Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ashoksinh Jayendrasinh v. State Of Gujarat .

Supreme Court Of India
May 7, 2019
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

On 23 November 1997, a dispute over the use of a road adjoining Survey No. 95, Dhemda Village, escalated into a shooting incident. According to the prosecution, appellant-Accused 1, his relatives (Accused 2-5) and their servant (Accused 6) attempted to plough the disputed road with a tractor. When complainant Somabhai Rupabhai (PW-3) and his family objected, caste-based abuses were allegedly hurled and Accused 1 and 2 fired three shots, killing Somiben and injuring Ramanbhai (PW-6) and Nandaben (PW-7).

An FIR was registered the next day under multiple sections of the Penal Code, the Arms Act and the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act. After investigation, a common charge-sheet was filed. The Sessions Court (15 November 2000) convicted Accused 1 and 2 for offences under Sections 302/307 read with Section 34 IPC and Section 25(c) of the Arms Act, among others, sentencing them to life imprisonment. Accused 3-7 were acquitted.

Both sides appealed. The Gujarat High Court (5 March 2009, 2009 SCC OnLine Guj 12170) upheld Accused 1’s convictions, acquitted him of the Atrocities Act charge, and extended the benefit of doubt to Accused 2, acquitting him entirely. The State’s appeal against the other acquittals was dismissed.

Accused 1 appealed to the Supreme Court. A parallel State appeal challenging Accused 2’s acquittal (Criminal Appeal No. 1125 of 2010) was dismissed by the Supreme Court on 2 May 2019 (2019 SCC OnLine SC 725). The present judgment resolves Accused 1’s appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the identification of the assailants in darkness, absent evidence of lighting or moonlight, was reliable.
  2. Whether contradictions regarding which accused fired the fatal shots created reasonable doubt.
  3. Whether recovery of a single-barrel rifle from Accused 1, without corroborative ballistic evidence or supportive panch testimony, sufficed to link him to the fatal injuries.
  4. Whether the concurrent findings of the trial court and High Court were so perverse as to warrant Supreme Court interference under Article 136 of the Constitution.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • No proof of lighting at the scene; eyewitnesses could not have identified assailants in complete darkness.
  • Panch witnesses did not support the recovery panchnama, undermining the alleged seizure of the rifle.
  • Post-mortem report only mentions puncture wounds; it is unclear whether a rifle or a double-barrel gun caused them, creating doubt about Accused 1’s role.
  • Contradictory statements by PW-3 regarding who fired the shots warrant benefit of doubt.

Respondent State’s Arguments

  • Eyewitness testimony of PW-3, PW-5, and injured witnesses PW-6 and PW-7 is cogent, consistent, and was rightly relied upon by both courts below.
  • The motive arising from pending civil litigation over Survey No. 95 reinforces the prosecution case.
  • No ground exists for the Supreme Court to disturb concurrent findings of fact.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ashoksinh Jayendrasinh v. State of Gujarat, 2009 SCC OnLine Guj 12170 High Court judgment affirming conviction (subject of present appeal). Reviewed and ultimately set aside for improper appreciation of evidence.
Order dated 2-5-2019, 2019 SCC OnLine SC 725 Dismissed State’s appeal against Accused 2’s acquittal. Noted to clarify procedural posture; no substantive rule extracted.
Mahesh Dattatray Thirthkar v. State of Maharashtra, (2009) 11 SCC 141 Supreme Court interference with concurrent findings is permissible only when findings are perverse. Court invoked this principle to justify re-appreciation of evidence and interference.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court conducted an independent review of the evidence and identified multiple infirmities:

