- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Income-tax Officer, Ward 7(3), Kolkata v. Shreyans Investments (P.) Ltd.
Structured Summary of the Tribunal Order (Assessing Officer v. Assessee)
Factual and Procedural Background
The Assessing Officer (AO) appealed against the order of the Commissioner (Appeals) dated 8 August 2011 in an assessment made under section 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 for the assessment year 2008-09. The assessee is a company (registered under the Companies Act, 1956) whose return showing a loss was selected for scrutiny. During assessment the AO noticed an increase in share capital and a capital reserve of Rs. 2,06,87,692 appearing in the current year's balance sheet but not in the preceding year. The assessee explained that this amount arose from an amalgamation (with Vidya Vincon Private Limited), effective from 1 April 2007, under a scheme approved by the Calcutta High Court. The AO treated the capital reserve as a benefit taxable as business income under section 28(iv) and added Rs. 2,06,87,692 to the assessee's income. The assessee appealed to the CIT(A), which deleted the addition relying on provisions excluding certain transfers in amalgamation from capital gains (section 47(vi) and 47(vii)) and on accounting/precedential support that such amalgamation reserve is capital in nature. The AO then appealed to the Tribunal; the Tribunal heard the matter and dismissed the AO's appeal, upholding the CIT(A)'s deletion of the addition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the capital reserve of Rs. 2,06,87,692 arising on amalgamation can be treated as a benefit or perquisite taxable as business income under section 28(iv) of the Income Tax Act, 1961.
- Whether transfers involved in the amalgamation fall within the definition of "transfer" under section 2(47)(i) and whether sections 47(vi) and 47(vii) exclude such transfers from capital gains taxation.
- Whether the amalgamation could be regarded as an "adventure in the nature of trade" (i.e., revenue/trading transaction) so as to bring the resulting benefit into the revenue field.
- Procedural/contention points raised by the AO in grounds of appeal: (a) CIT(A) erred in considering section 47(vii) though it was not relied upon during assessment proceedings; and (b) CIT(A) erred in not providing opportunity regarding consideration of section 47(vii).
Arguments of the Parties
Assessing Officer's (Appellant's) Arguments
- The capital reserve of Rs. 2,06,87,692 credited on amalgamation represents a surplus/benefit arising to the amalgamating (transferee) company and therefore is income under section 28(iv) (value of benefit or perquisite arising from business).
- The assets and liabilities of the amalgamated company were taken over resulting in a surplus attributable to the swap ratio; this surplus enhances the assessee's capital reserve and constitutes a tangible benefit to the company (goodwill, leverage for loans, enhanced capability to conduct business and earn profits).
- Given both companies were investment companies with similar (poor) trading performance and no substantive business activity, the amalgamation appears to be motivated by profit-making and thus is in the nature of an adventure in the nature of trade (relying on Rajputana Textiles (Agencies) Ltd. v. CIT on the concept of "adventure in the nature of trade").
- The CIT(A) erred procedurally and legally by relying on section 47(vii) when the assessee had not relied on it during assessment proceedings, and by not providing opportunity concerning that reliance.
Assessee's (Respondent's) Arguments
- The capital reserve arose solely from a court-approved amalgamation scheme; it is the result of merger of accounts and not a benefit, perquisite or advantage of the kind taxable as business income.
- The transaction is a capital account transaction (amalgamation in the nature of merger) — the reserve is akin to share premium or amalgamation reserve and should be treated as capital in nature.
- Relied on statutory provisions excluding transfers in amalgamation from being treated as transfers for capital gains (sections 47(vi) and 47(vii)), accounting standard AS-14 (Accounting for Amalgamation) and precedents finding amalgamation reserve not taxable as income.
CIT(A)'s Findings (as set out in the order under appeal)
- Agreed with the assessee that the transactions are transfers within the meaning of section 2(47)(i) but are excluded from capital gains by section 47(vi) and 47(vii).
- Held that the amalgamation is not an adventure in the nature of trade and that the transaction is a capital account transaction.
