Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bijli Investment (P.) Ltd. v. Income-tax Officer, Ward 3(1), New Delhi

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal
Jan 5, 2007
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal was filed by the assessee against the order of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), New Delhi dated 31-08-2006 for the assessment year 2002-03. The underlying penalty was levied under section 271(1)(c) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 in relation to an assessment addition arising from a fee paid to the Registrar of Companies (ROC). The Assessing Officer contended that the payment was capital in nature and therefore not allowable as a revenue expenditure; on that basis a penalty was imposed. The assessee challenged the penalty on multiple grounds including that (i) full particulars had been disclosed in the audited accounts and the return of income, (ii) the disallowance was a debatable legal issue and not concealment, (iii) no satisfaction was recorded by the Assessing Officer in the assessment order as required by law, and (iv) there was no mens rea or contumacious conduct. The CIT(A) confirmed the penalty in part, and the assessee appealed to the Tribunal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a penalty under section 271(1)(c) can be validly initiated and sustained where the assessment order does not record the Assessing Officer's satisfaction regarding concealment of income or furnishing of inaccurate particulars.
  2. Whether disclosure of the payment (fee paid to ROC) in audited accounts and the return of income precludes the imposition of penalty under section 271(1)(c) when the claim is disallowed as a matter of law.
  3. Whether mere disallowance of an expenditure (on a debatable legal point) amounts to concealment or furnishing of inaccurate particulars attracting penalty under section 271(1)(c).
  4. Whether there was mens rea (conscious or intentional concealment) on the part of the assessee to justify levy of penalty.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Assessee's) Arguments

  • The assessee disclosed full particulars about the fee paid to ROC in its audited accounts and return of income; therefore there was no concealment or inaccurate particulars.
  • The disputed addition was based on a debatable legal question (capital vs. revenue nature), and a mere decline of a legal claim should not attract penalty.
  • No satisfaction (statutory recording of satisfaction that concealment/inaccurate particulars existed) was recorded in the assessment order — a precondition for initiating penalty proceedings under section 271(1)(c).
  • There was no mens rea or contumacious conduct; penalty is thus unjustified where explanation is bona fide.

