- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Banco Products (India) Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax
Tribunal Opinion — Summary
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal arises from an assessment under the Income-tax Act in respect of public issue expenses incurred by the assessee-company. During the year under appeal the assessee offered 300,000 equity shares of Rs. 10 each and 100,000 partly convertible debentures (PCDs) of Rs. 100 each to the public. The prospectus stated three objects for the public issue: (1) finance capital expenditure, (2) supplement long-term working capital, and (3) obtain listing of equity shares and debentures.
The assessee incurred aggregate public issue expenses of Rs. 8,00,132 and apportioned these expenses between shares and debentures in the ratio 77:23 (debentures:equity) — allocating Rs. 3,78,233 to debentures and Rs. 1,12,979 to equity. The Rs. 3,78,233 (debenture portion) was claimed as a deduction under section 37(1) of the Income-tax Act. The Assessing Officer disallowed the debenture-issue expenditure on the ground that it was incurred to increase share capital and therefore was not allowable as a revenue deduction.
On appeal, the CIT (Appeals) gave partial relief: he held that the portion of the debentures which was convertible (Rs. 30 per debenture) was capital in nature (augmenting share capital), while the balance (non-convertible portion) could be treated as loan. The assessee then appealed further, and the Tribunal (per Shri B.L. Chhibber, Accountant Member) considered the issues, including a separate grievance about disallowance of one-fifth of motor car running expenses (Rs. 26,472) and related depreciation (Rs. 10,635) made by the authorities below.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether public issue expenses incurred on the issue of Partly Convertible Debentures (PCDs) are allowable as revenue expenditure, or whether the portion attributable to the convertible part must be treated as capital expenditure.
- Whether the disallowance of one-fifth of motor car running and maintenance expenses and the related depreciation (on account of possible personal use by directors/executives) was justified in law and on facts.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's (Assessee's) Arguments
- The borrowed funds (including funds raised by issue of partly convertible debentures) remain borrowing until conversion; what may happen at a future date is not determinative of the character of the receipt during the period in question.
- Expenditure incurred in raising borrowed funds should be regarded as expenditure on borrowing the funds and therefore as revenue expenditure; reliance was placed particularly on the Supreme Court's decision in India Cements Ltd. v. CIT to support that borrowing-related expenses are allowable as business expenditure.
- The fact that part of the debentures would be converted at a future date does not change the nature of the funds at the time they were raised; the assessee compared raising debenture funds to raising a term loan (where expenditure in raising the loan is treated as revenue expenditure by courts in many instances).
- The assessee cited several authorities (Jeewanlal (1929) Ltd v. CIT; Orissa Cement Ltd v. CIT; Addl. CIT v. C.S. Thacker; CIT v. Oswal Spg. & Wvg. Mills Ltd; Commissioner v. Tumus Electric Corporation Ltd.) to support the proposition that expenditure on raising borrowed funds can be revenue in nature.
Respondent's (Revenue's) Arguments
- The terms of issue in the prospectus created an obligation on the company to issue, and on holders to take up, three equity shares of Rs. 10 each for every debenture on a predetermined date (30-6-1987), making the convertible portion effectively equity from the outset.
- The convertible portion represented a constructive receipt of Rs. 30 by debenture holders and a constructive payment to the company towards equity; the conversion was automatic, compulsory, certain in date and manner, and therefore the convertible part had characteristics of equity rather than debt.
- Restrictions (such as prohibition on repurchase prior to conversion) and stipulations (e.g., adjustment on bonus issues) demonstrated that the convertible portion functioned as equity from the time of issue; thus the proportionate issue expenses attributable to the convertible portion were capital in nature.