  • Lack of Reliable Identification: The incident occurred at 9 p.m. in an agricultural field. The panchnama (Ext. P-73) and witness testimony provided no evidence of electric lighting or moonlight. Consequently, the ability of witnesses to recognise the shooters was doubtful.
  • Contradictory Eyewitness Accounts: The complaint alleged both Accused 1 and 2 fired, whereas PW-3’s court testimony attributed all three shots solely to Accused 2. These discrepancies undermined the prosecution narrative.
  • Uncertain Ballistic Link: Post-mortem report described puncture wounds but did not specify whether they were caused by a rifle or a double-barrel gun. Without recovery of the fired bullet and with hostile panch witnesses to the weapon seizure, the rifle allegedly recovered from Accused 1 could not be conclusively connected to the fatal injuries.
  • Hostile Panch Witnesses: Both witnesses to the recovery panchnama (Ext. P-79) turned hostile, leaving only police testimony. While police evidence is not inherently infirm, the Court held that, given the overall doubts, independent corroboration was prudent but absent.
  • Motive Insufficient Alone: Although civil litigation over land provided a possible motive, the Court emphasised that motive is “a double-edged weapon” and cannot substitute for proof of guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
  • Perverse Findings Below: Citing Mahesh Dattatray Thirthkar, the Court found that both the trial court and High Court failed to properly weigh these shortcomings, rendering their concurrent findings perverse and open to correction.

Holding and Implications

ALLOWED — Conviction Set Aside.

The Supreme Court quashed Accused 1’s convictions under Sections 302/34, 307/34 IPC and Section 25(c) of the Arms Act and ordered his immediate release unless required in another case.

Implications are confined to the parties: Accused 1 gains freedom; no broader legal principle is newly established, but the decision re-affirms the Court’s willingness to overturn concurrent findings when evidence is improperly assessed.

Show all summary ...

R. Banumathi, J.— This appeal arises out of the judgment dated 5-3-2009 passed by the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad in Ashoksinh Jayendrasinh v. State of Gujarat 2009 SCC OnLine Guj 12170 in and by which the High Court affirmed the conviction of appellant-Accused 1 under Section 302 of the Penal Code, 1860 read with Section 34 IPC and the sentence of life imprisonment imposed upon him. The High Court also affirmed the conviction of the appellant under Section 307 IPC read with Section 34 IPC and under Section 25(c) of the Arms Act and the sentence of imprisonment imposed upon him. The High Court acquitted the appellant for the offence under Section 3(1)(x) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989.

2. Brief facts which led to filing of this appeal are: On 23-11-1997 at about 9.00 p.m., Accused 1 to 5 along with their servant (Accused 6) and another one accused gathered themselves and started ploughing the disputed road with a tractor for which a civil suit in Regular Suit No. 131 of 1997 filed by complainant Somabhai Rupabhai (PW 3) against appellant-Accused 1 and Accused 3 was already pending before the Court of Civil Judge, Modasa. According to the prosecution, the said road was used by the complainant and his family members for going to and fro. On the date of incident i.e. on 23-11-1997 at about 9.00 p.m., when accused persons were ploughing the road, the complainant and his family members intervened and prevented them from carrying out the ploughing activities on which accused started abusing the complainant and his family members with caste remarks. Due to fear, complainant and his family members went back to their houses which were near to the place of incident. In the meantime, appellant-Accused 1 Ashoksinh Jayendrasinh and Accused 2 Kalusinh alias Harpalsinh armed with guns, Accused 4 Balbadhra Singh armed with stick and Accused 3 Gayendra Singh who was driving the tractor came there. Thereafter, Accused 1 and 2 fired three gunshots which hit deceased Somiben, wife of Hirabhai (PW 5), Ramanbhai (PW 6) and Nandaben (PW 7) due to which Somiben died on the spot and PWs 6 and 7 got injured. Thereafter, all the accused ran away from the place of incident. On 24-11-1997, on the basis of the complaint lodged by complainant (PW 3), FIR was registered against all the accused under Sections 302, 307 and 120-B IPC read with Section 34 IPC, Sections 143, 147, 148, 149, 506 Part II, 323 and 504 IPC, under Section 25(c) of the Arms Act and under Section 3(1)(x) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989.

3. Upon completion of investigation, charge-sheet was filed against the appellant and other co-accused under Sections 302, 307 and 120-B IPC read with Section 34 IPC, Sections 143, 147, 148, 149, 506 Part II, 323 and 504 IPC, under Section 25(c) of the Arms Act and under Section 3(1)(x) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989.

