- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ranjwant Singh v. Improvement Trust
2) To be referred to the Reporters or not? Yes/No
3) Whether judgment should be reported in the Digest? Yes/No Present:- For the complainants : Sh. S.S. Salar, Advocate For the opposite party : Sh. Neeraj Sharma, Advocate. JUSTICE PARAMJEET SINGH DHALIWAL, PRESIDENT : Earlier, this complaint was dismissed by this Commission, vide order dated 04.08.2015, observing that detailed adjudication was required to determine, whether the complainants are the legal heirs of deceased Bhagwant Kaur, who was original owner of the property on the basis of which the complainants are raising their claim as Local Consumer Complaint No.64 of 2014 Displaced Persons and for this purpose, liberty was granted to the complainants to approach the appropriate Civil Court. The said order was challenged by the complainants before the Honble National Commission, by way of First Appeal No.723 of 2015; which was disposed of, vide order dated 09.05.2019, whereby the order passed by this Commission was set aside, observing as under: As a new fact in the form of a court order in respect of Legal Heirs has come on record, order of the State Commission dated 04.08.2015 cannot sustain and is liable to be set aside. Accordingly the same is set aside and the matter is accordingly remanded to the State Commission for restoring the consumer complaint to its original number and to decide the same on the basis of fresh documents having been filed by the appellant. State Commission is further directed that respondent may also be allowed to file any further documents, if the respondent wants to file including any fresh evidence, if any. The State Commission shall proceed to decide the complaint afresh after considering all the issues and contentions raised by both the parties.
7. In terms of the above observations, F.A. No.723/2015 stands disposed of. Parties are directed to appear before the State Commission on 02.07.2019. After remand of the complaint, both the parties were afforded opportunity to lead further evidence, as per order of the Honble National Commission. The complainant filed Misc. Application No.1389 of 2019 to produce documents Ex.C-17 to Ex.C-19; which was allowed, vide order dated 05.08.2019 and the said documents were taken on record, subject to just exceptions. However, the opposite Consumer Complaint No.64 of 2014 party did not adduce any more evidence. Hence, we proceed to decide this complaint on merits, in accordance with the directions of the Honble National Commission.
2. The complainants, who are brothers, have filed this complaint, under Section 17 of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 (in short, the Act), against the opposite party, seeking following directions to it:
i) to allot a suitable plot, measuring 500 sq.yds. in the Development Scheme, for which the land was acquired on reserve sale price calculated as per annexed Rules OR in any other equally developed scheme of the Trust, if the plot is not available in the said Scheme; and ii) to pay compensation of 44,00,000/-, along with interest from the date of filing the complaint till realization and to pay costs. Facts of the Complaint
3. Brief facts, as set out in the complaint, are that late Smt. Bhagwant Kaur, grandmother of the complainants, was originally resident of Pakistan. She was married to late S. Bachan Singh in Pakistan. After the death of S. Bachan Singh, she was remarried to the grandfather of the complainants, namely S. Inder Singh and from their wedlock, father of the complainants, namely S. Sohan Singh, was born on 10.01.1946 in Pakistan. She, along with her son, migrated to India after partition and settled in Village Taraf Burara, Ludhiana, as the Government allotted land to her in the said village. She owned a chunk of land measuring 1B-6B-9B comprised in Khasra No.466, 2134/463/1 in the revenue estate of Village Taraf Burara, HB, 168, Tehsil and District Ludhiana. She wanted to construct a big residential house in the said land, but could not do so; as Consumer Complaint No.64 of 2014 the opposite party-Improvement Trust Ludhiana (in short, Trust) issued Notification dated 08.06.1973 under Section 36 as well as Notification dated 27.06.1974 under Section 42 of the Punjab Town Improvement Trust Act, 1922 (hereinafter to be referred as 1922 Act), expressing its intention to formulate 400 acres development scheme, known as Model Town Extension Part-II (hereinafter to be referred as Scheme) in the area of revenue estates of Village Taraf Burara, by acquiring land of private persons. Most