Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Hari Kishan Malik v. V N Shrama Builders Private Ltd

State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
Jul 2, 2019
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The complainant booked a 3 BHK flat in Savitry Greens, Zirakpur, by paying a booking amount and subsequently making payments totaling over ₹51,00,000. An Agreement to Sell was executed on 17.10.2013 with the complainant and his wife as joint allottees. Possession was contractually to be delivered within 24 months (by 16.10.2015), but the opposite party failed to deliver possession of the flat by that date. Instead, possession of an alternative flat was given on 16.09.2016 without the complainant's consent. The complainant alleged delay in possession, deficiencies in the flat, and non-provision of promised facilities, and sought compensation and removal of defects. A civil suit filed by the complainant’s wife claiming co-ownership was withdrawn without liberty to file fresh proceedings. The complainant filed the present consumer complaint on 28.06.2019 under Section 17 of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, seeking compensation for delayed possession, removal of deficiencies, damages for mental agony, and litigation expenses. The opposite party denied the claims, and the complaint was considered for admission.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the complaint is barred by limitation?
  2. Whether there are deficiencies in the flat and whether the complainant ceased to be a consumer after taking physical possession without protest?
  3. Whether the complaint is maintainable before the Consumer Forum without impleading the complainant’s wife as a party, given the withdrawal of the civil suit filed by her without liberty?

Arguments of the Parties

Complainant's Arguments

  • Possession of the flat was delayed beyond the stipulated period, entitling the complainant to compensation at the rate of ₹5 per sq.ft. per month for the delay period.
  • The opposite party delivered possession of an alternative flat without consent and later denied possession of the originally booked flat citing family disputes.
  • The counsel of the opposite party misled the complainant and his wife, causing disputes, and compelled the complainant to sign an affidavit and give a cheque under threat.
  • Possession taken was with many deficiencies and promised facilities were not provided.
  • The complainant suffered mental agony and harassment due to the opposite party’s conduct.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the opposite party’s arguments beyond denial of claims and contention that no deficiencies existed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State Bank of India v. B.S. Agricultural Industries, (2009) 5 SCC 121 Mandate of Section 24A of the Consumer Protection Act requiring complaints to be filed within two years of cause of action; consumer forums must examine limitation before admission. Court held that the complaint seeking delayed possession charges filed after two years was barred by limitation without condonation of delay.
V.N. Shrikhande (Dr.) v. Anita Sena Fernandes, 2011 CTJ 1 (Supreme Court) Consumer forums lack jurisdiction to entertain complaints filed beyond two years unless sufficient cause for delay is shown and condoned. Reiterated the limitation principle and emphasized dismissal of complaints barred by time without condonation application.
State Of Maharashtra v. Hindustan Construction Company Limited, 2007 Section 9 of the Limitation Act, 1963: Once limitation period begins, it continues uninterrupted; correspondence does not extend limitation. Court relied on this to hold that correspondence after limitation period does not revive or extend limitation.
United Bank of India vs. Janata Paradise Hotel and Restaurant, IV (2014) CPJ 383 (NC) Correspondence does not extend limitation, especially when claim is already time-barred. Used to reinforce that limitation period was not extended by any correspondence in the instant case.
Vandan Pareshkumar Manghita vs. The Divisional Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd., 2014 (4) CLT 254 Mere correspondence does not extend limitation; complaint must be filed within two years from first intimation. Supported the court’s conclusion on limitation bar in the present complaint.
T.K.A. Padmanabhan v. Abhiyan CGHS Ltd., 2016 (2) CPJ 273 Taking physical possession without protest extinguishes consumer relationship; agreement ends and complaint becomes non-maintainable. Applied to hold that complainant ceased to be consumer after taking possession without protest.
Harpal Arya v. Housing Board Haryana, Estate Manager, Housing Board, 2016 Taking possession without pre-conditions ends privity of contract and complainant ceases to be consumer; complaint filed thereafter is not maintainable. Relied upon to dismiss complaint on ground of cessation of consumer status post possession.
Smita Roy v. Excel Construction & Anr, II (2012) CPJ 204 (NC) Possession taken without objection bars subsequent complaint on deficiencies; complainant ceases to be consumer. Used to reinforce the principle that possession without protest precludes consumer claim.
M/s Chetak Construction Ltd. v. Om Parkash & Ors, Civil Appeal No. 2140 of 1998 Forum shopping is impermissible; litigants cannot choose forum to suit convenience and such attempts must be discouraged. Applied to hold that complainant’s filing of civil suit followed by consumer complaint amounted to forum shopping.
Ramesh Chandra Sankla & Ors. v. Vikram Cement, (2008) 14 SCC 58 Withdrawal of suit without leave of court precludes fresh litigation on the same cause of action; public policy bars re-agitation. Held that withdrawal of civil suit by complainant’s wife without liberty bars maintainability of present complaint.
Hulas Rai Baij Nath v. Firm K.B.Bass and Co., AIR 1968 SC 111 Order XXIII, Rule 1 CPC: Withdrawal of suit without court permission bars fresh suit on same subject matter. Relied upon to support bar on fresh complaint after withdrawal of civil suit without permission.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the complaint in light of the Consumer Protection Act and relevant case law. It first determined that the claim for delayed possession charges was time-barred as it was filed beyond the two-year limitation period prescribed under Section 24A of the Act, without any application for condonation of delay. The court emphasized that mere correspondence does not extend limitation and the limitation period started from the date of possession of the alternative flat (16.09.2016).