- The revenue relied on numerous decisions (including Richardson Hindustan Ltd; Motor Industries; Vazir Sultan Tobacco Co. Ltd; Shree Ram Mills; Avery India; Union Carbide; Mihir Textiles; Gujarat Steel Tubes; Ajit Mills, among others) to support the contention that in the circumstances the convertible proportion should be treated as capital expenditure and disallowed as a revenue deduction.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court (as stated in the opinion) |
|---|---|---|
| India Cements Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Madras [1966] 60 ITR 52 | Cited by the assessee to show that expenditure in obtaining a loan is business expenditure and therefore revenue in nature; the Court in that case held borrowing-related expenses allowable and observed that obtaining capital by issue of shares differs from obtaining loan by debentures. | The Tribunal distinguished India Cements because that case dealt with a pure loan (industrial finance corporation loan) and not with issue of convertible/partly-convertible debentures; the Tribunal held the ratio did not apply to the facts before it. |
| Hindustan Gas & Industries Ltd v. CIT [1979] 117 ITR 549 (Cal.) | Cited by the assessee (listed among High Court decisions relied on by the assessee's representative). | Listed by the assessee as authority supporting its position; the Tribunal recorded it among the decisions relied upon by the assessee. |
| Brooke Bond India Ltd. v. CIT [1983] 140 ITR 272 (Cal.) | Cited by the assessee (listed among High Court decisions relied on by the assessee's representative). | Recorded as one of the High Court decisions relied upon by the assessee; no separate application of its principle is elaborated beyond being relied upon. |
| CIT v. Motor Industries Co. Ltd [1988] 173 ITR 374 (Kar.) | Cited by the assessee to support revenue characterization of borrowing-related expenditure; also later cited by the revenue side in its list of authorities. | Recorded among authorities; the Tribunal noted it but relied on facts and principles specific to convertible debentures to reach its conclusion. |
| Mohan Meakin Breweries Ltd. v. CIT (No.2) [1979] 117 ITR 505 (HP) | Cited by both sides (appears in lists relied upon by the assessee and by CIT (Appeals)). | Recorded among authorities cited; the Tribunal did not treat it as dispositive for convertible debentures and reached its decision on the basis of convertibility and characteristics of equity. |
| Bharat Carbon & Ribbon Mfg. Co. Ltd. v. CIT [1981] 127 ITR 239 (Delhi) | Cited by both sides (listed among authorities relied upon by the assessee and by CIT (Appeals)). | Recorded among authorities; the Tribunal referred to it as one of the cases relied upon but made its decision on the specific facts of mandatory convertibility. |
| Vazir Sultan Tobacco Co. Ltd v. CIT [1988] 174 ITR 689 (AP) | Cited by the assessee (and later cited in other contexts by the revenue). | Recorded among authorities; the Tribunal noted the presence of divergent High Court views but relied on the specific characteristics of the convertible portion to treat it as capital. |
| CIT v. Aditya Mills [1990] 181 ITR 195 (Raj.) | Cited by the CIT (Appeals) in support of his finding that the convertible portion was capital in nature. | The CIT (Appeals) relied on this decision; the Tribunal upheld the CIT (Appeals)'s finding that the convertible part is capital in nature. |
| Bombay Burmah Trading Corpn Ltd v. CIT [1984] 145 ITR 793 (Bom.) | Cited by the CIT (Appeals) as supportive authority. | Used by the CIT (Appeals) in arriving at partial relief; the Tribunal sustained the CIT (Appeals)'s allocation of expenses to the convertible (capital) portion. |
| Jeewanlal (1929) Ltd v. CIT [1969] 74 ITR 753 (SC) | Cited by the assessee among Supreme Court authorities relied on to support revenue characterization of borrowing costs. | Recorded as cited by the assessee; the Tribunal considered the Supreme Court authorities but distinguished India Cements on its facts. |
| Orissa Cement Ltd v. CIT [1969] 73 ITR 14 (Delhi) | Cited by the assessee to support its position (listed among cases relied upon). | Recorded as cited by the assessee; the Tribunal did not adopt a blanket rule from these cases for convertible debentures. |
| Addl. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Bihar v. C.S. Thacker [1983] 142 ITR 438 (Pat.) | Cited by the assessee (listed among authorities supportive of revenue characterization for borrowing-related expenses). | Recorded as cited by the assessee; no specific further application beyond being considered among authorities. |