of the land falling in village Taraf Burara, including the land of late Smt. Bhagwant Kaur, was acquired under the said Scheme. Possession of the said land was taken by the Trust and entry was made in the record. Further, on 27.07.1976, award was passed by the Land Acquisition Collector. For disposal of acquired land, the Trust framed rules under Section 74 of 1922 Act, known as Ludhiana Improvement Trust Land Disposal Rules, 1964 (in short, 1964 Rules) for allotment of alternative plots to the landowners. Hence, Smt. Bhagwant Kaur was duly entitled to an alternative plot under the category of Local Displaced Persons (in short, LDP) on priority basis. She applied for allotment of plot, vide application dated 25.11.1983, and deposited 500/-, vide LIT receipt No.85041 dated 06.08.1985, after proper verification by the Trust. However, no plot/alternative plot was allotted to her. Smt. Bhagwant Kaur died on 28.12.1985 and her entire property devolved upon her son late S. Sohan Singh, father of the complainants. Further, on demise of S. Sohan Singh, the entire property devolved upon the complainants, being his only legal heirs. Later on, the complainants came to know about the order dated 13.11.2002, vide which claim of the father of the complainants for Consumer Complaint No.64 of 2014 allotment of plot under LDP category was rejected. Aggrieved by the same, they approached the Honble High Court, vide CWP No.19459 of 2010 for the quashment of order dated 13.11.2002. The Honble High Court, vide its order dated 29.10.2010, held that the complainants, while seeking the quashing of order dated 13.11.2002, had raised serious disputed questions of facts, which could not be resolved by exercising its writ jurisdiction and accordingly the writ petition was dismissed, with liberty to the complainants to approach an appropriate forum, if so permissible, in accordance with law. Thereafter, the complainants filed civil suit before the Civil Judge Senior Division, Ludhiana. During the pendency of the said civil suit, two letters dated 07.05.2012 and 17.12.2012 were written by the Principal Officers of the Department of Local Bodies, Punjab. It was stated in letter dated 17.12.2012 that the department had gone through letter dated 07.05.2012 moved by Executive Officer of the Trust as well as legal opinion of Legal Adviser Sh. S.S. Grewal and had come to the conclusion that late Smt. Bhagwant Kaur was entitled to plot being LDP and the complainants are her legal heirs, being the sons of late S. Sohan Singh; who was the only child of late Smt. Bhagwant Kaur. Therefore, the complainants are entitled to plot being LDPs and in case they would withdraw the civil suit, the Trust would consider and decide their genuine claim within 15 days. Therefore, the complainants withdrew the said civil suit on 25.02.2014 and, vide letter dated 05.03.2014, requested the Trust to decide their claim, as per those letters. However, despite repeated requests of the complainants, the Trust has not decided their claim till the date of filing of the complaint, without assigning any reason. The action of Consumer Complaint No.64 of 2014 the Trust in not allotting plot to the complainants being eligible under 1964 Rules is totally discriminatory. In case the plot was allotted in 1985, like other landlords, then the maximum cost of construction would come to 200/- per sq.yd. but at the time of filing of the complaint the same is not less than 900/- per sq.yd. As such, the complainants suffered loss due to deficiency in service on the part of the Trust. Hence, the present complaint. Defence of the opposite party
4. Upon notice, the opposite party appeared through counsel and filed reply to the complaint, raising preliminary objections that the complainants are not consumers of the Trust, as defined in Section 2(1) (d) of the Act, as the Trust has neither sold any goods to them, nor they hired or availed any service from it. The Trust only acquired the land of Smt. Bhagwant Kaur under the Scheme; for which the Trust had already paid the compensation to her. The complaint is liable to be dismissed on the ground of limitation. The Trust had taken possession of the land of Smt. Bhagwant Kaur in the year 1976, but she did not apply for allotment of plot under LDP category within the prescribed period. However, one Sohan Singh, who was a stranger and was not holding any General Power of Attorney (GPA) of Smt. Bhagwant Kaur, submitted application dated 29.07.1985 under his signature, along with affidavit, for allotment of plot on her behalf, without any authority and deposited the earnest money of 