- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
THE STATE OF RAJASTHAN v. KANHAIYA LAL
Procedural History:
- The High Court allowed the respondent's appeal and convicted him under Section 304 Part I of the Penal Code, 1860 instead of Section 302 IPC.
- The State filed an appeal against this decision.
- The High Court partly allowed the appeal by the accused and convicted him under Section 304 Part I IPC instead of Section 302 IPC.
Facts:
- The deceased, Rajmal, died due to a single injury caused by the appellant-accused Kanhaiya Lal using an axe.
- The Sessions Court initially convicted the accused under Section 302 IPC, which was later converted to Section 304 Part I IPC by the High Court.
- The High Court based its decision on the fact that it was a single blow causing the death and there were no repeated injuries.
Issues:
1. Whether the High Court erred in converting the conviction from Section 302 IPC to Section 304 Part I IPC.
2. Whether the High Court's decision was contrary to the evidence on record and a failure of interest of justice.
Arguments:
- The State argued that the injuries sustained by the deceased clearly indicated a case of murder under Section 300 IPC, justifying the initial conviction under Section 302 IPC.
- The State contended that the High Court's decision was manifestly perverse and not supported by the evidence on record.
Decision:
- The Supreme Court allowed the State's appeal, set aside the High Court's judgment, and restored the trial court's conviction of the accused under Section 302 IPC.
- The respondent-accused was sentenced to suffer imprisonment for life as per the trial court's judgment.
Reasoning:
- The High Court's reliance on the single blow and absence of repeated injuries as reasons for converting the conviction was deemed erroneous.
- The Court found that the injuries sustained by the deceased and the circumstances of the case supported a conviction under Section 302 IPC for murder.
Conclusion:
The Supreme Court's decision to set aside the High Court's judgment and restore the conviction under Section 302 IPC was based on the evidence and the proper application of the law.
M.R. Shah, J.— Leave granted. This appeal arises from the judgment and order of a Division Bench of the High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan dated 23-5-2014 passed in Kanhaiya Lal v. State of Rajasthan Criminal Appeal No. 303 of 2009. The High Court, while allowing the appeal filed by the respondent, convicted him under Section 304 Part I of the Penal Code, 1860 instead of Section 302 IPC. The High Court sentenced the respondent to undergo 8 years' RI and to pay a fine of Rs 1000 and in default of payment of fine, to suffer one month's simple imprisonment. The State preferred this appeal against the said decision.
2. A first information report was lodged by one Dalip Kumar at Police Station Nimbaheda being FIR No. 32/2008. It was alleged that on 26-1-2008, when PW 5 Ms Kailashi was returning from the farm, in her presence, Kanhaiya Lal attacked Raju (deceased) on his head by an axe. As per PW 5, Raju fell down and, on her cries, other persons reached the spot. The accused ran away. That Raju succumbed to the injuries.
3. After concluding the investigation, the investigating officer filed the charge-sheet against the accused for the offence punishable under Section 302 IPC. That the accused pleaded not guilty and therefore he came to be tried by the learned Sessions Court for the offence punishable under Section 302 IPC. That the prosecution examined as many as 17 witnesses including PW 1 Dr K. Asif, who issued the injury report (Ext. P-1); PW 5 Ms Kailashi; PW 15 Dr Anees Ahmed, who performed the post-mortem of the deceased. Through the witnesses who were examined, the prosecution brought on record the documentary evidence including the injury report (Ext. P-1) as well as the post-mortem report. That thereafter, the statement of the accused under Section 313 CrPC was recorded, in which the accused stated that he has been falsely implicated. No evidence/witness was produced by the accused in defence. That thereafter, on appreciation of evidence, the learned Sessions Court held the accused guilty for the offence punishable under Section 302 IPC and sentenced him to undergo life imprisonment with fine of Rs 1000 and in default to pay the fine, to undergo further one month's SI.
4. Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the judgment and order of conviction and sentence passed by the learned Sessions Court, the respondent—original accused preferred appeal before the High Court being Criminal Appeal No. 303 of 2009. By the impugned judgment and order Criminal Appeal No. 303 of 2009, the High Court has partly allowed the appeal preferred by the accused and has convicted the accused under Section 304 Part I IPC instead of Section 302 IPC. Hence, the present appeal by the State against the impugned judgment and order Criminal Appeal No. 303 of 2009 passed by the High Court, converting the conviction of the accused to Section 304 Part I IPC in place of conviction under Section 302 IPC.
5. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant the State of Rajasthan has vehemently submitted that in the facts and circumstances of the case, the High Court has materially erred in altering the conviction of the accused from Section 302 IPC to Section 304 Part I IPC.
5.1. It is vehemently submitted by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant State that the main reason given by the High Court while converting the conviction from Section 302 IPC to Section 304 Part I is that the deceased died because of a single injury caused on his head. It is submitted that however the High Court has not at all considered the fact that the accused gave the blow by an axe, a deadly weapon and that too on the vital part of the body i.e. head. It is submitted that as per the medical evidence, the head injury was sufficient to cause death in ordinary course of nature. It is submitted that, therefore, the High Court is not justified in converting the conviction from Section 302 IPC to Section 304 Part I IPC.
5.2. It is further submitted by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant State that another reason given by the High Court is that there was an altercation between the accused and the deceased and so it can be said that in the circumstances of the case there was no intention to cause death on the part of the appellant-accused. It is submitted that however the High Court has failed to consider and appreciate/reappreciate the fact that at the time when the incident had taken place, there was no altercation at all and the altercation was before few hours and not at the time when the incident had taken place.
5.3. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant State has submitted that in the facts and circumstances of the case and the injuries sustained by the deceased, it was a clear case of murder within the definition of Section 300 IPC and as such the learned Sessions Court rightly convicted the accused for the offence under Section 302 IPC. It is submitted by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant State that the judgment of the High Court is manifestly perverse and is totally contrary to the evidence on record and therefore the interference of this Court is warranted.
5.4. Making the above submissions and relying upon the decisions of this Court in Arun Raj v. Union of India (2010) 6 SCC 457; Ashokkumar Magabhai Vankar v. State of Gujarat (2011) 10 SCC 604; Vijay Ramkrishan Gaikwad v. State of Maharashtra (2012) 11 SCC 592, and a recent decision of this Court in State of Rajasthan v. Leela Ram (2019) 13 SCC 131, it is prayed to allow the present appeal and set aside the impugned judgment and order Criminal Appeal No. 303 of 2009 passed by the High Court and to restore the judgment and order of conviction and sentence passed by the learned Sessions Court.
6. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent-original accused, while opposing the present appeal, has vehemently submitted that while converting the conviction of the accused from Section 302 IPC to Section 304 Part I IPC, the High Court has given cogent reasons and has considered the relevant circumstances and thereafter has come to the conclusion that the intention of the accused cannot be said to be to cause death of the deceased. It is submitted that the High Court has considered the relevant circumstances and thereafter has converted the conviction from Section 302 IPC to Section 304 Part I IPC and therefore the same is not required to be interfered with by this Court.
7. Heard the learned advocates appearing for the respective parties at length.
7.1. We have considered in detail the judgment and order passed by the learned Sessions Court as well as the impugned judgment and order Criminal Appeal No. 303 of 2009 passed by the High Court. The learned Sessions Court convicted the accused for the offence under Section 302 IPC. However, in an appeal preferred by the accused, the High Court has converted the conviction from Section 302 IPC to Section 304 Part I IPC. While doing so, the High Court has assigned the following reasons in para 15:
“15. In the circumstances of the case, it is proved beyond doubt that Rajmal had died because of single injury caused on his head by appellant-accused Kanhaiya Lal by an axe. It is also an admitted fact that there was no repeated injury and furthermore, it is also on record that in the morning of the day of the incident, there was an altercation between the accused and the deceased and so it can be said that in the circumstances of the case, that there was no intention to cause death on the part of the appellant-accused but the act by which the death was caused appears to have been done with the intention of causing such bodily injury as was likely to cause death and so his conviction deserves to be altered from Section 302 of the Penal Code to Section 304 Part I of the Penal Code.”
7.2. Now so far as the main reason given by the High Court while converting the conviction from Section 302 IPC to Section 304 Part I IPC i.e. it was a case of a single blow is concerned, it is required to be noted that the deceased had died because of single injury caused on his head by the accused by an axe. The aforesaid can hardly be a ground to convert the conviction from Section 302 IPC to Section 304 Part I IPC.
7.3. In Arun Raj (2010) 6 SCC 457 this Court observed and held that there is no fixed rule that whenever a single blow is inflicted, Section 302 would not be attracted. It is observed and held by this Court in the aforesaid decision that nature of weapon used and vital part of the body where blow was struck, prove beyond reasonable doubt the intention of the accused to cause death of the deceased. It is further observed and held by this Court that once these ingredients are proved, it is irrelevant whether there was a single blow struck or multiple blows.
