- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
ITO, CHENNAI v. T.Premkumar, CHENNAI
PER CHANDRA POOJARI, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER These appeals by the Revenue are directed against the common order of the Commissioner of Income-tax(Appeals) dated 26.12.2013.
2. The common ground in all these appeals is with regard to deletion of addition made by the AO towards capital gains on sale of land treating it as non-agricultural land
3. The facts and the relevant details relating to all these above appeals in short are given as under:- Particulars Rajendra Assocites B.Rajendran Chitra Rajendran T.Premkumar Status Firm Individual Individual Individual Date of filing of return 14.10.2010 29.08.2011 24.08.2011 23.04.2011 Income Returned 48,46,670 17,06,290 3,97,670 4,52,510 Agricultural lands measurement in Paiyanur village
223 cents 2019 cents 291.1 cents 1230 cents Sale consideration 4,79,45,000 37,96,77,330 12,10,57,699 15,90,60,000 Income assessed 5,24,94,950 33,48,62,240 12,09,16,160 2,03,52,510 Since the facts are similar, we consider the relevant facts as narrated in the case of Mrs.Chitra Rajendran in ITA No.1097/Mds./2014. The facts of the case are that the assessee purchased lands on 9.10.2003 in two parts from Shri Abraham - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 3 Chacko for a total amount of 3,95,000/- ( 2,88,750/- and 1,06,250/-). During the previous year relevant to the AY 2010- 11, the assessee who was the owner of the lands measuring about 291.1 cents, at No.155, Paiyanoor village, Chengalpattu taluk, Kancheepuram District (survey numbers : 173/5AI (210.6 cents) and 63/1180.5 cents) sold the same (in two parts) for a total sum of 12.10 crores, on 15th February, 2010 to M/s. Truthful Realtors and Propbuild Pvt. Ltd., a company which is into real estate and construction business. The assessee has treated the sale proceeds amounting to 12,09,07,669/- ( 12,10,57,669/- less cost of acquisition 1,50,000/-) as exempted income claiming it to be agricultural lands. The assessee did not furnish any proof for having carried out agricultural operations in the above lands. The assessee has filed her returns for the first time this year, admitting income from other sources, being interest on deposits held and stated that the net agricultural income is reflected in her husbands return. 3.1 The AO has gone through the recitals of the sale deed for sale of 80.5 cents of land sold, wherein it is stated at page 3, second paragraph that WHEREAS presently the properties set - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 4 out in the Schedules hereunder is idle, barren and unfit for agricultural purposes and the Vendors find it very difficult to maintain the same and the said properties are lying fallow without any yield or return there from. Further, the AO observed that the other part sold is lying adjacent to this land and they share one common boundary. According to the AO, the assessee has herself admitted that the lands were sold with an intention of getting a higher profit. The AO stated that the assessee has purchased the lands abutting the Old Mahabalipuram Road (OMR-IT Corridor) in the year 2003 and the lands were sold at an exorbitant price which is far from the reach of any agriculturist to purchase for carrying out agricultural operations. According to the AO, the certificate from the Village Administrative Officer is incomplete and without the date, year etc. The certificate of the Dy. Tahsildar is dated 17.1.2006 and not relevant to the date of sale. To support the assessees case, she relied on the decision of the Madras High Court in the case of Shri M.S.Srinivasa (291 ITR 481). The assessee has also claimed that her husband had taken loan from Chingelput Co-op. Primary Agricultural Rural Development Bank Ltd. for carrying - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 5 out agricultural operations. The assessee has also stated that agricultural operations were carried out by Shri Ramachandra Naidu and a copy of the newspaper cutting which shows that a new variety of paddy, J-18 was cultivated during 2005-06. However, according to the AO, the assessee did not furnish any contemporaneous evidences to indicate that agricultural operations were carried out in the lands. Accordingly, the AO observed that the asset transferred is not an agricultural land and the same is treated as a capital asset, the transfer of which triggers capital gains. 