payment of CIRP cost in priority to repayment of other debts of CD in the manner specified by the Board At page 64, clause 3, the plan provides that CIRP Costs of upto Rs. 4 crores shall be paid upfront within
30 days from the Effective Date and such payment will be made in priority to any other repayment. Also at page 68, clause 7.7 Dues of Creditors during CIRP Except clause 5 & 6 above, any liabilities and/or claims that arise between the Insolvency Commencement Date and the Effective Date, shall stand waived, extinguished, abated, discharged in perpetuity as on Effective Date. Directions regarding Clause 7.7 are mentioned below in the order. (b) Plan must provide for repayment of debts of OCs in such manner as may be specified by the Board which shall not be less than the amount payable to them in the event of liquidation u/s Despite the Liquidation value due to the Operational Creditors being NIL, the plan provides for payment as stated below:
a) At page 65, clause 5, the plan provides for payment IN THE NATIONAL COMPANY LAW TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI BENCH MA 692/2018, MA 811/2018 in CP(IB)1399(MB)/2017
53 to Operational Creditors, Workmen and Employees, admitted claims of Rs. 1.59 crores within 30 days of the Effective Date from the cash balance available with the Company.
b) At page 66, in clause 6, the plan provides for payment to other Operational Creditors including statutory creditors, their admitted claims of Rs. 0.634 crores within 30 days of the Effective Date from the cash balance available with the Company. (c) Management of the affairs of the CD after approval of the resolution plan At page 76, in chapter VI, the plan provides for Control of Corporate Debtor. The Resolution Applicant shall take over the management control of the Company and appoint new directors. (d) Implementation and Supervision At page 78, in chapter VII, the plan provides for Implementation and Supervision. At page 76, in chapter VI, inter alia, the plan provides for either extension of Resolution Professionals role for the purpose of monitoring and supervising the plan or appointment of any reputed IN THE NATIONAL COMPANY LAW TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI BENCH MA 692/2018, MA 811/2018 in CP(IB)1399(MB)/2017 firm by the Resolution Applicant. (e) Plan does not contravene any of the provisions of the law for the time being in force. The provisions in contravention have been directed to be deleted. (f) Conforms to such other requirements as may be specified by the Board Details regarding regulations are discussed below. Reference of relevant Reg. Requirement How dealt with in the Plan 38(1) The amount due to the operational creditors under a resolution plan shall be given priority In payment over financial creditors. Since this regulation was amended after the Resolution Plan was filed before this Adjudicating Authority, directions are given below to make compliance with this sub-clause of regulation. 38(1A) Plan shall include a statement as to how it has dealt with the interests of all stakeholders. Including financial creditors and operational creditors, of At page 69, in clause 12, the plan deals with the interests of all stakeholders. 38(2)(a) Plan shall provide the term of the Plan and its implementation schedule At page 78, in chapter VII, the plan provides, inter alia, for term of the plan, approvals required for the plan and compliance with law, indicative timeline for implementation. 38(2)(b) Plan shall provide for the management and At page 76, in chapter VI, the plan provides for Control IN THE NATIONAL COMPANY LAW TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI BENCH MA 692/2018, MA 811/2018 in CP(IB)1399(MB)/2017 control of the business of Corporate Debtor during its term of Corporate Debtor. The Resolution Applicant shall take over the management control of the Company and appoint new directors. 38(2)(c) Plan shall provide for adequate means for supervising its implementation
a) At page 78, in chapter VII, the plan provides for Implementation and Supervision.
