Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Cadd Systems And Services Private Limited v. Competition Commission Of India .

Delhi High Court
Jul 17, 2019
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, CADD Systems and Services Private Limited, engaged in topographical land survey and related services, was implicated in an alleged cartelization case filed by Nagrik Chetna Manch before the Competition Commission of India (CCI) in March 2017. The allegation involved collusive bidding for Tender No. 338 of 2015 floated by Pune Municipal Corporation for conducting a trees census using GIS and GPS technology, purportedly violating Section 3(3)(d) of the Competition Act, 2002.

CCI initiated an investigation following a prima facie order dated 03.10.2017 and received the Director General's report on 20.09.2019, which concluded collusive arrangements among the petitioner and other parties. After the report was forwarded to the parties on 23.01.2019, replies and objections were filed, and the final hearing was scheduled and adjourned multiple times, with impugned orders dated 23.04.2019 and 08.05.2019 passed by CCI. The petitioner challenged these orders, contending they were passed without the presence of a judicial member, allegedly contravening established legal requirements.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the impugned orders passed by the Competition Commission of India without the presence of a judicial member are valid.
  2. Whether the absence of a judicial member during adjudicatory proceedings before CCI violates the law as laid down by the Division Bench in Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. & Ors v. Competition Commission of India & Anr.
  3. Whether Section 15 of the Competition Act, 2002, which provides that vacancies or defects in the constitution of the Commission do not invalidate its proceedings, applies to the present case.
  4. Whether the doctrine of necessity can be invoked to permit CCI to function and pass final orders despite the absence of a judicial member.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The impugned orders were passed without the presence of a judicial member, contrary to the law established by the Division Bench in Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. & Ors v. Competition Commission of India & Anr.
  • Since the impugned orders are adjudicatory in nature, the presence of a judicial member is mandatory.
  • The Central Government had failed to appoint a suitably qualified judicial member within the stipulated six months, rendering the final hearings invalid.
  • The doctrine of necessity cannot be invoked to justify the CCI’s functioning without a judicial member, as CCI can continue other functions pending such appointment.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The Central Government has accepted the Division Bench’s decision and issued a circular inviting applications for the judicial member position.
  • The functioning of CCI cannot be paralysed due to the vacancy; CCI can continue to operate notwithstanding the absence of a judicial member.
  • Section 15 of the Competition Act, 2002 protects the validity of acts and proceedings of the Commission despite vacancies or defects in its constitution.
  • The Division Bench’s decision in Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. & Ors does not interdict CCI from deciding matters pending appointment of a judicial member.
  • Supreme Court precedents, including B.K. Srinivasan and Ors. v. State of Karnataka and Ors., support that defects in constitution do not invalidate orders if no substantial prejudice results.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. & Ors v. Competition Commission of India & Anr. (W.P.(C) 11467 of 2018) Requirement of judicial member presence during adjudicatory orders by CCI Recognized the necessity of judicial member presence but did not interdict CCI’s functioning pending appointment; directed Central Government to fill vacancies within six months
Tamil Nadu Generation and Distribution Corporation Limited vs PN Power Generating Co. Pvt Ltd.: (2014) 11 SCC 53 Judicial member participation in adjudicatory bodies Referenced by Division Bench to support the necessity of judicial member presence
State of Gujarat v. Utility Users Welfare Association: (2018) 6 SCC 21 Requirement of judicial members in tribunals Supported the Division Bench’s view on judicial member necessity
K.R. Tamizhmani & Ors. v. The State of Tamil Nadu & Ors (MA No. 2217 of 2018 in T.C.(C) No. 137/2015) Clarification on tribunal functioning pending reconstitution Clarified that existing tribunal continues deciding cases until reconstitution after retirement of judicial member
B.K. Srinivasan and Ors. v. State of Karnataka and Ors.: (1987) 1 SCC 658 Validity of acts despite vacancies or defects in constitution of statutory bodies Supported application of Section 15 of the Competition Act to uphold validity of CCI orders despite vacancies

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court acknowledged the petitioner’s reliance on the Division Bench’s decision in Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. regarding the necessity of judicial member presence during adjudicatory orders. However, it observed that the Division Bench did not expressly prohibit the functioning of the CCI pending appointment of a judicial member, nor did it issue a direction to that effect. The Central Government was directed to fill the vacancy within six months, but the Court did not interpret this as an interdiction on CCI's operations during that period.

The Court emphasized the significance of Section 15 of the Competition Act, 2002, which explicitly provides that no act or proceeding of the Commission shall be invalid merely due to any vacancy or defect in its constitution. This statutory provision safeguards the validity of CCI’s orders notwithstanding the absence of a judicial member.

Further, the Court referred to the Supreme Court’s decision in B.K. Srinivasan and Ors., which upheld similar provisions in other statutes designed to prevent challenges based on vacancies or defects in statutory bodies, provided no substantial prejudice is caused.

Considering that the petitioner actively participated in the proceedings and the matter was reserved for orders after hearing submissions, the Court held it was not permissible for the petitioner to seek a rehearing merely due to the absence of a judicial member at the time of the impugned orders.