Next, the court examined whether the complainant could claim deficiencies after taking physical possession of the flat on 28.03.2019. The Letter of Possession and affidavit signed by the complainant and his wife stated the flat was complete and possession was taken without protest or reservation, thereby terminating the contractual relationship and estopping the complainant from alleging deficiencies or claiming compensation. The court relied on precedents establishing that taking possession without objection ends the consumer status.

Regarding maintainability, the court noted the civil suit filed by the complainant’s wife asserting co-ownership was withdrawn without liberty to file fresh proceedings. The complainant did not implead his wife in the present complaint, which the court found to be an attempt at forum shopping. Citing Supreme Court rulings, the court held that withdrawal of suit without leave bars fresh litigation on the same cause of action, and that the complainant’s filing in his individual capacity could not circumvent this principle.

The court also found no evidence to substantiate the complainant’s allegations against the opposite party’s counsel for misguidance or threats.

On these bases, the court concluded there was no ground to admit the complaint and dismissed it in limine.

Holding and Implications

The complaint is dismissed in limine.

The court held that the claim for delayed possession compensation was barred by limitation, the complainant ceased to be a consumer upon taking possession without protest, and the complaint was not maintainable due to withdrawal of the co-allottee’s civil suit without liberty and non-joinder of necessary parties. The decision directly affects the parties by denying relief to the complainant and upholding the legal principles on limitation, estoppel upon possession, and prohibition of forum shopping. No new precedent was established; rather, the court applied settled law consistently.

Show all summary ...

STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION, PUNJAB, CHANDIGARH. Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019 Date of institution : 28.06.2019 Date of decision : 02.07.2019 Sh. Hari Kishan Malik S/o Sh. Bhadur Chand, R/o Flat No.404, Tower No.5, Savitry Greens, VIP Road, Zirakpur, District SAS Nagar, Mohali- 140603. .Complainant Versus M/s V N Sharma Builders Private Ltd., Charanji Enclave, Lohagarh, Ambala Chandigarh Road, Zirakpur, District SAS Nagar, Mohali, through its Director Sh. Parminder Kumar Sharma. .Opposite Party Consumer Complaint under Section 17 of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986. Quorum:- Honble Mr. Justice Paramjeet Singh Dhaliwal, President Present:- For the complainant : Sh. Satinder Kumar Rana, Advocate. JUSTICE PARAMJEET SINGH DHALIWAL, PRESIDENT : The complainant has filed this complaint, under Section 17 of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 (in short, the Act), against the opposite party, seeking following directions to it:

a) to pay charges at the rate of 5/- per sq.ft. per month from 20.07.2015 to 16.09.2016 (till alternate possession was given)

i.e. 14 x 1690 x 5=1,18,300/- as per the latest guidelines laid down by the Honble Apex Court on account of delayed possession, as per Clause 12 of the allotment letter and Clause 4 (c) (ii) of the Agreement to Sell;

b) to provide all the facilities, as promised by the builder in the agreement and in the advertisement, such as club house, parking space for vehicle, green parks, swinging pool, 24 hours security, provision of two lifts, 24 hours electricity supply with Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019 prepaid meters and to remove all the deficiencies in the apartment, such as uneven level of the floors in the rooms/ the toilet, proper suiting/fixing of the doors and windows, proper utilities in the toilets;

c) to pay a sum of 2,00,000/- on account of mental agony and harassment suffered by the complainant; and