4. To bring home the guilt of the accused, the trial court examined four eyewitnesses viz. complainant Somabhai Rupabhai (PW 3), Hirabhai Somabhai (PW 5) and injured eyewitnesses Ramanbhai Mulabhai Rangjibhai (PW 6) and Nandaben Hirabhai (PW 7), Dr Rohit Kumar (PW 1) who conducted the post-mortem on the dead body of deceased Somiben, Dr Deshmukh Hiralal (PW 4) who examined the injured eyewitnesses and other witnesses.

5. Upon consideration of the evidence of injured eyewitnesses (PWs 6 and 7), recovery of weapons and other evidence on record, the trial court vide its judgment dated 15-11-2000 convicted the appellant-Accused 1 and Accused 2 under Section 302 IPC read with Section 34 IPC and sentenced them to undergo life imprisonment along with fine of Rs 5000 each. They were also convicted under Section 307 IPC read with Section 34 IPC and were sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for seven years along with fine of Rs 5000 each. They were also convicted under Section 25(c) of the Arms Act and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for three years along with fine of Rs 500 each and under Section 3(1)(x) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for six months along with fine of Rs 500 each. The trial court acquitted Accused 1 and 2 under Sections 147, 148, 149, 323, 504 and 506 Part II IPC. The trial court also acquitted Accused 3 to 7 from all the charges.

6. Being aggrieved, appellant-Accused 1 and Accused 2 Kalusinh filed Criminal Appeal No. 10 of 2001 before the High Court. Challenging the acquittal of Co-accused 3 to 7, respondent State has also filed Criminal Appeal No. 127 of 2001 before the High Court. By the common judgment dated 5-3-2009 2009 SCC OnLine Guj 12170, the High Court affirmed the conviction of appellant-Accused 1 under Section 302 and Section 307 IPC read with Section 34 IPC and under Section 25(c) of the Arms Act. The High Court acquitted the appellant under Section 3(1)(x) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 and also acquitted Accused 2 Kalusinh from all the charges by giving him the benefit of doubt. By the same judgment, the appeal preferred by the respondent State was dismissed by the High Court.

7. Being aggrieved by the dismissal of his appeal, appellant-Accused 1 has preferred this appeal. Challenging the acquittal of Accused 2 Kalusinh, respondent State has filed Criminal Appeal No. 1125 of 2010 which we have dismissed vide order dated 2-5-2019 2019 SCC OnLine SC 725.

8. Mr Anuj Bhandari, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant has submitted that the occurrence was of 23-11-1997 at 9.00 p.m. in the agricultural field of complainant-Somabhai Rupabhai (PW 3) and there is no evidence as to the electric light burning at the time of occurrence so as to enable the complainant and the witnesses to identify the assailants and in the absence of any vital evidence regarding the light, identity of the assailants by the witnesses ought not to have been relied upon. It was further submitted that two panch witnesses viz. Mukeshkumar Pranlal Sheth (PW 12) and Ramanbhai Hirabhai Panchal (PW 17) have not supported the panchnama (Ext. P-89) and in the absence of proof of recovery of weapons from the appellant, the fatal injuries sustained by deceased Somiben cannot be attributed to the appellant. It was submitted that in the post-mortem certificate (Ext. P-52), Dr Rohit Kumar (PW 1) has stated that there were puncture wounds but it is not clear as to whether those wounds were caused by rifle or by gun. It was urged that in the absence of any definite evidence as to which weapon—whether rifle or gun had caused the injuries, the court ought not to have convicted the appellant-Accused 1 under Section 302 IPC read with Section 34 IPC and Section 307 IPC read with Section 34 IPC and under Section 25(c) of the Arms Act and prayed for giving benefit of doubt to appellant-Accused 1.