- Relied on ICAI AS-14 and an expert opinion indicating the difference on amalgamation should be treated as capital reserve (akin to share premium), and on a Kolkata ITAT decision (ML Dalmia) holding amalgamation reserve cannot be treated as income.
- Deleted the addition of Rs. 2,06,87,692 under section 28(iv).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Rajputana Textiles (Agencies) Ltd. v. CIT [1961] 42 ITR 743 (SC) | Principle that purchase of shares from outset with intention to sell at profit can amount to an "adventure in the nature of trade". | The AO relied on it to argue amalgamation could be an adventure in the nature of trade. The Tribunal rejected its applicability, observing the case concerns share purchase with intent to sell and not an amalgamation by way of merger; thus it does not support treating amalgamation reserve as revenue income. |
| Dy. CIT v. M.L. Dalmiya & Co Ltd [2006] 98 ITD 93 (Kol.) | Authority holding that amalgamation reserve cannot be treated as undisclosed income in the facts of that search/section 158BB context (entries recorded in books and filed before search). | CIT(A) relied on this Kolkata ITAT decision to support that amalgamation reserve is not income. The Tribunal observed the Dy. CIT v. M.L. Dalmiya decision dealt with a different question (additions to undisclosed income under section 158BB) and therefore was not directly on point for the present issue, though the CIT(A) cite supported the capital nature argument. |
| Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. v. CIT [2003] 261 ITR 501 / 128 Taxman 394 | Principle that capital receipts cannot, by logic, be treated as business income under section 28(iv) (example: waiver of principal amount not business income). | The Tribunal relied on this decision to emphasise the distinction between capital and revenue receipts and to support the proposition that capital receipts are outside the scope of section 28(iv) unless a specific provision brings them within income. |
| Padmaraje R Kadambande v. CIT [1992] 195 ITR 877 / 62 Taxman 456 | Principle that amounts which are capital receipts are not income within the meaning of section 2(24). | Cited by the Tribunal to reinforce that capital receipts are not income and therefore cannot be taxed as business income under section 28(iv). |
| Dr K George Thomas v. CIT [1985] 156 ITR 412 / 23 Taxman 46 | Principle that the burden is on the revenue to establish that a receipt is of a revenue nature. | The Tribunal applied this principle to hold that the AO bore the onus of proving the receipt was revenue in nature; since the AO did not discharge this onus, section 28(iv) could not be invoked. |
| CIT v. Seshasayee Bros. (P.) Ltd. [1996] 222 ITR 818 / 89 Taxman 13 | Guidance that receipts referable to fixed capital are not taxable, while receipts referable to circulating capital or stock-in-trade may be revenue in nature. | The Tribunal applied the fixed-versus-circulating capital test from this decision and concluded that the amalgamation-related benefit is referable to capital and therefore not of income nature for section 28(iv). |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Tribunal proceeded on the undisputed factual foundation that the capital reserve in issue arose from a court-approved amalgamation (merger) of Vidya Vincon Private Limited into the assessee, resulting in enhanced assets and liabilities in the books of the transferee company. The Tribunal framed the narrow legal question: whether the transfer/credit of capital reserve on these facts can be considered an income of the assessee under section 28(iv) as a "benefit or perquisite arising from the business".
The Tribunal analyzed section 28(iv) and identified two preconditions for taxability under that provision: (i) there must be a "benefit or perquisite" and (ii) such benefit or perquisite must "arise from the business or exercise of the profession" — in other words it must be of a revenue or business receipt character. The Tribunal emphasized that despite the wide language of section 28, the fundamental distinction between capital and revenue receipts persists and cannot be overridden by broad interpretation.
Applying established precedent (including Mahindra & Mahindra; Padmaraje R Kadambande; Seshasayee Bros.), the Tribunal held that where a receipt is referable to fixed capital (i.e., affects capital structure or non-trading assets), it is a capital receipt and not an income under section 28(iv). The Tribunal noted the onus lies on the revenue (Assessing Officer) to prove that the receipt is of revenue character (citing Dr K George Thomas). Here, the Assessing Officer did not discharge that onus: he asserted benefits (goodwill, borrowing leverage, bolstered image) but did not demonstrate that the receipt was referable to revenue/circulating capital or otherwise arose from the business as a trading receipt.
