- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Aban Investments Pvt... v. Deputy Commissioner ...
Structured Summary of the Opinion — I.T.A. Nos. 573 & 658/Mds/11 (ITAT, Chennai)
Factual and Procedural Background
These are cross appeals by the assessee and the Revenue against an order dated 5.1.2011 of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-III, Chennai, in respect of the impugned assessment year. The assessee had claimed exemption under Section 10(34) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 on dividend income of ₹1,55,58,725. For the same year, total interest paid was recorded by the Assessing Officer ("A.O.") as ₹3,39,39,120. The assessee itself suo motu attributed only ₹82,57,520 as pro rata interest related to exempt dividend income for purposes of disallowance under Section 14A. The A.O. disallowed a larger amount by applying Rule 8D of the Income-tax Rules, 1962, relying on a Special Bench decision (ITO v. Daga Capital Management (P) Ltd. (117 ITD 169)), resulting in a disallowance of ₹3,54,92,425. The matter was appealed to the CIT(A), who directed the A.O. to re-work the disallowance after excluding the ₹82,57,520 admitted by the assessee, relying on the Bombay High Court decision in Godrej & Boyce Mfg. Co. Ltd. v. Dy. CIT (328 ITR 81).
A second, distinct ground concerned a disallowance of ₹5,61,200 made by the A.O. under Section 40(a)(ia) for failure to deduct tax at source on loan processing fees paid to M/s Cholamandalam DBS Finance Limited. The A.O. treated the processing fees as 'interest' within the meaning of Section 2(28A) and concluded that tax should have been deducted under Section 194A; the CIT(A) upheld that view.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the disallowance under Section 14A (and the methodology under Rule 8D) could be applied to amounts standing as share application money (i.e., whether such amounts can be treated as investments made for the purpose of earning exempt dividend income), and whether Rule 8D applies retrospectively to the impugned assessment year.
- Whether loan processing fees paid to a non-banking finance company (M/s Cholamandalam DBS Finance Limited) amount to 'interest' within the meaning of Section 2(28A) and thus are subject to tax deduction at source under Section 194A, with failure attracting disallowance under Section 40(a)(ia).
Arguments of the Parties
Assessee's Arguments
- Amounts invested with certain companies comprised share application money and no shares were allotted, so such amounts could not be treated as investments made for the purpose of earning dividend income (i.e., no intention to earn dividend could be attributed while amounts remained as application money).
- Loan processing fees paid to M/s Cholamandalam DBS Finance Limited are charges levied by a lender and are not 'interest' covered by the provisions requiring TDS under Section 194A; the definition of interest in Section 2(28A) could not be transported to Section 194A to impose TDS liability on the assessee.
Assessing Officer / Revenue's Arguments
- Whether shares were actually allotted was irrelevant; funds advanced as share application money were for the purpose of earning dividend income and therefore interest on borrowed funds attributable to such investments should be disallowed under Section 14A.
- Rule 8D was correctly applied to compute the disallowance, relying on the Special Bench decision in ITO v. Daga Capital Management (P) Ltd. (117 ITD 169).
- Loan processing fees fall within the definition of 'interest' in Section 2(28A); since they constitute interest and the lender was not a banking company, TDS under Section 194A was required and failure to deduct attracts disallowance under Section 40(a)(ia).
Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)'s Position (as recorded)
- Although borrowed money invested as share application money could have been for the purpose of earning dividend income (even if shares were not allotted), Rule 8D was not applicable for the impugned assessment year in view of the Bombay High Court decision in Godrej & Boyce (328 ITR 81); directed the A.O. to re-work disallowance excluding the ₹82,57,520 admitted by the assessee.