3.2 Further, the AO observed that as per sale deed land was lying as barren land and unfit for cultivation. For this purpose, he referred the preamble of the sale deed and also answer to question No.1 of the assessee in letter dated 11.2.2013. According to the AO, the assessees intention to sale the land was to get higher profit. The assessee has claimed that the land was agricultural land and agricultural income was declared in her husbands return of income as a proof of it, returns of income of her husband for the AY 1993-94 and 1999-2000 have been filed before him, which were brushed aside by the AO, as - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 6 these returns were not relating to the assessment year under consideration. He further observed that the mere fact that the lands were used for agriculture in the past and land revenue was paid cannot be reason enough to accept the claim of the assessee that the lands were agricultural. According to the AO, some agricultural operations should have been carried out in the lands. For this proposition, the AO relied on the judgment in the case of Raja Mustafa Ali Khan v. CIT (16 ITR 330) and CIT v. Officers in Charge (Court of Wards) reported in 105 ITR 133(SC). The purchaser, M/s.Truthful Realtors and Propbuild P. Ltd. is a real estate and construction company, as per which the AO inferred that the assessee sold the land for the purpose of non-agricultural purposes. Hence, he placed reliance on the above judgment for treating the impugned land as non- agricultural land. 3.3 According to the AO, the assessee, who has been keeping the lands barren, as evident from the recitals of the sale deed, has sold the lands to a construction company for windfall gains and in view of this, the gain has to be treated as capital gains and the ruling relied on by the assessee in the case of Shri - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 7 M.S.Srinivasa Naicker & Oters Vs. ITO [292 ITR 48(Mds.)] is not analogous to the assessees case, since the lands held by the assessee do not fall under the category of agricultural lands. Even on the date of sale, as per the sale deed recitals, the lands were unfit for cultivation and lying barren. According to the AO, the subject land was non-agricultural land, which is to be treated as a capital asset, even though it may be situated beyond 8 kms from the nearest municipal limits because these conditions of distance have to be applied only to lands which are primarily classified as agricultural lands. Accordingly, the AO treated the gain arising out of sale of land as long term capital gains and brought the same to tax. Against this, the assessee went in appeal before the CIT(Appeals).
4. On appeal, the CIT(Appeals) after considering the following judgments has observed that gain on sale of land not to be charged to capital gain as the total consideration received represent sale of agricultural land which are not capital assets u/s.2(14) of the IT Act and allowed the appeal of the assessee relying on the following case laws. - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 8
1. Bhavani Distelleries and Chemicals Ltd. (ITA No.667/09-10, CIT(A)-III, Chennai dated 31.3.2000
2. Smt. B. Jayanthi (ITA No.104/1-=11, CIT(A)-IV, Chennai dated 20.3.2011
3. Shri Sheriff Dyan (ITA No. 172/08-09, CIT(A)-IX, Chennai dated 13.09.2010 AY 2006-07 & ITA No.2088/MDS/2010, ITAT, B Bench, Chennai dt. 24.6.2007 AY 2006-07
4. Smt. S. Anuradha (ITA No.115/10-11, CIT(A)-IX, Chennai dated 26.3.2012
5. CIT(A) Vs. Shashiben (288 ITR 319) wherein it was held that agricultural land, barren and uncultivated land only gross was raised still it is considered as an agricultural land.
6. Gemini Pictures Circuit P. Ltd. Vs. CIT (130 ITR 686 (Mad) the onus is on the department to prove that land is non-agricultural. Once the assessee proves that the land is agricultural, the burden of proving that it is not agricultural land is on the revenue.
7. Borhat Tea Co. Ltd. Vs. CIT (138 ITR 783)(Cal) for the purpose of land being agricultural land, actual agriculture operation or cultivation or telling of lands is not necessary. What is to be seen is whether such land is capable of agriculture operation being carried on.
