- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Vivek Mudgil v. State Of Uttar Pradesh And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The Supreme Court (per R. Subhash Reddy, J.) addressed civil appeals arising from orders of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad concerning the appellant’s appointment as Principal under the U.P. Secondary Education Services Selection framework. An application for impleadment was allowed and leave was granted in the special leave petitions.
The U.P. Secondary Education Services Selection Board issued an advertisement on 3-3-2002 for the post of Principal, prescribing: (i) a postgraduate degree, (ii) a training qualification (BEd/LT/BT/BP Ed), and (iii) teaching experience—ten years in intermediate classes with a first/second class postgraduate degree, or fifteen years with a third class postgraduate degree. The last date for applications was 30-3-2002.
The appellant, a Lecturer in Physics regularised from 12-1-1990, was on foreign study leave from 15-4-1992 to 8-3-1996. On the application cut-off date, he had 9 years and 3 months’ teaching experience, short of the required 10 years. A selection panel prepared in August 2002 included the appellant, but was not operated due to litigation. Following a Supreme Court order in May 2008 ((2008) 12 SCC 1), the 2002 panel was operated, and the appellant was appointed Principal on 15-7-2008.
A complaint dated 18-7-2008 alleged the appellant lacked the mandatory ten years’ teaching experience under the U.P. Secondary Education Services Selection Board Rules, 1998 read with Regulation 1 of Chapter II of the Regulations under the Intermediate Education Act, 1921. The Board cancelled his appointment on 10-12-2008. The appellant’s writ petitions under Article 226 were dismissed by a Single Judge on 19-3-2015 (2015 SCC OnLine All 8719; (2015) 4 All LJ 658), holding that foreign study leave could not be counted as teaching experience and that he did not meet eligibility on the cut-off date. The Division Bench affirmed on 8-4-2015 in Vivek Mudgil v. State of U.P., 2015 SCC OnLine All 8749; (2015) 3 All LJ 691, holding the ten-year teaching experience requirement to be mandatory.
During pendency before the Supreme Court, the Board granted the appellant an exemption of nine months of teaching experience, allegedly in view of an order dated 8-7-2015 (2015 SCC OnLine SC 1764) in the pending SLP. That exemption order was challenged in a writ petition later transferred to the Supreme Court and registered as Transferred Case (C) No. 5 of 2018, heard together with the present appeals.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the ten years’ teaching experience requirement was a mandatory and necessary qualification for appointment as Principal under the governing Regulations and statutes.
- Whether the appellant’s period of foreign study leave (15-4-1992 to 8-3-1996) could be counted towards the requisite ten years’ teaching experience.
- Whether an exemption granted during the pendency of proceedings, without express retrospective effect, could cure the appellant’s ineligibility as on the last date for submission of applications and the date of panel preparation.
- Whether, after enforcement of the U.P. Secondary Education Services Selection Board Act, 1982, the authorities retained power under the proviso to Section 16-E(3) of the Intermediate Education Act, 1921 to grant exemptions from the experience requirement (issue raised but expressly left open by the Court).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The period of foreign study leave, granted under leave rules with increments, should be counted towards the ten years’ teaching experience requirement.
- Possession of ten years’ teaching experience was not an essential qualification in light of the Board’s power under the proviso to Section 16-E(3) of the 1921 Act to grant exemptions.
- In view of the subsequently granted exemption for nine months, the appellant should be permitted to continue as Principal.
Respondents' Arguments
- After the U.P. Secondary Education Services Selection Board Act, 1982 came into force, the ten-year teaching experience requirement became mandatory and an essential qualification.
- The period of foreign study leave cannot be treated as teaching experience.
- The power to grant exemptions under the proviso to Section 16-E(3) of the 1921 Act is not available after the 1982 Act (the Court noted this plea but found it unnecessary to decide in view of its conclusions).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Vivek Mudgil v. State of U.P., 2015 SCC OnLine All 8749; (2015) 3 All LJ 691 (Division Bench, Allahabad High Court) | Held that the ten years’ teaching experience requirement is mandatory for the post of Principal. | Affirmed; the Supreme Court agreed that the ten-year experience is a necessary qualification. |
| Order of Single Judge, Allahabad High Court, 19-3-2015, 2015 SCC OnLine All 8719; (2015) 4 All LJ 658 | Foreign study leave does not count as teaching experience; eligibility must exist on the cut-off date. | Referenced as the impugned order; reasoning endorsed in substance by higher courts. |
| (2008) 12 SCC 1 (Supreme Court) | No specific legal principle discussed in this opinion; referenced as the order after which the 2002 selection panel was operated. | Cited for procedural history to explain why appointments from the 2002 panel occurred in 2008. |
| Order dated 8-7-2015, 2015 SCC OnLine SC 1764 (Supreme Court) | SLP order issuing notice on how the appellant’s situation could be salvaged; no direction to grant exemption. | Relied upon to clarify that there was no mandate to grant exemption; thus, the later exemption could not be justified on its basis. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
- The Court first noted the undisputed fact that, on the last date for submitting applications (30-3-2002), the appellant had only 9 years and 3 months of teaching experience, short of the prescribed ten years under the advertisement and applicable Regulations.