Respondent's / Assessing Officer's Position

  • The Assessing Officer imposed penalty on the basis that the payment was capital in nature and therefore not allowable as revenue expenditure, implying concealment or furnishing of inaccurate particulars.
  • Penalty proceedings were initiated and pursued following the assessment process; the AO considered the matter to warrant imposition of penalty under section 271(1)(c).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
CIT v. Ram Commercial Enterprises Ltd. [2000] 246 ITR 568 The Assessing Officer must arrive at and record satisfaction during assessment proceedings that the assessee has concealed particulars of income or furnished inaccurate particulars; otherwise jurisdiction to initiate penalty under s.271(1)(c) is not conferred. Relied upon to hold that absence of recorded satisfaction in the assessment order deprived the AO of jurisdiction to initiate penalty proceedings; used to invalidate the penalty initiation.
Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Super Metal Re-Rollers [2004] 265 ITR 82 Supports the principle that satisfaction must be formed and recorded before initiating penalty proceedings. Referred to alongside other authorities to demonstrate that initiation of penalty cannot be presumed without recorded satisfaction.
CIT v. S.V. Angidi Chettiar [1962] 44 ITR 739 The assessing authority must form an opinion and record satisfaction before initiating penalty proceedings. Referred to as authority for the requirement of recording satisfaction prior to initiating penalty proceedings.
D.M. Manasvi v. CIT [1972] 86 ITR 557 Affirms that the assessing authority must form an opinion and record satisfaction before initiating penalty proceedings. Referred to in support of the proposition that satisfaction must be recorded and cannot be assumed.
Dewan Enterprises v. CIT [2000] 246 ITR 571 (Delhi) Non-recording of satisfaction in the assessment order is a jurisdictional defect which cannot be cured; initiation of penalty proceedings is bad in law if satisfaction is not recorded. Applied to conclude that initiation of penalty proceedings without recorded satisfaction is legally invalid and subsequent penalty proceedings must fail.
Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Vikas Promoters P. Ltd. [2005] 277 ITR 337 Recording of satisfaction before drawing inference for levying penalty in the assessment under s.143(3) is mandatory; penal provisions must be strictly construed and confirmation of satisfaction should be apparent from the orders. Relied on as binding jurisdictional authority requiring that the satisfaction be apparent on the face of the assessment order; used to invalidate the penalty where no such recording exists.
Commissioner Of Income Tax, Delhi-I v. Auto Lamps Ltd. [2005] 278 ITR 32 (Delhi) Similar proposition that satisfaction must be recorded in the assessment order before penalty proceedings are valid. Cited as part of the body of Delhi High Court decisions enforcing the requirement of recorded satisfaction.
Shri Bhagwant Finance Co. Ltd. v. CIT [2006] 280 ITR 412 (Delhi) Affirms requirement of recording satisfaction in assessment orders for valid initiation of penalty proceedings. Used as another supporting Delhi High Court authority to hold initiation of penalty without recorded satisfaction to be nullity.
Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Shri Pawan Kumar Dalmia [1987] 168 ITR 1 Findings in assessment or quantum proceedings are not conclusive or binding in separate penalty proceedings. Relied upon to support the proposition that penalty proceedings must consider the entire material afresh and are distinct from assessment/quantum proceedings.
Banaras Textorium v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax [1988] 169 ITR 782 Findings recorded or conclusions drawn in quantum appeals are neither conclusive nor binding in penalty proceedings. Referenced to reinforce that assessment findings do not automatically justify penalty without separate enquiry.
CIT v. Chetan Dass Lachhman Dass [1995] 214 ITR 726 Supports the non-conclusiveness of assessment or quantum findings in penalty proceedings. Cited as supporting precedent for treating penalty proceedings as distinct and requiring independent consideration.
National Textiles v. CIT [2001] 249 ITR 125 It is not enough for the purpose of penalty that an amount has been assessed as income; the circumstances must show animus (conscious concealment or furnishing inaccurate particulars). Applied as authority for the principle that both (i) material showing the amount represents income and (ii) animus must co-exist to justify penalty; used to conclude penalty not automatic upon addition.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal proceeded in two parallel strands of analysis: (A) jurisdictional/technical requirement of recording satisfaction in the assessment order, and (B) merits as to whether facts amounted to concealment or furnishing of inaccurate particulars.

(A) Jurisdictional / Procedural Requirement

  • The Tribunal examined the assessment order dated 12-01-2005 and found no recorded satisfaction by the Assessing Officer regarding concealment or furnishing of inaccurate particulars; at best the order stated that "penalty proceedings under section 271(1)(c) are being initiated separately".
  • Relying on a line of decisions of the jurisdictional High Court of Delhi (Ram Commercial Enterprises Ltd.; Dewan Enterprises; Vikas Promoters; Auto Lamps; Shri Bhagwant Finance), the Tribunal held that recording of satisfaction in the assessment order is a mandatory, jurisdictional precondition to initiating penalty proceedings under section 271(1)(c). The Tribunal emphasized that such satisfaction must be apparent on the face of the order and cannot be presumed or reconstructed by examining files or documents outside the order itself.
  • Given the absence of recorded satisfaction, the Tribunal concluded the initiation of penalty proceedings was vitiated as a nullity under the binding Delhi High Court authorities.