8. Gordhambhai Kahandas Dalwadi Vs. CIT (127 ITR 664)(Guj) the correct test that has to be applied is whether on the date of sale the land was agricultural land or not. After the sale the purchase was going to put the land to non-agricultural use. It is not mean that the land has seized to be agricultural land on the date of sale. - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 9
9. Madha Bai H Patel Vs. CIT (20. ITR 638 (Guj) if the land is recorded as agricultural and in the revenue records and if till the date of sale, it is used and exploited as agricultural land, then such piece of land would have to be regarded as agricultural even though it was included within the municipal limits or it was sold on per acreage basis. Against this the Revenue is in appeal before us in all the above cases.
5. We have heard both the parties and perused the material on record. It is the contention of the AR that the land was held by the assessee as an agricultural land and it is not falling within 8 KMs from the local limits of any Municipal or Cantonment Board as referred in section 2(14)(iii)(a) of the Income Tax Act and also not falling within the notified area as per provisions of section 2(14)(iii)(b) of the act. The land is situated 4 KMs from Thiruporur town panchayat and 8.4 KMs from Mahabalipuram both are town panchayaths which are not a notified area and the nearest municipal corporation is Chengalpet which is 30 KMs and Chennai Corporation is about 23 KMs from the land. The land was actually classified as agricultural land as per government revenue records and this land is subject to revenue land tax. The land was actually and ordinarily used for agricultural purpose, since it was purchased till the date of sale . Even today the land is classified under agricultural land as per revenue records. The land was never used for non agricultural purpose till the date of sale and it was never ceased to put to agricultural purpose. The lands were purchased in the years 1991 -92 to 1995-96 as agricultural land and - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 10 agricultural operations were carried out in the said land by the assessee on his own and agricultural income was admitted upto assessment year 1998-
99. Subsequently, the land was used for cultivation by the third party and chitta adangal showing the cultivation of paddy was furnished to the Assessing Office. The land was actually used for agricultural purposes and the land is capable of use for the purpose of agriculture till the date of sale. The assessee also explained the reasons for non-admission of agricultural income as the land was given to third party for the agricultural purposes and there was no income from the said land. The assessee has purchased the said land measuring about 291.1 cents for a sum of `12.86 lakhs two decades ago and harvested paddy only in the said land. The future scope of the area to use the land for non-agricultural purposes do not reflect that the land is not an agricultural land and also existence of one educational institution does not alter the character of the assessees land. The assessee never made any plot out of the impugned land and the land was sold in cents and not as square feet. The assessee has not made any roads or any facilities and it was undeveloped land fit to use for agricultural purpose at the time of sale. The entire land was sold as it was purchased. The assessee sold the land only because of favourable marketing conditions as the land was fetched a higher price and the getting up higher price due to industrialization or urbanization cannot be led to conclusion that agricultural land was sold as non-agricultural land when the classification of - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 11 land shown in revenue record as agricultural land. Even temporary stoppage of the agricultural activities due to un-favourable conditions, the land cannot be treated as non-agricultural land. The assessee shown the agricultural income, when the agricultural operations were carried on the said land. In certain years, there was no agricultural income, though it was let out to other persons for agricultural purposes. The purpose for which the purchaser used the land cannot be a reason to treat the agricultural land as non agricultural land. The assessee intent to carry on agricultural operations. This agricultural land is situated beyond the municipal limits. The Assessee has not taken any permission from the Government for making plots, as the assessee never had any intention to make the land into plots and carry on real estate business in respect of the land. The assessee has sold land as it is condition. Copies of Sale Deeds of the above said land were brought on record by the assessee before the lower authorities to prove the fact that the land held/sold by the assessee is agricultural land. 5.1. The AR submitted that the sale transaction effected by the assessee in respect of the above agriculture land constituted only sale of agriculture land, and by no stretch of imagination, it cannot be treated as gain on sale of such capital asset liable for taxable capital gains, or adventure in trade and so as to treat the same as 'business transaction' for the following reasons: - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 12
i) Purchase and holding of land for a period and subsequent sale thereof itself cannot be an indicator to hold that the intention of the assessee was to carry on business with those assets. The intention cannot be presumed unless supported by evidence. In this case the treatment given by the assessee for this asset in her hands cannot indicate that the intention of the assessee is to hold the same as business asset. ii) The asset acquired was agriculture land as per the evidence brought on record for `3,95,000/-in two parts i.e. Shri Abraham Chacko `2,88,750/- and `1,06,250/- -(including stamp duty). It was sold on for a consideration of `.12,10,57,669/-. Thus, the assessee held the agriculture land for about two decades. During that period the assessee carried on regular agricultural operations in the land. In the light of favourable market conditions the assessee thought it good to sell the asset to realize a good amount. Realization of better price in a booming market cannot be considered as an adventure in trade. iii) The expression adventure in the nature of trade occurs in the definition of business under section 2(13) but the expression adventure in the nature of trade has not been defined in the Act. It may be pertinent to mention here that a specific transaction partake the character of business or an adventure in the nature of trade or realization of capital asset or a mere conversion of asset has to be decided depending upon facts of each case. iv) In deciding as to whether a particular transaction is an adventure in the nature of trade, the Assessing Officer must consider all the relevant and proved facts and circumstances. Realization of - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 13 investments consisting of purchase of agricultural land and resale, though profitable are clearly outside the domain of adventure in the nature of trade.