- On the processing fees, the CIT(A) held that the definition of 'interest' in the Act should be applied for all purposes of the Act, and processing fees fell within the definition, so the disallowance under Section 40(a)(ia) was justified for failure to deduct TDS.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| ITO v. Daga Capital Management (P) Ltd. (117 ITD 169) — Special Bench | Authority relied upon by A.O. for applying Rule 8D of the Income-tax Rules, 1962 to compute disallowance under Section 14A. | The A.O. applied Rule 8D based on this Special Bench decision. The Tribunal noted this reliance but found the A.O.'s method of applying Rule 8D not correct for the impugned year in view of the subsequent Bombay High Court decision in Godrej & Boyce. |
| Godrej & Boyce Mfg. Co. Ltd. v. Dy. CIT (328 ITR 81) — Bombay High Court | Held that Rule 8D would not apply retrospectively and would operate only from assessment year 2008-09; for earlier years a disallowance under Section 14A could still be made based on facts and circumstances. | The Tribunal relied on this holding to conclude that applying Rule 8D retrospectively (as the A.O. did) was not correct for the impugned year; however, it recognized that Section 14A disallowance could still be made for earlier years depending on facts, and so remitted the matter to the A.O. for fresh consideration of the factual aspects concerning share application money. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Tribunal considered the two principal issues separately and proceeded as follows.
On Section 14A disallowance / Rule 8D and share application money
- The Tribunal observed that the A.O. applied Rule 8D pursuant to the Special Bench decision in Daga Capital, but the Bombay High Court in Godrej & Boyce had held that Rule 8D does not apply retrospectively and is applicable only from 2008-09. Consequently, application of Rule 8D to the impugned year by the A.O. "does not appear to be correct."
- Nonetheless, the Bombay High Court had also stated that for years prior to 2008-09, a disallowance under Section 14A could still be made after examining the facts and circumstances. The Tribunal therefore turned to the factual question whether amounts shown as share application money could be treated as investments for the purpose of earning dividend.
- The Tribunal accepted the proposition that share application money by itself will not yield any dividend; unless and until shares are allotted no dividend can be earned. The critical inquiry, the Tribunal held, is whether the share application money was made with the intention of earning dividend — which depends on whether the company had committed to a definite date for allotment of shares or there was other evidence showing intention/commitment.
- The Tribunal noted factual gaps in the record: Revenue had not examined whether any date for allotment was declared by M/s North Chennai Power Company Limited, whether the assessee was aware of such a date, nor were relevant share application forms available on record, and Revenue had not examined whether the company had failed to issue shares despite declaring dates. The Tribunal emphasized that if no date for allotment existed, share application money cannot be equated with an investment made for earning dividend and may at best be considered a loan to the company.
- Because these factual aspects had not been investigated by the authorities below, the Tribunal set aside the orders of the authorities below on this issue and remitted the matter to the Assessing Officer for fresh consideration in accordance with law (i.e., to examine whether there was a commitment or definite date for allotment or other facts justifying attribution of intention to earn dividend).
On TDS and loan processing fees (Sections 2(28A), 194A and 40(a)(ia))
- The Tribunal reproduced the definition of 'interest' under Section 2(28A), which includes any service fee or other charge in respect of moneys borrowed or debt incurred or in respect of any credit facility, whether utilized or not.
- Applying the statutory interpretation principle that "In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires," words defined in Section 2 are to be used unless context requires otherwise, the Tribunal found nothing in the context of Section 194A that required departing from the definition in Section 2(28A).
- Section 194A imposes a duty to deduct tax at source on payments of interest to a resident; since Section 194A does not itself define 'interest' and the processing fees were payments in respect of loans, the Tribunal concluded that such fees fell within the Section 2(28A) definition and therefore constituted 'interest' for purposes of TDS liability under Section 194A.
- Because the assessee failed to deduct tax at source on that processing fee payment, the Tribunal held that the rigours of Section 40(a)(ia) were attracted and found no grounds to interfere with the CIT(A)'s order disallowing ₹5,61,200 for failure to deduct TDS.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling:
- The Tribunal set aside the orders of the authorities below on the Section 14A / share application money issue and remitted the matter to the Assessing Officer for fresh consideration in accordance with law. The Tribunal held that Rule 8D could not be applied retrospectively for the impugned year (following the Bombay High Court in Godrej & Boyce), and that whether share application money can be treated as an investment for earning dividend depends on factual inquiries (e.g., existence of a definite date for allotment or commitments by the issuer), which had not been examined.
