- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
S.R. Thorat Milk Products Pvt. Ltd. v. Cit
Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This is an order by Pradip Kumar Kedia, Accountant Member, concerning five appeals filed by the same assessee against the consolidated order of CIT(A)-III, Pune dated 27.05.2014 relating to assessment years (A.Y.) 2004-05 and 2007-08 to 2009-10 passed under section 143(3) read with section 147 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, and A.Y. 2005-06 passed under section 143(3) read with section 263 of the Act. The appeals were clubbed because they involved identical issues.
Procedurally, the court first addressed preliminary legal objections raised by the assessee in respect of A.Y. 2004-05, 2007-08 and 2008-09 alleging improper compliance with section 147 (and related notices under section 148 and reasons under section 148(2)). For A.Y. 2004-05 the record shows: notice under section 148 issued on 08.07.2010 and served on 26.10.2010; the assessee wrote on 26.11.2010 that the original return be treated as response; the assessee acknowledged receipt of reasons on 18.11.2010; but no legal objections were filed until after 07.12.2011, by which time the Assessing Officer indicated limitation constraints for completing assessment by 31.12.2011. The Assessing Officer did not pass a speaking order on the objections because of these constraints.
On the merits, the principal substantive issue across the appeals was the allowability of interest paid on share application money (SAM) received from shareholders pending allotment. The Assessing Officer disallowed the interest (claimed under sections 36(1)(iii) and 37(1)) on the ground that pending SAM is not a borrowing with an obligation of repayment and that SAM represents capital (not borrowed funds) intended for allotment and expansion of share capital; the AO relied on Supreme Court decisions (Brooke Bond India Ltd. and Punjab State Industrial Development Corpn. Ltd.) to treat such interest as capital expenditure. CIT(A) largely endorsed the AO's factual findings but also recorded detailed fact findings on receipts, allotments, refunds, interest paid and the corporate resolutions.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the legal objections to reasons recorded under section 148(2) were properly required to be disposed of by the Assessing Officer in the circumstances of delay by the assessee (i.e., whether non-disposal rendered subsequent proceedings invalid) — procedural challenge under section 147/148.
- Whether interest paid by the assessee on share application money pending allotment is allowable as a deduction under section 36(1)(iii) or alternatively under section 37(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (i.e., whether such interest is revenue in nature or capital in nature).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's (Assessee's) Arguments
- The assessee's Authorized Representative (AR) argued that share application money pending allotment is in the nature of ordinary funds akin to borrowed funds until actual allotment; until allotment, applicants do not acquire shareholder rights, and the money may legitimately be used for business purposes.
- The AR contended that the obligation to refund the principal is inherent until allotment, and hence interest paid on SAM at a reasonable market rate is an allowable revenue expenditure when the funds were used for business (supported by cash flow and final accounts demonstrating business use).
- The AR relied on precedents (including the Pune ITAT decision in ACIT v. Rohit Exhaust Systems (P.) Ltd.) that supported allowance of interest on SAM on principles of commercial expediency and therefore pleaded for relief.
Revenue's Arguments (Assessing Officer / Departmental Representative)
- The Assessing Officer's case (endorsed by CIT(A)) was that SAM is not a borrowing because the act of receiving SAM is not akin to borrowing and there is no obligation of repayment once allotment is intended — SAM is for allotment and expansion of share capital, so expenditure on interest is capital in nature and not allowable under section 37(1) or as interest on borrowed capital under section 36(1)(iii).
- The AO relied on Supreme Court authorities (Brooke Bond India Ltd. and Punjab State Industrial Development Corporation Ltd.) to support the proposition that interest on SAM is capital in nature and not deductible as revenue expenditure.