9. Ms Jesal Wahi, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent State has taken us through the judgment of the trial court and the impugned judgment 2009 SCC OnLine Guj 12170 and submitted that the evidence of injured eyewitnesses (PWs 6 and 7) and the evidence of complainant Somabhai Rupabhai (PW 3) and other eyewitness Hirabhai (PW 5) are cogent and consistent and the courts below rightly convicted the appellant-Accused 1 and the concurrent findings warrant no interference.

10. We have carefully considered the rival contentions and perused the impugned judgment 2009 SCC OnLine Guj 12170 and the judgment of the trial court and other materials placed on record.

11. As per the prosecution case, the motive for the occurrence is regarding the dispute over the enjoinment of the road in Survey No. 95 of Dhemda Village belonging to Accused 1. Complainant Somabhai Rupabhai (PW 3) filed a civil suit in Regular Suit No. 131 of 1997 for the land measuring four acres and twenty-two guntas in the Court of Civil Judge, Modasa against Accused 1 and 3. In the said suit, by the order dated 16-10-1998 (Ext. P-5), the court has ordered “status quo”. Against the said order of status quo, the accused has filed an appeal in CFO No. 67 of 1998 and the copy of said appeal has been marked as Ext. P-126. Regarding the enjoyment of the land bearing Survey No. 95, there was enmity between the parties and thus the prosecution has proved the motive. Proof of motive was taken as one of the important aspects by the trial court as well as by the High Court. Though motive is a relevant aspect, it is to be kept in view that motive is a double-edged weapon. Proof of motive merely adds to the value of evidence of the eyewitnesses.

12. The occurrence was of 23-11-1997 at 9.00 p.m. in the agricultural field of complainant-Somabhai Rupabhai (PW 3), where it was dark. The panchnama of the scene of occurrence (Ext. P-73) shows no indication of the electric light either in the animal shed situated behind the house of complainant or that there is any electric pole anywhere in the vicinity or that there is a light on the well which is supplying water. Case of prosecution is that the appellant and six other co-accused surrounded the complainant party and there were three gunshots fired. The injured witness (PW 6) in his cross-examination has admitted that he had not stated anything about the burning light either in the animal shed or anywhere in the vicinity. In the absence of any evidence as to the light aspect, the possibility of identifying the accused in the darkness of the agricultural field of the complainant, particularly at 9.00 p.m. becomes doubtful. It is also to be pointed out that there is no evidence as to whether there was moonlight on 23-11-1997 and complainant has also not stated that he has identified the appellant or other co-accused with the help of moonlight. In the absence of evidence as to the availability of sufficient light, the identification of the accused and the overt act attributed to the appellant becomes doubtful.

13. In the complaint filed by complainant Somabhai Rupabhai (PW 3), it has been stated that appellant-Accused 1 Ashoksinh Jayendrasinh and Accused 2 Kalusinh fired three gunshots from their guns. Whereas, in the statement before the court, PW 3 has stated that “Kalu Sinh fired three shots which injured Nandaben and Ramanbhai”. As per the case of complainant as stated in the court, total three gunshots were fired and all three were fired by Accused 2 Kalusinh. As rightly submitted by the learned counsel for the appellant, there are contradictions in the case of the prosecution as to who fired those gunshots and the benefit of doubt is to be given to the appellant.

14. Dr Rohit Kumar (PW 1) has conducted the post-mortem on the dead body of deceased Somiben and as per post-mortem certificate (Ext. P-52), PW 1 noted the following injuries:

(i) One entry wound on left side of chest above the nipple of 0.5 cm diameter.
(ii) Puncture wound, round, on left side of neck measuring 0.5 cm.
(iii) Injury (i) passed into the back forming exit wound at the side of middle of spine of right scapula measuring 1 cm in diameter. At the back at the level of 1st exit wound 5th rib was broken. At the level of 2nd exit wound 7th rib was broken at the back side of left chest.

15. PW 1 opined that cause of death was due to rupturing of trachea, oesophagus and difficulty in breathing. In post-mortem certificate Ext. P-52, PW 1 has not stated that the injury was caused either by bullet or by pellets. PW 1 has also admitted that he has not seen the recovered articles i.e. the recovered rifle and the double-barrel gun. In the absence of definite evidence as to which of the firearm caused the fatal injury, the same cannot be attributed to the appellant from whom rifle was recovered.

