Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Uttar Pradesh Housing And Development Board v. Ramesh Chandra Agarwal .

Supreme Court Of India
May 1, 2019
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, U.P. Awas Evam Vikas Parishad, launched a housing scheme for economically weaker sections in 1982. The respondent registered for the scheme in 1982 by paying ₹500 and paid an additional ₹500 in 1985 when the registration fee was raised to ₹1,000. Clause 5 of the Registration Booklet, Rule 15 and Rule 30 of the U.P. Awas Evam Vikas Parishad-Registration and Allotment of Plots and Houses Rules, 1979, made it clear that registration alone did not guarantee allotment.

A first advertisement inviting written consent from registrants was issued in 1992, yet the respondent submitted no consent. On 30 August 1993—eleven years after registration—the respondent filed a consumer complaint. The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum, Ghaziabad, on 5 April 1995, allowed him the liberty to seek allotment at the then-current price. The respondent appealed to the State Commission (SCDRC) but neither he nor counsel appeared on multiple dates, leading to dismissal on 28 April 2015.

The respondent filed a revision before the National Commission (NCDRC) on 18 August 2016. After directing the appellant to disclose available flats, the NCDRC on 11 December 2018 ordered the appellant to allot the respondent a ground-floor flat in the Mandola Vihar Yojana, Ghaziabad, for ₹2,50,000. The appellant challenged that order before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Does mere registration under the 1979 Rules confer a legal right to allotment of a house or plot?
  2. Was the National Commission justified in compelling the appellant, a statutory housing authority, to allot a flat to the respondent at a fixed price of ₹2,50,000 despite the absence of contract or consent to participate in a draw of lots?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Registration does not create a contractual entitlement; Clause 5, Rule 15 and Rule 30 explicitly negate any guarantee of allotment.
  • Written consent for participation in a draw of lots is mandatory; the respondent never furnished such consent.
  • The respondent waited eleven years before approaching a consumer forum and remained absent before the SCDRC, evidencing laches.
  • The NCDRC order forces the appellant to enter a contract and fixes an arbitrary price unsupported by any legal basis.

Respondent's Arguments

  • He made repeated enquiries but was never informed about available schemes or allotment opportunities.
  • After waiting since 1982, compelling him to pay current market rates would be inequitable; the NCDRC’s directive is fair and just.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court examined the governing documents:

  • Clause 5 of the Registration Booklet—registration does not create any right to allotment.
  • Rule 15—the Board is not bound to allot a house/plot to every registrant.
  • Rule 30—registrants must give written consent for each scheme and only then are they included in a lottery draw; priority rules apply thereafter.

On these provisions, the Court found the respondent had no vested right to allotment. His failure to submit consent letters or participate in draws meant he did not satisfy mandatory conditions. The District Forum had merely allowed him to seek allotment at prevailing rates, not at a concessional or fixed price.

The NCDRC’s directive compelling allotment for ₹2,50,000 had “no rational basis” and amounted to forcing the appellant, a public authority, into a contract absent any contractual obligation. Such an order contradicts settled contractual principles and exceeds the National Commission’s jurisdiction under consumer law.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; NCDRC order dated 11-12-2018 is set aside.

Direct Effect: The respondent is not entitled to a mandatory allotment at the subsidised price; any future allotment must follow the Board’s rules and current pricing. Broader Implication: The decision reinforces that mere registration with a statutory housing board does not create enforceable rights to allotment, and consumer fora cannot compel public authorities to enter contracts outside statutory and contractual frameworks.

Show all summary ...

Dr D.Y. Chandrachud, J.— Leave granted. In 1982 the appellant floated a scheme for economically weaker sections. The respondent deposited an amount of Rs 500, initially in 1982, for registration. Later, in 1985, an additional amount of Rs 500 was deposited when the registration fee was enhanced to Rs 1000. Clause 5 of the Registration Booklet provided as follows:

“The registration of a person does not in any way confer any right or guarantee that the Board is bound to allot a plot or house to him, nor will he be entitled to claim any compensation if he is not allotted the property as desired by him.”

2. The appellant is governed by the U.P. Awas Evam Vikas Parishad-Registration and Allotment of Plots and Houses Rules, 1979 (“the 1979 Rules”). Rule 15 provides as follows:

“15. Board is not bound to allot the houses/plots to every registration holder. Those who are not allotted the land/house by the Board are not entitled to claim the dues/amount spent.”

