- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Burdge v. Pyne (Inspector of Taxes)
Pennycuick, J.—I have before me an appeal by Mr. William Wyatt Burdge from a decision of the general commissioners whereby they affirmed an assessment to income tax upon the taxpayer for the year 1966-67 in the sum of £2,054 less capital allowances. The assessment was made under Case I of Schedule D in respect of the profit of the trade of a club proprietor carried on by the taxpayer at certain premises known as "The Spinning Wheel," Potley, Corsham. Shortly, the issue is this. The taxpayer contended and contends that £1,410 18s. of the profit assessed represents personal winnings by him at cards at the club, and he says that on that basis the sum of £1,410 18s. ought not to have been brought into the receipts of the club.
2. It will be convenient to read at once the statement of facts as found by the commissioners :
"(a) During 1965 'The Spinning Wheel' was a club and registered as such, providing the usual club facilities including a bar, dancing, cabaret, fruit machines, a card room for gambling and roulette. The roulette had been discontinued in 1966. (b) Any club members or their guests could use the card room, which forms part of the club premises ; a fee (now discontinued) was charged to members and guests for admission to the card room and these fees totalled £350 in 1965. (c) Shortly after the club was opened in 1964, the taxpayer discovered that he was invariably successful at a card game known as Three-Card Brag. During 1965 this was the only game played in the card room. (d) The taxpayer played Three-Card Brag regularly with members in the card room when he was not superintending other club activities. He usually started playing at about 11 p.m. and went on until 4 a.m. or 5 a.m. He was not prepared to lose but had to make a profit because the profits from the other club activities only just covered the overheads. (e) Either the taxpayer or his wife or occasionally his daughter always sat in as a member of a 'school' whenever cards were played; the taxpayer or a member of his family always acted as dealer. (f) When the accounts of the business for the year ended December 31, 1965, were being prepared, a cash shortage was discovered and a balancing figure of £1,410 18s. had to be included in the takings. This figure has been included among the receipts in Exhibit 'A.' A break-down of the cash account for the year to December 31, 1965, is attached hereto marked ' B.' There is no record of this £1,410 18s. in any of the business books or private memoranda of the taxpayer, nor did the taxpayer keep such a sum separate from other moneys."
3. Before going further with the case, I will refer briefly to the two exhibits. The first is a balance sheet and profit and loss account of the taxpayer and his wife in respect of the club business for the year ended December 31, 1965. That account shows a number of receipts, including the £350 in respect of the card room mentioned in paragraph 4(b) of the case stated. It also includes "Bar and catering," "Fruit machines and sundries," "Cover charges," "Roulette" and "Subscriptions." It wholly omits to mention winnings at cards. Then, on the other side, there are the outgoings and the net profit of £1,805. The cash account, which is the other exhibit, shows a deficiency of £1,410 18s. That is the sum which the taxpayer contended represented his winnings at cards, and ought to have been included specifically under that head in the receipt in the profit and loss account instead of somehow being merged in the other items.
4. To continue with the case stated,
"5. We were referred to the case of Graham v. Green [1925] 2 KB 37 ; 9 TC 309.
"6. It was contended on behalf of the taxpayer that (a ) of the said assessment of £2,054 the sum of £1,410 18s. was referable to the taxpayer's personal winnings at the card game of Three-Card Brag ; (b) that such winnings did not constitute a part of the profits of the club and should be excluded from the amount of the assessment.
"7. It was contended on behalf of the Crown that (a ) It had not been established in evidence that the taxpayer made £1,410 18s. winnings at cards during the year to December 31, 1965. (b) In the alternative, if he did make such winnings : (i) such winnings were part of the profits of the business ; and (ii) the assessment should be confirmed.
"8. We, the commissioners who heard the appeal were of opinion that the card playing was carried on systematically in the club organisation and as a commercial undertaking, and we noted that the figure of £1,410 18s. did not appear specifically in the taxpayer's accounts as 'Card winnings.' We, therefore, held that any winnings from the playing of Three-Card Brag formed a part of the regular income of the club and were properly included in the assessment.
We, therefore, dismissed the appeal and confirmed the assessment."
The finding in paragraph 8 is not perhaps quite as lucid as one would like it to be. The commissioners might have accepted the first alternative contention on behalf of the Crown ; that is, that the sum of £1,410 18s. was not winnings at cards at all. However, they do not appear to have done that. What they appear to have done by implication is to have accepted the taxpayer's evidence that the £1,410 18s. did represent card winnings, or at least in part represented card winnings, but to have held that those winnings arose in the course of carrying on the trade of the club. I propose to deal with it on that basis, and upon the view which I take upon that basis there can be no question of remitting the case to the commissioners to make more precise findings of fact.