(B) Merits — Whether Facts Warrant Penalty

  • The Tribunal reviewed the material and noted that all particulars relating to the impugned expenditure (fee paid to ROC) were disclosed in the return of income and in the audited annual accounts for the year ended 31-03-2002; those documents were part of the return filed with the department and verified by the company's auditor.
  • It reiterated established principles that penalty proceedings are distinct from assessment/quantum proceedings, and findings in assessment are not conclusive in penalty proceedings; the Explanation to section 271(1)(c) creates only a rebuttable evidentiary presumption and does not make the assessment order conclusive proof of concealment.
  • The Tribunal articulated the two-factor test required to justify penalty: (i) material or circumstances leading to the reasonable conclusion that the amount represents the assessee's income, and (ii) circumstances showing animus (conscious concealment or furnishing of inaccurate particulars). The Explanation affects only the second factor (animus) by creating a rebuttable presumption.
  • Applying these principles, the Tribunal found that the assessee had provided a bona fide explanation, had disclosed all material facts, and there was no evidence of mens rea or contumacious conduct. Mere disallowance of expenditure on a debatable legal point did not suffice to draw an inference of concealment.
  • Consequently, even on merits the Tribunal found the imposition of penalty to be without merit because the facts were equally consistent with the absence of concealed income and the assessee's explanation was not disproved to the extent of establishing conscious concealment.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED.

Direct effect: The Tribunal allowed the assessee's appeal and held that the imposition of penalty under section 271(1)(c) was devoid of merits and invalid. The Tribunal reached this conclusion both because (a) the assessment order did not record the statutory satisfaction required before initiating penalty proceedings (a jurisdictional defect under binding Delhi High Court jurisprudence), and (b) on the merits the facts showed disclosure of the relevant particulars and absence of conscious concealment or mens rea required to sustain a penalty.

The Tribunal's reasoning expressly relied on and applied binding decisions of the jurisdictional High Court requiring that satisfaction be recorded in the assessment order and on authorities explaining that penalty proceedings are distinct from assessment proceedings and demand proof of animus before penalty can be imposed.

Show all summary ...

1. This is an appeal filed by the assessee against the order of the CIT (Appeals), New Delhi dated 31-8-2006 for the assessment year 2002-03 in the matter of order passed under section 271(1)(c) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 wherein following common grounds have been taken :

"(1) That the learned CIT (Appeals) has erred on facts and in law in partly sustaining the penalty order of the learned Assessing Officer under section 271(1)(c). The assessee has neither concealed its income nor filed inaccurate particulars of the same. The addition in assessment as made by the Assessing Officer is based on debatable legal issue. As such the penalty on addition Rs. 1,07,500 as sustained by the learned CIT (Appeals) is liable to be deleted in toto.

(2) That the penalty order of the learned Assessing Officer under section 271(1)(c) as sustained by the learned CIT (Appeals) is bad in law and wrong on facts inasmuch as the addition on account of fee paid to ROC on which the penalty has been levied is based on legal issue and further all material facts were disclosed by the assessee in audited books of account and return.

(3) That no specific opportunity was provided to the assessee as to the incorrect particulars or concealments involved. As such too, the penalty as levied is unmerited and unlawful and against the principles of equity, natural justice and fair play. Accordingly also, the penalty deserves to be quashed.

(4) That there is no mens rea or contumacious conduct. Penalty is not justified on bona fide difference of law.

(5) That the penalty order under section 271(1)( c) as sustained by the learned CIT (Appeals) is based on erroneous views and/or non-appreciation of the facts and law involved without properly considering the material on record and without following case law that clearly support the appellant.

(6) That the penalty as levied is against law and facts of the case involved because no satisfaction as to any concealment of income or furnishing any inaccurate particulars of income was recorded in the assessment order. As such too the penalty levied is unlawful and deserves to be quashed.

(7) That the grounds of appeal as herein are without prejudice to each other.

(8) That the assessee respectfully craves leave to add, amend, alter and/or forego any ground(s) at of before the time of hearing."