- The Tribunal upheld the CIT(A)'s order on the TDS issue: processing fees paid to M/s Cholamandalam DBS Finance Limited were held to fall within the definition of 'interest' under Section 2(28A), thus attracting TDS obligations under Section 194A; failure to deduct resulted in disallowance under Section 40(a)(ia). The Tribunal dismissed the assessee's ground on this issue.
- Result in the appeals: the appeal of the Revenue was allowed for statistical purposes and the appeal of the assessee was partly allowed for statistical purposes.
Practical consequences and next steps: The Assessing Officer is to re-examine and re-work the Section 14A disallowance after making factual inquiries about share application money (for example, whether there was a definite allotment date or any commitment by the company), and to decide disallowance under Section 14A consistent with the factual findings and law. On the TDS point, the disallowance of ₹5,61,200 stands. The opinion does not state or announce any new binding precedent beyond applying existing case law cited.
Supplementary Information (as recorded in the opinion)
Panel: Abraham P. George (Accountant Member) and Challa Nagendra Prasad (Judicial Member). The order was pronounced on 17th April, 2012. The CIT(A) order under challenge was dated 5.1.2011. Copies were directed to parties and records as listed in the opinion.
PER ABRAHAM P. GEORGE, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER : These are cross appeals of the assessee and Revenue respectively, directed against an order dated 5.1.2011 of the
2 I.T.A. Nos. 573 & 658/Mds/11 Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-III, Chennai, for the impugned assessment year.
2. The sole ground taken by the Revenue in its appeal and one of the grounds taken by the assessee concerns direction of the CIT(Appeals) to the A.O. for re-working the disallowance under Section 14A of Income-tax Act, 1961 (in short 'the Act'). Since this issue is common in both the appeals, it is dealt with first.
3. Short facts apropos are that assessee had claimed exemption under Section 10(34) of the Act on an amount of ` 1,55,58,725/- received as dividend. Though such dividend income was claimed as exempt, assessee had considered only a sum of ` 82,57,520/- as pro rata interest on investments made to earn such an exempt income. As per the A.O., the total interest payment for impugned assessment year was ` 3,39,39,120/-. A.O. also noted that out of the above amount, a sum of ` 82,57,520/- was considered by the assessee for disallowance under Section 14A of the Act suo motu. Submission of the assessee was that no shares were allotted to it for the investments made with M/s North Chennai Power Company Limited and the money invested in such company was lying as share application money. Therefore, according to assessee, interest could not be attributed to earning of any dividend income on such investments. However, the A.O. was
3 I.T.A. Nos. 573 & 658/Mds/11 not impressed. According to him, whether shares were allotted or not was not relevant. The funds having been advanced for allotment of shares, the investment was made with the purpose of earning dividend income. Such dividend income being exempt from tax, interest on borrowed funds had to be disallowed. Relying on the decision of Special Bench of this Tribunal in the case of ITO v. Daga Capital Management (P) Ltd. (117 ITD 169), A.O. applied Rule 8D of Income- tax Rules, 1962 and made disallowance of ` 3,54,92,425/-.
4. In its appeal before ld. CIT(Appeals), argument of the assessee was that the money invested in various companies were lying as share application money and no shares were allotted to it. Hence, it could not be presumed that the investments were made for the purpose of earning dividend income. Reliance was also placed on the decision of Honble Bombay High Court in the case of Godrej and Boyce Mfg. Co. Ltd vs. Dy. CIT (328 ITR 81). After going through the submission of the assessee, ld. CIT(Appeals) was of the opinion that borrowed money was invested in various companies and though shares were not allotted in some of such companies, the purpose for investment was only to earn dividend income. According to him, nature of borrowed fund would not change just because shares were not allotted. Nevertheless, he held that Rule 8D was not applicable for the impugned assessment year in view of the decision of Honble Bombay
4 I.T.A. Nos. 573 & 658/Mds/11 High Court in the case of Godrej and Boyce Mfg. Co. Ltd (supra). Ld. CIT(Appeals) directed the A.O. to re-work the disallowance after excluding ` 82,57,520/- suo motu admitted by the assessee for the impugned assessment year.