500/-, vide receipt No.85041 dated 06.08.1985; whereas the complaint has been filed on 31.03.2014 i.e. after 29 years. As per Section 24A of the Act, the complaint could be Consumer Complaint No.64 of 2014 filed within two years from the date of accrual of cause of action. However, since Smt. Bhagwant Kaur never applied for allotment of Plot under LDP category within the prescribed period, so she was not entitled to the same. Furthermore, mere deposit of earnest money does not create any vested right in favour of the complainants, for allotment of the plot under LDP category. It was further pleaded that this complaint is liable to be dismissed for want of pecuniary jurisdiction of this Commission. The complainants have prayed for allotment of suitable plot measuring 500 sq.yds. and also sought compensation of 44,00,000/-, in case the plot is not available; which is highly exaggerated just to bring the complaint within the pecuniary jurisdiction of this Commission. Only a sum of 500/- stood deposited. It is settled proposition of law that the compensation amount cannot exceed the amount deposited or to be refunded. It was further pleaded that the complainants are not LDPs, as defined in the Punjab Improvement Trust (Utilization of Land & Allotment of Plots) Rules, 1983 (in short, 1983 Rules); which came into force with effect from 22.12.1983. Section 16 of 1983 Rules repealed Utilization of Land and Allotment of Plots Improvement Rules, 1975 (in short, 1975 Rules). According to 1983 Rules, the Local Displaced Persons means a person who is the owner of the land for a continuous period of two years immediately before the first publication published under Section
36 of such Scheme. Further, the LDP shall be allotted a residential plot of 100 sq.yds. on reserve sale price, if the area of land acquired is not less than acres, in accordance with the criteria mentioned Consumer Complaint No.64 of 2014 therein; provided he applies for such allotment in Form-A within a period of three years from the date of taking over of possession of land acquired by the Trust. The land of Smt. Bhagwant Kaur measuring 972 sq.yds. (less than acre), was acquired by the Trust for the development of the Scheme. Notification under Section 36 of the Punjab Town Improvement Act was published on 08.06.1973 and Notification under Section 42 of the Punjab Town Improvement Act was issued on 27.06.1974. The award was passed on 27.07.1976 and possession of the land was taken by the Trust. As per Rule 4 (2) of 1983 Rules, a LDP shall be allotted a residential plot, provided he/she applies for such allotment in Form A, along with affidavit and earnest money, within a period of three years from the date of taking over the possession of his land acquired by the Trust. However, Smt. Bhagwant Kaur did not apply within the prescribed period, so she was not entitled to the same. The complainants have alleged a number of documents in the shape of letters, revenue record, certificate and want to examine the witnesses and also raised disputed question of fact, which can only be resolved by way of filing of civil suit in the Civil Court. Decision of CWP No.19459 of 2010, vide order dated 29.10.2010, giving liberty to the complainants to approach the appropriate Forum was admitted. On merits, similar pleas, as raised in preliminary objections, were reiterated. It was further pleaded that at the time of acquisition of land, 1964 Rules were in force and thereafter 1975 Rules came into force. Thereafter 1983 Rules came into force; which repealed 1975 Rules. Sh. Sohan Singh, who was not attorney holder of Smt. Bhagwant Kaur, Consumer Complaint No.64 of 2014 deposited the earnest money of 500/- on 06.08.1985 on her behalf, without any authority. At that time 1983 Rules were applicable. All other allegations levelled in the complaint were denied and it was prayed that the complaint be dismissed with costs. Evidence of the Parties
5. To prove their claim, the complainants tendered in evidence affidavit of complainant No.1 as Ex.CW-1/A, along with copies of documents i.e. jamabandi for the year 1973-74 Ex.C/1, receipt dated 06.08.1985 Ex.C/2, death certificate of S. Sohan Singh Ex.C/3, order dated 13.11.2002 Ex.C/4, order dated 19.10.2010 Ex.C/5, civil suit Ex.C/6, written statement Ex.C/7, replication Ex.C/8, letters Ex.C/9 and Ex.C/10, application dated 25.02.2014 Ex.C/11, statement dated 25.02.2014 Ex.C/12, order dated 25.02.2014 Ex.C/13, letter dated 05.03.2014 Ex.C/14, assessment Ex.C/15 and resolution Ex.C/16. They also produced on record aforesaid documents Ex.C-17 to Ex.C-19 after remand of the case.