- Addressing the contention that foreign study leave should count towards teaching experience, the Court emphasized that the appellant was on scholarship abroad (15-4-1992 to 8-3-1996) and that such academic study does not constitute “teaching experience.” Consequently, that period could not be counted toward the ten-year requirement.
- The Court agreed with the Division Bench of the High Court that the ten years’ teaching experience requirement was a necessary and mandatory qualification for appointment as Principal under the relevant Regulations.
- On the subsequently granted exemption:
- The Supreme Court’s order dated 8-7-2015 (2015 SCC OnLine SC 1764) merely issued notice on how the appellant’s situation could be salvaged and did not direct the grant of an exemption. Thus, the Board should not have granted exemption while the matter was sub judice.
- The exemption order did not confer retrospective effect. Without explicit retrospective operation, a later exemption cannot cure a candidate’s ineligibility as on the crucial dates—the last date for application submission and the date of panel preparation.
- Given this, even the exemption could not validate the appellant’s selection and appointment.
- The respondents also argued that the power to grant exemptions under the proviso to Section 16-E(3) of the 1921 Act is unavailable post-1982 Act. The Court found it unnecessary to reach this question because, in any event, the non-retrospective exemption could not salvage the appellant’s ineligibility.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: APPEALS DISMISSED. The civil appeals are dismissed. The transferred case (Transferred Case (C) No. 5 of 2018) is consequently DISPOSED OF. The issue of whether authorities retain power to grant exemptions under the proviso to Section 16-E(3) of the 1921 Act after the 1982 Act is left open for decision in an appropriate proceeding, uninfluenced by this judgment.
Implications: The immediate effect is that the appellant’s appointment as Principal remains invalid due to failure to meet the mandatory ten years’ teaching experience on the cut-off date, and a later, non-retrospective exemption cannot cure such ineligibility. The decision reaffirms that eligibility conditions must be satisfied at the relevant cut-off date and that periods of foreign study leave do not count as “teaching experience” for this purpose. No broader ruling was made on the post-1982 scope of exemption powers, which remains unresolved.
R. Subhash Reddy, J.— Application seeking impleadment of the applicants is allowed as prayed for. Leave granted in special leave petitions.
2. These civil appeals are filed by the appellant aggrieved by the order dated 8-4-2015 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in Vivek Mudgil v. State of U.P. 2015 SCC OnLine All 8749, (2015) 3 All LJ 691 By the aforesaid order, the Division Bench of the High Court has confirmed the order dated 19-3-2015 2015 SCC OnLine All 8719, (2015) 4 All LJ 658 passed by the learned Single Judge in writ petitions filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India in which an order dated 10-12-2008 passed by the U.P. Secondary Education Services Selection Board (hereinafter referred to as “the Board”) was under challenge.
3. The Board has issued an advertisement on 3-3-2002 inviting applications for appointment to the post of Principal. The last date for submission of applications was 30-3-2002. The qualifications prescribed were — (i) the possession of a postgraduate degree from an institution or a university established in accordance with law; and (ii) possession of a training qualification, namely, BEd LT, BT and BP Ed. The advertisement contained a stipulation requiring teaching experience of ten years in intermediate classes of any recognised institution together with a postgraduate degree in the first or second class or a teaching experience of fifteen years for a candidate possessing postgraduate degree in the third class.
4. The appellant herein was originally appointed as Lecturer in Physics and his services were regularised from 12-1-1990. He was on study leave for the period between 15-4-1992 to 8-3-1996. It is not in dispute that on the last date of submission of the applications, pursuant to advertisement issued by the Board, the experience of the appellant was 9 years and 3 months as against the requirement of 10 years. Initially the Board prepared a panel of selected candidates in the month of August 2002, which contained the name of the appellant herein. In view of the litigation concerning selection of panels, the said panel was not operated for the purpose of issuing appointment orders. Only after orders are passed (2008) 12 SCC 1 by this Court in the month of May 2008, the panel prepared in the year 2002 was operated and the appellant was appointed as the Principal of the college and he joined as such on 15-7-2008.
5. On 18-7-2008, a complaint was lodged before the District Inspector of Schools, Jhansi alleging that appellant did not possess 10 years of teaching experience and same was mandatory for selection to the post of Principal as per U.P. Secondary Education Services Selection Board Rules, 1998 read with Regulation 1 of Chapter II of the Regulations framed under the Intermediate Education Act, 1921. In view of such complaint, on the ground that appellant herein has not fulfilled required qualification of 10 years' experience, his appointment was cancelled on 10-12-2008, which order was subject-matter of challenge in the writ petition filed by the appellant herein before the High Court of Allahabad.
6. The learned Single Judge has dismissed the writ petitions by order dated 19-3-2015 2015 SCC OnLine All 8719, (2015) 4 All LJ 658 by holding that, the period during which the appellant was on study leave cannot be counted towards teaching experience and on the last date of submission of applications, the appellant did not fulfil the required eligibility criterion i.e. possessing ten years of teaching experience. The learned Single Judge, by recording a finding that the appointment could not be protected under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, rejected the petitions.