v) The assessee treated the assets as investment in agricultural land. Therefore disposal of the same would not convert, what was a capital accretion, to an adventure in the nature of trade. To make it more clear, sale of agricultural land by the assessee and realization of good price would not alter the basic nature and characteristic of the transaction. There was no element of trade attached to the activity of the assessee in purchase and sale of the land. A continuous business requires more activity and greater organization. This is absent in the transaction of sale of land by the assessee. Therefore, although there is profit in the transaction the transaction cannot be characterized as an adventure in the nature of trade. vi) Whether a transaction in respect of an asset is capital or business income being adventure in the nature of trade depends on the facts and circumstances of the case. There are many factors like frequency of transactions, period of holding, intention for resale etc, which determine whether the gain arising of a transaction is in the process of realisation of investment or in the course of business. The mere fact that the person has purchased a land and subsequently sold it, giving rise to a substantial profit cannot change the character of the transaction. It is the general human tendency to earn profit out of capital asset. No one invests to incur a loss. If the market condition suddenly goes up or down, it is always the tendency of a person to take a quick decision so that the realization on the investment is maximum or the loss is minimum. - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 14 vii) As already mentioned the assessee carried on agricultural operations in the said agriculture land. In that process the assessee itself involved in the primary operation such as ploughing, tilling, sowing, watering etc. The assessee has declared agricultural income in earlier assessment years and there was no income in the assessment year under consideration. 5.2. From the above, it is clear that:
a) The assessee purchased agriculture land now under consideration situated beyond 8 km from the municipal limits.
b) The assessee treated the same as fixed asset in her hand as land.
c) The land was identified as agriculture land in the revenue records.
d) The assessee carried on agricultural operations in the land.
e) The assessee did not carry on any commercial activity with reference to that land such as getting of approval for converting into sites, plotting of the same into sites etc. Thus, the character of the land i.e., agriculture nature was continuing till the same was sold by the assessee company.
f) Because of favourable market conditions the assessee sold the land and the same fetched them a good price. - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 15 5.3. Therefore, in the present case there is no dispute regarding the fact that the assessees acquired agricultural land. There is also no dispute that there was agricultural operation in this land before sale of this land. 5.4. The Assessing Officer was of the opinion that the amount received on sale of this agricultural property is nothing but long term capital gains on transfer of such an agricultural land and the same was brought into income from business. In this case, the assessee held the land always as investment and not at all converted into stock-in-trade. The character of the land in the hands of the assessees has not changed. There is no material on record in respect of this land to show that the assessee carried on activities of buying and selling of land in a systematic manner so as to justify the action of the AO in treating the activities of the assessee as adventure in the nature of trade. The assessee is not in the business of Real Estate as alleged by the lower authorities. 5.5. Now the question as to whether a land is agricultural land or not is essentially a question of fact. The question has to be answered in each case having regard to the facts and circumstances of that case. There may be factors both for and against a particular point of view. We have to answer the question on a consideration of all of them, a process of evaluation and the inference has to be drawn on a cumulative consideration of all the relevant facts. It may be stated here that not all the factors or tests would be present or absent in any case and that in each case one or more of the factors may make appearance and - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 16 that ultimate decision will have to be reached on a balanced consideration of the totality of the circumstances. 5.6. The expression 'agricultural land' is not defined in the Act, and now, whether it is agricultural land or not has to be determined by using the tests or methods laid down by the Courts from time to time. 5.7. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Smt. Sarifabibi Mohmed Ibrahim (204 ITR 631) has approved the decision of a Division Bench of the Hon'ble Gujarat High Court in the case of CIT vs. Siddharth J. Desai (1982) 28 CTR (Guj)
148 : (1983) 139 ITR 628 (Guj) and has laid down 13 tests or factors which are required to be considered and upon consideration of which, the question whether the land is an agricultural land or not has to be decided or answered. We reproduce the said 13 tests as follows:
(i) Whether the land was classified in the Revenue records as agricultural and whether it was subject to the payment of land revenue?