6. The opposite party its evidence tendered affidavit of Sh. Supreet Singh Gulati, Chairman, Improvement Trust, Ludhiana, Ex.OP-1/A, copy of letter along with affidavit and proforma of Annexure-A Ex.OP/1, order dated 13.11.2002 Ex.OP/2 and copy of order dated 29.10.2010 Ex.OP/3. Contentions of the Parties
7. We have heard learned counsel for the parties have gone through the record carefully. Consumer Complaint No.64 of 2014
8. Learned counsel for the complainant argued on the lines of the complaint. It was further contended that the land of Smt. Bhagwant Kaur, grandmother of the complainants was acquired by the opposite party on 27.07.1976 under the Scheme for providing residential plots, namely Model Town Extension Part-II. After her death, the rights with respect of acquire land stood transferred to her only son S. Sohan Singh, father of the complainants. After his death, the rights with respect of acquired land stood transferred to his sons i.e. the complainants. Thus, the complainants fall under the category of Local Displaced Person. The 1964 Rules were superseded by 1975 Rules; which were further superseded by 1983 Rules. It was further contended that according to 1963 Rules and 1975 Rules, which were prevalent at that time, the complainants are entitled for allotment of a plot under LDP category. During her lifetime, Smt. Bhagwant Singh applied for allotment of plot under LDP category, by depositing earnest money of 500/-, vide receipt dated 06.08.1982 and completed all the requisite formalities, but no plot had so far been allotted to her or to the complainants, in lieu of her acquired land. The opposite party rejected the claim of S. Sohan Singh, father of the complainants, for allotment of plot, vide order dated 13.11.2002, Ex.C/4. Against that order, the complainants filed CWP No.19459 of 2010 before the Honble High Court, which was dismissed, vide order dated 29.10.2010, Ex.C/5, giving liberty to them to approach the appropriate Forum, in accordance with law. Thereafter, the complainants filed civil suit before the Civil Judge Senior Division, Ludhiana. However, on the basis of Consumer Complaint No.64 of 2014 letters dated 07.05.2012 and 17.12.2012 issued Department of Local Bodies, Punjab, in which the claim was of the complainants was informed to be considered, the complainants withdrew the said civil suit on 25.02.2014. Thereafter, the complainants requested the Trust, vide letter dated 05.03.2014, to decide their claim, but without any effect. Due to deficiency in service on the part of the opposite parties, the complainant suffered mental agony and harassment. Hence, they are entitled to all the reliefs, as prayed for in the complaint. In support of his contentions, learned counsel for the complainants has relied upon following cases:
i). Lata Construction & Ors. v. Dr. Rameshchandra Ramniklal Shah & Anr. 2000 (1) S.C.C. 586; ii) S.B. Kishore v. Union of India AIR 1991 Supreme Court 90. iii) Basawaraj and Anr. v. Special Land Acquisition Officer AIR 2014 SC 746 (SC); iv) Jagdish Rai Vs.State of Punjab 1994 PLJ Page 354;
v) CWP No.940 of 2007 "Ranjit Kaur Vs. Punjab State" decided on 23.07.2007(P & H High Court); vi) Improvement Trust, Ludhiana v. Joginder Singh & Ors. LPA No.821 of 2012, decided on 30.08.2012 (P & H High Court) vii) Gurdev Kaur & Ors. v. State of Punjab & Anr. CWP No.17248 of 1999 decided on 25.04.2001 (P & H High Court); viii) Ranjit Kaur v. State of Punjab & Anr. CWP No.940 of 2007, decided on 23.07.2008 (P & H High Court); Consumer Complaint No.64 of 2014 ix) Improvement Trust & Anr. v. Rajinder Singh Revision Petition No.2165 of 2014 decided on 30.01.2015 (NC);
x) Karnail Kaur v. Punjab Urban Planning and Development Authority & Anr. 2005 (1) CLT-571 (NC) xi) Delhi Development Authority v. Parveen Kumar & Ors. 2015 SCC OnLine NCDRC 1594; xii) Ludhiana Improvement Trust v. Jangir Singh & Ors. First Appeal No. 261 of 2009 & Ors., decided vide order dated 28.01.2014 (NC); xiii) Ludhiana Improvement Trust v. Surinder Singh 2015 SCC OnLine NCDRC; and xiv) Jangir Singh v. State of Punjab Consumer Complaint No.12 of 2008, decided by this Commission on 28.01.2009.