2. Rival contentions have been heard and record perused. Brief facts of the case are that penalty levied under section 271(1)(c) of the Act with respect to addition made on account of fee paid to ROC was confirmed by the CIT (Appeals). The contention of the Assessing Officer while imposing penalty was that alleged payment was capital in nature and, therefore, not allowable as revenue expenditure. It was contended by the learned AR that full particulars regarding payment of fee were disclosed in the audited accounts as well as return of income filed by the assessee, thus there was no concealment of any particulars of income shown to the department, merely decline of legal claim does not amount to concealment of income. He, therefore, submitted that no penalty should be imposed for mere decline of legal claim. He further submitted that no satisfaction was recorded by the Assessing Officer while passing the assessment order, which is a statutory requirement as per the verdict of jurisdictional High Court in case of CIT v. Ram Commercial Enterprises Ltd. [2000] 246 ITR 5681 (Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Super Metal Re-Rollers [2004] 265 ITR 822 (Delhi).

3. I have considered the rival contentions and found that in the assessment order dated 12-1-2005, there was no recording of any satisfaction regard- ing concealment of income or furnishing of inaccurate particulars of its income. At page 5, there was only mention of "penalty proceedings under section 271(1)(c) are being initiated separately". The issue regarding recording of satisfaction in the assessment order has been dealt with by the jurisdictional High Court as follows :

In case of Ram Commercial Enterprises Ltd. (supra), their Lordships while observing that satisfaction as to assessee having concealed particulars of his income or furnishing inaccurate particulars of such income is to be arrived at by the Assessing Officer during the course of any proceedings under the Act which would mean the "assessment proceedings" without which the very jurisdiction to initiate the penalty is not conferred on the assessing authority by reference to clause (c) to section 271(1)(c) of the Act. The decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in CIT v. S.V. Angidi Chettiar [1962] 44 ITR 739 and D.M. Manasvi v. CIT [1972] 86 ITR 557 were also referred wherein it was held that the assessing authority has to form his opinion and record his satisfaction before initiating the penalty proceedings, and merely because the penalty proceedings having been initiated, it cannot be assumed that such a satisfaction was arrived at.

4. In Dewan Enterprises v. CIT [2000] 246 ITR 571 (Delhi), it was observed by Delhi High Court that non-recording of satisfaction in the assessment order is jurisdictional defect which cannot be cured. The initiation of penalty proceedings was itself bad in law and consequently all the subsequent proceedings leading up to the passing of the penalty order must fail.

5. In Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Vikas Promoters P. Ltd. [2005] 277 ITR 3371 , it was observed by Delhi High Court that recording of satisfaction before drawing an inference for purpose of levying penalty while completing the assessment under section 143(3) is mandatory for the Assessing Officer. Provisions of section 271(1)(c) are penal in nature, must be strictly constitute and the confirmation of satisfaction should be apparent from the orders itself, it is not for the court to go into the mind of the authorities to trace the reasons from the file of such authorities.

6. Similar view has been taken by the jurisdictional High Court in case of Commissioner Of Income Tax, Delhi-I… v. Auto Lamps Ltd.…. [2005] 278 ITR 32 (Delhi), Shri Bhagwant Finance Co. Ltd. v. CIT [2006] 280 ITR 4122 (Delhi).

7. We have considered the submissions of learned DR and also deliberated on the case laws cited by him which pertains to other High Court, with regard to recording of satisfaction in the assessment order itself. I am unable to agree with the learned DR as we are working under the jurisdictional High Court of Delhi so the decisions of jurisdictional High Court are binding on the Tribunals working under it. I am bound to follow these orders of the jurisdictional High Court which have consistently taken the view that in case the satisfaction in the assessment orders has not been recorded by the Assessing Officer, the initiation of penalty proceedings under section 271(1)(c) of the Act and the orders passed thereof is nullity.