d) to pay 50,000/- towards litigation expenses. Facts of the Complaint

2. Brief facts, as set out in the complaint, are that on 20.07.2012, the complainant applied for booking of a 3 BHK flat bearing No.404, 4th Floor, Tower 5, measuring 1690 sq.ft. in Savitry Greens, VIP Road, Zirakpur, District S.A.S. Nagar, Mohali by paying booking amount of 1,00,000/-, vide cheque No.573200 dated 17.07.2012 drawn on PNB, Fatehabad. After payment of 26,50,000/- to the opposite party towards the price of the said flat, as detailed in Para No.2 of the complaint, Agreement to Sell dated 17.10.2013 was executed between the complainant, his wife Jagdish Kaur Malik and the opposite party. Initially, the said flat was booked by the complainant, but later on as per advice of the builder, the name of his wife was also added in the agreement. The basic price of the said flat was 51,00,000/-, but in the agreement, the consideration amount thereof was shown as 25,50,000/-. The payment plan i.e. Plan-B was opted by the complainant, whose details are given in Para No.3 of the complaint. It is alleged that the complainant paid a total sum of 51,00,221/- to the opposite party in cash or through RTGS till 23.09.2016. As per Clause 4(a) of the agreement dated 17.10.2013, possession of the flat was to be delivered within 24 months from the Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019 date of execution of the said agreement i.e. upto 16.10.2015. However, the opposite party could not deliver the possession of fully completed flat by the said date. When the complainant insisted upon the opposite party to deliver possession or return the deposited amount, along with interest at the rate of 18% per annum, then the opposite party delivered possession of alternative flat No.1204 in Tower-10, as temporary/alternative arrangement on 16.09.2016 i.e. after 14 months without any consent of the complainant and his family. Thus, as per Clause 4 (c) (ii) of the agreement, opposite party is liable to pay charges at the rate of 5/- per sq.ft. per month for the period of delay in offering the possession of the flat beyond the period indicated in Clause 4 (a) (ii). The opposite party agreed to pay the delayed possession charges and to adjust the same against the other pending amount at the time of giving final possession of the originally booked flat. The complainant requested the opposite party, vide letters dated 16.10.2017 and 18.10.2018, to deliver possession jointly to him and his wife. Thereafter, he also issued legal notice dated 29.10.2018 through his counsel Sh. Rajeev Patyal, Advocate; which was replied by the opposite party through its counsel Sh. Balwinder Singh, Advocate, denying the possession on the ground that there was dispute between family members of the complainant. The said counsel of the opposite party misguided the complainant and his wife, which led to the dispute between them. Initially, the said counsel of the opposite party compelled the complainant to discard his wife and son by publishing notice in the newspaper, so that the flat could be handed over to the Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019 complainant only. As there was mismatching of names in the booking letter and agreement to sell, so to clear this dispute, counsel of the opposite party advised the complainant to disown his wife and son and for that purpose an affidavit was got written on behalf of the complainant, which was published in the newspaper. Thereafter, taking the advantage of the affidavit and newspaper notification, Sh. Balwinder Singh, Advocate misguided wife of the complainant to file Civil Suit for declaration before the Court of Civil Judge (Senior Division), Dera Bassi, to the effect that the plaintiff (wife of the complainant) is co-allottee and owner of flat No.404, comprising 3 BHK on 4th Floor in Tower No.05, Savitry Greens, VIP Road, Zirakpur to the extent of half share and further for directing the opposite party to deliver vacant possession of the flat to the plaintiff, along with the complainant. The complainant and his wife have been trying their level best to get possession of the flat. The opposite party issued legal notice dated 02.02.2019, through its counsel Sh. Balwinder Singh, Advocate, for taking possession of the flat, in question, and to vacate the alternative accommodation, failing which it was threatened that rent at the market rate, maintenance and holding charges would be charged. The said notice was duly replied by the complainant, through his counsel, on 11.02.2019. The complainant is a senior citizen and retired person. He was called in the office of the opposite party and abused and humiliated by its officials on the asking of its counsel. The complainant was also called in the house of Sh. Balwinder Singh, Advocate on 22.03.2019 and was threatened and compelled to sign Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019 pre-drafted affidavit and to give a cheque for 1,89,840/- and balance amount after calculating the charges on account of delayed possession was to be returned after clearance of the cheque. The complainant had already deposited the total cost of the flat and only 50,000/- towards club charges and 40,000/- towards Interest Free Maintenance Security were to be paid at the time of taking possession of the flat, in question. Therefore, the receipt dated 23.03.2019 for depositing cheque No.000004 dated 23.02.2019 drawn on RBL Bank, Zirakpur for 1,89,840/- and affidavit dated 23.03.2019 was signed under compulsion and threat. Thereafter, on 25.03.2019, the complainant approached the office of the opposite party for collecting the cheque for the amount towards delayed possession charges, but the same was not given on the pretext that the signing authority was not available at that point of time. Possession of the flat, in question, was physically handed over to the complainant on 28.03.2019, but it was found that there were many deficiencies therein. The same were informed to the opposite party orally, who assured to remove the same. However, neither the delayed possession charges have been paid nor the deficiencies in the flat have been removed by it. Lastly, the complainant sent a representation to the opposite party through registered post on 08.05.2019, explaining the deficiencies in the flat such as inferior quality of the material used, uneven level of floors, bathrooms, improper drainage, non-fixing of doors properly etc. He also raised the issue of non-providing the agreed facilities therein. However, the opposite party, vide its reply dated 24.05.2019, flatly Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019 refused to pay compensation for delayed possession and to remove the deficiencies in the flat. The aforesaid Civil Suit filed by the wife of the complainant was withdrawn on 18.05.2019, by making a statement that she did not want to proceed further with the said suit. The aforesaid act and conduct of the opposite party amount to deficiency in service, as a result of which the complainant suffered mental agony and harassment. Hence, the present complaint. Contentions of the Complainant