(ii) Whether the land was actually or ordinarily used for agricultural purposes at or about the relevant time?
(iii) Whether such user of the land was for a long period or whether it was of a temporary character or by any of a stopgap arrangement? - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 17
(iv) Whether the income derived from the agricultural operations carried on in the land bore any rational proportion to the investment made in purchasing the land?
(v) Whether, the permission under s. 65 of the Bombay Land Revenue Code was obtained for the non-agricultural use of the land? If so, when and by whom (the vendor or the vendee)? Whether such permission was in respect of the whole or a portion of the land? If the permission was in respect of a portion of the land and if it was obtained in the past, what was the nature of the user of the said portion of the land on the material date?
(vi) Whether the land, on the relevant date, had ceased to be put to agricultural use? If so, whether it was put to an alternative use? Whether such lesser and/or alternative user was of a permanent or temporary nature?
(vii) Whether the land, though entered in Revenue records, had never been actually used for agriculture, that is, it had never been ploughed or tilled? Whether the owner meant or intended to use it for agricultural purposes?
(viii) Whether the land was situated in a developed area? Whether its physical characteristics, surrounding situation and use of the land in the adjoining area were such as would indicate that the land was agricultural? - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 18
(ix) Whether the land itself was developed by plotting and providing roads and other facilities?
(x) Whether there were any previous sales of portions of the land for non- agricultural use?
(xi) Whether permission under s. 63 of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Land Act, 1948, was obtained because the sale or intended sale was in favour of a non-agriculturist? If so, whether the sale or intended sale to such non-agriculturists was for non-agricultural or agricultural user?
(xii) Whether the land was sold on yardage or on acreage basis?
(xiii) Whether an agriculturist would purchase the land for agricultural purposes at the price at which the land was sold and whether the owner would have ever sold the land valuing it as a property yielding agricultural produce on the basis of its yield?"