8. Even on merit, we found that the assessee has disclosed all the material facts in the return of income and there was no conscious or deliberate concealment. Mere disallowance of the expenditure, does not make the case fit for imposition of penalty under section 271(1)(c) of the Act. There is no dispute to the well-settled legal proposition that the penalty proceedings are distinct and different from assessment proceedings. Findings in the assessment proceedings are not conclusive. The entire material available should be considered afresh by the authorities before imposing penalty under section 271(1)(c). The Explanation to section 271(1)(c) provides a rule of evidence raising a rebuttable presumption in certain circumstances. No substantive right is created or annulled thereby. The substantive law relating to levy of the penalty is preserved. The initial burden of proof is cast on the assessee to establish the presumption arising in certain cases. The assessee can discharge the onus either by direct evidence or circumstantial evidence or by both. The cumulative effect of all facts should be taken into consideration. During the course of penalty proceedings, the assessee is entitled to show and establish by the material and relevant facts, which may go to affect and having direct hearing on the liability for penalty. Whether there is a concealment to make the penalty exercisable is normally a question of fact. Where the burden of proof in a given case has been discharged on a set of facts, is also a question of fact. The burden is cast on the assessee to offer a bona fide explanation. There are also plethora of judgments to the effect that findings recorded or conclusion drawn in deciding the quantum appeal, are neither conclusive nor binding. For this proposition reliance may be placed on the judgment of Hon’ble Kerala High Court in the case of Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Shri Pawan Kumar Dalmia [1987] 168 ITR 11 and the judgment of the Hon’ble Allahabad High Court in the case of Banaras Textorium v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax. [1988] 169 ITR 7822 and also the judgment of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of CIT v. Chetan Dass Lachhman Dass [1995] 214 ITR 7263.

9. The considerations in penalty proceedings are different from those in quantum proceedings. It is trite law that merely because an addition has been made and confirmed in the appeal, levy of penalty is not automatic. In National Textiles v. CIT [2001] 249 ITR 1254, the Gujarat High Court held that it is not enough for the purpose of penalty that the amount has been assessed as income, the circumstances must show that there was animus i.e. conscious concealment or act of furnishing inaccurate particulars on the part of the assessee. In the present case, the appellant’s conduct and the explanation offered by it shows that there was no conscious or intentional act of appellant to conceal or furnish inaccurate particulars of income.

10. In order to justify the levy of penalty, two factors must co-exist, (i) there must be some material or circumstances leading to the reasonable conclusion that the amount does represent the assessee’s income. It is not enough for the purpose of penalty that the amount has been assessed as income, and (ii) the circumstances must show that there was animus i.e., conscious concealment or act of furnishing of inaccurate particulars on the part of the assessee. The Explanation has no bearing on factor No. 1 but it has bearing only on factor No. 2. The Explanation does not make the assessment order conclusive evidence that the amount assessed was in fact the income of the assessee. No penalty can be imposed if the facts and circumstances are equally consistent with the hypothesis that the amount does not represent concealed income as with the hypothesis that it does. If an assessee given an explanation which is unproved but not disproved i.e., it is not accepted but circumstances do not lead to the reasonable and positive inference that the assessee’s case is false, the explanation cannot help the Department because there will be no material to show that the amount in question was the income of the assessee. Alternatively, treating the Explanation as dealing with both the ingredients (i) and (ii) above, where the circumstances do not lead to the reasonable and positive inference that the assessee’s explanation is false, the assessee must be held to have proved that there was no mens rea or guilty mind on his part. Absence of proof acceptable to the Department cannot be equated with fraud or wilful default. In the instant case, disallowance of expenditure for non-deduction of tax at source does not lead to the inference that assessee-company had concealed its particulars of income in terms of section 271(1)(c) of the Act. All the particulars relating to the impugned expenditure were undisputedly furnished before the Assessing Officer as well as in its return of income and the audited annual accounts for the year ended on 31-3-2002. All these documents were enclosed with and forming part of the return of income filed with the department. Thus, there was no concealment nor furnishing of any inaccurate particulars of income. The offence of concealment is a direct attempt to hide an item of income from the knowledge of the Income-tax Department. Whereas in the instant case the assessee has furnished full details in the return of income and the same were verified as correct by the auditor of the company. There is no dispute to the well-settled legal proposition that the penalty proceedings are distinct and different from assessment proceedings. Findings in the assessment proceedings are not conclusive. The entire material available should be considered afresh by the authorities before imposing penalty under section 271(1)(c). The Explanation to section 271(1)(c) provides a rule of evidence raising a rebuttable presumption in certain circumstances. No substantive right is created or annulled thereby. The substantive law relating to levy of the penalty is preserved. The initial burden of proof is cast on the assessee to establish the presumption arising in certain cases. The assessee can discharge the onus either by direct evidence or circumstantial evidence or by both. The cumulative effect of all facts should be taken into consideration. During the course of penalty proceedings, the assessee is entitled to show and establish by the material and relevant facts, which may go to affect and having direct hearing on the liability for penalty. Whether there is a concealment to make the penalty exercisable is normally a question of fact. Where the burden of proof in a given case has been discharged on a set of facts, is also a question of fact. The burden is cast on the assessee to offer a bona fide explanation. There are also plethora of judgments to the effect that findings recorded or conclusion drawn in deciding the quantum appeal, are neither conclusive nor binding. For this proposition reliance may be placed on the judgment of Hon’ble Kerala High Court in the case of Pawan Kumar Dalmia (supra) and the judgment of the Hon’ble Allahabad High Court in the case of Banaras Textorium (supra) and also the judgment of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of Chetan Dass Lachhman Dass (supra).