3. I have heard learned counsel for the complainant at the admission stage of the complaint and have gone through the record carefully.

4. Learned counsel for the complainant has vehemently contended that the complainant applied for booking of a 3 BHK flat bearing No.404, 4th Floor, Tower 5, measuring 1690 sq.ft. in Savitry Greens, VIP Road, Zirakpur, District S.A.S. Nagar, Mohali by paying booking amount of 1,00,000/-, vide cheque No.573200 dated 17.07.2012 drawn on PNB, Fatehabad. Later on, as per advice of the builder, the name of his wife was also added in the Agreement to Sell as co-allottee; which was executed between the complainant, his wife Jagdish Kaur Malik and the opposite party on 17.10.2013. The basic price of the said flat was 51,00,000/- and the complainant paid a total sum of 51,00,221/- to the opposite party till 23.09.2016. As per Clause 4(a) of the agreement dated 17.10.2013, possession of the flat was to be delivered within 24 months from the date of execution of the said agreement i.e. upto 16.10.2015; failing which charges at the rate Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019 of 5/- per sq.ft. per month for the period of delay were payable by the opposite party as per Clause 4 (c) (ii) of the agreement. The opposite party failed to deliver the possession within the stipulated period. However, it delivered possession of alternative flat No.1204 in Tower- 10, as temporary/alternate arrangement on 16.09.2016 i.e. after 14 months without any consent of the complainant. Later on, the opposite party denied to give possession of the flat, originally booked by the complainant, on the ground that there was dispute in his family. In fact, the counsel of opposite party Sh. Balwinder Singh, Advocate had misguided the complainant and his wife, which led to the dispute between them. He advised the complainant to disown his wife and son and got executed an affidavit on behalf of the complainant, which was published in the newspaper. Thereafter, said counsel of the opposite party misguided wife of the complainant, who filed Civil Suit for declaration before the Court of Civil Judge (Senior Division), Dera Bassi, stating herself to be the owner of half share in the flat, in question; which was later on withdrawn by her on 18.05.2019. Sh. Balwinder Singh, Advocate threatened and compelled the complainant on 22.03.2019 to sign pre-drafted affidavit and to give a cheque for 1,89,840/- and balance amount after calculating the charges on account of delayed possession was to be returned after clearance of the cheque. Therefore, the receipt dated 23.03.2019 for depositing cheque No.000004 dated 23.02.2019 drawn on RBL Bank, Zirakpur for 1,89,840/- and affidavit dated 23.03.2019 was signed under compulsion and threat. Possession of the flat, in question, was Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019 physically handed over to the complainant on 28.03.2019 but with many deficiencies therein. The same were informed to the opposite party, who assured to remove the same. However, neither the delayed possession charges have been paid nor the deficiencies in the flat have been removed by it. The act and conduct of the opposite party amount to deficiency in service and, as such, the complaint is liable to be admitted and decided on merits after issuing notice to the opposite party. Consideration of Contentions

5. I have given my thoughtful consideration to the contentions raised by the learned counsel for the complainant.

6. Admittedly, the complainant booked 3 BHK flat in the project of the opposite party bearing No.404, 4th Floor, Tower 5, measuring 1690 sq.ft. in Savitry Greens, VIP Road, Zirakpur, District S.A.S. Nagar, Mohali by paying booking amount of 1,00,000/-, vide cheque No.573200 drawn on PNB, Fatehabad, through receipt dated 20.07.2012, Ex.C-1, and booking letter Ex.C-2 was issued in his name. The complainant made various payments to the opposite party towards the price of the flat, in question, vide receipts/Statement of Account and Passbook entries, Ex.C-1, Ex.C-3 to Ex.C-7, Ex.C-9 to Ex.C-20 and Ex.C-26. Later Agreement to Sell, Ex.C-8, was executed between the complainant and his wife Smt. Jagdish Kaur Malik on one side and the opposite party on the other side on 17.10.2013. It is alleged by the complainant that name of his wife was added in the agreement on the Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019 advice of the opposite party, but there is no evidence to prove any such advice of the opposite party.