| CIT v. Oswal Spg. & Wvg. Mills Ltd [1986] 160 ITR 426 (Punj. & Har.) | Cited by the assessee (listed among authorities). | Recorded as cited by the assessee; the Tribunal's conclusion was based on characteristics of compulsory convertibility rather than adopting a rule from this case. |
| Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Tumus Electric Corporation Ltd. [1989] 179 ITR 219 (MP) | Cited by the assessee (listed among authorities). | Recorded as cited by the assessee; the Tribunal distinguished the facts before it from pure loan cases. |
| Richardson Hindustan Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax [1988] 169 ITR 516 (Bom.) | Cited by the revenue (listed among authorities supporting revenue's position). | Recorded as cited by the revenue; the Tribunal considered the weight of authorities but decided on the basis of mandatory convertibility and equity characteristics. |
| Vazir Sultan Tobacco Co. Ltd v. CIT [1990] 184 ITR 70 (AP) | Cited by the revenue (later decision of the same party) in support of its submissions. | Recorded among authorities cited by the revenue; the Tribunal noted divergent High Court views and proceeded on facts of compulsory conversion. |
| Shree Ram Mills Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax [1992] 195 ITR 215 (Bom.) | Cited by the revenue (listed among authorities). | Recorded as cited by the revenue; not applied beyond being noted among authorities. |
| Avery India Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax [1993] 199 ITR 745 (Cal.) | Cited by the revenue (listed among authorities). | Recorded as cited by the revenue; the Tribunal used the collective context of authorities while deciding the issue on facts. |
| Union Carbide India Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax [1993] 203 ITR 584 (Cal.) | Cited by the revenue (listed among authorities). | Recorded as cited by the revenue; the Tribunal's decision turned on mandatory convertibility rather than relying solely on this precedent. |
| Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Mihir Textiles Ltd. [1994] 206 ITR 112 (Guj.) | Cited by the revenue (listed among authorities). | Recorded as cited by the revenue; the Tribunal noted jurisdictional practice and binding local precedent in its reasoning. |
| Gujarat Steel Tubes Ltd v. CIT [1994] 210 ITR 358 (Guj.) | Cited by the revenue (listed among authorities before the Tribunal). | Recorded as cited by the revenue; the Tribunal observed that Ahmedabad Benches consistently follow the Shree Digvijay Cement line of authority in the jurisdiction. |
| Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Ajit Mills Ltd. [1994] 210 ITR 658 (Guj.) | Cited by the revenue (listed among authorities). | Recorded as cited by the revenue; noted among local authorities but not adopted as sole basis for decision. |
| Shree Digvijay Cement Co. Ltd v. CIT [1982] 138 ITR 45 | Identified as the Gujarat High Court decision consistently followed by Ahmedabad Benches (jurisdictional precedent relevant to share-issue expenditure). | The Tribunal noted that Ahmedabad Benches consistently follow this Gujarat High Court decision; this informed the Tribunal's approach and supported the treatment of convertible portion as capital. |
| ITO v. Ashoka Betelnut Co. (P.) Ltd [1985] 21 TTJ (Mad.) 465 | Cited by the Tribunal in relation to the motor car expense issue (appeal against 1/5th disallowance). | The Tribunal relied on this Bench decision (Madras) to conclude that the 1/5th disallowance and related depreciation were not maintainable and deleted the additions. |
| Perfect Pac Ltd v. IAC [1993] 46 TTJ (Delhi) 438 | Cited by the Tribunal in relation to the motor car expense issue (appeal against 1/5th disallowance). | The Tribunal relied on this Delhi Bench decision alongside Ashoka Betelnut to reverse the disallowance of 1/5th of motor car expenses and related depreciation. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Tribunal examined the legal character of the convertible portion of the partly convertible debentures by focusing on the essential characteristics of a debt and the specific terms of the debenture issue.
- The Tribunal stated the basic legal requirement of a debt: broadly, repayability; a debt is a liquidated money obligation enforceable in praesent or in futuro. The convertible portion, in the Tribunal's view, could not be termed a debt because it lacked the essential characteristic of repayability as a debt — the convertible portion was to be converted compulsorily into equity on a predetermined date.
- The Tribunal characterized convertible debentures as "equity shares in embryo" because the conversion was mandatory and led to augmentation of the company's equity base. In the case before it, the convertible portion was clearly identifiable as equity capital from the outset due to mandatory and certain conversion terms.