The Tribunal rejected the Assessing Officer's reliance on Rajputana Textiles (adventure in the nature of trade) as inapposite because that case addressed share purchase with intention to resell, whereas the present matter concerns amalgamation by way of merger. It accepted the CIT(A)'s application of accounting standards (AS-14) and press/authority views that the difference resulting from share swap on amalgamation is capital in nature (akin to share premium/amalgamation reserve).
Because the Tribunal concluded that the alleged "benefit", if any, was capital in nature and not a revenue/business receipt, section 28(iv) could not be invoked. Given this decisive conclusion on the fundamental point, the Tribunal declined to deal with peripheral legal and procedural issues raised by the AO (for example, objections about CIT(A) relying on section 47(vii) or procedural opportunity), calling them academic in light of the main finding.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: The Tribunal upheld the order of the Commissioner (Appeals) and dismissed the Assessing Officer's appeal. In the words of the order: "In the result, the appeal is dismissed."
APPEAL RESULT: APPEAL DISMISSED
Direct consequences of this holding (as stated in the opinion):
- The addition of Rs. 2,06,87,692 to the assessee's income under section 28(iv) has been deleted; that amount was held to be capital in nature and not taxable as business income under section 28(iv).
- The Tribunal accepted that the amalgamation was an amalgamation in the nature of merger, resulting in a capital account transaction and an amalgamation reserve akin to share premium.
- Because the Tribunal decided the appeal on the fundamental issue (capital character of the receipt), it expressly did not adjudicate other peripheral or procedural issues raised by the parties, deeming them academic.
Judge / Member: P. Sen
ORDER
Pramod Kumar, Accountant Member - By way of this appeal, the appellant Assessing Officer has called into question correctness of learned Commissioner (Appeals)'s order dated 8th August 2011, in the matter of assessment under section 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act') for the assessment year 2008-09, on the following grounds:
2. The relevant material facts are not in dispute. The assessee before us is a company registered under the Companies Act, 1956. The return of income filed by the assessee, which disclosed a loss of Rs 1,26,760, was selected for scrutiny assessment under the Computer Aided Scrutiny Selection (CASS) scheme. In the course of these scrutiny assessment proceedings, the Assessing Officer noticed that the company had increased its share capital, and that an amount of Rs 2,06,87,692, which was shown as 'Capital Reserve (other than profit and loss account)', was to shown in the current year's balance sheet, whereas no such amount was reflected in the immediately preceding year's balance sheet. In response to the Assessing Officer's requisition to explain these facts, it was submitted by the assessee that the assessee company was part to am amalgamation scheme, duly approved by Hon'ble Calcutta High Court, wherein one Vidya Vincon Private Limited (VVPL, in short), i.e. amalgamating company, amalgamated in the assessee company with effect from 1st April 2007. It was also explained that the capital reserve of Rs 2,06,87,692 came into existence in the books of the assessee, on account of amalgamation with VVPL. The Assessing Officer, on these facts, called upon the assessee to show cause as to why the amount of Rs 2,06,87,692, being the capital reserve credited by the company on amalgamation, not be treated as income of the assessee under section 28(iv) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The assessee's explanation was that the said amount is neither a benefit, nor a perquisite, nor even advantage of any kind, but simply a result of merger of accounts of amalgamating and amalgamated company. This explanation did not satisfy the Assessing Officer. He rejected the submissions of the assessee, and, in a very scholarly discussion, observed as follows:
3. Aggrieved by the stand so taken by the Assessing Officer, the assessee carried the matter in appeal before the CIT(A). Learned CIT(A) deleted the impugned addition, and observed as follows:
I have gone through the submissions of the A.R. and the order of the AO, I agree with the A/R that the amalgamation of the two companies are consequent transfer of assets of amalgamating company into amalgamated company and issue of shares by amalgamated company to the shareholders of amalgamating company in lieu of transfer of undertaking of amalgamating company are all transfers within the meaning of section 2(47)(i) of Income Tax Act and are to be charged as capital gains on two counts, one in the hands of amalgamating company and secondly in the hands of shareholders of amalgamating company. However, as per section 47(vi) and section 47(vii), these transfers are outside the purview of capital gains.
