- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Manoj Kumar Pal v. High Court Of Tripura
Structured Summary of the Opinion (S. Talapatra, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The writ petitioner is the Chief Librarian of the High Court of Tripura, appointed on promotion with effect from 01.07.2014. He had earlier joined service in 1989 as an Assistant Librarian and was later appointed to the feeder post of Librarian-cum-Research Officer, which qualifies for promotion to the post of Chief Librarian. Recruitment rules provide that the post of Chief Librarian is to be filled by promotion from Librarian-cum-Research Officer on the basis of merit-cum-seniority, failing which by direct recruitment subject to eligibility criteria.
The petitioner's grievance is that his initial pay upon promotion was fixed at a lower amount than the entry pay specified for a direct recruit to the same post. The petitioner contends that had he been directly recruited his initial pay would have been higher (various figures are referenced in the record). He sought by writ petition an order setting aside the initial pay fixation dated 16.07.2014 and directing fixation at the higher entry pay applicable to direct recruits.
In response, the High Court constituted a Committee to examine the petitioner's representation (submitted on 03.02.2017). The Committee produced a report identifying a disparity between the pay fixed for promotees and the entry pay specified for direct recruits, and concluded that an amendment to the Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 would be necessary to remove the anomaly. The matter was argued before the court by counsel for the petitioner and for the respondents, and the court issued directions seeking executive action by the Finance Department to address the identified anomaly.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a promotee to the post of Chief Librarian is entitled to have his initial pay fixed at the same entry pay as that prescribed for a direct recruit to the identical post, where the relevant pay fixation rules produce different initial pay for promotees and direct recruits.
- Whether the principle of "stepping up" (including under FR-27 or the Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009) applies to the petitioner's case so as to remedy any disparity in initial pay between promotees and direct recruits.
- Whether the operation of the relevant pay fixation rules (notably Rule 12 of the TSCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 read with the Fourth Amendment) that results in different initial pay for the same post when filled by different sources of recruitment is constitutionally permissible, having regard to equality principles (Article 14) and other constitutional provisions (Article 39) relied on by the petitioner.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments (as advanced by Mr. D.K. Biswas)
- The petitioner contended that the operation of the rules permitted two different initial pay fixations for the same and identical post depending only on the source of appointment, which is impermissible and violates constitutional principles (Article 39 read with Article 14 of the Constitution of India).
- Although the petition sought stepping up, counsel conceded that the specific principle of stepping up may not directly apply in this case; nevertheless, he maintained that under Rule 12 of the TSCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 (as amended) the petitioner's pay was fixed and that the result is arbitrary and unjustified.
- Counsel emphasized the urgency because the petitioner was due to retire shortly and sought appropriate relief to rectify the anomaly before retirement.
Respondents' Arguments
- High Court respondents (No. 1 & 3) submitted that there was no challenge to the rule itself in the writ petition and that the difference in initial pay arose from the clear operation of Rule 12, which provides different methodologies and schedules for promotees and direct recruits. They pointed out that the rules specify an entry pay for direct recruits (record refers to an entry pay figure of Rs. 29,920/- in one place and other figures appear in the committee report) and that the petitioner as a promotee had his pay fixed in accordance with Rule 12.
- The Committee constituted by the High Court reported that the promotee's pay fixation was done under Rule 12(i) of the Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 read with the Fourth Amendment. The Committee compared the promotee's pay (in its report one figure recorded is Rs. 24,340/-) with the entry pay for a direct recruit (in that report shown as Rs. 26,480 at entry level) and concluded that there exists an anomaly between the pay of direct recruits and promotees; it recommended amendment of the rules to rectify the disparity.
- Respondent No. 2 (represented by Mr. R. Datta) argued that the post of Chief Librarian is a solitary post to be filled on promotion and therefore cannot be fairly compared on a hypothetical basis; he further submitted that stepping up (including any subsequent amendment) may not apply because there is no junior-senior relationship in the same post for stepping up to operate, and therefore the petitioner's averment on stepping up was misconceived.
Table of Precedents Cited
The opinion does cite constitutional provisions and statutory rules but does not cite judicial precedents (case law).
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the parties' submissions, the relevant statutory provisions (in particular Rule 12 of the Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 and its Fourth Amendment, and the pay schedules for direct recruits set out in Rule 8 read with Schedule-1, Part-E), and the Committee's report prepared by the High Court.