b) At page 76, in chapter VI, inter alia, the plan provides for either extension of Resolution Professionals role for the purpose of monitoring and supervising the plan or appointment of any reputed firm by the Resolution Applicant. 38(3) Plan shall contain details of resolution applicant and other connected persons as mentioned in Explanation to this Regulation At page 56, in chapter II, the plan provides for details of the Resolution Applicant and its management. 39(4) Resolution Professional shall submit the Plan to Adjudicating Authority with certification that the contents of the plan meet all the requirements of the IBC and the Regulations At page 366, exhibit V is the certificate of Resolution Professional confirming that the plan meets all mandatory requirements under S.30(2) of IBC and Regulation 38 of the CIRP Regulations. IN THE NATIONAL COMPANY LAW TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI BENCH MA 692/2018, MA 811/2018 in CP(IB)1399(MB)/2017
10. As regards payment to financial creditors, the plan provides for a payment of Rs. 480 crores of which upfront payment of Rs. 175 crores will be made within 30 days of Effective date and balance amount of Rs. 305 which is termed as Balance Payment shall be paid over 6 years as per the terms laid down in the plan.
11. An upfront payment of Rs. 226 crores is to be infused in the Company by way of equity capital of Rs. 76 crores and Rs. 150 crores as Rupee denominated External Commercial Borrowing.
12. As to amendment to the constitutional documents of the Company, the plan provides that the Resolution Applicant will cause necessary amendments to the transactions contemplated in the Resolution Plan.
13. MA 811/2018 has been filed under Section 60(5) of the IBC by a dissenting secured Financial Creditor namely, Axis Bank Limited, constituting voting share of 5.73%, seeking following reliefs:
a) That this Honble Tribunal be pleased to declare that the Applicant is entitled to receive an amount of Rs. 46.70 crores, under the Resolution Plan, as liquidation value due to a dissenting financial creditor seeking direction to the Respondent No. 2, namely the Resolution Applicant- Formation Textiles LLC, to pay the aforesaid amount of Rs. 46.70 crores, to the Applicant in priority to any payment to the financial creditors, within a period of 30 days from approval of the resolution plan by this Honble Tribunal; Pending hearing and final disposal of this Application prayer has been made to direct the Respondent No. 1, namely Charu Desai- the Resolution Professional of Corporate Debtor, not to proceed with the implementation of the resolution plan of the Corporate Debtor.
14. The Counsel for the Assenting Financial Creditors have opposed the reliefs sought in MA 811 of 2018 by arguing that once a resolution plan is approved, all the assets of a corporate debtor form part of a common pool and no preferential treatment can be afforded to any creditor based on its nature of charge over the properties of the Corporate Debtor. Reliance was also placed on Central Bank of India v. Resolution professional of Sirpur Paper Mills Ltd.1, to contend (a) that there can be no discrimination between the Financial Creditors of a Corporate Debtor in a Resolution Plan; (b) that the question of
1 Company Appeal (AT) Insolvency No. 526 of 2018. IN THE NATIONAL COMPANY LAW TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI BENCH MA 692/2018, MA 811/2018 in CP(IB)1399(MB)/2017 granting any liquidation value to a dissenting financial creditor cannot be applied at the stage of Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process and that the provisions of Section 53 would be applicable only at the stage of liquidation. It was also contended that the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India, by a notification dated 5th October, 2018 deleted regulation which provided for the payment of liquidation value to dissenting financial creditors. In view of the Honble NCLATs order and amendment in regulations, the Assenting Financial Creditors submitted that the provisions of Regulation 38(1) of the CIRP Regulations would not be applicable in the case of a Resolution Plan being approved by the Adjudicating Authority. Further, it was contended that seeking priority in payment would defeat the intent of the provisions of resolution process of a Corporate Debtor under the IBC.
15. The Counsel for the Axis Bank, a dissenting Financial Creditor, prayed that it is not pressing relief (a) of MA 811 of 2018 due to change in law. The written submissions filed by Axis Bank make reference to the case of Central Bank of India v. Resolution professional of Sirpur Paper Mills Ltd.2, wherein it was held that: no discrimination can be made between the Financial Creditors in the Resolution plan on the ground that one has dissented and voted against the Resolution Plan or the other has supported and voted in favour of the Resolution Plan. Further that the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India, by a notification dated 5th October, 2018 has deleted Regulation 38(1)(c) of the CIRP Regulations, which provided for the payment of liquidation value to dissenting financial creditors.
