- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
R.K. Sharma v. Union Of India And Ors.
High Court of Delhi — R.K. Sharma v. Union of India & Ors. (W.P.(C) 4760/2018) — Decision dated 13.11.2018
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, R.K. Sharma, challenged an order of the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) dated 21.02.2017 in O.A. No.38/2014, which had rejected his claim for ante-dating (preponement) of the date of grant of his second financial upgradation under the Modified Assured Career Progression (MACP) scheme from 01.09.2008 to 01.01.2006.
The petitioner had been promoted to the post of Director with effect from 09.02.1994 in the BICP (Tariff) Commission in the pre-revised scale. He was granted the second financial upgradation under the MACP scheme in pay band IV with grade pay of 8700 with effect from 01.09.2008 (the date the respondents asserted MACP was implemented). After his representation was rejected, he approached the CAT, which also rejected his claim; the petitioner then approached the High Court by way of this writ petition, limiting his claim to preponement of the MACP date to 01.01.2006 and expressly not seeking any benefit under the Non-Functional Upgradation (NFU) scheme.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the second financial upgradation under the MACP scheme should be effective from 01.01.2006 (as contended by the petitioner) or from 01.09.2008 (as maintained by the respondents).
- Whether the MACP benefit is part of the pay structure (and thus effective from 01.01.2006 under the Government Resolution implementing the 6th Central Pay Commission) as opposed to being an allowance effective from 01.09.2008.
- Whether the Supreme Court's decision in Union of India & Ors. v. Balbir Singh Turn & Anr. (C.A. Diary No.3744/2016, decided 08.12.2017) — holding MACP effective from 01.01.2006 for defence personnel — applies to the petitioner (a civilian employee) because the relevant pay revision is para materia between civilian and defence implementations.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner limited his claim to preponement of the date of grant of the second MACP upgradation to 01.01.2006 and did not claim NFU benefits.
- He relied on the Government Resolution dated 29.08.2008 implementing the 6th Central Pay Commission (6th CPC), which (as pleaded) provided that revised pay scales and the pay structure would be made effective from 01.01.2006, whereas other allowances were made effective from 01.09.2008; thus MACP (being part of pay structure/ACP provisions in Annexure-I Part A) should be treated as effective from 01.01.2006.
- The petitioner sought to rely on materials (including parts of Annexure-I and the ACP/MACP scheme contained therein) and the Supreme Court decision in Balbir Singh Turn, which concluded for defence personnel that MACP is part of the pay structure and effective from 01.01.2006.
Respondent's Arguments
- The respondents contended that the Central Government consciously took the decision to grant financial upgradation under the MACP scheme only with effect from 01.09.2008; accordingly the petitioner could not claim the benefit from 01.01.2006.
- It was argued (as recorded from respondent's counsel submissions in the cited Supreme Court reasoning) that making MACP applicable from 01.01.2006 could create "gainers and losers" and might require recovery of excess payments from some employees because of the change from the old ACP mechanism to pay-band/grade-pay approach after 6th CPC implementation.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Union of India & Ors. v. Balbir Singh Turn & Anr. (C.A. Diary No.3744/2016, decided 08.12.2017) | The Supreme Court held that the MACP (modified ACP) is part of the pay structure (placed in Part-A of Annexure-I) and therefore the benefits of MACP affect grade pay and pension; consequently MACP applies from 01.01.2006 (date for pay structure implementation) and not from 01.09.2008 (date for other allowances). The Court also held that any executive or administrative instruction purporting to delay MACP to 01.09.2008 was ultra vires the Cabinet decision reflected in the Government Resolution of 30.08.2008. | The High Court applied the ratio to the present civilian employee's case on the ground that the 6th CPC implementation for civilian employees is para materia with that for defence personnel; therefore the Supreme Court's interpretation that MACP is part of pay structure and effective from 01.01.2006 governs the present petitioner's entitlement. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeded by reference to the Government Resolution dated 29.08.2008 implementing the 6th CPC and to the Annexure-I thereto. The Resolution, as quoted and analysed in the judgment, (a) made revised pay scales and pay structure effective from 01.01.2006 and (b) expressly provided that revised allowances (other than dearness allowance) would be effective from 01.09.2008. The court emphasised that the mechanism for fixing pay under the 6th CPC (multiplying previous basic pay as on 01.01.2006 by the fitment factor, rounding, and adding approved grade pay) was set out in that Resolution.