The legislature in its wisdom has treated certain transactions in course of amalgamation outside the purview of 'transfer' for taxation purposes.
Section 47(vi) specifically states 'any transfer, in a scheme of amalgamation, of a capital asset by the amalgamating company to the amalgamated company if the amalgamated company is an Indian Company'/
Section 47(vii) states that 'any transfer by a shareholder, in a scheme of amalgamation, of a capital asset being a share or shares held by him in the amalgamating company, if-
The amalgamation is not an adventure in the nature of trade. This transaction is clearly a capital account transaction. I further find that ICAI AS-14 (Accounting for Amalgamation) read with Expert opinion published in C.A. Journal (April 2004) has also opined that the difference in the share capital issued by the transferee company on amalgamation and amount of share capital of the transferor companies is of capital nature. Accordingly, the difference should be treated as capital reserve, since it is akin to share premium.
The Kolkata ITAT in ML Dalmia and Company case (supra) has also observed that amalgamation reserve cannot be treated as income of the appellant. Thus, I conclude that amalgamation reserve of Rs.2,06,87,692/- cannot be treated as business income under section 28(iv) of the Income Tax Act. Thus Ground No. 1 is decided in the favour of the appellant.
4. The Assessing Officer is aggrieved, and is in appeal before us.
5. We have heard the rival contentions, perused the material on record and duly considered factual matrix of the case as also the applicable legal position.
6. We find that there is no dispute about the fundamental factual position that it is a case of amalgamation of companies, and it is as a result of this scheme of amalgamation, duly approved by Hon'ble jurisdictional High Court - a copy of which is placed on our records as well, that the capital reserve of the amalgamating company, i.e. VVPL, was shown in the books of accounts of the assessee. The short question that we really need to answer is whether on these facts, the transfer of capital reserve to the assessee company can indeed be considered to be an income of the assessee under section 28 (iv) as a 'business income'. As we deal with this issue, we may also mention that given these facts, as far as learned CIT(A)'s reliance on this Tribunal's decision in the case of Dy. CIT v. M.L. Dalmiya & Co Ltd [2006] 98 ITD 93 (Kol.) is concerned, it is really out of place inasmuch as the question before the Tribunal in the said case whether an addition, in respect of entries pertaining to inter alia share amalgamation reserve, can be made to the 'undisclosed income' under section 158 BB - particularly when all the relevant details were furnished at the time of regular assessment proceedings. Answering this question, the co-ordinate bench observed that, "Coming to the merits of the case, we find that the learned CIT(A) has deleted the addition observing that the addition made by the Assessing Officer on account of undisclosed income was not justified at all as all the transactions pertaining to the share amalgamation reserve and share application money were duly recorded in the books of accounts and were filed before the date of search in the form of account and were filed before the income tax department before the date of search and in the form of audited statement, and, therefore, the same cannot be taxed as undisclosed income of the assessee" [emphasis by underlining supplied by us now]. Be that as it may, let us come back to the question that we have posed for our ourselves and the question, which, in our humble understanding, is decisive factor in this appeal.
