- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Institute Of Companies Secretaries Of India v. Paras Jain .
Factual and Procedural Background
The respondent, having failed the December 2012 final examination for Company Secretary conducted by the Institute of Company Secretaries of India (“ICSI”), sought inspection and certified copies of his answer scripts under the Right to Information Act, 2005 (“RTI Act”). ICSI demanded a fee of Rs 500 per answer book for certified copies and Rs 450 per answer book for inspection pursuant to Guideline 3 framed by its Examination Committee under the Company Secretaries Act, 1980. Contending that only the lower fee prescribed by Rule 4 of the Right to Information (Regulation of Fee and Cost) Rules, 2005 (“RTI Rules”) applied, the respondent filed a writ petition before the Delhi High Court. A learned Single Judge dismissed the petition, but the Division Bench, in a letters patent appeal, quashed Guideline 3 and directed ICSI to levy only the RTI Rules fee. ICSI appealed that decision.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, when a candidate seeks his answer scripts, the applicable fee is (a) the amount fixed by Rule 4 of the RTI Rules or (b) the higher amount fixed by Guideline 3 framed by ICSI under the Company Secretaries Act, 1980.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant (Institute of Company Secretaries of India)
- The RTI Act is applicable, but the special examination guidelines framed under the Company Secretaries Act should prevail for examination-related requests.
- The Division Bench improperly quashed Guideline 3 without any specific prayer from the respondent.
- Restricting ICSI to the nominal RTI fee imposes undue financial strain on the Institute.
Respondent
- When information is sought under the RTI Act, only the fee stipulated in Rule 4 of the RTI Rules can be charged.
- Candidates must have the choice to obtain answer scripts either through the RTI mechanism or under ICSI’s internal guidelines.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court observed that two parallel avenues exist for candidates to access their answer scripts: (i) the RTI Act and RTI Rules, and (ii) Guideline 3 framed under the Company Secretaries Act. These mechanisms are not mutually exclusive. If a candidate applies under the RTI Act, the fee must conform to Rule 4 (Rs 2 per page, etc.). If the candidate proceeds under Guideline 3, ICSI may levy the higher fee (Rs 500 for certified copies; Rs 450 for inspection). Because both regimes can co-exist, the Division Bench’s blanket quashing of Guideline 3 was unwarranted, especially in the absence of any plea for such relief. The court therefore reinstated Guideline 3 while affirming that candidates retain the option to proceed under the RTI Act at the statutory fee. It further noted that ICSI is free to represent to the Government for enhancement of the RTI fee.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL ALLOWED IN PART; GUIDELINE 3 RESTORED; DIVISION BENCH ORDER SET ASIDE.
The decision permits ICSI to charge fees under Guideline 3 when that route is chosen, while compelling adherence to the lower RTI fee when the RTI pathway is invoked. It clarifies the concurrent applicability of internal examination guidelines and the RTI Act, without setting a broader new precedent.
Order
1. This appeal is directed against the order dated 22-4-2014 2014 SCC OnLine Del 7671 of the Delhi High Court wherein, while allowing the letters patent appeal, filed by the respondent herein, it set aside Guideline 3 notified by the statutory council of appellant Institute of Companies Secretaries of India and directed it to charge fee prescribed as per Rule 4 of the Right to Information (Regulation of Fee and Cost) Rules, 2005.
2. The factual matrix of the case is that the respondent appeared in the final examination for Company Secretary conducted by the appellant in December 2012. On being unsuccessful in qualifying the examination, the respondent made an application under the Right to Information Act for inspection of his answer sheets and subsequently, sought certified copies of the same from the appellant. The appellant thereafter has demanded Rs 500 per answer sheet payable for supply of certified copy(ies) of answer book(s) and Rs 450 per answer book for providing inspection thereof respectively as per Guideline 3 notified by the statutory council of the appellant. It is to be noted that the respondent obtained the said information under the Right to Information Act, 2005.
3. Being aggrieved by the demand made by the appellant, the respondent preferred a writ petition before the Delhi High Court wherein the learned Single Judge dismissed 2014 SCC OnLine Del 7672 the petition. A letters patent appeal was thereafter preferred by the respondent wherein, the Division Bench quashed Guideline 3 notified by the appellant and held that the appellant can charge only the prescribed fee under Rule 4, the Right to Information (Regulation of Fee and Cost) Rules, 2005.