3. Rule 30 contains the following stipulations:

“30. Sending application form, written consent is necessary.—
(1) In the event of availability of property in any scheme, intimation to that effect shall be published in newspapers through advertisement or written intimation shall be sent to the registered persons through registered post or both means of communication. Apart from description of available proper, date of allotment, draw, place and time shall also be mentioned in the said written intimation.
(2) Application form in prescribed format shall be available at the place mentioned in the aforesaid intimation as well as in the office of Estate Management Officer of the city. Merely getting his/her name registered with the Parishad, the name of a registered person shall not automatically be included in the lottery draw. It would be compulsory for the registered person to submit written consent letter (in prescribed format) for each and every scheme before the date of lottery draw so that his/her name could be included in the draw.
(3) Application form can also be sent through registered post so as to reach in the office concerned before the last date. The Parishad shall not be responsible for postal delay.
(4) The willing buyer must ensure that he is providing true and correct information in the application form. Incomplete and conditional form shall not be entertained. At any point of time, if it is found that the applicant has concealed any vital/relevant fact or has provided incorrect information, his application form shall be subject to rejection and if a plot or house has already been allotted to him/her, the Housing Commissioner shall have the power to cancel his allotment and to make deduction and to impose fine as provided in Rule 45.
(5) Priority will be given to the willing buyers, whose registration was done in first phase over those who were registered in the second phase. Similarly, persons registered in the second phase shall get priority over the buyers registered in the third phase, etc.:
Provided that the Parishad shall reserve the right to invite application for allotment from registered persons of only one phase or more than one phases of any scheme. The Parishad further reserves the right to grant liberty to a particular class to participate in the registration phase. The particular class, so granted liberty, shall take benefit of priority in the registration phase e.g. willing buyers of reserved class, who were registered in the first phase shall get priority over those reserved class buyers who were registered in the second phase.”

4. The first advertisement was published by the appellant in 1992. In terms of the above Rules, registered applicants were required to furnish their written consent for being included in the draw of lots. None was provided by the respondent.

5. The respondent filed a consumer complaint on 30-8-1993, nearly eleven years after the date of registration. In the meantime, a second advertisement was published by the appellant on 15-1-1995. By an order dated 5-4-1995, the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum, Ghaziabad (District Forum) disposed of the complaint by directing that the respondent, at the highest, may secure an allotment, if he so desires at the current value fixed by the appellant. Against this order of the District Forum, the respondent filed a first appeal before the State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (Scdrc).

6. On 25-9-1995, the appellant published an allotment notice indicating the proposed allotment of vacant properties. On 28-8-1996, the appellant enhanced the registration amount and all existing registered applicants were required to pay the difference in order to keep their registration alive for future schemes. On 1-11-2002, the appellant issued an office order providing that those applicants who failed to get an allotment in the draw of lots could be entitled to refund of the registration monies. However, it was made clear that unsuccessful applicants would have to apply afresh for any new scheme.

7. Between 27-10-1998 and 28-4-2015, the appeal filed by the respondent was listed before Scdrc at Lucknow on eight dates of hearing. Neither the respondent nor his counsel appeared. Eventually, by an order dated 28-4-2015, the appeal was dismissed by Scdrc in the absence of any representation by the respondent. The respondent then filed a revision before the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (Ncdrc) on 18-8-2016. During the course of the hearing, the appellant filed an application to place on record relevant documents including the Registration Booklet, the office order dated 1-11-2002 and the 1979 Rules. The appellant also sought to produce copies of the advertisements which were published from time to time.

8. On 26-7-2018 2018 SCC OnLine NCDRC 1173 Ncdrc directed the appellant to explore whether any plots/flats were available in any scheme of the appellant and to place relevant data including the particulars for allotment on affidavit.

