- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dolly Singh v. State Of U.P And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, having passed the U.P.T.E.T Examination 2018 (Primary Level) with an initial score of 80 marks, applied on 18th December 2018 to appear in the Assistant Teacher Examination scheduled for 6th January 2019. The application was rejected on the ground that the petitioner did not meet the minimum required score of 82 marks for Scheduled Caste category candidates. Subsequently, following an earlier order of this Court, an amended mark sheet was issued on 20th December 2018, increasing the petitioner’s score to 82 marks, thereby rendering her eligible to appear in the examination. The petitioner sought urgent hearing out of turn to permit her participation in the examination, invoking the Court’s extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution by filing a writ petition in the nature of mandamus.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner is entitled to be permitted to appear in the Assistant Teacher Examination, 2018 based on the amended mark sheet showing eligibility.
- Whether the respondent authorities are obligated to accept the petitioner’s registration form and issue the admit card for the examination scheduled on 6th January 2019.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner’s Arguments
- The petitioner initially scored 80 marks but was subsequently issued an amended mark sheet awarding 82 marks, meeting the eligibility criteria for Scheduled Caste candidates.
- The petitioner’s registration form was wrongly rejected despite the amended mark sheet, and she should be permitted to appear in the examination.
- Urgency was emphasized due to the imminent examination date, justifying an out-of-turn hearing.
Respondent’s Arguments
- The opinion does not detail specific arguments advanced by the respondent beyond the learned Additional Chief Standing Counsel’s appearance.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court noted the petitioner’s entitlement to appear in the examination based on the amended mark sheet that granted her the minimum qualifying marks required for Scheduled Caste candidates. Recognizing the urgency due to the examination date, the Court exercised its extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 to issue a mandamus directing the respondents to accept the petitioner’s registration and permit her to appear. The Court emphasized that this permission is provisional and the result of the petitioner shall not be declared without the Court’s leave, ensuring judicial oversight pending final adjudication. The directions to issue the admit card and ensure necessary arrangements reflect the Court’s intent to prevent irreparable harm to the petitioner while preserving the rights of the respondents.
Holding and Implications
The Court accepted the petitioner’s prayer and directed the respondents to permit her to appear in the Assistant Teacher Examination scheduled for 6th January 2019.
The order is provisional and subject to final adjudication, with the respondent restrained from declaring the petitioner’s result without Court permission. The immediate implication is that the petitioner can participate in the examination, while the Court retains control over the final outcome. No new legal precedent was established; the decision primarily addresses the petitioner’s urgent right to appear based on corrected eligibility documentation.
Prakash Padia, J.:— Since the examination of Assistant Teacher (Primary Level), 2018 is going to be held on 6.1.2019 and the petitioner was not permitted to participate in the same, due to urgency a mention was made by the petitioner regarding hearing of the matter out of turn.
2. The prayer made by the petitioner is accepted.
3. Heard Sri. C.L Chaudhary, learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri. Ram Manohar Dube, learned Addl. Chief Standing Counsel for the respondent.
4. The petitioner has approached this Court invoking its extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution seeking a writ in the nature of mandamus directing the respondents to accept the registration form of the applicant and permit her to appear in Assistant Teacher Examination, 2018, which is scheduled to be held on 6.1.2019
5. The facts as narrated in the writ petition are that the petitioner passed his U.P.T.E.T Examination 2018 (Primary Level) and initially obtained 80 marks in the aforesaid examination. On the basis of the same she filled up the form on 18th December, 2018 for appearing in the said examination. The said applicant form of the petitioner was rejected on the ground that the petitioner has not obtained minimum 82 marks which is required for the scheduled caste category candidates.
6. Subsequently, orders were passed by this Court and on the basis of the decision given an amended mark sheet was issued to the petitioner on 20 December, 2018. By the amended mark sheet now the petitioner has been provided 82 marks in place of 80. Accordingly to the petitioner now she became eligible to appear in the said examination.
7. In view of the aforesaid in the interest of justice a direction is issued to the respondent to permit the petitioner in the examination in question which is scheduled to be held on 6.1.2019
8. The petitioner is directed to place a copy of this order before respondent no. 2 by 5.00 p.m today.
9. Respondent no. 2 is directed to ensure necessary arrangements for issue of admit card to the petitioner for her appearance in the examination which is scheduled to be held on 6.1.2019
10. It is made clear that the aforesaid order permitting the petitioner to appear in the examination is provisional in nature and the respondent will not declare the result of the petitioner without leave of the Court.
11. Learned Standing counsel is granted two weeks time to file counter affidavit. One week thereafter is granted to file rejoinder affidavit.
12. List thereafter for admission/final hearing.
Alert