6. In the present case, there is no dispute that the assessee's lands were classified as agricultural land in the Revenue Records. As held by the Apex Court, when the land is assessed to the land revenue as agricultural land under State Revenue Law, it is certainly a relevant factor but not conclusive. The land was already classified as agricultural land in the Revenue Records and the assessee carried on agricultural activities in the said land, for which was no dispute as the assessee declared income from agricultural operations upto assessment year - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 19 1998-99. Since the intention of the assessee was not to use the agricultural land for non-agricultural purposes, there is no question of taking of any permission for conversion of the land. 6.1. The A.R submitted that assessee carried on agricultural operations in the land upto assessment year 1998-99. The owner intended to use it for agricultural purposes only and the intention of the owner is fulfilled since the agricultural activities generated income. The land was situated in a area wherein lot of agricultural activities are being carried on. No development of the land was done by making plots and providing roads and other facilities. It is wrong to conclude that work has been done aiming to plotting, developing infrastructure because the land development was done in other land. There was no previous sale of the portions of the land for non-agricultural use. The land was sold only as agricultural lands at the time of sale and agricultural operations were continued as on the date of sale. The land was sold on acreage basis only. The land was sold at prevailing market prices only. Non production of evidence for agricultural expenditure which was actually incurred does not make an agricultural land a non-agricultural one. What has to be seen here is whether the income was received on agricultural activity or not, instead of seeing the ratio of judgments relied by the parties. It is wrong to say that the activities of the assessee, which are agricultural in fact, confirm to the commercial nature. In view of the above, we are of the opinion that the judgment of Supreme Court in the case of Smt. - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 20 Sarifabibi Mohamed Ibrahim & Ors. (cited supra) supports the case of the assessee rather than against the assessee. 6.2. A reference could be made to the case of CWT vs. Officer-in- charge (Court of Wards) (105 ITR 138) (SC) wherein the Constitution Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court stated that the term 'agriculture' and 'agricultural purpose' was not defined in the Indian IT Act and that we must necessarily fall back upon the general sense in which they have been understood in common parlance. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed that the term 'agriculture' is thus understood as comprising within its scope the basic as well as subsequent operations in the process of agriculture and raising on the land all products which have some utility either for someone or for trade and commerce. It will be seen that the term 'agriculture' receives a wider interpretation both in regard to its operation as well as the result of the same. Nevertheless there is present all throughout the basic idea that there must be at the bottom of its cultivation of the land in the sense of tilling of the land, sowing of the seeds, planting and similar work done on the land itself and this basic conception is essential sine qua non of any operation performed on the land constituting agricultural operation and if the basic operations are there, the rest of the operations found themselves upon the same, but if the basic operations are wanting, the subsequent operations do not acquire the characteristics of agricultural operations. The Constitution Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 21 aforesaid case observed that the entries in Revenue records were considered good prima facie evidence. 6.3. The Hon'ble Gujarat High Court in the case of Dr. Motibhai D. Patel vs. CIT (1982) 27 CTR (Guj) 238 : (1981) 127 ITR 671 (Guj) referring to the Constitution Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court had stated that if agricultural operations are being carried on in the land in question at the time when the land is sold and further if the entries in the Revenue records show that the land in question is agricultural land, then, a presumption arises that the land is agricultural in character and unless that presumption is rebutted by evidence led by the Revenue, it must be held that the land was agricultural in character at the time when it was sold. The Division Bench of the Hon'ble Gujarat High Court further held that there was nothing on record to show that the presumption rose from the long user of the land for agricultural purpose and also the presumption arising from the entries of the Revenue records are rebutted. 6.4. The Hon'ble Bombay High Court in the case of CWT vs. H. V. Mungale (1983) 32 CTR (Bom) 301 : (1984) 145 ITR 208 (Bom) held that the Hon'ble Supreme Court had pointed out that the entries raised only a rebuttable presumption and some evidence would, therefore, have to be led before taxing authorities on the question of intended user of the land under consideration before the presumption could be rebutted. The Court further held that the Supreme Court had clearly pointed out that the burden to rebut the presumption - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 22 would be on the Revenue. The Hon'ble Bombay High Court held that the ratio of the decision of the Supreme Court was that what is to be determined is the character of the land according to the purpose for which it was meant or set apart and can be used. It is, therefore, obvious that the assessee had abundantly proved that the subject land sold by them was agricultural land not only as classified in the Revenue records, but also it was subjected to the payment of land revenue and that it was actually and ordinarily used for agricultural purpose at the relevant time. 6.5. We may also refer to the case of CIT vs. Manilal Somnath (1977) 106 ITR
917 (Guj), wherein the Division Bench of the Hon'ble Gujarat High Court observed that the potential non- agricultural value of the land for which a purchaser may be prepared to pay a large price would not detract from its character as agricultural land on the relevant date of sale. 6.6. We may also refer to the case of Gopal C. Sharma vs. CIT (1994) 116 CTR (Bom) 377 : (1994) 209 ITR 946 (Bom), in which, the case of Smt. Sarifabibi Mohamed Ibrahim & Ors. vs. CIT (supra) was referred to and relied, amongst other cases. In this case, the Division Bench of the Bombay High Court has stated that the profit motive of the assessee selling the land without anything more by itself can never be decisive for determination of the issue as to whether the transaction amounted to an adventure in the nature of trade. In other words, the price paid is not decisive to say whether the land is agricultural or not. - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 23 6.7. We may refer to a judgment of the Hon'ble Madras High Court in the case of CWT vs. E. Udayakumar (2006) 284 ITR 511 (Mad) where the Hon'ble Madras High Court has referred to the decision of the Hon'ble Punjab & Haryana High Court in the case of CIT vs. Smt. Savita Rani (2004) 186 CTR (P&H) 240 : (2004)
270 ITR 40 (P&H) and has observed and held as under : "8. It is well settled in the case of CIT vs. Smt. Savita Rani (2004)
186 CTR (P&H) 240 : (2004) 270 ITR 40 (P&H), wherein it is held that the land being located in a commercial area or the land having been partially utilised for non-agricultural purposes or that the vendees had also purchased it for non-agricultural purposes, were totally irrelevant consideration for the purposes of application of s. 54B.