- The Departmental Representative (DR) before the Tribunal relied on the orders of the lower authorities (AO and CIT(A)).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| GKN Driveshafts India Ltd. v. ITO [2003] 259 ITR 19 / [2002] 125 Taxman 963 | Directs Assessing Officers to dispose of objections by passing a speaking order — founded on principles of natural justice. | Applied to the procedural objection: the Tribunal noted GKN's direction but held that the assessee had not filed objections within a reasonable time; therefore the failure to dispose by the AO (due to limitation) did not render the objections sustainable and the procedural objection failed. |
| Punjab State Industrial Development Corpn. Ltd. v. CIT [1997] 225 ITR 792 | Authority cited for the proposition that expenditure on interest paid on share application money is capital in nature and not allowable as revenue expenditure. | Relied upon by the Assessing Officer and CIT(A) to treat the interest as capital expenditure; noted by the Tribunal as part of the lower authorities' reasoning but the Tribunal ultimately followed co-ordinate authority to reach a different result on facts. |
| Brooke Bond India Ltd. v. CIT [1997] 225 ITR 798 | Authority cited for the proposition that interest on share application money is capital in nature and not deductible under section 37(1). | Relied upon by the Assessing Officer and CIT(A); Tribunal recorded that these are established decisions relied upon by revenue but, on facts and following co-ordinate bench precedent, allowed the interest. |
| ACIT v. Rohit Exhaust Systems (P.) Ltd., ITA No.686/PN/2011 (Order dated 05.10.2012) (ITAT Pune) | Held that interest on share application money pending allotment is allowable (principle of commercial expediency) where such money was used for business; discussed applicability of Companies Act provisions on interest rates for refunds. | The Tribunal (present order) treated this Co-ordinate Bench decision as squarely covering the issue and followed it to find merit in the assessee's case, deleting the addition in respect of interest on SAM. |
| Western India Forging Ltd. (Pune ITAT, ITA No.419/PN/2002 dated 24-07-2007) | Held that, following commercial expediency, interest on share application money pending allotment is allowable where the funds were used as working capital. | Relied upon by CIT(A) in the Rohit Exhaust decision and by the Tribunal as an influential co-ordinate bench authority supporting allowance of interest; formed part of the chain of authority the Tribunal followed. |
| Hindustan Conductor Pvt. Ltd. — CIT v. Hindustan Conductor Pvt. Ltd. (240 ITR 762) | Cited by the assessee in Rohit Exhaust as supporting allowance of interest where funds are used for business. | Mentioned among authorities cited by the assessee in Rohit Exhaust; the Tribunal in the present order noted Rohit Exhaust relied on various authorities including this one in considering allowability. |
| Kejariwal Enterprises v. CIT (260 ITR 341) | Cited by the assessee in Rohit Exhaust to support allowance of interest when funds are used for business. | Mentioned in Rohit Exhaust's list of authorities relied on by the assessee; the present Tribunal noted the Rohit decision covering the issue. |
| India Cements Ltd. v. CIT (60 ITR 52) | Cited by the assessee in Rohit Exhaust as relevant authority on nature of expenditure. | Mentioned in Rohit Exhaust; the present Tribunal referred to Rohit Exhaust as a co-ordinate bench authority addressing similar facts. |
| Challapalli Sugard Ltd. v. CIT (98 ITR 167) | Cited by the assessee in Rohit Exhaust as supporting authority. | Listed among authorities cited before the tribunal in Rohit Exhaust; the present Tribunal took Rohit Exhaust to be squarely on the point. |
| Shivalik Fuel (P) Ltd. v. CIT [2005] 276 ITR 638 | Decision cited by AO in Rohit Exhaust but the CIT(A) observed it related to computation under section 80J and was not relevant to the issue of deductibility of interest on SAM. | Not treated as relevant by CIT(A) in Rohit Exhaust; noted in the present opinion via reproduction of Rohit Exhaust's discussion. |
| Travancore Titanium Products Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-Tax, Kerala [1978] 114 ITR 626 | Cited by AO in Rohit Exhaust but the CIT(A) observed the case dealt with Companies (Profits) Surtax Act and was not relevant to the present Income-tax Act issue. | Distinguished as not relevant by CIT(A) in Rohit Exhaust; recorded in the present opinion's reproduction of Rohit Exhaust. |
| Addl. CIT v. Bangalore Soft Drinks (P) Ltd. [1980] 126 ITR 38 | Cited by AO in Rohit Exhaust but the CIT(A) observed it related to deduction under section 80J and computation of capital employed, so not relevant to the SAM interest issue. | Distinguished and considered not relevant by CIT(A) in Rohit Exhaust; referenced in the present opinion via Rohit Exhaust. |
| Sales Magnesite (214 ITR 1) | Held that expenditure incurred voluntarily on the ground of commercial expediency to facilitate carrying on of business is deductible under section 37. | Relied upon in Rohit Exhaust (as recounted in the present opinion) to support the proposition that voluntary expenditure for commercial expediency can be deductible; formed part of the reasoning leading to allowance in Rohit. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Tribunal divided its reasoning into two parts: (A) the procedural objection under section 147/148; and (B) the substantive question of deductibility of interest on share application money.