16. Case of the prosecution is that as per the disclosure statement of Accused 1 and 2, a rifle was recovered from the house of Accused 1 which has a single-barrel. Similarly, as pointed out earlier in post-mortem certificate (Ext. P-52), a double-barrel gun was also recovered from the house of Accused 2. It is merely stated that there were puncture wounds. The post-mortem certificate does not state as to whether those gun wounds were caused by rifle or by gun. In the absence of any definite indication as to whether those fatal wounds were caused either by rifle or by double-barrel gun, the courts ought not to have held appellant-Accused 1 responsible for the fatal firearm wounds on the body of deceased Somiben.

17. Yet another circumstance raising doubts about the prosecution case is to be pointed out. Mukeshkumar Pranlal Sheth (PW 12) and Madhusudanbhai Arvindbhai Pandya (PW 13) are the witnesses to the panchnama (Ext. P-79) for recovery of weapons from Accused 1 and 2 and both of them have not supported the prosecution case. The police officer-investigating officer has spoken about the recovery of the firearms. There is no rule of law that the evidence of police officer has to be discarded or that it suffers from some inherent infirmity. But in the facts and circumstances of the present case where two firearms viz. rifle and gun are said to have been used by Accused 1 and 2 respectively, prudence requires corroboration of recovery of the weapons from independent source. When panch witnesses in Ext. P-79 have turned hostile, the court has to seek corroboration from other sources regarding the recovery of weapons.

18. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant mainly contended that fired bullet was not recovered and only empty cartridges made of bronze were recovered near the mango tree. Contention of the appellant is that since the fired bullet which caused fatal injuries to the deceased was not recovered, the ballistic expert cannot give definite opinion as to which weapon was used to cause the fatal gun wounds to the deceased. The learned counsel further contended that ballistic expert has stated that he only tested the fired bullet C2 from rifle C1 and examined only empty bullet recovered and therefore, from the evidence of ballistic expert, it cannot be said that gunshot injury was caused to the deceased only from the rifle recovered from the appellant. Non-recovery of bullet cannot be said to be fatal to the prosecution case. Since benefit of doubt is given to the accused on other aspects like darkness in the place of occurrence and doubts as to who caused fatal injuries, we are not inclined to consider the merits of the contention assailing the opinion of the ballistic expert.

19. There was darkness at the time and the place of occurrence making it difficult for the witnesses to identify the assailants. The evidence of eyewitnesses are contradictory to each other as to the firing of the fatal blow. The guilt of the accused has not been proved beyond reasonable doubt and the benefit has to be given to the accused.

20. We are conscious that the Supreme Court would be slow to interfere with the concurrent findings of the courts below. In an appeal under Article 136 of the Constitution of India, concurrent findings of fact cannot be interfered with unless shown to be perverse (vide Mahesh Dattatray Thirthkar v. State of Maharashtra (2009) 11 SCC 141). Where the appreciation of evidence is erroneous, the Supreme Court would certainly appreciate the evidence. In our considered view, the High Court ought to have weighed and considered the materials. When the findings of the trial court and the High Court are shown to be perverse and there is no proper appreciation of evidence qua the appellant, the Supreme Court would certainly interfere with the findings of fact recorded by the High Court and the trial court. It is to be pointed out that the High Court has not appreciated the oral evidence, other evidence and the points raised by the appellant-Accused 1. In our considered view, the impugned judgment 2009 SCC OnLine Guj 12170 affirming the conviction of the appellant-Accused 1 cannot be sustained and the impugned judgment 2009 SCC OnLine Guj 12170 is liable to be set aside.

21. The conviction of appellant-Accused 1 under Section 302 IPC read with Section 34 IPC and Section 307 IPC read with Section 34 IPC and under Section 25(c) of the Arms Act is set aside and this appeal is allowed. The appellant-Accused 1 Ashoksinh Jayendrasinh is ordered to be released forthwith unless his presence is required in any other case.