The Court also rejected the petitioner’s contention that CCI’s functioning would not be paralysed if interdicted from passing final orders, noting that the principal function of CCI is to dispose of cases, and interdicting final orders would effectively halt its functioning, which was not the intent of the Division Bench’s ruling.

Holding and Implications

The Court dismissed the petition as unmerited and disposed of the pending applications.

The direct effect of this decision is that the impugned orders passed by the Competition Commission of India without the presence of a judicial member are valid and binding. The ruling confirms that vacancies or defects in the constitution of the CCI do not invalidate its proceedings or orders, pursuant to Section 15 of the Competition Act, 2002. No new precedent was established beyond affirming the continued functioning of CCI despite such vacancies.

Show all summary ...

$~1 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

+ W.P.(C) 6661/2019 & CM APPL. 28107/2019, 28108/2019

CADD SYSTEMS AND SERVICES PRIVATE

LIMITED ..... Petitioner Through Mr Raj Shekhar Rao, Mr Tushar Gupta, Mr Sumit Mishra, Mr Pramod Singh, Mr Siddharth H. Raval, Advocates. versus

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF INDIA..... Respondent Through Mr Samar Bansal, Mr Devahuti Pathak, Mr Manan Shishodia, Advocates for

CCI.

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIBHU BAKHRU

O R D E R

% 17.07.2019

VIBHU BAKHRU, J

1. The petitioner has filed the present petition, inter alia, impugning the orders dated 23.04.2019 and 08.05.2019 (hereafter 'the impugned orders') passed by the respondent (Competition Commission of India - CCI) in Case No. 12 of 2017 titled as "Nagrik Chetna Manch v. SAAR IT Resources Private Limited and Ors". By the order dated 23.04.2019, CCI adjourned the final hearing of the said case to 08.05.2019. On 08.05.2019, CCI heard detailed arguments and reserved the matter for judgment.

2. The petitioner contends that the impugned orders were passed without the presence of a judicial member and therefore, were in

1

contravention of the law laid down by the Division Bench of this Court in Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. & Ors v. Competition Commission of India & Anr.: W.P.(C) 11467 of 2018. The petitioner contends that the impugned orders are adjudicatory in nature and hence, the presence of a judicial member was mandatory as per the law.

3. The petitioner is a company which is engaged in the business of topographical land survey, differential GPS (DGPS)/ GPS survey, GIS, civil consultancy and supervision of quality control in dam projects.

4. In March, 2017, Nagrik Chetna Manch, filed an information under Section 19(l)(a) of the Competition Act, 2002 (hereafter 'the Act') before CCI alleging cartelization among the petitioner and certain other parties (hereafter 'the Opposite Parties'), who bid for Tender No. 338 of 2015 floated by Pune Municipal Corporation (PMC) for conducting trees census within the PMC jurisdiction area, using GIS and GPS Technology, in contravention of Section 3(3)(d) of the Act.

5. CCI considered the information as filed under Section 19(1) (a) of the Act and passed a prima facie order dated 03.10.2017 under Section 26(1) of the Act, directing the Director General (DG) to conduct an investigation in the said matter.

6. On 20.09.2019, Director General submitted a report to CCI (hereafter 'the DG report') concluding that the petitioner and the other

2

Opposite Parties as named in Case No. 12 of 2017, have acted in an alleged collusive arrangement while bidding for the Tender No. 338 of

2015.

7. The report was considered by CCI on 23.01.2019 and forwarded to the parties, vide order dated 23.01.2019. The parties were directed to file replies/objections to the DG report by 28.02.2019 and to appear for a final hearing before CCI on 27.03.2019.

8. The petitioner filed its replies/objections to the report with CCI on 25.02.2019. One of the Opposite Parties in Case No. 12 of 2017 sought adjournment of the hearing and CCI, vide order dated 07.03.2019, adjourned the final hearing to 25.04.2019.

9. On 23.04.2019, CCI vide the impugned order provided a last opportunity to some of the Opposite Parties (not including the petitioner) to submit copies of their financial statements by 03.05.2019, failing which they would render themselves liable under Section 43 of the Act. Upon request of one of the Opposite Parties, the final hearing was further adjourned to 08.05.2019. Two members and the Chairperson of CCI were present when the impugned order was passed.

10. On 08.05.2019, the Opposite Parties made their respective detailed submissions in the matter. After hearing the said submission, CCI decided to pass an appropriate order in due course. CCI also granted liberty to the parties to file their respective synopsis of arguments within seven days. On the said date, two members and the

3

Chairperson of CCI were present.

11. Mr Raj Shekhar Rao, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner referred to the decision of this Court in Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. & Ors v. Competition Commission of India & Anr.