A. Procedural Objection (section 147/148)
- The Tribunal reviewed the chronology for A.Y. 2004-05: notice under section 148 was issued and served; reasons under section 148(2) were acknowledged by the assessee; however, the assessee did not file legal objections within a reasonable time and only sought to raise them belatedly.
- While the Supreme Court in GKN directs Assessing Officers to dispose objections by passing a speaking order (on natural justice grounds), the Tribunal found those directions cannot operate to handicap assessment completion where the assessee itself caused inordinate delay in filing objections. The Assessing Officer faced a limitation embargo and thus could not pass a speaking order before the deadline.
- On that basis, the Tribunal concluded that the procedural objections were unsustainable: the assessee failed to demonstrate timely filing of the objections and therefore cannot shift blame to the Assessing Officer for non-compliance with GKN in the circumstances.
- The Tribunal applied parity of reasoning to A.Y. 2007-08 and 2008-09 and held objections for those years similarly unsustainable.
B. Substantive Issue — Deductibility of Interest on Share Application Money
- The Tribunal identified the single substantive issue as whether interest on SAM is deductible under section 36(1)(iii) or alternatively under section 37(1).
- The Tribunal examined the factual matrix recorded by CIT(A): SAM was received primarily from existing shareholders and relatives; part of SAM was refunded with interest in certain years; allotments were made in some years (notably A.Y. 2004-05 and A.Y. 2007-08); corporate resolutions authorized payment of interest where allotment delayed; accounting and fund-flow statements showed utilization of funds for business and not siphoning off for non-business purposes.
- CIT(A)'s analysis (reproduced in the record) emphasized the intention to allot shares (equity character) and noted that the fact that some funds were used for business does not change their character as intended equity; CIT(A) relied on Brooke Bond and Punjab State Industrial Development Corp. to treat interest as capital in nature and dismissed the claim.
- The Tribunal considered co-ordinate bench authority (Rohit Exhaust Systems Pvt. Ltd.) which had allowed interest on SAM on the principle of commercial expediency where SAM was utilized as working capital, and which relied on Western India Forging Ltd. and Sales Magnesite. The Tribunal found Rohit Exhaust to be squarely on point.
- The Tribunal evaluated the legal character of SAM: it held that SAM per se cannot automatically be equated with share capital prior to allotment because an obligation to return the money is implicit if allotment does not occur, and allotment is subject to statutory regulation. Where the SAM remains unconverted and is used for business, payment of interest on such amounts can be treated as revenue expenditure.
- Given the factual findings on business use and the authority of the co-ordinate bench, the Tribunal concluded the assessee's claim for interest as revenue expenditure deserved acceptance and directed the Assessing Officer to delete the addition made on account of interest on SAM.
- Because the issues and facts were largely parallel across the other assessment years, the Tribunal applied the same reasoning and disposed the other appeals similarly.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Tribunal disposed of the appeals as follows:
- On the procedural point concerning disposal of objections to reasons recorded under section 148(2): the Tribunal held the assessee's preliminary objections for A.Y. 2004-05, 2007-08 and 2008-09 to be unsustainable because the assessee did not raise the objections within a reasonable time; reliance on the GKN direction did not avail the assessee in view of its delay.