9. In the abovesaid case, the assessee an individual sold 15 karnals,
18 marlas of land out of her share in 23 karnals, 17 marlas land during the financial year 1990-91, relevant to the asst. yr. 1991-92, the sale was effected by three registered sale deeds. While filing her return of income, she claimed exemption from levy of capital gains under s. 54B of the Act on the ground that the land sold by her was agricultural land and the sale proceeds were invested in the purchase of agricultural land within two years. The AO rejected the claim of the assessee holding that the land sold by the assessee was not agricultural land and this was upheld by the CIT(A). On further appeal, the Tribunal accepted the claim of the assessee holding that the transaction in question duly fulfilled the conditions specified for relief. On further appeal to the High Court, the Punjab & Haryana High Court found that the finding that the land had been used for agricultural purposes was based on cogent and relevant material. - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 24 The Revenue record supported the claim. Even the records of the IT Department showed that the assessee had declared agricultural income from this land in her returns for the preceding two years. The land being located in commercial area or the land having been partially utilised for non-agricultural purposes or that the vendees had also purchased it for nonagricultural purposes, were totally irrelevant consideration for the purposes of application of s. 54B.
10. It is seen from the aforesaid decision that the agricultural land sold by the assessee with an intent to purchase another land within two years had also been permitted to claim exemption under s. 54B of the IT Act, 1961. In the instant case, even though there was no sale as such, the assessee owned agricultural land within the limits of Tirunelveli Corporation and he had not put up any construction thereon, the assessee is entitled to claim exemption from the WT Act for the assessment of wealth-tax. That the land in question is adjacent to the hospital is totally irrelevant."
7. Adverting to the facts of the present case, the land in question is classified in the Revenue records as agricultural land and there is no dispute regarding this issue and actual cultivation has been carried on this land upto assessment year 1998-99 and income was declared from this land in the return of income filed by the assessee for the assessment year as agricultural income. It is also an admitted fact that the AO has not brought on record any evidence to show that the agricultural land was used for non-agricultural purposes after the assessment year 1998-99 and the assessee has not put the land to any purposes other than agricultural purposes after the assessment year 1998-99. - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 25
8. It is also an admitted position that mere inclusion or proximity of land to any development area without any infrastructure development thereupon or without establishing and proving that the land was put into use for non- agricultural purposes by the assessee does not and cannot convert the agricultural land into non-agricultural land. In the instant case, at the relevant point of sale of the land in question, because the surrounding area was totally developed and mere possibility to put the land into use for non-agricultural purposes would not change the character of the agricultural land into non- agricultural land, when the land was sold by the assessee. It is also an admitted position that the assessee had not applied for conversion of the land in question into non-agricultural purposes and no such permissions were obtained from the concerned authority. In the Revenue records, the land is classified as agricultural land and has not been changed from agricultural land to non-agricultural land at the relevant point of time when the land was sold by the assessee. It is also not in dispute that there was no activity undertaken by the assessee of developing the land by plotting and providing roads and other facilities and there was no intention also on the part of the assessees herein to put the same for non- agricultural purposes at time of their ownership that land. No such finding has been given by the Department. No material or evidence in support of the fact that the assessees have put the land in use for non-agricultural purposes has been brought on record. At the relevant point of time the land was used for agricultural purposes only and nothing is brought on record to show that the land - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 26 was put in use for non-agricultural purposes by the assessee. In view of the decision of the Hon'ble High Court in the case of Gopal C. Sharma vs. CIT (209 ITR 946) (Bom), it is also clear that the profit motive of the assessee in selling the land without anything more by itself can never be decisive to say that the assessee used the land for non-agricultural purposes. We may also refer to a decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of N. Srinivasa Rao vs. Special Court (2006) 4 SCC 214 where it was observed that the fact that agricultural land in question is included in urban area without more, held not enough to conclude that the user of the same had been altered with passage of time. Thus, the fact that the land in question in the instant case is bought by Developer cannot be a determining factor by itself to say that the land was converted into use for non-agricultural purposes.