5. Now before us, Revenue is aggrieved regarding the direction of ld. CIT(Appeals) for excluding ` 82,57,520/-, whereas, assessee is aggrieved that investments which were lying as share application money were also considered while making disallowance under Section 14A of the Act.
6. Learned A.R. submitted that as long as the money was lying as mere share application money, no intention could be attributed for earning dividend income. According to him, this aspect was not considered by the authorities below.
7. Per contra, supporting the order of ld. CIT(Appeals), learned D.R. submitted that Rule 8D was correctly applied based on the decision of Special Bench of this Tribunal in the case of Daga Capital Management (P) Ltd. (supra).
8. We have perused the orders and heard the rival submissions. Insofar as application of the decision of Special Bench of this Tribunal in the case of Daga Capital Management (P) Ltd. (supra) is
5 I.T.A. Nos. 573 & 658/Mds/11 concerned, Honble Bombay High Court in the case of Godrej and Boyce Mfg. Co. Ltd (supra) has clearly held that Rule 8D would not apply retrospectively but only from 2008-09. So, the method adopted by the A.O. by applying Rule 8D does not appear to be correct. Nevertheless, Honble Bombay High Court has also observed that for earlier years also, a disallowance under Section 14A could be made considering the facts and circumstances of the case. Coming to the argument of the learned A.R. that share application money by itself will not yield any dividend, this, in our opinion, is absolutely true. As long as an investment remains as share application money, no dividend can be earned thereon. However, the question here is whether investment as share application money is with the intention of earning dividend, since shares will eventually get allotted against it. In our opinion, this question of intention of the assessee for earning dividend will be relevant only if there is a definite date for allotment of shares declared by the concerned company. Admittedly, here the amount was lying as share application money and no shares were allotted. Revenue has not examined as to whether any date for allotment of shares was declared by M/s North Chennai Power Company Limited nor has it examined as to whether assessee was aware of the possible date of allotment, at the point of time when it invested as share application money. Relevant share application forms are not available on record. Revenue has also not examined whether it is a case where
6 I.T.A. Nos. 573 & 658/Mds/11 despite such dates for allotment, being declared by the company, it had failed to issue shares on the application money placed by the assessee. Share application money with no known date on which shares are to be allotted, cannot be equated with an investment made for the purpose of earning dividend income. There is no question of any dividend unless and until the shares are allotted against the share application money. Assessee will not also be eligible for any interest on such money unless there is any agreement to that effect with the company. We are of the opinion that intention of the assessee for earning dividend income could not be attributed to the amounts invested in share application money, unless and until there is a commitment brought on record by the concerned company for allotment of shares. These aspects have not been looked into by the authorities below. If the concerned company in which assessee had made share application money, had given a definite date for allotment of shares but had failed to do so, no doubt, intention for earning dividend income can be attributed on the assessee. If no such date is there, no intention can be attributed, and the share application money can at the best be considered only as a loan given by the assessee to the said company. In our opinion, all these matters have to be looked into afresh. We, therefore, set aside the orders of authorities below and remit the issue back to the Assessing Officer for fresh consideration in accordance with law.
7 I.T.A. Nos. 573 & 658/Mds/11
9. Coming to the other ground taken by the assessee, which is regarding disallowance made by A.O. to the tune of ` 5,61,200/-, the said disallowance was made for a reason that assessee had not deducted tax at source on loan processing fees paid to one M/s Cholamandalam DBS Finance Limited. Explanation of the assessee was that payment of loan processing fees did not fall under the category of professional, consultancy, technical fees or contractual payments prescribed under Section 194J or 194C of the Act and therefore, these were not subject to TDS. However, Assessing Officer was not impressed. According to him, loan processing fees could be considered as interest in view of the definition of term interest given in Section 2(28A) of the Act. Payment of interest could be made only to banking companies as per Banking Regulations Act, 1949 without deduction of tax at source. Since M/s Cholamandalam DBS Finance Limited was not a banking company, as per the A.O., Section 2(28A) applied. Assessee having failed to deduct tax at source, disallowance as mandated under Section 40(a)(ia) of the Act was made.