11. The considerations in penalty proceedings are different from those in quantum proceedings. It is trite law that merely because an addition has been made and confirmed in the appeal, levy of penalty is not automatic. In National Textiles’ case (supra), the Gujarat High Court held that it is not enough for the purpose of penalty that the amount has been assessed as income, the circumstances must show that there was animus i.e. conscious concealment or act of furnishing inaccurate particulars on the part of the assessee. In the present case, the appellant’s conduct and the explanation offered by it shows that there was no conscious or intentional act of appellant to conceal or furnish inaccurate particulars of income.

12. In order to justify the levy of penalty, two factors must co-exist, (i) there must be some material or circumstances leading to the reasonable conclusion that the amount does represent the assessee’s income. It is not enough for the purpose of penalty that the amount has been assessed as income, and (ii) the circumstances must show that there was animus i.e., conscious concealment or act of furnishing of inaccurate particulars on the part of the assessee. The Explanation has no bearing on factor No. 1 but it has bearing only on factor No. 2. The Explanation does not make the assessment order conclusive evidence that the amount assessed was in fact the income of the assessee. No penalty can be imposed if the facts and circumstances are equally consistent with the hypothesis that the amount does not represent concealed income as with the hypothesis that it does. If an assessee given an explanation which is unproved but not disproved i.e., it is not accepted but circumstances do not lead to the reasonable and positive inference that the assessee’s case is false, the explanation cannot help the Department because there will be no material to show that the amount in question was the income of the assessee. Alternatively, treating the Explanation as dealing with both the ingredients (i) and ( ii) above, where the circumstances do not lead to the reasonable and positive inference that the assessee’s explanation is false, the assessee must be held to have proved that there was no mens rea or guilty mind on his part. Absence of proof acceptable to the Department cannot be equated with fraud or wilful default. In the instant case, disallowance of expenditure for non-deduction of tax at source does not lead to the inference that assessee-company had concealed its particulars of income in terms of section 271(1)(c) of the Act. All the particulars relating to the impugned expenditure were undisputedly furnished before the Assessing Officer as well as in its return of income and the audited annual accounts for the year ended on 31-3-2002. All these documents were enclosed with and forming part of the return of income filed with the department. Thus, there was no concealment nor furnishing of any inaccurate particulars of income. The offence of concealment is a direct attempt to hide an item of income from the knowledge of the Income-tax Department. Whereas in the instant case the assessee has furnished full details in the return of income and the same were verified as correct by the auditor of the company.

13. In view of the above discussion I am inclined to agree with ld. Authorised Representative Shri V.K. Garg that action of lower authorities in imposition of penalty was devoid of any merits.

14. In the result, the appeal filed by the assessee is allowed.