Step-by-step the court's analysis proceeded as follows:
- The court held that the stepping up principle under FR-27 or under the Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 (as amended) did not apply to the present facts. It also found that stepping up the initial pay to the minimum of the pay band for the promotional post was not relevant in this case.
- Notwithstanding the inapplicability of stepping up, the court observed that the relevant rules, as presently framed, allow a situation in which two persons holding the same and identical post (Chief Librarian) but appointed through different recruitment sources (promotion vs direct recruitment) could receive different initial pay simply by operation of the rules. The court described this result as "apparently unsustainable."
- The court accepted the Committee's finding that there exists an anomaly: a direct recruit to the post is entitled under the rules to a higher entry pay than a promotee, despite the posts being identical and no special qualifications being prescribed for direct recruits that would justify the divergence in pay.
- On constitutional ground, the court indicated that such an anomaly would jeopardise the equality clause (Article 14) and thus required correction. The court did not strike down the rule nor directly alter the pay fixation, but treated the matter as an anomaly requiring executive correction (legislative/administrative amendment) rather than immediate judicial re-fixation of pay.
- Accordingly, the court directed an administrative course of action: respondents No. 1 & 3 were to file their report with the Finance Department within a week (with a copy of the order); the petitioner was to submit a representation to the Principal Secretary, Finance Department, attaching the Committee report and the court's order; and the Finance Department was directed to take steps to consider and "obliterate the anomaly" within three months. The court expressly stated the guiding principle for consideration: if a direct recruit can get the higher initial pay, a promotee cannot be deprived of such pay.
- The court further clarified the interim and consequential financial implications: if the petitioner retires before a decision is taken, his pension and retiral benefits shall be fixed on the basis of the last pay drawn; if the Finance Department subsequently decides in the petitioner's favour to grant the higher initial pay equal to that of the direct recruit, the petitioner's pension and retiral benefits shall be revised in accordance with that decision.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The writ petition is allowed to the extent that the court directed the administrative respondents to pursue executive action to remove the identified pay anomaly. The court ordered respondents No. 1 & 3 to place a report to the Finance Department within a week and directed the Finance Department to remove the anomaly within three months after receiving the petitioner's representation.
Implications and immediate effects:
- The court did not itself re-fix the petitioner's pay but mandated executive consideration and correction of the anomaly in the rules that result in different initial pay for the same post depending on the mode of recruitment.
- The Finance Department was instructed to consider equalizing the initial pay of promotees with that of direct recruits where the rules currently produce a disparity; the court specified that the foundational principle for the Finance Department's exercise is that a promotee should not be deprived of higher initial pay available to a direct recruit.
- Interim pension and retiral consequences: if the petitioner retires before a final decision, pension and retiral benefits will be fixed on the last pay drawn; if the Finance Department later decides to award the higher initial pay, pension and retiral benefits shall be revised in accordance with that decision.
- The court observed that remedying the anomaly would require amendment of the Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 (as identified by the Committee), and thus the correction was entrusted to the appropriate executive/departmental authority rather than being effectuated by judicial amendment of the rules.
- No order as to costs was made.
This summary is confined strictly to the material and conclusions contained in the provided opinion and does not infer or introduce information not present in the text.
S. Talapatra, J.:— Heard Mr. D.K Biswas, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner as well as Ms. P. Dhar, learned standing counsel appearing for the respondents No. 1 & 3 and Mr. R. Datta, learned counsel appearing for the respondent No. 2.
2. The writ petitioner who is presently serving as the Chief Librarian of the High Court of Tripura was so appointed with effect from 01.07.2014 The petitioner was initially appointed as the Assistant Librarian in the year 1989 and in the course of time he was appointed in the post of the Librarian cum Research Officer which is the Feeder post for the promotion to the post of Chief Librarian. It may not be out of place to mention that the relevant rules for recruitment to the post of Chief Librarian provide that the post of the Chief Librarian is to be filled up by promotion from the post of Librarian-cum-Research Officer on the basis of merit-cum-seniority, failing which by direct recruitment after taking competitive examination and fulfilling the eligibility criteria viz. (i) Law degree (ii) Degree in Library Science having proficiency in computer and (iii) in case of promotion, three years experience as Librarian-cum-Research Officer. As the petitioner was found suitable for the post he was appointed as the Chief Librarian on promotion with effect from 01.07.2014
3. The grievance canvassed in this writ petition in short is that if the petitioner was directly appointed, his initial pay would have been fixed at Rs. 29,920/-. But his pay has been fixed, for being promoted to the post, at Rs. 28,030/- with effect from on 01.07.2014 Hence the petitioner by means of the writ petition has urged before this court to direct the respondents to set aside the said initial fixation of pay in the post of Chief Librarian and fix his pay what would have been in the case of the direct recruit. Consequently, the challenge has been made against the order dated 16.07.2014 by which the initial pay of the petitioner has been fixed in the post of Chief Librarian.