- The Tribunal considered and distinguished India Cements (supra). It noted India Cements dealt with a pure loan raised from a financial institution and that the expenditure in that case was held to be revenue as it secured the use of money for a period. The Tribunal held India Cements was not applicable because the present case concerned expenditure on issues of equity shares and partly convertible debentures rather than a straightforward loan.
- The Tribunal observed divergence in High Court decisions on whether expenditure on the issue of shares is revenue or capital. However, it noted that Ahmedabad Benches consistently follow the Gujarat High Court decision in Shree Digvijay Cement Co. Ltd v. CIT. The Tribunal recorded that none of the High Court cases referred to by the parties directly dealt with convertible or partly convertible debentures.
- Based on the contractual terms showing automatic, compulsory and certain conversion, and the observable indicia of equity characteristics (including provisions dealing with bonus issues and restrictions on repurchase before conversion), the Tribunal held that the proportionate expenditure attributable to the convertible portion must be treated as capital expenditure (for augmentation of equity) and therefore not allowable as revenue deduction.
- On the separate issue of the motor car expenses, the Tribunal concluded that the approach of the authorities below (disallowing one-fifth of running/maintenance expenses and related depreciation) was not legally tenable. The Tribunal relied on two Tribunal Bench decisions (ITO v. Ashoka Betelnut Co., and Perfect Pac Ltd v. IAC) and reversed the disallowance, deleting the impugned additions.
Holding and Implications
Core Holding: The appeal is ALLOWED IN PART.
Specific rulings:
- The Tribunal upheld the CIT (Appeals)'s conclusion that the proportion of the public issue expenses attributable to the convertible portion of the partly convertible debentures (the Rs. 30 per debenture convertible portion) is capital in nature because the convertible portion had the character of equity (shares in embryo) — that proportion of issue expenditure is not allowable as a revenue deduction.
- The Tribunal reversed the disallowance of one-fifth of motor car running and maintenance expenses (Rs. 26,472) and the related depreciation (Rs. 10,635) previously disallowed by the Assessing Officer and confirmed by the CIT (Appeals); those additions were deleted.
Consequences / Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: the portion of issue expenses attributable to the convertible element of the PCDs is treated as capital and disallowed as a revenue deduction; the non-convertible portion remains treated as borrowing-related and (implicitly from the CIT(A) disposition) treated differently. The motor car expense additions imposed on the assessee were reversed.
- The Tribunal distinguished the Supreme Court decision in India Cements on the ground that that case concerned a pure loan. The Tribunal emphasized that the presence of mandatory and certain convertibility changes the character of the funds and therefore the character of the associated expenditure.
- No novel legal rule was propounded by the Tribunal beyond applying established principles: it relied on jurisdictional practice (Shree Digvijay Cement Co. Ltd as followed by Ahmedabad Benches) and existing authorities to decide the question of character of expenditure for convertible components; it did not purport to overrule or create a new general principle beyond this fact-based application.
Outcome summarised: Part of the issue expenses attributable to the convertible element of the PCDs is capital in nature (disallowable as a revenue deduction), while the motor car expense disallowances were deleted — overall the appeal succeeds in part.
Per ShriB.L. Chhibber (Accountant Member) -A short but important issue raised in this appeal by the assessee is whether Public Issue expenses incurred on issue of Partly Convertible Debentures is allowable as revenue expenditure.
2. The assessee-company offered 3 lacs Equity Shares of Rs. 10 each and 1,00,000 1596 Partly Convertible Debentures of Rs. 100 each to the Public during the year under appeal. The objects of the public issue specified in the Prospectus issued by the assessee-company were as follows:
(1)To Finance the capital expenditure of the company;
(2)To Supplement the company’s long term resources for working capital; and
(3)To obtain listing of the Equity Shares and Debentures of the company on the stock exchange.