10. In its appeal before ld. CIT(Appeals), argument of the assessee was that fees for processing loans were charges levied by the lender and it could not be considered as interest covered by Section 194A of the Act. According to assessee, definition of interest under Section
8 I.T.A. Nos. 573 & 658/Mds/11 2(28A) of the Act could not be transported to Section 194A of the Act for casting on the assessee a liability to deduct tax at source on payment of processing fees. However, ld. CIT(Appeals) was not impressed. According to him, when a word was defined in the Act, such a definition was to be used for all the purposes of the Act and there was no necessary to define it again and again. Ld. CIT(Appeals) noted that the term interest was clearly defined in the Act and processing fees paid by the assessee, as per the said definition fell within the ambit of interest. Assessee having failed to deduct the tax at source, according to him, A.O. was justified in making the disallowance.
11. Now before us, learned A.R. reiterated the arguments put forth before ld. CIT(Appeals).
12. Per contra, learned D.R. strongly supported the order of ld. CIT(Appeals).
13. We have perused the orders and heard the rival submissions. The question is whether the processing fees against the loan taken from M/s Cholamandalam DBS Finance Limited has to be considered as interest or not and if it is to be considered as interest, whether it is covered under Section 194A of the Act. Interest as defined under Section 2(28A) of the Act, is reproduced hereunder:-
9 I.T.A. Nos. 573 & 658/Mds/11 Interest means interest payable in any manner in respect of any moneys borrowed or debt incurred (including a deposit, claim or other similar right or obligation) and includes any service fee or other charge in respect of the moneys borrowed or debt incurred or in respect of any credit facility which has not been utilized. The definition is clear in that it includes all the charges in respect of moneys borrowed or debt incurred or in respect of any credit facility whether it has been utilized or not. There is no dispute that the loan processing fees paid by the assessee was in respect of loans being raised from M/s Cholamandalam DBS Finance Limited. Therefore, without doubt, such loan processing fee fell within the definition interest under Section 2(28A) of the Act. Now the question is whether the said definition of interest can be transported to Section 194A of the Act. Section 194A does not define interest as such. It simply casts a duty on a person who is responsible for paying to a resident any income by way of interest, to deduct tax at source at rates in force. So, it is clear that the person responsible for paying interest has to deduct tax at source, unless the payment fell within the exclusions provided in Section 194A. There is no case for the assessee that it fell under any of such exclusion. Section 2 of the Act start with the words In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires. Thus unless context otherwise requires interest mentioned, in Section 194A has to be understood in accordance with the definition of
10 I.T.A. Nos. 573 & 658/Mds/11 interest given under Section 2(28A) of the Act. There is nothing in the context of Section 194A which will warrant any different definition to be adopted. Therefore, we are of the opinion that the A.O. was justified in considering the processing fees paid as interest falling within the definition given in Section 2(28A) of the Act. Assessee was obliged to deduct tax at source which it had not done so. Rigours of Section 40(a)(ia) of Act is attracted. We do not find any necessity to interfere with the order of ld. CIT(Appeals). This ground taken by the assessee is dismissed.
14. To summarize result, appeal of the Revenue is allowed for statistical purposes and that of the assessee is partly allowed for statistical purposes. Order pronounced in the open court after conclusion of hearing on 17th April, 2012. sd/- sd/- (Challa Nagendra Prasad) (Abraham P. George) Judicial Member Accountant Member Chennai, Dated the 17th April, 2012. Kri. Copy to: (1) Assessee (2) Assessing Officer (3) CIT(A)- III, Chennai (4) CIT, Chennai-I, Chennai (5) D.R. (6) Guard file
Alert