4. Mr. Biswas, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has submitted that it is really surprising that by operation of the rules for the same and identical post two different initial pay can be fixed without factored by any other circumstances. According to Mr. Biswas, learned counsel this is in gross violation of the constitutional principle as laid down in Article 39 read with Article 14 of the Constitution of India, meaning one post cannot be provided with two different pay. Mr. Biswas, learned counsel has fairly submitted that though in the writ petition the petitioner has urged for stepping up, but the principle of stepping up will not apply in this case. However, Mr. Biswas, learned counsel has submitted that in terms of the Rule 12 of the TSCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 read with TSCS (Revised Pay) (fourth amendment) Rules, 2010 the pay of the petitioner has been fixed. Rule 12(i) of the said Rules, 2009 provides that in the case of promotion from one grade to another, in the revised pay structure the fixation will be done in the following manner:
“(i) One increment equal to 2½ % of the sum of the pay in the pay band and the existing grade pay will be computed and rounded off to the next multiple of 10. This will be added to the existing pay in the pay band. The grade pay corresponding to the promotion post will thereafter be granted in addition to this pay in the pay band. In cases where promotion involves change in the pay band also, the same methodology will be followed. However, if the pay in the pay band after adding the increment is less than the minimum of the higher pay band to which promotion is taking place, pay in the pay band will be stepped up to such minimum.”
5. Rule 8 of the said Rules, 2009 vide Schedule-1, Part-E prescribes the pay structure for the direct recruits and it directs the pay of the Chief Librarian, directly appointed, would be fixed differently.
6. Mr. Biswas, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has further submitted that the petitioner is entitled to the pay which would have been fixed for the direct recruit but denying that the pay to the petitioner the respondents are acting arbitrarily.
7. In reply for the High Court respondents it has been categorically submitted that there is no challenge against the rule under which the pay of the petitioner has been fixed in the post of the Chief Librarian in this writ petition and the said projected difference in the initial pay is caused due to the operation of the said Rule-12 as the Rule-12 provides that two different schedule for the direct recruit and the promotee. In the reply, it has been categorically stated that the Rule specified entry pay for employees directly recruited to different posts based on grade pay of the post. It is discernible that if the post of Chief Librarian is filled up by direct recruitment after taking competitive examination as per the Rules for recruitment, the pay of the fresh direct recruit (the new entrant) would be fixed at the entry pay of Rs. 29,920/- (the modified revised pay) as specified. Those respondents have made no qualms by showing the fixation of pay of the petitioner that on promotion on 01.07.2014 the initial pay of the petitioner as a promotee has been fixed at Rs. 28,030/- not Rs. 26,240/-.
8. Ms. P. Dhar, learned standing counsel appearing for the respondents No. 1 & 3 has submitted that the petitioner had submitted a representation on 03.02.2017 and the same was sent to the State Government with request to consider whether the petitioner was entitled to get the initial pay of the direct recruit appointed on or after 01.01.2006 in the post of the Chief Librarian. In this regard, the High Court of Tripura had constituted a Committee for examining the grievance of the petitioner and they have prepared a report. In the report, the following has been observed:
“As stated above Sri. Paul while holding the post of Librarian-cum-Research Officer of the High Court was promoted to the Post of Chief Librarian, High Court of Tripura by a notification dated 30.06.2014 in the Pay Band-4 of Rs. 13,575-Rs. 37,000/- with Grade Pay of Rs. 5,600/- plus other allowances as admissible under the rules and thereafter pay fixation of Sri. Paul was done by an order dated 16.07.2014 and his pay was fixed at Rs. 24,340/-. The pay fixation was done as per Rule 12(i) of Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 read with TSCS (RP) (Fourth amendment) Rules, 2010.
Rule 12(i) of Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 read with TSCS (RP) (Fourth amendment) Rules, 2010 which relates to fixation of pay on promotion on or after 01.01.2006 talks about the procedure that is to be followed in case of promotion from one Grade Pay to another in the Revised Pay structure and following that the pay fixation of Sri. Paul was done.