The assessee incurred aggregate expenditure of Rs. 8,00,132 on these public issues. The entire expenditure of Rs. 8,00,132 was bifurcated in the ratio of the amount of shares and debentures to the total public issue. The ratio worked out to 77: 23 and accordingly 77% of the expenditure was apportioned to Debentures and 23% of the expenditure was apportioned to Equity Shares. The expenditure relating to Debentures amounting to Rs. 3,78,233 was claimed as deduction permissible under section 37(1) of the Income-tax Act and the expenditure relating to Equity. Shares amounting to Rs. 1,12,979 was considered as preliminary expenditure. It was submitted before the Assessing Officer that in respect of each debenture of the face value of Rs. 100, Rs. 30 was convertible into 3 shares of Rs. 10 each on 30-6-1987 and the balance portion of Rs. 70 was non-convertible and was redeemable in the 6th, 7th and 8th years of issue. The Assessing Officer while completing the assessment, disallowed the Debenture issue expenditure of Rs. 3,78,233 on the ground that the expenditure was incurred to increase the share capital of the company and hence the same was not allowable as deduction.
3. The assessee appealed to the CIT (Appeals). Relying on the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in the case of India Cements Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Madras. [1966] 60 ITR 52 the assessee’s representative submitted that the Apex Court had observed in the aforesaid case that procuring of capital by way of issue of shares was different from obtaining loans through debentures. Reliance was further placed on the following High Court decisions:
(1)Hindustan Gas &IndustriesLtd v. CIT [1979] 117 ITR 549/ 1 Taxman 546 (Cal.),
(2)Brooke Bond India Ltd. v. CIT [1983] 140 ITR 272/[1982] 10 Taxman 18 (Cal.),
(3)CIT v. Motor Industries Co. Ltd [1988] 173 ITR 374/[1985] 23 Taxman 261 (Kar.),
(4)Mohan Meakin Breweries Ltd. v. CIT (No.2) [1979] 117 ITR 505 (HP),
(5)Bharat Carbon & Ribbon Mfg. Co. Ltd. v. CIT [1981] 127 ITR 239 [1980] 3 Taxman 568 (Delhi),
(6)Vazir Sultan Tobacco Co. Ltd v. CIT [1988] 174 ITR 689/ 41 Taxman 7 (AP).
The learned CIT (Appeals) held that the expenditure incurred on the convertible portion of Rs. 30 each was in the nature of capital expenditure because 3096 of the debenture issue would go to augment the share capital of the company and the balance 70% could be treated as loan. In support of his findings, he relied upon the following decisions:
(a )CIT v. Aditya Mills [1990] 181 ITR 195 / 50 Taxman 120 (Raj.);
(b) Mohan Meakin Breweries Ltd’s case ( supra);
(c) Bharat Carbon & Ribbon Mfg. Co. Ltd’s case ( supra);
(d )BombayBurmah TradingCorpn Ltd v. CIT [1984] 145 ITR 793 /[1983] 12 Taxman 178 (Bom.).
Thus, the learned CIT (Appeals) gave part relief.
4. Shri S.N. Soparkar, the learned counsel for the assessee submitted that it was true that part of the borrowed funds were going to be converted into equity shares at a future date. That by itself, however, cannot change the characteristics of the receipts. Borrowings continued to remain borrowings till the end of the year .If that be so, expenditure incurred by the assessee would certainly be regarded as expenditure incurred on borrowing the funds. According to the learned counsel for the assessee what might happen at a future date is an issue which is not relevant for the purpose of deciding this controversy. It was true that at the end of the specific period (10 months), part of the debentures would be, as a matter of fact, converted into shares. However, till the date of conversion the said amount was only a debt. Relying upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of India Cements Ltd (supra), the learned counsel for the assessee submitted that the assessee was entitled to the deduction of the entire expenditure attributable to the issue of Partly Convertible Debentures (P.C.Ds). According to the learned counsel the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of India Cements Ltd (supra) categorically laid down that, such an expenditure incurred for creating a debt would be allowable expenditure. Hence, it is irrespective of the length for which the debt would be available. The learned counsel for the assessee further submitted that whenever a term loan is raised the benefit of the same is available for a number of years, and even then the department does not hold the expenditure for raising the term loan as a capital expenditure or whenever such attempt is made by the department the Courts have always held that such an expenditure is Revenue expenditure. In support of his arguments he relied upon the following decisions:
(1)Jeewanlal (1929) Ltd v. CIT [1969] 74 ITR 753 (SC),
(2)Orissa Cement Ltd v. CIT [1969] 73 ITR 14 (Delhi),
(3)Addl. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Bihar v. C.S Thacker [1983] 142 ITR 438/ 14 Taxman 439 (Pat.),
(4)CIT v. Oswal Spg. & Wvg. Mills Ltd [1986] 160ITR 426/ 26 Taxman 206 (Punj. & Har.),
(5)Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Tumus Electric Corporation Ltd. [1989] 179 ITR 219 /[1990] 49 Taxman 249 (MP).