7. The said order was challenged by way of special appeal being SAs Nos. 189 and 190 of 2015 mainly on the ground that possession of 10 years of experience cannot be regarded as an essential qualification in view of the power conferred on the Board under proviso to Section 16-E(3) of the 1921 Act. The Division Bench of the High Court, rejecting the plea of the appellant herein, dismissed 2015 SCC OnLine All 8749, (2015) 3 All LJ 691 the special appeals by recording a finding that after enforcement of the U.P. Secondary Education Services Selection Board Act, 1982 the requirement of 10 years' teaching experience is a necessary qualification and is mandatory.
8. During the pendency of the proceedings, the Board has issued exemption proceedings in favour of the appellant granting exemption of 9 months of teaching experience. As pleaded in the counter-affidavit it is stated that such an exemption order was passed in view of the order dated 8-7-2015 2015 SCC OnLine SC 1764 passed by this Court in special leave petitions. When order of exemption is passed, such order was again challenged by way of writ petition before the High Court which is ordered to be transferred to this Court and on such transfer the same is numbered as Transferred Case (C) No. 5 of 2018 which is also taken up for hearing along with these civil appeals. For the sake of convenience, the facts of the civil appeals are being referred to.
9. We have heard the learned counsel on both sides appearing in civil appeals as well as in transferred case and perused the material on record.
10. It is not in dispute that as on the last date of submission of applications pursuant to the advertisement issued by the Board inviting applications for appointment to the post of Principal, the appellant herein was having only 9 years 3 months of teaching experience. Even as per the notification, having regard to academic qualification possessed by the appellant, there was a requirement of 10 years of teaching experience. It is not in dispute that the appellant had only 9 years 3 months of teaching experience on the last date of making applications. Mainly the writ petitions were filed in the High Court alleging that his period of foreign study leave is to be computed for the purpose of computing the teaching experience of 10 years. It was the case before the High Court that as he was granted leave as per the leave rules and he was also granted increments for the said period, as such, such period has to be computed. It is to be noticed at this stage that he was granted scholarship for higher studies in Czechoslovakia. It is not in dispute that from 15-4-1992 to 8-3-1996 he was studying in Czechoslovakia and same cannot be considered as a teaching experience. Further, having regard to the requirements in the Regulations teaching experience of 10 years is rightly considered as a necessary qualification by the Division Bench of the High Court.
11. Before this Court, it is pleaded that in view of the exemption granted he is entitled to continue as Principal of the college. We have also perused the order of exemption which is granted during the pendency of the proceedings. It is stated in the counter-affidavit, such an exemption is granted in view of the order passed by this Court on 8-7-2015 2015 SCC OnLine SC 1764. The order dated 8-7-2015 2015 SCC OnLine SC 1764 passed by this Court reads as under:
“The contention of the petitioner is that the petitioner was working as Lecturer in another college when he was selected as Principal in Respondent 5 College in the year 2002 and where he worked till 2008. He submits that in order to join the services with Respondent 5 as Principal to which post he was selected, he resigned as Lecturer where he was serving earlier and after his termination as Principal, the petitioner is left high and dry as he is not working anywhere now.
Issue notice to the respondents on the limited aspect as to how this situation can be salvaged, if at all.”
12. It is clear from the aforesaid order that there was no direction at all to consider for grant of exemption. By all fairness, when the matter is seized before this Court the respondent authorities should not have passed any order granting exemption in favour of the appellant. In any event, from the perusal of the order, it is clear that no retrospective effect is given to such exemption proceedings. Even by grant of such exemption it will not cure the disqualification of the appellant as on last date of submission of the applications and on the date of preparing the panel. In the absence of any such express provision granting retrospective effect, even the exemption granted will not come to the rescue of the appellant to support his case. It is also pleaded that after the enforcement of the provisions of the U.P. Secondary Education Services Selection Board Act, 1982, the power of exemption is also not available but the same is not required to be considered at this stage as we are of the view that exemption granted also will not come to the rescue of the appellant to make his selection and appointment valid. Having regard to the notified required qualifications under the Regulations, we are in agreement with the view taken by the Division Bench of the High Court that such qualification of 10 years of teaching experience is necessary qualification for appointment to the post of Principal. Although it is pleaded by the learned counsel appearing for the respondents that the power of exemption is not available after enactment of the provisions of the 1982 Act but in view of the reasoning assigned by us as referred above, it is not necessary to record any finding on such issue at this stage.
13. For the aforesaid reasons, these appeals are dismissed and consequently the transferred case also stands disposed of. However, the issue, whether the respondent authorities are empowered to grant any order of exemption in exercise of powers under proviso to Section 16-E(3) of the 1921 Act, after enforcement of the provisions of the 1982 Act is left open. If any such need arises, it is open for the parties to approach the High Court in which event such issue is to be decided independently uninfluenced by the order of the High Court and this Court.
Alert