Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Kerala State State C... v. Maradu Municipality,...

Supreme Court Of India
Nov 27, 2018
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners received a show-cause notice dated 4 June 2007 directing removal of buildings allegedly situated within a prohibited Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ) area. Instead of responding to the notice, they filed writ petitions before the High Court. A Single Bench allowed those petitions on 10 September 2012. The concerned Municipality filed writ appeals, but the Division Bench dismissed them on 2 June 2015. The present opinion arises in further proceedings where the Supreme Court is examining the correctness of the lower-court orders and the underlying classification of the land under the CRZ Notification of 19 February 1991.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the land on which the petitioners’ buildings are situated falls under CRZ Category I, II, or III as per the 19 February 1991 Notification.
  2. Whether the construction in question is located within a prohibited zone and is therefore illegal.
  3. Whether the High Court erred in granting relief without first requiring the petitioners to exhaust the statutory remedy of replying to the show-cause notice.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted that neither the Single Bench nor the Division Bench of the High Court made a categorical finding on the precise CRZ classification of the area. Because the petitioners claimed the land is in Category II while the Kerala Coastal Zone Management Authority asserted it is in Category III, the Supreme Court determined that a factual inquiry is essential before the legality of the construction can be adjudicated.

To obtain an authoritative finding, the Court constituted a three-member committee comprising:

  • The Secretary to the Local Self Government Department,
  • The Chief Municipal Officer of the concerned Municipality, and
  • The Collector of the District.

The committee is directed to:

  • Hear objections from the affected parties, the Kerala State Coastal Zone Management Authority, and the State Government.
  • Determine the correct CRZ category of the land under the 19 February 1991 Notification.
  • Assess the legality of the constructions and whether they fall within a prohibited zone.

The committee must complete this exercise within two months and submit a report to the Court.

Holding and Implications

Order: The Court constituted a three-member committee to ascertain the CRZ classification and legality of the constructions, directing it to submit a report within two months. The matter is listed for the third week of February 2019.

Implications: The Supreme Court has not finally decided the merits but has initiated an expert fact-finding process. The immediate effect is a temporary remand for factual clarification; no new legal precedent is set at this stage.

Show all summary ...

1. The writ petitions filed questioning the show cause notice dated 4.6.2007 issued for removal of the buildings, which according to show cause notice were falling within the prohibited area of CRZ Category. Various violations were mentioned in the show cause notice. Without availing the remedy of filing reply to the show cause notice, writ petitions were filed directly in the High Court. The Single Bench of the High Court vide its judgment and order dated 10.09.2012, allowed the writ petition. Aggrieved thereby, the Municipality preferred writ appeals before the Division Bench, which were dismissed by the impugned judgment and order dated 02.06.2015.

2. Considering the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, as there is no categorical finding recorded either by the Single Bench or by the Division Bench that whether area in question is in CRZ Category-III, Category-I or Category-II. It was claimed by the petitioner before the Single Bench that they fell within the CRZ Category-II, whereas the case set up by Coastal Zone Management Authority in this Court is that area is of CRZ Category-III. We deem it appropriate to call for the findings on the aforesaid aspect.

3. We constitute a Three-Member Committee consisting of the Secretary to the Local Self Government Department, the Chief Municipal officer of the concerned Municipality and the Collector of the District, to hear the objections and to give a finding in terms of Notification dated 19 February, 1991.

4. Let the Committee hear the affected parties as well as Kerala State Coastal Zone Management Authority and State Government and consider the matter as submitted by the parties and send a report to this Court as to legality of construction and precisely in which category the area in question is to be categorized and whether building is in prohibited zone. Let the exercise be done within a period of two months and a report be submitted to this Court.

5. Let the report be submitted covering the aspect that may be urged by the parties as to the legality of construction.

6. List in the 3 week of February, 2019.