9. Per contra, learned counsel for the opposite party argued on the lines of the reply filed by it. It was further contended that the Trust had already paid the compensation to Smt. Bhagwant Kaur in lieu of her acquired land. The complaint is barred by limitation, as the land Smt. Bhagwant Kaur was acquired in the year 1976, whereas the complaint has been filed on 31.03.2014 i.e. after 38 years. She did not immediately apply for allotment of plot under LDP category within the prescribed period. However, one Sohan Singh, who was a stranger and was not holding any General Power of Attorney (GPA) of Smt. Bhagwant Kaur, submitted application dated 29.07.1985 under his signature, without any authority and deposited the earnest money of 500/-, vide receipt No.85041 dated 06.08.1985. Since Smt. Bhagwant Consumer Complaint No.64 of 2014 Kaur never applied for allotment of Plot under LDP category within the prescribed period, so she is not entitled to the same. The complainants are not LDPs, as defined in 1983 Rules. According to 1983 Rules, the LDP shall be allotted a residential plot of 100 sq.yds. on reserve sale price, on filing of application in Form-A within a period of three years from the date of taking over of possession of land acquired by the Trust. The acquired land of Smt. Bhagwant Kaur (972 sq.yds.) was less than acre. Since no application was filed by Smt. Bhagwant Kaur for allotment of plot under LDP category within the prescribed period, so she was not entitled to the same. It was further contended that at the time of acquisition of land, 1964 Rules were in force, which were repealed by 1975 Rules. Later on, 1983 Rules came into force; which repealed 1975 Rules. Sh. Sohan Singh, who was not attorney holder of Smt. Bhagwant Kaur, deposited the earnest money of 500/- on 06.08.1985 on her behalf, without any authority and, as such, 1983 Rules were applicable at that time. However, the complainants are not proved to be LDPs and, thus, are not entitled to allotment of any plot. There is no deficiency in service on the part of the opposite party and the complaint is liable to be dismissed. Consideration of Contentions
10. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the respective contentions raised by learned counsel for parties.
11. In view of the arguments raised by the learned counsel for the parties and the evidence on record, the following questions arise for disposal of this complaint: Consumer Complaint No.64 of 2014
I) Whether the complainants fall under the definition of Local Displace Person (LDP) as provided under 1964 Rules, 1975 Rules or 1983 Rules? II) How much land of the grandmother of the complainants was acquired? III) Whether the complaint is barred by limitation? IV) Whether the complaint has been filed, by exaggerating the claim, with a purpose to bring the same within the pecuniary jurisdiction of this Commission? Question No.(I) Whether the complainants fall under the definition of Local Displace Person (LDP) as provided under 1964 Rules, 1975 Rules or 1983 Rules?
12. Admitted facts are to the effect that Notification under Section 36 of 1922 Act was issued by the Improvement Trust Ludhiana on 08.06.1973. Another Notification under Section 42 of the said Act was issued on 27.06.1974 and the Award was passed on 27.07.1976.
13. Local Displaced Person has been defined under Rule 2 (b) of 1964 Rules, which reads as under :- "2.(b) Local Displaced Person: means a person whose land has been acquired by the trust for the execution of any scheme under the Punjab Town Improvement Act, 1922".
14. In 1975, the Government of Punjab in exercise of powers conferred under the Punjab Town Improvement Act, 1922, framed new set of rules, namely 1975 Rules, fully described above. As per 1975 Consumer Complaint No.64 of 2014 Rules, the definition of Local Displaced Person (LDP) was changed, which is reproduced below:- 2(a): Local Displaced Person: means a person who is the owner of a property acquired by the Trust for the execution of a Scheme and has been such owner for a continuous period of two years immediately before the first publication of the Scheme by the Trust under Section 36 of the Punjab Town Improvement Act, 1922."
15. Thereafter, the Government of Punjab framed new rules
i.e. 1983 Rules, described above. Definition of Local Displaced Person is given under sub Rule 2 (d), which is reproduced as under: Local Displaced Person means a person who is the owner of any land acquired by the Trust for the execution of any scheme under the Act and who has been such owner for a continuous period of two years immediately before the first publication of such scheme by the Trust under Section 36.