7. As per Clause 4(a) of the agreement, possession of the flat was to be delivered within 24 months (2 years) from the date of execution of the said agreement, failing which opposite party was liable to pay charges at the rate of 5/- per sq.ft. per month for the period of delay in offering the possession of the flat, as per Clause 4 (c) (ii). As per version of the complainant, instead of delivering possession of the flat, in question, alternative possession of flat No.1204 in Tower-10 was given to him on temporary basis on 16.09.2016. Later on, the possession of the flat, originally booked by the complainant, was delivered to him on 28.03.2019, vide Letter of Possession, Ex.C-28. The complainant alleged there are so many deficiencies in the flat. He further alleged that neither the compensation on account of delay in delivery of possession of the flat, in question, has been paid to him, not the deficiencies/defects in the flat have been removed by the opposite party, despite his repeated requests.

8. In view of the aforesaid factual matrix involved in the complaint as well as the contentions raised by the learned counsel for the complainant, the following questions arise for determination, at the admission stage of the complaint:

I) Whether the complaint is time barred? II) Whether there are any deficiencies in the flat, in question and whether after taking physical possession of the flat, in question, Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019 without raising any kind of protest at that time, the complainant ceased to be consumer of the opposite party? III) Whether, after the withdrawal of the Civil Suit filed before the Civil Court by the wife of the complainant, concerning the flat in question, the complaint is maintainable before the Consumer Fora, without impleading her as party being co-allottee, specifically when the Civil Suit had been withdrawn without liberty? Question No.(I): Whether the complaint is time barred?

9. The complainant has sought direction (a) to the opposite party to pay charges at the rate of 5/- per sq.ft. per month for the specific period i.e. with effect from 20.07.2015 to 16.09.2016 (till alternate possession was given) i.e. 14 x 1690 x 5=1,18,300/-, as per Clause 12 of the allotment letter and Clause 4 (c) (ii) of the Buyer Agreement. However, the said relief could have been sought by the complainant within two years from 16.09.2016, whereas the complaint has been filed on 28.06.2019 i.e. after limitation period of two years, seeking the aforesaid relief along with others. Therefore, the complaint to the extent of this relief is clearly barred by time. The complainant alleged that he wrote letters and notices to the opposite party to deliver possession of the flat, in question, and to pay compensation on account of delay in delivery of possession. However, Section 24-A of the Act lays down that the Consumer Forum shall not entertain a complaint, unless it is filed within two years from the date on which the Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019 cause of action has arisen. The Honble Supreme Court in State Bank of India v. B.S. Agricultural Industries (I), 2009 CTJ 481 (SC)(CP)=(2009) 5 SCC 121 observed in Para No.8 as under:-

8. It would be seen from the aforesaid provision that it is peremptory in nature and requires consumer forum to see before it admits the complaint that it has been filed within two years from the date of accrual of cause of action. The consumer forum, however, for the reasons to be recorded in writing may condone the delay in filing the complaint if sufficient cause is shown. The expression, `shall not admit a complaint' occurring in Section 24A is sort of a legislative command to the consumer forum to examine on its own whether the complaint has been filed within limitation period prescribed thereunder. As a matter of law, the consumer forum must deal with the complaint on merits only if the complaint has been filed within two years from the date of accrual of cause of action and if beyond the said period, the sufficient cause has been shown and delay condoned for the reasons recorded in writing. In other words, it is the duty of the consumer forum to take notice of Section 24A and give effect to it. If the complaint is barred by time and yet, the consumer forum decides the complaint on merits, the forum would be committing an illegality and, therefore, the aggrieved party would be entitled to have such order set aside.

10. This view of law was further reiterated by the Honble Supreme Court in its judgment reported as V.N. Shrikhande (Dr.) v. Anita Sena Fernandes 2011 CTJ 1 (SUPREME COURT) (CP). It was held by the Honble Supreme Court as under:- Section 24A(1) contains a negative legislative mandate against admission of a complaint which has been filed after Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019

2 years from the date of accrual of cause of action. In other words, the consumer forums do not have the jurisdiction to entertain a complaint if the same is not filed within 2 years from the date on which the cause of action has arisen. This power is required to be exercised after giving opportunity of hearing to the complainant, who can seek condonation of delay under Section 24A(2) by showing that there was sufficient cause for not filing the complaint within the period prescribed under Section 24A(1). If the complaint is per se barred by time and the complainant does not seek condonation of delay under Section 24A(2), the consumer forums will have no option but to dismiss the same. Reference in this connection can usefully be made to the recent judgments in State Bank of India v. B.S. Agricultural Industries (I), 2009 CTJ 481 (SC)(CP)=(2009) 5 SCC 121 and Kandimalla Raghavaiah and Company v. National Insurance Company and another, 2009 CTJ 951 (SC)(CP)=(2009) 7 SCC 768.