4. The short issue before us is when the answer scripts of the appellant's examination are sought whether the fee prescribed under Rule 4 of the Right to Information (Regulation of Fee and Cost) Rules, 2005 payable or that under Guideline 3 of the Guideline, Rules and Procedures for Providing Inspection and/or Supply of Certified Copy(ies) of Answer Book(s) to Students, framed by the Examination Committee of the appellant's statutory council at its 148th meeting held on 14-8-2013.
5. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant argued that it is undisputed that the Right to Information Act, 2005 is applicable to the appellant. However, in light of specific guidelines formulated under the Company Secretaries Act, 1980, the same should be applicable and not that which is provided under the Right to Information Act. He further contends that owing to quashing of Guideline 3 by the Division Bench of the Delhi High Court, the appellant cannot collect any amount of fee except the one prescribed under Rule 4, the Right to Information (Regulation of Fee and Cost) Rules, 2005, which adds to financial strain on the appellant.
6. On the other hand, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent submitted that any candidate who seeks his answer scripts under the Right to Information Act, 2005 can only be charged under Rule 4, the Right to Information (Regulation of Fee and Cost) Rules, 2005. Further, the learned counsel submits that the candidates must have a choice to seek the answer scripts either by the avenue under the Right to Information Act or under the Guidelines of the appellant framed by the Examination Committee of statutory council under the Company Secretaries Act, 1980.
7. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and we have also meticulously perused the record.
8. The appellant is governed by the provisions of the Company Secretaries Act, 1980 and under Sections 15, 15-A and 17, the Examination Committee of the statutory council has framed Guideline 3 providing an avenue to the candidates to either inspect their answer scripts or seek certified copies of the same on payment of the stipulated fees. Guideline 3 stipulates payment of Rs 500 for obtaining certified copies and Rs 450 for seeking inspection of the same:
“3. Fee of Rs 500 per subject/answer books payable for supply of certified copy(ies) of answer book(s) and Rs 450 per answer book for providing inspection thereof respectively. The fee shall be paid through demand draft drawn in favour of “The Institute of Company Secretaries of India”, payable at New Delhi.”
9. On the contrary, Rule 4, the Right to Information (Regulation of Fee and Cost) Rules, 2005 stipulates:
“4. For providing the information under sub-section (1) of Section 7, the fee shall be charged by way of cash against proper receipt or by demand draft or banker's cheque or Indian Postal Order payable to the Accounts Officer of the public authority at the following rates—
(a) rupees two for each page (in A-4 or A-3 size paper) created or copied;
(b) actual charge or cost price of a copy in larger size paper;
(c) actual cost or price for samples or models; and
(d) for inspection of records, no fee for the first hour; and a fee of rupees five for each subsequent hour (or fraction thereof).”
(emphasis supplied)
10. Thus, it is clear that the avenue for seeking certified copies as well as inspection is provided both in the Right to Information Act as well as the statutory guidelines of the appellant.
11. We are cognizant of the fact that guidelines of the appellant, framed by its statutory council, are to govern the modalities of its day-to-day concerns and to effectuate smooth functioning of its responsibilities under the Company Secretaries Act, 1980. The guidelines of the appellant may provide for much more than what is provided under the Right to Information Act, such as re-evaluation, re-totalling of answer scripts.
12. Be that as it may, Guideline 3 of the appellant does not take away from Rule 4, the Right to Information (Regulation of Fee and Cost) Rules, 2005 which also entitles the candidates to seek inspection and certified copies of their answer scripts. In our opinion, the existence of these two avenues is not mutually exclusive and it is up to the candidate to choose either of the routes. Thus, if a candidate seeks information under the provisions of the Right to Information Act, then payment has to be sought under the Rules therein, however, if the information is sought under the guidelines of the appellant, then the appellant is at liberty to charge the candidates as per its guidelines.
13. The appellant has submitted that the Division Bench of the Delhi High Court erred in quashing Guideline 3 which is affecting not only the appellant but also the candidates. Taking into consideration the fact that such quashing was done despite no prayer being made to that effect on behest of the respondent, we hold that quashing of Guideline 3 was unwarranted. It is to this limited extent that we allow the appeal and set aside the impugned order 2014 SCC OnLine Del 7671 of the Division Bench of the Delhi High Court whereby it quashed Guideline 3.
14. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant further submitted that owing to nominal fee fixed under the Right to Information Act, the dissemination of information by the appellant has become financially burdensome and he wants to make a representation to the Government for enhancing the fee prescribed under the Right to Information Act. It is left open to him to make such a representation.
15. The appeal is disposed of in the aforestated terms and pending applications, if any, shall also stand disposed of.
Alert