16. Rule 4 of 1983 Rules deals with Reservation of residential plots and multi-storeyed houses and sub Rule 2 of this Rule reads as under: (2) A local displaced person shall be allotted a residential plot on reserve sale price in accordance with the following criteria, provided he applies for such allotment in Form A within a period of three years from the date of taking over the possession of his land acquired by the Trust:
(i) If the area of land acquired is not 100 Square Yards less than acre and is not more than one acre or if the land acquired consists of a dwelling unit even though it is less than acre. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
(v) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Provided that the local displaced persons having a joint khata being co-sharers shall be allotted only one plot taking into account the whole or their joint land acquired. Consumer Complaint No.64 of 2014
17. If we look at the definition of LDP, so far as 1964 Rules is concerned, there is no mention as to from which date the owner of the concerned property is to be taken into consideration. In the definition of LDP given in 1975 Rules, it is mentioned that that LDP must be owner of property two years prior to the issuance of Notification under Section
36 of 1922 Act. Similar definition of LDP is given in 1983 Rules. Admittedly, grand-mother of the complainant applied for allotment of plot on 25.11.1983 and deposited the amount of 500/- on 06.08.1985, vide receipt Ex.C/2. She died on 28.12.1985. The land, in question, vested in the Improvement Trust in the year 1976, when the Award was passed and the possession was taken. In this manner, 1975 Rules have come into play in this case. However, the complainants do not fall under the definition of LDP under these Rules. As per Jamabandi for the year 1973-74, Ex.C-1, ownership of the property, in question, vested in the Central Government, as is evident from column No.4 of this Jamabandi. The Central Government transferred the property, vide mutation No.3025. It means that if the grandmother of the complainants would have been owner of the land prior to 1973-74, then her share should have been in the ownership column, but from perusal of the note given on the above said Jamabandi, it is clear that the land had been transferred in the name of Smt. Bhagwant Kaur, grandmother of the complainants, after 15.06.1973. In this manner, as per definition of LDP, she must be owner of the property two years prior to the issuance of the above said Notification under Section 36. In the present case, Notification under Section 36 of 1922 Act was issued Consumer Complaint No.64 of 2014 on 08.06.1973 and, as such, the complainants were required to prove that the ownership of the land vested in favour of their grandmother on 08.06.1971, but they have failed to produce on record any cogent evidence in the shape of revenue record or any other document to prove so. Thus, we are of the view that grandmother of the complainants did not fall under the definition of LDP, either under 1964, or 1975 Rules or 1983 Rules, when she applied for allotment of the plot. Hence, we hold that the complainants do not fall under the category of LDP and they are not covered under 1964 Rule, 1975 Rules or 1983 Rules. Question No.(II) How much land of the grandmother of the complainants was acquired?
18. Now coming to the question, as to how much land of the grandmother of the complainants was acquired? As per Jamabandi for the year 1973-74, Ex.C-1, the land measuring 7 Biswas, 11 Biswasi was transferred in the name of Smt. Bhagwant Kaur widow of Sh. Bachan Singh (grandmother of the complainants) and one Bant Kaur @ Basant Kaur widow of Sh. Uday Singh. In this manner, share of Bhagwant Kaur, as per this Jamabandi, comes to only 3 Biswas and
15 Biswasi. One Biswa is equivalent to 50 sq.yds. approximately. Thus, are of the said land cannot, in any circumstances, exceed 180 sq.yds. However, in the complaint, the claim has been raised by the complainants for allotment of 500 sq.yds., which is otherwise not permissible. At the most, if the complainants would have been eligible Consumer Complaint No.64 of 2014 for the allotment of plot, then they would have acquired only 150 sq.yds. plot falling in Group-II. However, once we have already come to the conclusion that the complainants do not fall under the category of LDP under 1975 Rules or otherwise, so they are not entitled to allotment of plot of 500 sq.yds. Not only this, since the grandmother of the complainants had deposited only 500/- on 06.08.1985, so 1983 Rules have come into play. As per those Rules, land of the complainants was required to be less than one acre, but the minimum requirement of the acquired land was acre. Since the land of the grandmother of the complainants was less than acre, so on account of this reason also, the complainants are not entitled to allotment of the plot. Moreover, much water has flown since the acquisition of the land till date and, as such, the complainants cannot be allotted the plot at the old rates, which they are claiming. Question No.(III): Whether the complaint is barred by limitation?