- On the substantive issue of interest on share application money: the Tribunal found merit in the assessee's claim and, following co-ordinate bench authority (Rohit Exhaust Systems Pvt. Ltd. and Western India Forging Ltd.), directed deletion of the addition made by the Assessing Officer and allowed the interest as revenue expenditure where the SAM remained unconverted and was utilized for business purposes. In consequence, the assessee succeeded on this substantive issue for all five assessment years under appeal.
- Result: All captioned appeals relating to A.Y. 2004-05, 2005-06, 2007-08, 2008-09 and 2009-10 were disposed of in the terms set out above.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The assessments were to be revised (the Assessing Officer was directed to delete the addition relating to interest on share application money) and the assessee's claim for interest as revenue expenditure was allowed across the appeals on the facts and authorities relied upon.
- Broader precedent: The Tribunal expressly relied on existing co-ordinate bench authority (Rohit Exhaust Systems and Western India Forging Ltd.) in reaching its decision. The opinion does not purport to overrule higher court authority (for example, Brooke Bond and Punjab State Industrial Development Corp. were noted as contrary authorities relied upon by the Assessing Officer and CIT(A)); the Tribunal followed co-ordinate bench precedent rather than creating a new binding precedent of higher status. The opinion does not state that it sets any new legal precedent beyond its application to the facts of these appeals.
End of summary — the above is compiled strictly from the contents of the provided opinion and does not add any external facts or inferences beyond the text reproduced in that opinion.
ORDER
Pradip Kumar Kedia, Accountant Member - The aforesaid captioned five appeals filed by the same assessee are directed against the consolidated order of CIT(A)-III, Pune dated 27.05.2014 relating to A.Ys. 2004-05 and 2007-08 to 2009-10 passed u/s 143(3) r.w.s. 147 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (in short "the Act") and A.Y. 2005-06 passed u/s 143(3) r.w.s. 263 of the Act. Since the issues involved in all these captioned appeals are identical, hence, all these appeals are clubbed together and adjudicated by way of this common order for sake of convenience.
2. Before we proceed to deal with the merits of the case, we shall first dispose of legal objection raised on behalf of the assessee concerning assessment years 2004-05, 2007-08 and 2008-09. The assessee has inter-alia raised preliminarily objections for improper compliance of section 147 of the Act for the assessment years 2004-05, 2007-08 and 2008-09. The Ld. Authorized Representative (AR) for the assessee submitted in the course of hearing that the objections were raised by the assessee against reasons recorded under section 148(2) of the Act, which were not disposed off.
3. To delineate the issue, we shall take the facts concerning the assessment year 2004-05. On perusal of the assessment order, we find that the notice under section 148 of the Act was issued on 08.07.2010 which was duly served on the assessee on 26.10.2010. The assessee vide letter dated 26.11.2010 submitted that original return filed on 21.10.2004 may be taken as return filed in response to notice under section 148 of the Act dated 15.10.2010. As per letter of the assessee dated 18.11.2010, the assessee acknowledged the receipt of reasons recorded under section 148(2) of the Act. The Assessing Officer noted that till 07.12.2011, no legal objections thereof were filed by the assessee. In the circumstances, owing to embargo of limitation for completion of assessment by 31.12.2011, the Assessing Officer observed that no speaking order is needed on the issue. A sequence of events noted above would suggest that the Assessing Officer was restrained from complying with the judicial directions and disposed of objection. Thus, there is no force in the contention of the assessee that objection to reasons recorded ought to have been disposed of irrespective of inordinate delay on the part of the assessee. It is the assessee who has to blame itself for not raising the objection in reasonable time after receipt of the reasons recorded. The blame cannot be shifted on the Assessing Officer for delay on the part of the assessee. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of GKN Driveshafts India Ltd. v. ITO [2003] 259 ITR 19/[2002] 125 Taxman 963 directed the Assessing Officers to dispose of the objections by passing a speaking order. These directions are founded on the principles of natural justice. As noted earlier, in the instant case, the assessee has not been able to demonstrate that the objections were filed within reasonable time where the Assessing Officer has failed to adhere to the judicial fiat of the Hon'ble Supreme Court. Needless to say, the Assessing Officer is under statutory duty to frame the assessment after making such enquiries as it may deem fit in accordance with law. In order to enable him to discharge these statutory responsibilities, it is expected that reasonable time is left at his disposal. The task of completing assessment cannot be made unenviable with barely few days left. We find that the action of the assessee in filing belated legal objection of reasons recorded has led to the present situation for which the assessee itself only has to blame. In the absence of timely response to the notice issued under section 148 and raising the objections within reasonable time after compliance, the assessment process cannot be stifled. The Ld. AR also failed to demonstrate as how the objections disposed of does not meet the requirement of law. Therefore, we find that the legal objections are unsustainable and accordingly decided against the assessee. Following the parity of reasoning in similar facts, the objections of the assessee concerning the assessment years 2007-08 and 2008-09 are also found unsustainable in law.
4. On merits, the solitary issue involved is disallowance of interest expenditure incurred on share application money received from shareholders. The facts germane to the issue are that the assessee is a closely held company. It is engaged in the business of processing of milk and manufacturing of milk products. For the assessment year 2004-05, the assessee claimed interest expenses of Rs.23,04,273/- on account of interest paid on share application money received from existing shareholders pending allotment. Similar interest expenses were claimed on the impugned share application money in other assessment years in appeal. The Assessing Officer questioned the allowability of interest expenditure under section 36(1)(iii) as well as under section 37(1) of the Act. The Assessing Officer built-up the case against the assessee on the ground that ingredients of borrowing by the assessee as a positive act of lending by one and expense thereof by the other, coupled with an obligation of refund or repayment thereof are not present when the interest is paid on receipts in the nature of share application money. As per the Assessing Officer, the amount received being in the nature of share application money, the obligation of repayment of alleged borrowing is totally absent. The Assessing Officer also proceeded against the assessee on the premise that the receipt of amount of share application money is not for the purpose of business of the assessee as the amount represents receipt against allotment and expansion of its share capital. The Assessing Officer observed that share capital is never borrowed but is subscribed. Therefore, the receipt of share application money which is a source of capital for the assessee can neither be characterized as capital borrowed in terms of section 36(1)(iii) nor can be ascribed to have been incurred for business purposes. The Assessing Officer next observed that the share application money has been solely obtained for increasing the capital based on the assessee company as the object of such receipt was to allot the share and thus to increase its share capital. In the light of aforesaid, he relied upon the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Punjab State Industrial Development Corpn. Ltd. v. CIT [1997] 225 ITR 792/93 Taxman 5 and Brooke Bond India Ltd. v. CIT [1997] 225 ITR 798/91 Taxman 26 (SC) to hold that expenditure on account of interest paid on share application money is not of a revenue in nature but a capital expenditure in nature and therefore is not allowable under section 37(1) of the Act. As regards the allowability of the interest expenditure under section 36(1)(iii), the Assessing Officer observed that in the absence of any act of borrowing by the assessee per se conditions laid down under section 36(1)(iii) are not fulfilled. He accordingly disallowed the interest claimed to have been paid at the rate of 12% per annum and added to the total income of the assessee.