(supra) and drew the attention of this Court to paragraph 148 of the said decision, wherein the Division Bench of this Court had held that at all times, when adjudicatory orders (especially final orders) are made by CCI, the presence and participation of the judicial member is necessary. He further pointed out that the Court had issued directions to the Central Government to take expeditious steps to fill all existing vacancies in the CCI within a period of six months. He contended that since the Central Government had not appointed a person having the requisite qualification/experience in the field of law, CCI could not hold any final hearings. He also submitted that the doctrine of necessity cannot be invoked as CCI could continue to discharge other functions while awaiting appointment of a judicial member.

12. Mr Samar Bansal, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent countered the aforesaid submissions. He submitted that the Central Government had accepted the decision of the Division Bench of this Court in Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. & Ors v. Competition Commission of India & Anr. (supra) and had issued a circular inviting application from persons with the requisite qualifications for appointment as a judicial member of CCI. He stated that notwithstanding the same, the functioning of CCI could not be paralysed and CCI could function notwithstanding any vacancy. To

4

substantiate his contention, he referred to Section 15 of the Act.

13. He further submitted that in Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. & Ors

v. Competition Commission of India & Anr. (supra), the Division Bench had relied upon the decision of the Supreme Court in Tamil Nadu Generation and Distribution Corporation Limited vs PN Power Generating Co. Pvt Ltd.: (2014) 11 SCC 53 and State of Gujarat v. Utility Users Welfare Association: (2018) 6 SCC 21. He submitted that the Supreme Court had subsequently clarified in the order dated 10.09.2018 passed in MA No. 2217 of 2018 in T.C. (C) No. 137/2015 captioned K.R. Tamizhmani & Ors. v. The State of Tamil Nadu & Ors. that till such time a reconstitution of the Tribunal does not take place arising from a retirement of a member from the legal field, the existing Tribunal will decide all the cases.

14. He submitted that in view of the above clarification, the decision in Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. & Ors v. Competition Commission of India & Anr. (supra) could not be read as interdicting CCI from deciding matters, pending appointment of a member having legal and judicial background. He also referred to the decision of the Supreme Court in B.K. Srinivasan and Ors. v. State of Karnataka and Ors.: (1987) 1 SCC 658 in support of his contention that by virtue of Section 15 of the Act, any defect in constitution would not invalidate the orders passed by CCI.

15. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties.

16. The contentions advanced on behalf of CCI are merited.

5

Although in Mahindra & Mahindra (supra), the Division Bench had unequivocally expressed its opinion that it was necessary for CCI to include a judicial member as observed by the Supreme Court in Utility Users Welfare Association (supra), however, the Court did not interdict the functioning of the CCI pending such appointment. There is no specific direction that was issued to the aforesaid effect. The Central Government was directed to fill the vacancy within the period of six months and it cannot be assumed that the Court had interdicted the working of the CCI during this period.

17. There is also much merit in the contention that the orders passed by the CCI cannot be called into question on account of any vacancy or any defect in the constitution. Section 15 of the Act is relevant and is set out below:-

"15. Vacancy, etc., not to invalidate proceedings of Commission.—No act or proceeding of the Commission shall be invalid merely by reason of—

(a) any vacancy in, or any defect in the constitution of, the Commission; or

(b) any defect in the appointment of a person acting as a Chairperson or as a Member; or

(c) any irregularity in the procedure of the Commission not affecting the merits of the case."

18. The aforesaid Section makes it amply clear that no Act or proceedings of CCI would be invalid by reason of any vacancy or any defect in its constitution. Thus, notwithstanding, that a judicial member is required to be appointed to CCI, the orders passed by the CCI pending such appointment cannot be called into question.

6

19. In B.K. Srinivasan and Ors. v. State of Karnataka and Ors. (supra) the Supreme Court had referred to Section 76-J of the Mysore Town and Country Planning Act, 1961 which expressly provided that

"no act done or proceeding taken under this Act would be questioned on the ground merely of existence of any vacancy in, or any defect in the constitution of the Board or any Planning Authority". The Supreme Court had referred to the said Section 76-J as the Ganga Clause - alluding to the belief of Hindus that waters of Ganga purify, cleanse the sins and remedy all insufficiencies. The Court observed that "provisions similar to Section 76-J are found in several modern Acts and their object is to put beyond challenge defects of constitution of statutory bodies and defects of procedure which have not led to any substantial prejudice."

20. In the present case, the petitioner had participated in the proceedings before CCI and it has reserved orders after hearing submissions made on behalf of the parties. It is clearly not open for the petitioner to now seek a rehearing of the matter after appointment of a judicial member.

21. The petitioner's contention that the functioning of CCI would not be paralysed if it is interdicted from passing final orders, is unmerited. Whilst, it is correct that CCI is also required to pass administrative orders as well, its principal function is to dispose of cases instituted either on an information or complaints. Plainly, interdicting CCI from passing final orders would effectively bring its functioning to a standstill. As observed above, this is not the import of

7

the order passed by the Division Bench of this Court in Mahindra & Mahindra's (supra) case.

22. In view of the above, the petition is unmerited and, accordingly, dismissed. The pending applications are disposed of.

VIBHU BAKHRU, J

JULY 17, 2019

pkv

8