19. Now, coming to the point of limitation. Admittedly, the Award was passed on 27.07.1976. Notification under Section 36 of 1922 Act for land acquisition was issued on 08.06.1973. Similar Notification was issued under Section 42 of 1922 Act on 27.06.1974. The claim of one Sohan Singh, GPA of Smt. Bhagwant Kaur, grandmother of the complainants, was rejected by the opposite party, vide order dated 13.11.2002. The complainants did not challenge that order for a considerable long period. However, they filed CWP No.19459 in the year 2010, Ex.C/5, before the Honble Punjab and Consumer Complaint No.64 of 2014 Haryana High Court for quashing the said order dated 13.11.2002. The same was dismissed, vide order dated 29.10.2010, Ex.C/5, giving liberty to the petitioners/complainants to approach appropriate Forum, if so permissible in accordance with law. It was specifically observed in that order that the petitioners had raised serious disputed questions of facts, which cannot be resolved by the Honble High Court, in exercise of its writ jurisdiction. Thereafter, the complainants filed civil suit, Ex.C- 6, in the Court of Civil Judge (Senior Division), Ludhiana in the year 2011. The same was dismissed as withdrawn, vide order dated 25.02.2014, Ex.C/12, in view of the application, Ex.C/11, moved by the complainants in this regard. No liberty was granted to the complainant while dismissing the suit as withdrawn. Without availing liberty while getting the civil suit withdrawn, the complainants are estopped from filing the present complaint before this Commission. We are fortified in this respect from the observations made by the Honble Supreme Court in Ramesh Chandra Sankla & Ors. v. Vikram Cement, (2008)
14 SCC 58, in which was held as follows:- "From the above case law, it is clear that it is open to the petitioner to withdraw a petition filed by him. Normally, a Court of law would not prevent him from withdrawing his petition. But if such withdrawal is without the leave of the Court, it would mean that the petitioner is not interested in prosecuting or continuing the proceedings and he abandons his claim. In such cases, obviously, public policy requires that he should not start fresh round of litigation and the Court will not allow him to re-agitate the claim which he himself had given up earlier." Consumer Complaint No.64 of 2014
20. In Hulas Rai Baij Nath v. Firm K.B.Bass and Co., AIR 1968 SC 111 also, the Honble Supreme Court, after considering the provision of Order XXIII, Rule 1 of CPC, and particularly sub-rule (3) thereof, held that where plaintiff withdraws from a suit without the permission of the Court, he is precluded from instituting a fresh suit/complaint in same subject matter against the same parties.
21. Thus, it is clear that the complainants made attempts; firstly before the Honble High Court; secondly before the Civil Court for allotment of the plot and after withdrawal of the civil suit without obtaining any liberty; and thirdly they have filed the present complaint in this Commission, without any application for condonation of delay in filing the same. From the facts, it is clear that the cause of action arose to the complainants on 13.11.2002, when the claim for allotment of plot was rejected by the opposite party and after lapse of 12 years from the date of rejection of their claim and after 38 years from the date of acquisition of land/passing of Award, the present complaint has been filed in the year 2014 without any application for condonation of delay in filing the complaint; which is highly belated/time barred. Hence, the complaint deserves to be dismissed. Question No.(IV): Whether the complaint has been filed, by exaggerating the claim, with a purpose to bring the same within the pecuniary jurisdiction of this Commission?
22. It also needs to be mentioned that the value of the plot sought to be allotted is much less than 20,00,000/-. However, an imaginary compensation of 44,00,000/- has been sought by Consumer Complaint No.64 of 2014 exaggerating the claim in the complaint, just with a view to bring the complaint within the pecuniary jurisdiction of this Commission. However, we do not want to go into this aspect, once we have already recorded findings on merits that the complainants do not fall under the definition of LDP and they are not entitled to allotment of the plot under the aforesaid Rules and the complaint is barred by limitation. The authorities cited by the learned counsel for the complainants are not applicable to the facts and circumstances of the case.
23. In view of our above discussion, the complaint is dismissed, being devoid of any merit. (JUSTICE PARAMJEET SINGH DHALIWAL) PRESIDENT (MRS. KIRAN SIBAL) MEMBER September 10, 2019. (Gurmeet S)
Alert