7. Section 28 sets out the incomes which are chargeable to income-tax under the head 'Profits and gains of business and profession', and clause (iv) thereto refers to "the value of any benefit or perquisite, whether convertible into money or not, arising from the business or exercise of a profession". It is thus clear that besides the profits and gains from business and profession carried on by the assessee at any time during the previous year, any other benefit or perquisite, whether convertible into money or not, is also chargeable to tax under this head of income. A plain reading of this provision shows two conditions precedents for such taxability i.e. (i) that there should be benefits or perquisites; and that (ii) that such benefits or perquisites should arise from the business or exercise of the profession. The expression 'arising from the business' essentially implies that the benefit or perquisite must be in the nature of a business receipt or revenue receipt. No matter how wide be the scope of Section 28(iv), the difference between a capital receipt and revenue receipt cannot be overlooked. In the case of Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. v. CIT [2003] 261 ITR 501/128 Taxman 394 , Hon'ble Bombay High Court has, in the context of this significant distinction between revenue and capital receipts, held that waiver of principal amount in respect of imports of plant and machinery could, by no stretch of logic, be treated as 'business income', and, therefore, as an income taxable under section 28(iv). One must bear in mind the fact that section 28 only refers to the "income" which can be charged to income tax under the head "profits and gains from business or profession", and, therefore, when a particular advantage, perquisite or receipt is not in the nature of income, there cannot be any occasion to bring the same to tax under section 28(iv). Hon'ble Supreme Court, in the case of Padmaraje R Kadambande v. CIT [1992] 195 ITR 877/62 Taxman 456 observed that, "…we hold that the amounts received by the assessee during the financial year in question have to be regarded as capital receipts, and, therefore, are not income within meaning of section 2(24) of the Income Tax Act." (Emphasis by underlining supplied by us). This clearly shows, as is the settled law, that a capital receipt, in principle, is outside the scope of income chargeable to tax. Of course, there are specific provisions under the Income Tax Act which provide that certain capital receipts can also be considered as income, such as under section 2 (24)(vi) which covers "any capital gains chargeable under section 45", but right now we are confined to normal connotations of the expression 'income'. Howsoever liberal or narrow be the interpretation of expression 'income', it cannot alter character of a receipt, i.e. convert a capital receipt into revenue receipt or vice versa. The crucial distinction between capital and revenue cannot be blurred or nullified by even the most liberal interpretation of expression 'income'. It is also important to bear in mind that, as held by Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Dr K George Thomas v. CIT [1985] 156 ITR 412/23 Taxman 46 , "the burden is on the revenue to establish that the receipt is of a revenue nature" though "once a receipt is found to be of revenue character, whether it comes under exemption or not, it is for the revenue to establish". It is thus clear that capital receipts are inherently outside the scope of an income which can be taxed under section 28(iv), and Hon'ble Bombay High Court, in the case of Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. (supra) also holds so. As to what constitutes capital receipt, we find guidance from Hon'ble Madras High Court's judgment in the case of CIT v. Seshasayee Bros. (P.) Ltd. [1996] 222 ITR 818/89 Taxman 13 wherein Their Lordships, after elaborately surveying the legal precedents on this issue, concluded that, "Thus, a combined reading of the abovesaid judicial pronouncements would go to show that when a receipt is referable to fixed capital, it is not taxable, and it is taxable as a revenue receipt when it is referable to circulating capital or stock in trade". To sum up, unless it is a revenue receipt, it cannot be in the nature of income [except in a situations in which capital receipts are specifically included in the definition of income such as under section 2(24)(vi)], and unless it is in nature of income, it cannot be considered for taxation under section 28(iv). The reference to benefits which can be brought to tax under section 28(iv) for benefits 'arising from the business' also indicates that such benefit must be a business receipt, or revenue receipt, in nature.