5. The CIT(A) also endorsed the findings of the Assessing Officer. The relevant findings from the order of the CIT(A) are reproduced as under :—
| Item | A.Y.2004-05 | A.Y.2005-06 | A.Y.2006-07 | A.Y.2007-08 | A.Y. 2008-09 | A.Y. 2009-10 | |
| SAM received pending allotment | 5,95,70,652 | 3,50,61,817 | 2,66,20,454 | 71,86,490 | 81,80,578 | 1,81,05,056 | |
| SAM allotted | 2,37,05,000 | - | - | 2,99,75,000 | - | - | |
| SAM refunded | 28,72,918 | 1,00,36,101 | 1,90,29,387 | 25,27,797 | - | - | |
| Interest payable | 23,04,273 | 17,78,963 | 13,09,805 | 10,52,770 | 9,65,429 | 14,76,023 | |
| TDS deducted & paid | 2,35,190 | 1,84,225 | Not available | 1,06,657 | 94,021 | 1,52,031 |
6. Aggrieved by the order of the CIT(A), the assessee is in appeal before us for all the five assessment years.
7. The Ld. AR vehemently submitted that amount was received and lying as share application money. Till the time actual allotment of shares are made, it is in the nature of ordinary fund similar to a borrowed fund. It was pointed out that before the allotment is crystallized in favour of the applicants, no right accrues in the capacity of shareholders. Hence, mere receipt of share application money pending allotment thereof cannot be seen differently from ordinary borrowed capital. Till the time, the decision to allot shares against the share application money and subject to fulfillment of other attendant terms and conditions, the assessee cannot be blamed for making payment of interest thereon at a reasonable market rate. The Ld. AR referred to the final accounts and cash flow statements filed with the Paper Book and submitted that a perusal thereof would show that the entire amount has been deployed for business purposes. The interest expenditure incurred to retain the share application money is thus in the revenue field. Therefore, the contention of the revenue that the expenditure is not allowable is not justified. The obligation to refund or repayment of principal amount received is always inherent in such share application money unless there is a positive act on the part of the assessee to convert the share application money into share capital. The Ld. AR submitted that one has to look into the inherent nature of the receipt kept as share application money which is pending allotment. He, therefore, submitted that the revenue has proceeded on an entirely wrong premise and has made wrongful disallowances both under section 36(1)(ii) as well as section 37(1) of the Act. He relied upon the decision of the Pune Bench of ITAT in the case of ACIT v. Rohit Exhaust Systems (P.) Ltd. in ITA No.686/PN/2011 and others, order dated 05.10.2012 which clearly supports the case of the assessee. He accordingly pleaded for suitable relief.
8. The Ld. Departmental Representative (DR) for the Revenue, on the other hand, relied upon the orders of the authorities below.
9. We have carefully considered the rival submissions and perused the orders of the authorities below and case laws cited. The only issue involved is the allowability of interest on share application money under the provisions of the Income-tax Act. We find that the issue is squarely covered by the order of the Co-ordinate Bench of ITAT in the case of Rohit Exhaust Systems Pvt. Ltd. (supra). The relevant paras concerning the issue are reproduced hereunder :—
10. In the light of the decision of the Co-ordinate Bench of ITAT, we find considerable merits in the argument of the assessee. We also find substance in the various contentions raised on behalf of the assessee. We are of the view that the share application money per se cannot be characterized and equated with share capital. The obligation to return the money is always implicit in the event of non-allotment of shares in lieu of the share application money received. Allotment of share are subject to certain regulations and restrictions as provided under the Companies Act. Therefore, receipt by way of share application money is not receipt held towards share capital before its conversion. Therefore, payment of interest of share application money cannot be treated differently in the Income-tax Act. Once the contention of the assessee that the money has been utilized for the purpose of business remains un-converted, there is no justification to hold the issue against the assessee. Accordingly, the claim of interest expenditure on share application money as revenue expenditure deserves to be allowed. The Assessing Officer is thus directed to delete the addition on merits. In the result, the assessee succeeds on this issue.
11. The identical issue has been raised in other appeals pertaining to different assessment years. In view of the parity of facts, the other appeals are also disposed of in the aforesaid noted terms.
12. Resultantly, all the captioned appeals of the assessee relating to assessment year 2004-05, 2005-06, 2007-08 to 2009-10 are disposed off, as above.
jyoti
Alert