11. Still further, Honble Bombay High Court in case State Of Maharashtra v. Hindustan Construction Company Limited of 2007 decided on 01.02.2013 held in Para No.32 as follows:

32. In my view, refusal to pay the amount demanded by the petitioner, would not commence fresh period of limitation which had already commenced. In view of Section 9 of the Limitation Act, 1963, once time is begun to run, no subsequent disability or inability to institute a suit or make an application stops it. Once time starts, it does not stop. Limitation is extended only when there is an Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019 acknowledgment of liability or part payment. Correspondence does not extend the period of limitation.

12. Similarly, in United Bank of India vs. Janata Paradise Hotel and Restaurant, IV (2014) CPJ 383 (NC), Honble National Commission observed as under:- 6..........This argument is devoid of force because correspondence does not extend limitation, particularly, when first request for refund is made after claim became time- barred. In this matter, claim became time barred in the year 1995 and letter has been written on 18.11.2007. Complainant has not placed any letter from 1995 to 2007 and, thus claim being barred by limitation, learned District Form committed error in allowing complaint."

13. Likewise, in Vandan Pareshkumar Manghita vs. The Divisional Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd., 2014 (4) CLT. 254, Hon'ble National Commission has also observed that "mere correspondence does not extend limitation and complaint was to be filed within period of 2 years from first intimation.

14. In view of the ratio of the law laid down in the above noted authorities, it is clear that no amount of correspondence can extend the limitation period, which had already commenced from the date of accrual of cause of action in the present complaint on 16.09.2016, i.e. the date up to which the complainant has sought compensation on account of alleged delay in delivery of possession. No application has been filed along with the complaint seeking condonation of delay in that regard. Thus, it is evident that the complainant has not approached this Commission within two years from 16.09.2016, the Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019 date on which the possession of alternative flat was taken. In such circumstances, the present complaint with regard to relief (a) is hopelessly barred by limitation. Question No.(II) Whether there are any deficiencies in the flat, in question and whether after taking physical possession of the flat, in question, without raising any kind of protest at that time, the complainant ceased to be consumer of the opposite party?

15. The plea of the complainant that there are deficiencies in the flat or that he is entitled to compensation for delay in delay of possession is falsified by the contents of the Letter of Possession, Ex.C-28, which clearly shows that the flat, in question, is complete in all respects and has been constructed, as per plan and specifications given in the agreement. It is also mentioned therein that there is no defect or deficiency in the flat, in question, and the complainant and his wife have taken over the possession thereof, without any pressure or undue influence. The Letter of Possession, Ex.C-28, has been duly signed by the complainant and his wife Jagdish Kaur Malik as well as the Director of the opposite party. Not only this, the complainant has also executed an affidavit on the same date (28.03.2019), Ex.C-27, stating that he, along with his wife, has taken over the possession of the flat, in question, from the opposite party on 28.03.2019 and he is fully satisfied with the flat, in question, and will not claim anything from the opposite party. He also deposed in the said affidavit that after taking over possession of the flat, neither he nor his legal heirs would claim any right or compensation against the opposite party. It is also Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019 mentioned in this affidavit that the same has been executed by the complainant with his free will and without any kind of pressure. Since the complainant took over the possession of the flat, in question, vide Letter of Possession, as discussed above, without any protest or conditions, therefore, he is estopped by his own act and conduct from alleging that there are deficiencies in the flat and that he has not been paid the compensation for delay in delivery of possession. Moreover, after taking the possession of the flat, in question, complete in all respects, without any protest, the complainant ceased to be consumer of the opposite party. Honble National Commission in case T.K.A. Padmanabhan v. Abhiyan CGHS Ltd. 2016 (2) CPJ 273 held in Para No.10 as follows:

10. It is an admitted fact that petitioner had taken the physical possession of the flat on 27.02.2004, though there was delay of 11 months in giving possession on behalf of the respondent. However, the Consumer Complaint was filed on 08.08.2005, that is, about one and half years, after petitioner got possession. There is nothing on record to show that at the time of taking possession of the flat, petitioner had lodged any protest with regard to delay or took conditional possession. When petitioner had taken the possession of the flat on 27.02.2004, unconditionally and without any protest, thereafter he ceased to be a consumer. The agreement executed between the parties comes to an end. Thus, on the date when Consumer Complaint was filed, there was no privity of contract between the parties. As such, the Consumer Complaint on the face of it is not maintainable.

