- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sushant Deshmukh v. Visvesvaraya Technological University And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, an engineering student who quit the course in the 2nd Respondent-College mid-way, challenged the college's retention of his original educational records, alleging the records were being withheld to coerce payment of a liquidated sum for quitting and thereby causing loss. After notice, the 2nd Respondent-College appeared through senior panel counsel and opposed the petition. The court heard counsel for both sides and perused the records.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether an educational institution has the right to retain a student's original School/College records where the student quits the course mid-way.
- Whether an undertaking given by the student to pay a liquidated sum (and the college's reliance on pacta sunt servanda) justifies retention of records and bars relief by a writ court.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The college is retaining his original educational records to coerce payment of liquidated damages after he quit the course mid-way, causing loss.
Respondent-College's Arguments
- The petitioner voluntarily gave an undertaking on stamped paper to pay a specified sum by way of liquidated damages approximating the management's likely loss from his quitting.
- Pacta sunt servanda: agreements must be honoured; the petitioner's conduct does not warrant relief at the college's expense.
- The undertaking is legally enforceable, and it is open to the college to retain the original records until the undertaking is discharged; a writ court must consider this aspect when entertaining the petitioner's grievance.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| W.P.No.47380/2017 (Edn-Res) (judgment dated 27.03.2018) | Answered the question of an educational institution's right to retain School/College records in the negative, i.e., in favour of the student and against the institution. | The court treated that decision as controlling (the question is no longer res integra), found no derogatory circumstances to depart from it, and followed it in allowing the petition and ordering return of records. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court observed that the central question—whether an educational institution may retain students' original records when they quit mid-course—is no longer res integra because a Coordinate Bench in W.P.No.47380/2017 (Edn-Res) (27.03.2018) decided the question in the negative. Having heard counsel and perused the records, and finding no derogatory circumstances to justify departing from that precedent, the court applied the prior decision to the present facts. While mandamising the return of records, the court preserved the college's right to pursue legal remedies to enforce the alleged undertaking; all contentions on that point were kept open.
Holding and Implications
Writ Petition allowed.
Direct effect: The 2nd Respondent-College is mandamised to return the petitioner's original educational records within four weeks. The college retains liberty to sue the petitioner to enforce the alleged undertaking; all related contentions remain open. No broader implications were discussed beyond the direct effect on the parties, and the decision follows the earlier Coordinate Bench ruling rather than announcing a new precedent.
The short grievance of the petitioner, an engineering student who has quit the course in the 2nd Respondent-College mid-way is against the act of the said college in retaining his original educational records for coercing the payment of a liquidated sum of money for so quitting and thereby occasioning the loss.
2. After service of notice, the Respondent-College has entered appearance through its senior panel Counsel Sri.N.S. Sanjay Gowda, who opposes the petition on the ground that the petitioner has given an undertaking on a stamped paper voluntarily to pay a certain sum of money by way of liquidated damages which would approximate the likely loss the management would suffer for his quitting the course half way through; the basic rule being pacta sunt servanda ie., abide by what is agreed to, the conduct of the petitioner does not warrant grant of any relief to him at the cost of the college.
3. The learned panel counsel Shri N.S.Gowda further submits that the undertaking being legally enforceable, it is open to the 2nd respondent-College to retain the School/College Records so that petitioner discharges the undertaking given by him, an argument to the contrary having the effect of diluting the enforceability of the said undertaking in question. A Writ Court has to take this aspect of the matter in entertaining the grievance of the petitioner, contends the counsel.
4. I have heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and the learned panel counsel for the respondent-college. I have perused the records.
5. The question as to the right of the educational institution to retain the School/College Records of the students quitting the course mid-way is no longer res integra. A Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in W.P.No.47380/2017 (Edn-Res) has in identical circumstances rendered a judgment dated 27.03.2018 answering the said question in the negative ie., in favour of the petitioner and against the educational institution. No derogatory circumstances that justify taking of a different path than the one indicated in the said judgment are shown to exist in the matter.
6. In the above circumstances, this Writ Petition succeeds; the 2nd Respondent-College is mandamised to return the original educational records of the Petitioner within a period of four weeks. However, liberty is reserved to the 2nd respondent-College/its management to sue the petitioner for enforcing the alleged undertaking furnished by him, all contentions having been kept open. Costs made easy. Sd/- JUDGE
Alert