- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Anand Kumar Sharma v. Bar Council Of India Through Secretary And Another
Facts:
- The Bar Council of Rajasthan received a complaint alleging that the appellant's enrolment in the Bar Council of Himachal Pradesh was obtained by suppression of facts and relevant material.
- The appellant applied for enrolment as an advocate in the Bar Council of Rajasthan seeking exemption from one year of training based on his prior experience as an advocate.
- The appellant also filed an application for enrolment as an advocate before the Bar Council of Rajasthan, which was rejected on 29-6-2003.
Issues:
1. Whether the appellant's enrolment in the Bar Council of Himachal Pradesh was obtained by suppression of facts and relevant material.
2. Whether the appellant is entitled to exemption from one year of training based on his prior experience as an advocate.
3. Whether the rejection of the appellant's application for enrolment by the Bar Council of Rajasthan was justified.
Decision:
The court found that the orders impugned in the appeals did not have any infirmity and upheld them. The appeals were dismissed accordingly.
Outcome:
The appellant's appeals were dismissed, and the orders of the Bar Council of Rajasthan were upheld.
Summary:
The appellant, a qualified medical doctor and advocate enrolled in the Bar Council of Himachal Pradesh, faced complaints regarding the manner of his enrolment. He sought exemption from training in the Bar Council of Rajasthan based on his prior experience but was rejected. The court upheld the decisions of the Bar Council of Rajasthan, resulting in the dismissal of the appellant's appeals.
L. Nageswara Rao, J.— Leave granted in SLP (C)… CC Nos. 10531-532 of 2013. The appellant was enroled as an advocate in the Bar Council of Himachal Pradesh in July 1988. He applied for transfer of his enrolment to the State of Rajasthan which was permitted by the Bar Council of India on 27-5-1989. The Bar Council of Rajasthan received a complaint that the appellant's enrolment in the State of Himachal Pradesh was obtained by suppression of facts and relevant material. The enrolment of the appellant was cancelled on 6-11-1995 by the Bar Council of India. The said order was affirmed by this Court as the special leave petition filed by the appellant was dismissed on 5-8-1996 SLP (C) No. 2814 of 1996.
2. Thereafter, the appellant applied for enrolment as an advocate seeking exemption from training of one year in view of his experience as an advocate earlier. He approached the High Court of Rajasthan seeking a direction to the Bar Council of Rajasthan to decide his application for exemption from training. The said writ petition was dismissed by a learned Single Judge by holding that the appellant was not entitled for enrolment. In the appeal filed against the said judgment of the learned Single Judge, a Division Bench directed the Bar Council of Rajasthan to consider the application filed by the appellant without being influenced by the observations made by the learned Single Judge.
3. The Bar Council of Rajasthan dismissed the application of the appellant for enrolment on 16-1-2000 and referred the matter for confirmation of the Bar Council of India. The Bar Council of India confirmed the order passed by the Bar Council of Rajasthan on 16-1-2000. The appellant filed yet another application for enrolment as an advocate before the Bar Council of Rajasthan which was rejected on 29-6-2003. The Bar Council of India confirmed the order of 29-6-2003 by its resolution dated 3-1-2004.
4. The appellant made another attempt for enrolment by filing an application before the Bar Council of Rajasthan. Initially, the said application was rejected on the ground that the appellant cannot be admitted as an advocate since he has crossed the age of 45 years in view of Rule 1-A of the Enrolment Rules, Bar Council of Rajasthan framed under Section 28(1)(d) read with Section 24(1)(e) of the Advocates Act, 1961. The said Rule was struck down by the High Court of Rajasthan by judgment dated 19-8-2008 2008 SCC OnLine Raj 734, (2009) 1 RLW 609. Taking into account the earlier order dated 16-1-2000 by which the application for enrolment filed by the appellant was rejected, the Bar Council of Rajasthan refused to enrol the appellant as an advocate by the order dated 14-7-2012. The order dated 14-7-2012 of the Bar Council of Rajasthan was affirmed by the Bar Council of India on 15-9-2012.
5. CA No. 294 of 2007 is filed by the appellant challenging the order dated 29-6-2003 of the Bar Council of Rajasthan and the consequential orders dated 2-1-2004 of the Bar Council of India and the order dated 18-3-2004 of the Bar Council of Rajasthan. The legality of the orders dated 14-7-2012 of the Bar Council of Rajasthan affirmed by the Bar Council of India on 15-9-2012 is subject-matter of Special Leave Petitions (C) … CC Nos. 10531-532 of 2013.
6. The appellant is a qualified medical doctor who was appointed as a Medical Officer on contract basis by the Government of Himachal Pradesh. In the affidavit filed in Special Leave Petitions (C) … CC Nos. 10531-532 of 2013, the appellant stated that an FIR was registered against him at Police Station Dhambola on 15-4-1988. He was arrested and sent to judicial custody. He further stated that he was absent from service without obtaining leave for which reason his services were terminated by the Director. The appellant has also referred to his conviction under Section 419 of the Penal Code, 1860 by the Judicial Magistrate on 7-1-1988. He has also filed the judgment of the Sessions Judge, Dungarpur, Rajasthan by which his appeal against the conviction under Section 419 IPC was allowed. The suppression that was alleged against the appellant at the time of seeking enrolment in the Bar Council of Himachal Pradesh pertains to his being in government service in the State of Himachal Pradesh and his involvement in a criminal case. Subsequent acquittal cannot come to the rescue of the appellant. Section 26 of the Advocates Act, 1961 confers power on the Bar Council of India to remove the name of a person who entered on the roll of advocates by misrepresentation. It is in exercise of this power that the enrolment of the appellant was cancelled.
7. The first order that was passed by the Bar Council cancelling his enrolment as an advocate was confirmed SLP (C) No. 2814 of 1996 by this Court. The repeated attempts made by the appellant later amount to an abuse of process. The appellant would be better advised not to indulge in pursuing the matter pertaining to his enrolment as advocate. The orders impugned in the appeals do not suffer from any infirmity and are upheld.
8. The appeals are dismissed accordingly.
Alert