16. The Counsel for Axis Bank prayed that in view of the NCLAT ruling and subsequent deletion of the corresponding regulation by the IBBI, the references to payment of liquidation value to dissenting financial creditors, in the Resolution Plan, including but not limited to clause 9, should be deleted.
17. The Counsel for Axis Bank further contended that since the Baramati land is exclusively charged to the Axis Bank as security for the loans given, the proceeds from the sale should be paid to the Axis Bank in priority to the other financial creditors. The
2 Supra n1. IN THE NATIONAL COMPANY LAW TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI BENCH MA 692/2018, MA 811/2018 in CP(IB)1399(MB)/2017 counsel for Axis Bank reasoned it by saying that in case the resolution plan fails after the Baramati land has been alienated and the sale consideration thereof was distributed to all secured Financial Creditors instead of Axis Bank alone; and the Corporate Debtor has to be liquidated subsequent to such sale and distribution, Axis Bank will have lost its rights as a secured creditor (exclusive charge holder) even though it had an exclusive security. Further, that such priority is not resulting in preferential treatment in comparison to other financial creditors since interest continues to accrue in relation to the Balance Payment for all financial creditors.
18. The secured creditors are placed above other creditors in terms of receiving payments. The Resolution Plan provides for sale of security of only Axis Bank while securities of all other creditors are intact so therefore if the sale proceeds of security of Axis Bank, the sole charge holder, is being utilized to make payment, Axis Bank is to be given priority as it is just and legal. Therefore, different treatment given to secured financial creditor Axis Bank regarding priority payment in respect to other creditors is just and reasonable. This Bench is of the considered view that the prayer of Axis Bank, a secured creditor who is losing its security, to receive its share of dues in priority to other creditors is justified.
19. This Bench is of the considered view that following clauses have to be deleted from the Resolution Plan for being non-compliant to law:
a) Clause 7.7 Dues of Creditors during CIRP Except clause 5 & 6 above, any liabilities and/or claims that arise between the Insolvency Commencement Date and the Effective Date, shall stand waived, extinguished, abated, discharged in perpetuity as on Effective Date.
b) Chapter VIII of the resolution plan seeking reliefs and concessions.
c) References to payment of liquidation value to dissenting financial creditors, in the Resolution Plan, including but not limited to clause
20. This Bench further directs that :
a) As to rationalizing employee strength provided for in clause 2 at page 77, the same shall be done as per Industrial Disputes Act and other applicable laws in force. IN THE NATIONAL COMPANY LAW TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI BENCH MA 692/2018, MA 811/2018 in CP(IB)1399(MB)/2017
b) As to SEBI/ stock exchange approvals, the same has to be in accordance with SEBI Regulations i.e. ICDR Regulations, LODR Regulations and other applicable laws.
c) As to External Commercial Borrowing is concerned, the same has to be in accordance with FEMA Regulations, RBI Regulations and other applicable laws.
d) In accordance with amended Regulation 38 of the CIRP Regulations, there shall be a clause providing priority in payment to the operational creditors over financial creditors under a resolution plan for the amount due.
e) The clauses related to payments shall be modified to give priority in payment to Axis Bank from the sale proceeds of Baramati Land.
f) The outstanding statutory dues will be governed as per the respective Acts.
g) The CIRP costs will be paid on actual as applicable as approved by the CoC.
21. In the circumstances, the Resolution Plan approved by the Resolution Professional and the Committee of Creditors with 80.92% voting has been found in conformity Section 30(2) of the IBC along with the regulations 38 and 39 of the IBBI (Insolvency Resolution Process for Corporate Persons) Regulations, 2016 has been approved as per Section 31(1) of the IBC with modifications as stated above.
22. This plan shall be binding on the Corporate Debtor and its employees, members, creditors and other stakeholders as said out under Section 31(1) of the IBC.
23. Accordingly, MA 692/2018 and MA 811/2018 are disposed of.
Alert