5. Shri P.N. Dixit, the learned DR strongly supported the orders of the authorities below. He took us through the relevant extracts from the terms of issue of such debentures and submitted that the company was under an obligation as was clear from the following paragraph relating to conversion:
"The debentures shall carry an obligation on the part of the company to issue to the holders of every such fully paid debenture on 30th June 1987and on the part of the holders of the debentures, to take up without any further act or application, three Equity Shares of Rs. 10 each credited as fully paid up at par. Thus, there will be a constructive receipt of Rs. 30 by the holders of the debentures towards the convertible part of each debenture and constructive payment of the same amount by them to the company towards the price of three fully paid up Equity Shares to be issued against each such debentures." [Emphasis added]
According to the learned DR, the following factual position clearly emerged from the Prospectus:
"(1)The Debenture issued as per terms of issue itself was liable to be converted into Equity Shares on 30-6-1987, within a year from the date of issue being 3-9-1986, automatically and compulsorily without any further act or application on the part of such debenture holder.
(2)The debenture holder or any subsequent transferee, before the date of conversion, has to hold such shares with the aforesaid condition of automatic and compulsory conversion having no choice or option in the matter.
(3)The date and manner of such conversion was pre-determined and final at the date of issue of such debentures itself.
(4)Further, although the date of conversion was a subsequent date, but in view of legal amendments as noted above, such convertible portion had characteristics of Equity Shares which becomes further clear from stipulation regarding augmentation of number of such shares by conversion in the event of issue of bonus shares prior to such conversion. Had that been not so, then there was no need of such stipulation.
(5)The further restriction on repurchase of such debenture prior to conversion makes it abundantly clear as such restriction was obviously self-imposed in view of provisions of section 77 of the Companies Act, 1956 prohibiting repurchase of its share capital from open market."
According to the learned DR it was clear that funds so obtained through the issue of Convertible Debentures were clearly identifiable as Equity Capital and loan funds from the very beginning and for all the time thereafter. The mere fact that such funds, temporarily for a brief period of about 6 months from the time of completion of formalities of allotment, were treated as raised against debenture with a mandatory condition of convertibility will not bestow on the entire funds, the characteristics of loan funds. The date and manner of conversion was certain and specific and nothing was left to chance and in any case when the return of income of the company was due to be filed on 30-6-1987, and was actually filed on that date, the factum of conversion was a dead certainty. He therefore submitted that the CIT (Appeals) rightly attributed the proportionate part of the issue expenses towards capital a argumentation. In support of his arguments, he relied upon the following decisions:
(1)Richardson Hindustan Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax. [1988] 169 ITR 516/[1987] 32 Taxman 466 (Bom.),
(2)Motor Industries Co. Ltd’s case (supra),
(3) Vazir Sultan Tobacco Co. Ltd’s case (supra ),
(4) Vazir Sultan Tobacco Co. Ltd v. CIT [1990] 184 ITR 70 (AP),
(5)Shree Ram Mills Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax. [1992] 195 ITR 215 (Bom.),
(6)Avery India Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax [1993] 199 ITR 745 (Ca.l.),
(7)Union Carbide India Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax. [1993] 203 ITR 584 (Cal.),
(8)Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Mihir Textiles Ltd. [1994] 206 ITR 112 (Guj.),
(9)Gujarat Steel Tubes Ltd v. CIT [1994] 210 ITR 358 (Guj.),
(10)Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Ajit Mills Ltd. [1994] 210 ITR 658 (Guj.).
