- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sep Mp Rinkoo v. Union Of India & Ors.
The petitioner has come up before this Court against the order of his dismissal passed on 21.11.2012.
2. The petitioner was enrolled in the Army on 06.09.2010 from recruiting office, IRO Delhi. He reported to CMP Centre of School on 9th September, 2010. He also underwent basic training from 01.10.2010 to 03.03.2012. It appears that certain doubt had arisen in respect of the domicile certificate supplied by the petitioner in which he claimed that he is a resident of Narela (Delhi). He obtained the domicile certificate from Tehsildar, Narela which he had appended with the form. On a suspicion being raised regarding domicile certificate issued in favour of the petitioner, he was put to questioning by Integrated Head Quarters, Ministry of Defence. Based upon the answers to the questions, the respondents came to the conclusion that the domicile certificate submitted by the petitioner was fake. After enquiry from the petitioner regarding the genuineness of domicile certificate issued in his favour, the petitioner was issued a show cause notice on 29.09.2012.
3. In the show cause notice, it was alleged that the petitioner had used a fake domicile certificate. The certificate was issued on the basis of proof that the petitioner had been residing in Delhi for the last three years. This certificate was attested by one Sri Dharm Pal, Principal, Senior Secondary School, Narela. On enquiry being initiated by the respondents, a report was called from the concerned school as to whether the petitioner had studied in the school or not and also whether any certificate was issued by the said Sri Dharmpal. The report from the concerned school was received in which it was clearly stated that no person by the name Sri Dharmpal ever served in the school. Consequently, on that basis the SDM office stated that the domicile certificate issued by the Tehsildar was fake. All these documents were served on the petitioner as enclosures to the show cause notice. The petitioner, in his reply, has stated that the domicile certificate issued in his favour is genuine. Not being satisfied with the reply submitted by the petitioner, a detailed order of dismissal has been issued by the respondents which is subject matter of challenge before this Court.
4. The contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner is that in case a false answer is made by a person at the time of his enrolment, it is necessary to try him by court martial. In this regard, he relied on Section 44 of the Army Act. The essence of the argument is that no other action can be taken against him, except by trying him by the court martial. The second contention raised is that no enquiry in the matter has been conducted.
5. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties. So far as the first contention is concerned, Section 44 of the Army Act envisages that for any false statement made at the time of enrolment, a person can be tried by a court martial. The option is always open to the respondents to resort to administrative action instead of trying a person by court martial. This power is conferred on the authority under Section 20(3) of the Army Act read with Rule 17 of the Army Rules framed under the Act. In view of the above, the first contention raised by the learned counsel for the petitioner cannot be accepted.
6. So far as the second contention that no enquiry has been conducted in the matter of the petitioner, the facts are not in dispute. The petitioner received a show cause notice accompanied by five enclosures which includes the certificate issued by Tehsildar, Narela, the communication addressed by the SDM and the Principal of the School. All these documents have been served on the petitioner and he was required to submit his reply. All that he has stated in his reply is that the domicile certificate issued in his favour was genuine. It is not specifically denied that the letter issued by the Principal of the School as well as by the SDM are based on incorrect facts. The question of enquiry arises only when some disputes would have been raised by the petitioner regarding genuineness of the communication addressed by the SDM and the Principal of the School. Rules of natural justice is not an ideal formality nor it can be resorted to in a routine manner. Unless the petitioner shows that non-observance of rule of natural justice has prejudiced him, it cannot be said that the said rule has been violated. The respondents have considered the reply submitted by the petitioner to the show cause notice and passed a detailed order in this regard. The question of holding an enquiry would arise only if the rule so permits. In the absence of there being any such rule, it cannot be said that a regular inquiry in the matter is necessary. However, if the petitioner is prejudiced on this count, only then some sort of enquiry would be required. The pleadings of the petitioner are also defective. The petitioner has not pleaded what was argued in the court. Since no prejudice has been caused in this behalf, it cannot be said that the rules of natural justice have been violated.
7. In view of the discussions made above, we find no force in the petition. The petition is accordingly dismissed.
Alert