8. To find out whether or not the benefit, even if that be so, is on capital account or revenue account, it is necessary to understand the nature of transaction which has resulted in, what the Assessing Officer, perceives as 'benefit to the assessee'. This was a case of amalgamation in the nature of merger, and an amalgamation in the nature of merger, in corporate parlance, is the process of blending of two or more companies into one of these blending companies, the shareholders of each blending company becoming substantially the shareholder of the company which holds the blended undertaking. The expression 'amalgamating company' is used for the 'blending company' which loses its existence into the other company and the expression 'amalgamated company' is used for blended undertaking, which holds existence of those two or more companies. In essence thus, the whole exercise of amalgamation in the nature of merger is an exercise in that of pooling of resources, as also pooling of assets, into the company in which two or more companies are blended. It is a process of corporate reconstruction and it is only with the approval of Hon'ble jurisdictional High Court that this exercise is carried out. In the present case also, as stated in paragraph 4 of Part I of Schedule A (i.e. scheme of amalgamation) to Hon'ble Calcutta High Court's order dated 9th April 2008, "for the purpose of better, efficient and economical management, control and running of the business and to withstand the recessionary trend in the economy of the business undertaking concerned and for administrative convenience and to obtain advantage of economies of large scale, the present scheme is proposed to amalgamate the transferor company (i.e. VVPL) with the transferee company (i.e. the assessee)". As a result of amalgamation, the assessee, being the transferee company, will increase its assets and liabilities, and, even if there be any benefit in the process, such a benefit can only be in the capital field because it is relatable to the non trading assets and capital. What it affects is the capital structure of the assessee company and the manner in which business is consolidated. As the Assessing Officer himself observes, "……this exercise of amalgamation is also aimed at bolstering the capability of the assessee to conduct business more dynamically and earn more profit. So, the enhancement of its capital reserve, as a result of this amalgamation can only be construed as a benefit accrued to the assessee…", but then it is not even the case of the Assessing Officer that the benefit is in the revenue field, and unless the Assessing Officer is to discharge the onus of demonstrating that the benefit is in the revenue field, there cannot be any occasion to invoke Section 28(iv). Applying the test laid down by Hon'ble Madras High Court, in the case of Seshasayee Brothers (supra), also, we find that the benefit is referable to the capital, and is thus not of an income nature. Even if, as the Assessing Officer observes, "it can be surmised that the assessee is benefited in a myriad ways by way of amalgamation", it does not lead to the conclusion that the benefit is in revenue field which alone can be treated as income and thus be considered for taxability under section 28(iv) of the Act. The onus is on the Assessing Officer to demonstrate that the receipt is of the revenue nature.
9. We have noted that the Assessing Officer's observations to the effect that 'business' under section 28 has a very broad meaning and may be used in different connotations" and that it includes adventure in the nature of trade, as also his reliance on Hon'ble Supreme Court's judgment in the case of Rajputana Textiles (Agencies) Ltd. v. CIT [1961] 42 ITR 743 (SC) , wherein it was held that where from the very beginning, purchase of shares is made with the intention of selling them, at a profit, it is an adventure in the nature of trade. However, we are unable to see any merits in these arguments either. Whatever be the scope of expression 'business', an advantage has to be of income nature first, and when it is not of income nature, it cannot be brought to tax under the head profits and gains from business or profession. As regards the transactions in the nature of 'adventure in the nature of trade' in a situation in which shares are purchased with an intention of selling the same, right now we are dealing with a case of amalgamation by way of merger and not by way of purchase of shares, and, therefore, there cannot be any question of selling of the shares, nor does this judicial precedent deal with the issue before us in any other manner. There is no material whatsoever before us to indicate that the benefit, even if accruing to the assessee, was in revenue field, in the course of assessee's business dealings or of trading nature. In view of these discussions, we are of the considered view that the benefit, if any, derived by the assessee on account of amalgamation by way of merger was not in revenue field, and not of an income nature. Accordingly, there was no occasion to invoke Section 28(iv) of the Act. Learned CIT(A) was quite justified in his observations that "the amalgamation is not an adventure in the nature of trade" and that "this transaction is clearly a capital account transaction". Learned CIT(A) was quite justified in deleting the impugned addition, we uphold his conclusions, and we decline to interfere in the matter.
10. As we have decided the appeal on the fundamental issue that the benefit, even if any, was not in the revenue field, and could not have been brought to tax under section 28(iv) for this short reason, we see no need to deal with other peripheral legal issues raised by the parties, as also assessee's contention to the effect that there was no benefit at all to the assessee. These issues are rendered academic and call for no adjudication.
11. In the result, the appeal is dismissed.
P. Sen
Alert