6. We have considered the rival submissions and perused the facts on record. Basic requirement of a debt is repayability. Broadly stated, a debt is a liquidated money obligation for the recovery of which an action will lie. It is an ascertained liquidated quantified obligation enforceable in praesenti or in futuro. A debt must be a debitum that is due. Debitum in praesent, solvendum in futuro is vital conception of a debt. Viewed from this angle, convertible portion of the debenture cannot be termed as a debt because in our considered view convertible debentures have characteristics of equity shares; these are equity shares in embryo. The conversion of such debentures on the stipulated date leads to augmentation of the equity base of the company. In the case before us convertible debentures were clearly identifiable as Equity capital. The conversion was mandatory. Hence, it cannot be said that convertible part had the characteristics of loan funds. The date and manner of conversion was certain and nothing was left to chance and in any case when the return of income of the company was due to be filed on 30-6-.1987 and was actually filed on that date, the factum of conversion was a dead certainty.
6.1 In India Cement Ltd ‘s case (supra) on which heavy reliance has been placed by the learned counsel for the assessee, the Apex Court was dealing with a case of an appellant who had obtained a loan of Rs. 40 lakhs from the Industrial Finance Corporation secured by a charge on its fixed assets. In connection therewith it spent a sum of Rs. 84,633 towards stamp duty, registration fee, lawyer’s fee, etc. and claimed this amount as business expenditure. The Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the amount spent was not in the nature of capital expenditure and was laid out or expended wholly and exclusively for the purpose of the assessee’s business and was therefore allowable as a deduction under section 10(2)(xv) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922. The act of borrowing money was incidental to the carrying on of business, the loan obtained was not an asset or an advantage of enduring nature, the expenditure was made for securing the use of money for a certain period and it was irrelevant to consider the object with which the loan was obtained. The Hon’ble Supreme Court further held that "obtaining capital by issue of share is different from obtaining loan by debentures". It is obvious that the Supreme Court was dealing with a case where loan was raised and the loan was in the nature of debt. It was neither a case where issue of equity shares or convertible/partly convertible debenture was involved. Before us is the case where expenditure was admittedly incurred on issue of equity shares and partly convertible debentures. Accordingly, the ratio laid down by the Supreme Court will not apply to the facts of the case before us.
6.2 On the issue whether expenditure incurred on issue of shares of a company is of a revenue or capital nature, there is a divergence of opinions among different High Courts as is evident from the cases of different High Courts cited by both the parties supra. But so far as Ahmedabad Benches are concerned, they are consistently following the judgment of the Gujarat High Court (Jurisdictional High Court) in the case of Shree Digvijay Cement Co. Ltd v. CIT [1982] 138 ITR 45. None of the cases of the High Courts referred to supra deals with issue of convertible partly convertible debentures. In the case before us the issue relates to the expenditure on issue of partly convertible debentures and for the reasons discussed above, we hold that the proportionate expenditure on the convertible part of the debentures is for the augmentation of equity base of the company and as such has to be treated as capital expenditure. We accordingly uphold the findings of the CIT (Appeals). This ground fails and is dismissed.
7. The next grievance of the assessee is that the learned CIT (Appeals) is not justified in law and on facts in confirming the disallowance of 1/5th of the motor car expenses amounting to Rs. 26,472 and depreciation of Rs. 10,635 thereon.
7.1 The assessee is a Public Limited Company. The Assessing Officer disallowed 1/5th of the expenditure on running and maintenance of Motor cars and depreciation thereon for possible personal use of the cars by the Directors and Executives of the company. On appeal, the CIT (Appeals) confirmed the disallowance made by the Assessing Officer.
7.2 In our considered view the approach of both the authorities below is not legally tenable. The decision of Madras Bench of this Tribunal in the case of ITO v. Ashoka Betelnut Co. (P.) Ltd [1985] 21 TTJ (Mad.) 465 and the decision of Bench ‘E’ of Delhi Tribunal in the case of Perfect Pac Ltd v. IAC [1993] 46 TTJ (Delhi) 438 squarely apply to the facts of the case. We therefore reverse the findings of the authorities below and delete the impugned additions.
8. In the result, the appeal is allowed in part.
Alert