16. Similarly, in Revision Petition No.3338 of 2007 (Harpal Arya v. Housing Board Haryana, Estate Manager, Housing Board, Sector 6, Panchkula) decided on 04.01.2016, the Honble National Commission held in Para-15 as under:

15. Thus, from the aforesaid documents, it is manifestly clear that petitioner had executed the Hire Purchase Tenancy Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019 Agreement with the respondent and in pursuance thereof, he had also taken possession of house on 27.10.2004. Further, as per possession certificate, it is clear that petitioner had taken the possession without any pre-conditions. Now, after getting the possession, it does not lie in the mouth of the petitioner to state that house is not in a habitable condition. Once petitioner had taken the possession with open eyes and without any pre-conditions, he cease to be a consumer. The Consumer Complaint was filed on 25.05.2005, that is, after about seven months of taking over of possession of the house. Therefore, on the face of it, the petitioner was not a consumer at the time of filing of the complaint, since there was no privity of contract between the parties. Therefore, complaint is liable to be dismissed on this ground alone.

17. Likewise, in another case Smita Roy v. Excel Construction & Anr. II (2012) CPJ 204 (NC), the Honble National Commission observed in Paras No.12 to 14 as follows:

12. It is an admitted fact that possession of flats no. 205 and

305 was taken by the appellant on 21.4.2009 without any objection. Copy of No Dues/Possession letter is placed at page 17 of the paper book, which read as under: NO DUES/POSSESSION LETTER To whomsoever it may concern This is to certify that today dated 21.4.2009 we have handed over and given possession of the flat no.205 & 305 at Vaishali Pride, Minacha Colony, Vikas Nagar Mangla, Bilaspur (C.G.) to Miss Smita Roy after completion of the flat with full respect. We have got the full payment of the flat and there is no outstanding amount. Signature of the Regd. Flat Owner Signature of the Builder/Promoter

13. Appellant after getting the possession of the flats in question did not raise the issue with regard to the location of the flats as well as with regard to the inferior construction with the respondent. It was for the first time in its notice dated 25.11.2009, appellant had raised these issues.

14. Once the possession has been received by the appellant with open eyes and without any objection, now it does not lie in her mouth to allege about the location and deficiencies etc. Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019

18. In view of the ratio of aforesaid authorities, the complainant, after taking possession of the flat, without raising any kind of objection, ceased to be the consumer of the opposite party; because after taking physical possession of the flat, the agreement between the parties came to an end and thereafter there was no privity of contract between them. Question No.(III) Whether, after the withdrawal of the Civil Suit filed before the Civil Court by the wife of the complainant, concerning the flat in question, the complaint is maintainable before the Consumer Fora, without impleading her as party being co-allottee, specifically when the Civil Suit had been withdrawn without liberty?

19. Admittedly, the Agreement to Sell, Ex.C-8, was executed in the joint names of the complainant and his wife, Jagdish Kaur Malik, on one side and the opposite party on the other side. Earlier, there was some dispute between the complainant and his wife. The plaintiff (wife of the complainant) had instituted the said Civil Suit No.160 of 2018, Ex.C-31 (colly.) against the complainant and the opposite party (defendants), for declaration to the effect that plaintiff is co-allottee and owner of flat, in question, to the extent of half share; for grant of Permanent Injunction against the defendants to restrain from making any change in the title of suit property mentioned in the allotment letter dated 17.10.2013 issued by defendants No.2 & 3 (opposite party); for further restraining the defendants from selling/mortgaging/leasing/ renting out and to invest power of attorney of the said flat in the name of any other person during the pendency of the said suit; and for issuing directions to defendants No.2 & 3 (opposite party) to deliver Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019 and hand over the vacant possession of the above mentioned flat to the plaintiff (wife of the complainant) also, along with defendant No.1 (complainant). From perusal of aforesaid Civil Suit, it is clear that there was dispute between the complainant and his wife regarding ownership of the flat, in question. Smt. Jagdish Kaur Malik was necessary party. She has not been impleaded as party, so the complainant is bad for non-joinder of necessary party.