5. So, upon the findings of fact regarded on the above basis, the taxpayer was carrying on the business of a club; upon the club's premises he habitually played the game of Three-Card Brag with other members of the club ; and at that game he was invariably successful. That does not mean, I suppose, that he succeeded on every hand, but he was successful either every evening or, perhaps, on a slightly broader average of time.
6. Given those facts, it seems to me that the commissioners came to the right conclusion in finding that the winnings of the taxpayer from Three-Card Brag did represent a receipt by him in carrying on the business of the club. He owned the club ; he carried on this game upon the club premises as such ; and, moreover, it was members of the club in whose company he played the game and from whom, it appears, he invariably won money. I see no reason to think that that particular activity on the part of a club proprietor is not an activity in the course of carrying on the business of the club, and consequently winnings from that activity fall into the receipts of the club for the purpose of ascertaining the profits of its business.
7. Mrs. Wilson, who appeared for the taxpayer and said all that there was to say, contended that these winnings should be treated as the fruit of a private activity of the taxpayer outside the business of the club, and accordingly should not be taken into account in computing the profits of the club. In support of her contention she relied upon two cases, to which I must refer. The first is Graham (supra). The headnote in Tax Cases reads:
"Apart from certain bank deposit interest, an individual's sole means of livelihood was, and had been for many years, betting on horses from his private residence with bookmakers at starting prices only. He was assessed to income tax under Schedule D in respect of his betting transactions, and the general commissioners, on appeal, confirmed the assessment. Held, that his winnings from betting were not profits or gains assessable to Income Tax, Schedule D, either under Case I or Case II as from a trade or vocation, or under Case VI."
8. Rowlatt J., in his judgment, considers closely the nature of betting transactions, and he reaches the conclusion that, in the absence of an organisation comparable to that of a bookmaker, betting transactions do not themselves amount to a trade or such an enterprise as would give rise to a charge under Case VI of Schedule D. That case is a long way from the present, because here there is a trade, whereas there the person charged was not carrying on any trade at all.
9. The other case is Down v. Compston [1937] 2 All. ER 475. The headnote there reads:
"The respondent, a professional golfer, had, in addition to his other activities, for a number of years habitually engaged in private games of golf for bets of varying amounts. The respondent was assessed under Schedule D, to include, inter alia, the balance of gains over losses arising out of the bets made on such games, on the ground that the winnings made could not accurately be called mere betting receipts, but were profits arising out of his vocation as a professional golfer. Held: the respondent's winnings did not arise from his employment or vocation, and they were not analogous to gratuities for services rendered, nor was there any organisation to support the view that the respondent was carrying on a business of betting. The assessment ought, therefore, to be discharged."
In that case, it will be seen, Mr. Compston was carrying on a business or profession—namely, that of a professional golfer—but it was held that his private bets with those with whom he was engaged to play rounds of golf could not be said to arise out of his profession as a professional golfer. Lawrence J. said at page 476 :
"The argument for the Crown is, as I understand it, that there is in this case the vocation of a golf professional, and that the winnings on bets on golf matches played by a golf professional are in the course of his vocation as a golf professional, and arise out of that vocation, and that therefore it is not necessary to find that there are so many transactions, or such an organisation of these betting transactions as to constitute a separate employment or vocation in itself ; but it is said that, as the respondent has the vocation of a golf professional, the winnings which he makes in these matches occur in the course of, and arise out of, that vocation, and are therefore taxable, just as much as the Easter offerings of a clergyman or the gratuities of a waiter. On the other hand, on behalf of the respondent it is contended that the winnings of the respondent do not in any true sense arise out of his vocation; they arise from the bets, and not from his vocation as a professional golfer; his vocation as a professional golfer merely affords the opportunity for making the bets, and does not give rise in any proper sense to the winnings from the bets."
10. Then, after considering certain examples given by counsel for the appellant, he said: "I am in agreement with the argument which has been presented for the respondent, and with the decision of the commissioners in this case, and I hold that the winnings of the respondent did not arise from his employment or vocation." Then, finally, he says there was no organisation.
11. So in that case the vocation afforded in some sense the opportunity for making the bets, in that Mr. Compston would not have had companions on his rounds against whom to bet if he had not been a professional golfer, but the bets did not arise out of his vocation. Again it seems to me that that case is wholly distinguishable, for this short, simple reason: that in the present case the club was not merely the occasion which enabled the taxpayer to play private games of cards. The playing of cards was part of the activities of the club, and his winnings from those games of cards, it seems to me, arose in the full sense out of the carrying on of the club.
12. The point is a short one and does not permit of much elaboration. I think that the commissioners came to a correct view even upon the footing, which I think must be implied, that they accepted the evidence that this £1,410 18s. did represent card winnings. I must, therefore, dismiss this appeal.
Solicitors : Robbins, Oling & Lake; Solicitor of Inland Revenue.
Alert