9. It is also evident from the Memorandum explaining the provisions of Finance Act, 1970, whereby s. 2(14) was amended so as to include the agricultural land located within the jurisdiction of a municipality in the definition of the expression 'Capital Asset'. The relevant portion of the said memorandum is reproduced hereunder: "30. ... The Finance Act, 1970 has, accordingly, amended the relevant provisions of the Income-tax Act so as to bring within the scope of taxation capital gains arising from the transfer of agricultural land situated in certain areas. For this purpose, the definition of the term "capital asset" in section 2(14) has been amended so as to exclude from its scope only agricultural land in India which is not situate in any - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 27 area comprised within the jurisdiction of a municipality or cantonment board and which has a population of not less than ten thousand persons according to the last preceding census for which the relevant figures have been published before the first day of the previous year. The Central Government has been authorised to notify in the Official Gazette any area outside the limits of any municipality or cantonment board having a population of not less than ten thousand up to a maximum distance of 8 kilometres from such limits, for the purposes of this provision. Such notification will be issued by the Central Government, having regard to the extent of, and scope for, urbanisation of such area, and, when any such area is notified by the Central Government, agricultural land situated within such area will stand included within the term "capital asset". Agricultural land situated in rural areas, i.e., areas outside any municipality or cantonment board having a population of not less than ten thousand and also beyond the distance notified by the Central Government from the limits of any such municipality or cantonment board, will continue to be excluded from the term "capital asset". 9.1 In view of the above discussion, we are of the opinion that the land in question cannot be considered as stock in trade in the hands of assessee or capital asset liable for taxable capital gains on its transfer. It is nothing but transfer of agricultural land in terms of Sec.2(14)(iii) r.w.s. 10(37) of the Act and transfer of that land cannot lead to taxable capital gains or income from business. - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 28 9.2 Further, it is also be noted that our above view is also supported by the recent judgment of Jurisdictional High Court in T.C.A.No. 483/2016 dated 1-9-2016 in the case of M/s Mansi Finance Chennai Ltd. In view of the above, we direct the AO to consider gain on sale of impugned land as exempted from capital gain and to treat as capital receipt under provisions of section 10(37) of the Act only. Accordingly, we dismiss the ground taken by the Revenue in its appeal.
10. Since the issue in other appeals by the Revenue in ITA Nos. 1144/Mds./2014, 1164/Mds./2014, & 1165/Mds./2014 are identical, following the ratio laid down in ITA No.1097/Mds./2014 as discussed above, we are inclined to dismiss these appeals of the Revenue also.
11. In the result, all the appeals of the Revenue are dismissed. Order pronounced on Wednesday , the 05th of April 2017 at Chennai. Sd/- Sd/- (. ) (& ) (G. Pavan Kumar) (Chandra Poojari)
8 :/Judicial Member :/Accountant Member 8/Chennai, B/Dated, the 05.04.2017. K S Sundaram - - ITA 1097, 1164/14 etc. 29 DE FE/Copy to:
1. /Appellant
2. /Respondent
3. G ()/CIT(A)
4. G/CIT
5. E J/DR
Alert