20. It is averred by the complaint in the complainant that the said dispute between him and his wife was over and he filed this complaint on his behalf as well as on behalf of his wife. It is important to mention that the said suit was dismissed as withdrawn by the wife of the complainant, on the basis of the following statement, Ex.C-31 (colly.) made by her before the Civil Court on 18.05.2019: Stated that I do not want to proceed further with the present suit and withdraw the same. Perusal of above said statement of the wife of the complainant clearly shows that the said suit was withdrawn, without seeking/granting any liberty to file complaint before this Commission or any other court of competent jurisdiction, in accordance with law. It is alleged by the complainant that he and his wife, being joint allottees of the flat, in question, had been trying their level best to get the possession of the flat. However, in the absence of specific liberty granted to the wife of the complainant or the complainant, their rights to file the complaint, concerning any dispute with regard to the flat in question, (which is in their joint names), before this Commission stood closed/stopped at the Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019 time of making such statement before the Civil Court and withdrawal of Civil Suit.

21. From the above discussed evidence as well as facts and circumstances, it stands clearly proved that the complainant and his wife are indulging in forum-shopping by firstly filing Civil Suit and after that the present complaint. If the complainant (or his wife) was interested in claiming the relief under the Act, then he/she should have approached this Commission straightway within the limitation period and not after approaching the Civil Court, that too without grant of specific liberty to file complaint before this Commission. The Honble Supreme Court in case M/s Chetak Construction Ltd. v. Om Parkash & Ors. Civil Appeal No. 2140 of 1998 decided, vide order dated 20.04.1998, held as under: We certainly, cannot approve of any attempt on the part of any litigant to go "forum shopping". A litigant cannot be permitted `choice' of the `forum' and every attempt at "forum shopping" must be crushed with a heavy hand.

22. Certainly, keeping this thing in mind, the complainant has instituted the present complaint in his individual capacity and has not joined his wife as co-complainant; as by doing so, the principle of estoppel would have been applicable against them, in view of the withdrawal of the Civil Suit from the Civil Court without permission to file fresh case. However, by doing so, the complainant cannot escape from the application of law laid down by the Honble Supreme Court in Ramesh Chandra Sankla & Ors. v. Vikram Cement, (2008) 14 SCC 58, held as follows:- Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019 "From the above case law, it is clear that it is open to the petitioner to withdraw a petition filed by him. Normally, a Court of law would not prevent him from withdrawing his petition. But if such withdrawal is without the leave of the Court, it would mean that the petitioner is not interested in prosecuting or continuing the proceedings and he abandons his claim. In such cases, obviously, public policy requires that he should not start fresh round of litigation and the Court will not allow him to re-agitate the claim which he himself had given up earlier."

23. In Hulas Rai Baij Nath v. Firm K.B.Bass and Co., AIR 1968 SC 111 also, the Honble Supreme Court, after considering the provision of Order XXIII, Rule 1 of CPC, and particularly sub-rule (3) thereof, held that where plaintiff withdraws from a suit without the permission of the Court, he is precluded from instituting a fresh suit/complaint in same subject matter against the same parties.

24. The complainant has filed Misc. Application No.1230 of 2019 under Section 12 (c) of the Act, along with the complaint, seeking permission to file the complaint in his individual name, on the ground that his wife Smt. Jagdish Kumar is a senior citizen and retired Government employee. However, it is clear that he filed the complaint in his individual name, just to wriggle out of the rigor of the settled law, as discussed above, but since the complainant is also a co-allottee of the flat, in question, so the above discussed settled law is also applicable to him.

25. Therefore, the present complaint is not maintainable before this Commission, in view of the withdrawal of civil suit by his wife from Consumer Complaint No.497 of 2019 the Civil Court concerning the flat, in question, without any liberty to file a fresh complaint on the same cause of action. Moreover, due to having dispute between the complainant and his wife regarding the ownership of the flat, in question, intricate questions of law and facts are involved and, as such, the same cannot be tried summarily and are liable to be settled through the process of the Civil Court or other competent Court of law.

26. So far as the allegations of the complainant regarding misguidance given by Sh. Balwinder Singh, Advocate, who gave reply, Ex.C-23, on behalf of the opposite party to the notice, Ex.C-22, sent by the complainant, are concerned; it is relevant to mention that there is no evidence produced by the complainant on record to prove that he ever misguided or threatened him or his wife. Sh. Balwinder Singh, Advocate, being professional in the legal field, just gave replies to the notices/letters issued by the complainant, only on the instructions of the opposite party and not in his individual capacity. Moreover, without any cogent and convincing evidence in this regard, such allegations of the complainant cannot be believed/proved.

27. In view of my above discussion, there is no ground or justification for issuance of notice of the complaint to the opposite party and the same is dismissed in limine. (JUSTICE PARAMJEET SINGH DHALIWAL) PRESIDENT July 02, 2019. (Gurmeet S)