On the other hand part E of the aforesaid Rules of 2009 talks about entry pay in the Revised Pay Structure for direct recruits appointed on or after 01.01.2006 and following that a direct recruit to the post of Chief Librarian in the High Court of Tripura will be entitled to get PB-4 (Rs. 13,575-Rs. 37,000/-) and he will get Grade Pay of Rs. 5,600/- and his pay will be in the Pay Band of Rs. 20,880/- and the total will come to Rs. 26,480 at the entry level.
Now as we compare the aforesaid pay of direct recruit with that of Chief Librarian who is promoted from the post of Librarian-cum-Research Officer it is vivid that there exist disparity in the pay. A person who is recruited directly to the post of Chief Librarian will be getting a higher pay in comparison to an official promoted from the post of Librarian-cum-Research Officer to the post of Chief Librarian.
Therefore, this committee is of the view that there is anomaly in respect to pay in between a direct recruit and a promotee to the post of Chief Librarian in the High Court of Tripura and the difference is because of the provisions in Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 and if the salary of a promote and a direct recruit to the post of Chief Librarian are to be brought at par then an amendment in the Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 will be necessary.”
9. It shows that according to the High Court it is a case of ‘anomaly’ as there is an unacceptable difference between the pay of the Officer who is appointed on promotion and the pay of the officer, if recruited directly in the event if no person is found eligible in the Feeder post. It has been clearly asserted in the report that if the salary of the promotee and the direct recruit to the post of the Chief Librarian are to be brought at par, then an amendment in the Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 will be necessary.
10. Ms. P. Dhar, learned standing counsel has clarified that the High Court has not sent that report to the Nodal Department i.e the Finance Department, Government of Tripura.
11. Mr. R. Datta, learned counsel appearing for the respondent No. 2 has submitted that the post of the Chief Librarian is a solitary post to be filled up on promotion and hence, it cannot be compared on hypothesis. Mr. Datta, learned counsel, has referred to the provisions of Rule 12 and submitted that even the stepping up of pay in terms of the subsequent amendment may not have any application in the present case inasmuch as there is no senior and junior officer in the same post for stepping up. According to the respondent No. 2, the averment made by the petitioner on stepping up of pay is absolutely misconceived and does not have any foundation for consideration by this court.
12. Mr. Biswas, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has further submitted that the petitioner would retire from the post very shortly and as such it is required that this anomaly be appropriately appreciated.
13. Having regard to the submissions made by learned counsel for the parties and the records as produced this court is of the considered opinion that the principle of the stepping up under FR-27 or under the Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 [as amended] shall not apply in the present case. Even the ‘stepping up’ of the initial pay to the minimum of the pay band earmarked for the promotional post is not relevant in the case in hand. But what this court has observed is that for the same and identical post a possibility has been generated by the said rule that two persons appointed through two different sources would get two different initial pay, which is apparently unsustainable inasmuch as for direct recruitment, no special qualification has been prescribed by the Rules for recruitment and the report of the High Court has therefore correctly identified the said ‘anomaly’. The said ‘anomaly’ is required to set right by the Finance Department, Government of Tripura within a period of three months from today by removing the said ‘anomaly’. It is the further opinion of this court that the prescription either by operation of the rules or directly would jeopardise the equality clause.
14. Having observed thus, the respondents No. 1 & 3 are directed to place their report to the Finance Department, Government of Tripura within a week from today along with a copy of this order. The petitioner shall further submit a representation giving details of his grievance with the copy of the report of the High Court and a copy of this order through the proper channel to the Principal Secretary, Finance Department, Government of Tripura. Having received this representation, the Finance Department shall take the necessary exercise to consider and obliterate the ‘anomaly’ [as stated]. If the direct recruit can get the higher initial pay a promotee cannot be deprived of such pay. This shall be the foundation of the entire consideration as would be carried out by the Finance Department.
15. It is further clarified that if in the meanwhile the petitioner retires from the service, his pension and other retiral benefits may be fixed on the basis of the last pay he would draw, but if the Finance Department takes a decision which would favour the petitioner to get the higher initial pay scale as indicated, equal to that of the direct recruit, his pension and other retiral benefits shall be revised in terms of the said decision of the Finance Department.
16. Having observed thus, this writ petition stands allowed to the extent as indicated above.
17. The record produced by Ms. P. Dhar, learned standing counsel is returned.
18. No order as to costs.
Alert