9. In pursuance of the above direction, the appellant filed an affidavit on 8-8-2018 indicating the following position.

“That … the flats which are available today are subject to auction wherein the rates are fixed according to the size of the flat, the location of the flat i.e. ground floor, first floor, second floor and third floor. A perusal of the auction booklet of the answering respondent with regard to the aforesaid scheme of the Parishad would show the price at which the left over flats under different schemes are provided to general public. The allotment is done by way of auction and a perusal of the auction rates for Mandola Vihar Yojna, Ghaziabad residential flats is Rs 12.61 lakhs for ground floor; Rs 11.37 lakhs for first floor; Rs 11.23 lakhs for second floor and Rs 11.09 lakhs for third floor.”

10. Ncdrc decided the revision by its order dated 11-12-2018 2018 SCC OnLine NCDRC 1172 which is impugned in the present appeal. A direction has been issued to the appellant to allot a flat on the ground floor in the Mandola Vihar Yojana, Ghaziabad to the respondent subject to his paying a sum of Rs 2,50,000 towards consideration for the flat within a period of six weeks from the date of the passing of the order.

11. Assailing the judgment of Ncdrc, it has been urged by Mr Vishwajit Singh, the learned counsel for the appellant that in the present case the respondent merely got himself registered for allotment. There was no allotment to the respondent. Moreover, it was submitted that the Rules for allotment which have been adverted to earlier, more specifically Rules 15 and 30, indicate that mere registration does not confer an entitlement to the allotment of a flat and every registered applicant is required to furnish written consent for participating in the draw of lots. In the present case, it was submitted that the appellant did nothing of the kind and eventually filed a consumer complaint only after eleven years after the date of registration. The learned counsel submitted that even before Scdrc, the respondent consistently remained absent. Before the Ncdrc, the appellant filed a statement indicating the current prices for the allotment of residential flats in the Mandola Vihar Yojana. It has been urged that Ncdrc by compelling the appellant to allot a flat to the respondent for a sum of Rs 2,50,000 has acted in a manner contrary to law. There was no contract between the appellant and the respondent.

12. On the other hand, the respondent, who appeared in person, has submitted before the Court that after he registered himself with the appellant in 1982, he had from time to time made queries with the appellant in regard to the likelihood of his being allotted a flat in any of the schemes of the U.P. Awas Evam Vikas Parishad. The respondent submitted that he was never informed of any scheme or of any allotment in his favour. The respondent urged that the order which has been passed by Ncdrc is just and equitable. Having waited since 1982 for an allotment, he cannot be now compelled to get an allotment at the current market value.

13. The appellant is governed by the terms and conditions advertised in its Registration Booklet and by the 1979 Rules. Clause 5 of the Registration Booklet indicates that mere registration does not confer a right for allotment. Rule 15 makes a provision to the effect that the Board is not bound to allot a house or plot to every registered holder. Rule 30 indicates that after the Board advertises the availability of a scheme in the newspaper, every registered applicant is at liberty to submit a consent letter for participation in the draw of lots. Mere registration does not oblige the authority to include every registered applicant in the draw of lots. The applicant must show readiness and willingness to participate in a draw of lots in respect of a specified scheme. This is evident from Rule 30(2). A set of priorities is provided in Rule 30(5). In view of the clear position in the brochure and the 1979 Rules, the respondent had no vested right to seek an allotment. As a registered applicant, the respondent was at liberty to seek to participate in the draw of lots by indicating his consent to the appellant. After paying an initial sum of Rs 500 in 1982 and a further sum of Rs 500 in 1985, the respondent did not pursue any remedies until 1993 when he moved the District Forum. The order of the District Forum gave liberty to the respondent to seek allotment at the current market value under any of the schemes of the appellant. Ncdrc was manifestly in error in issuing a direction to the appellant to make an allotment to the respondent for a total sum of Rs 2,50,000 in any of the flats available in the Mandola Vihar Yojna, Ghaziabad. There is no rational basis or justification for the amount of Rs 2,50,000 which has been fixed by Ncdrc. This direction proceeds purely on the basis of the ipse dixit of the forum. The appellant, as a public authority, could not have been compelled to enter into a contract with the respondent. There was no contractual entitlement of the respondent to the allotment of a flat much less for an allotment at a specified price. In its effort to render justice, Ncdrc has adopted a view which is contrary to the basic principles of contract governing the law on the subject.

14. In the circumstances, we allow the appeal. The impugned order 2018 SCC OnLine NCDRC 1172 of Ncdrc shall stand set aside. There shall be no order as to costs.