7.4. In Ashokkumar Magabhai Vankar (2011) 10 SCC 604, the death was caused by single blow on head of the deceased with a wooden pestle. It was found that the accused used pestle with such force that head of the deceased was broken into pieces. This Court considered whether the case would fall under Section 302 or Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC. It is held by this Court that the injury sustained by the deceased, not only exhibits intention of the accused in causing death of victim, but also knowledge of the accused in that regard. It is further observed by this Court that such attack could be none other than for causing death of victim. It is observed that any reasonable person, with any stretch of imagination can come to conclusion that such injury on such a vital part of the body, with such a weapon, would cause death.
7.5. A similar view is taken by this Court in the recent decision in Leela Ram (2019) 13 SCC 131 and after considering a catena of decisions of this Court on the issue on hand i.e. in case of a single blow, whether a case falls under Section 302 or Section 304 Part I or Section 304 Part II, this Court reversed the judgment 2008 SCC OnLine Raj 945 of the High Court (in that case also the judgment impugned was from the Rajasthan High Court) and convicted the accused for the offence under Section 302 IPC. In the same decision, this Court also considered Exception 4 of Section 300 IPC and observed in para 21 as under: (SCC para 21)
“21. Under Exception 4, culpable homicide is not murder if the stipulations contained in that provision are fulfilled. They are: (i) that the act was committed without premeditation; (ii) that there was a sudden fight; (iii) the act must be in the heat of passion upon a sudden quarrel; and (iv) the offender should not have taken undue advantage or acted in a cruel or unusual manner.”
8. Applying the law laid down by this Court in the aforesaid decisions to the facts of the case on hand and the reasoning given by the High Court while converting the conviction from Section 302 to Section 304 Part I, the reasons stated in para 15 of the impugned judgment and order Criminal Appeal No. 303 of 2009, we are firmly of the view that the judgment of the High Court is manifestly perverse and is totally contrary to the evidence on record. As per the deposition of PW 1 Dr K. Asif, the deceased sustained following injuries:
“1. Incised wound 7 cm × 0.5 cm skin-deep and bone visible on the middle part of the head.
2. Abrasion 1 cm × 0.5 cm on the middle portion of right leg.”
As per PW 15 Dr Anees Ahmed, a fracture of 4 cm length was found in the parietal and occipital bones. He also stated that the said head injury was sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature. Thus, the accused used a deadly weapon—axe on the vital part of the body—head, which proved to be fatal.
9. Another reason given by the High Court is that there was no repeated injury. The aforesaid can hardly be a ground to convert the conviction from Section 302 to Section 304 Part I IPC. A single blow on the vital part of the body like head and that too by deadly weapon axe and used with force which proved to be fatal, was sufficient to hold that it was a case of murder within the definition of Section 300 IPC.
10. Another reason given by the High Court is that in the morning on the day of the incident, there was an altercation between the accused and the deceased and so it can be said that in the circumstances of the case there was no intention to cause death on the part of the accused but the fact by which the death was caused appears to hold down that the intention of causing such bodily injury as was likely to cause death. The aforesaid is contrary to the evidence on record. It is required to be noted that it is not a case on behalf of the accused that there was an altercation between the accused and the deceased at the time of commission of the offence. The altercation, if any, had taken place, in the morning and much earlier than the time of the incident. Merely because the altercation might have taken place much earlier and not immediately prior to and/or at the time of commission of the offence, it cannot be inferred that there was no intention on the part of the accused to cause death of the deceased. Therefore, on the aforesaid ground, the High Court has committed a grave error in converting/altering the conviction from Section 302 IPC to Section 304 Part I IPC. Thus, we are of the view that the judgment of the High Court is manifestly perverse and is totally contrary to the evidence on record. The High Court has committed a grave error in altering the conviction from Section 302 IPC to Section 304 Part I IPC and therefore the interference of this Court is warranted to obviate a complete failure of interest of justice.
11. In view of the above and for the reasons stated above, we allow this appeal, set aside the impugned judgment Criminal Appeal No. 303 of 2009 of the High Court and restore the judgment of the trial court convicting the accused under Section 302 IPC. The respondent-accused is sentenced to suffer imprisonment for life as per the judgment of the learned trial court. If the accused is already released after undergoing the sentence as per the impugned judgment and order Criminal Appeal No. 303 of 2009 passed by the High Court, the respondent-accused shall surrender forthwith to serve his sentence.
12. A copy of this order shall be forwarded by the Registry to the Chief Judicial Magistrate of the area concerned to seek compliance.
Alert