The court noted that Part-A of Annexure-I dealt with pay structure, grade pay and pay bands and included the ACP/MACP provisions; the placement of MACP in Part-A indicated that the Government itself considered MACP to be part of the pay structure rather than an allowance. The court also referred to contemporaneous departmental communications in the defence context (Special Army Instructions and subsequent letters) which indicated an understanding that MACP/ACP would be applicable with effect from 01.01.2006.
The High Court relied heavily on the Supreme Court's reasoning in Balbir Singh Turn. In that decision the Supreme Court parsed the Government Resolution and concluded that MACP is part of the pay structure and therefore must be effective from 01.01.2006; further, an administrative instruction (letter dated 30.05.2011) that purported to make MACP effective only from 01.09.2008 was held to be ultra vires the Cabinet decision embodied in the 30.08.2008 Resolution. The High Court adopted that interpretation and reasoning as applicable to the present case because the 6th CPC implementation for civilian employees is para materia with the defence implementation considered in Balbir Singh Turn.
After considering the parties' submissions and the Supreme Court authority, the Court concluded that the petitioner was entitled to the second financial upgradation under the MACP scheme from 01.01.2006, provided the petitioner is found fit under the relevant rules and schemes in all other respects. The Court therefore directed the respondents to pass appropriate orders within four weeks to grant the back-dated upgradation if entitlement requirements are satisfied.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The writ petition was allowed to the extent that the petitioner is entitled to the second financial upgradation under the MACP scheme with effect from 01.01.2006, provided he is otherwise entitled under the relevant rules and schemes. The respondents were directed to take steps and pass appropriate orders within four weeks. The petitioner was awarded costs of Rs.5,000/-. The petition was disposed of in those terms.
Implications:
- Direct effect: The respondent is required to grant the petitioner's second MACP financial upgradation retrospectively from 01.01.2006 if he satisfies all other entitlement criteria; the respondents must issue appropriate orders within four weeks and pay costs of Rs.5,000/- to the petitioner.
- Precedential scope: The Court applied the Supreme Court decision in Balbir Singh Turn to a civilian employee's case on the basis that the 6th CPC implementation for civilian employees is para materia with the defence implementation. The opinion did not purport to lay down a novel principle but applied existing Supreme Court precedent to the facts of this petition. No separate new precedent was announced by the High Court beyond applying the Supreme Court's ratio to the present facts.
Judges: Vipin Sanghi, J.; A.K. Chawla, J. — Judgment delivered orally on 13 November 2018.
$~21. * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI + Date of Decision: 13.11.2018
% W.P.(C) 4760/2018 & C.M. No. 18339/2018
R.K. SHARMA
..... Petitioner Through: Mr. Prateek Tushar Mohanty and Mr. Tushar Ranjan Mohanty, Advocates versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
..... Respondent Through: Mr. Arun Bhardwaj, CGSC and Mr. Nikhil Bhardwaj, Adv. with Mr. Amardev Bahlwal, Section Officer
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIPIN SANGHI HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE A. K. CHAWLA
VIPIN SANGHI, J. (ORAL)
1. The petitioner is aggrieved by the order dated 21.02.2017 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT/ Tribunal) in O.A. No.38/2014. The petitioners claim for ante-dating his second financial upgradation benefit under the MACP scheme from 01.09.2008 to 01.01.2006 has been rejected by the tribunal.
1
2. At the outset, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that he limits his claim to preponement of the date of grant of second financial upgradation under the MACP scheme to 01.01.2006, and he does not claim any benefit under the Non Functional Upgradation (NFU) scheme provided for under the office memorandum dated 24.04.2009. Learned counsel for the petitioner clarifies that he had sought to rely upon the OM dated 24.04.2009 - by which NFU scheme was formulated, only to contend that like the NFU scheme was made applicable from 01.01.2006, so also the MACP scheme be made applicable from the said date and not from 01.01.2008 - as was sought to be contended by the respondent.
3. The petitioner was promoted to the post of Director with effect from 09.02.1994 in BICP (Tariff) Commission in the pre revised scale of 3700-125- 4700-1500-5000. He was granted the second financial upgradation under the MACP scheme in pay band IV with grade pay of 8700 with effect from 01.09.2008, which was the date on which the respondent claimed that the MACP scheme was implemented. Being aggrieved by the delay of grant of second financial upgradation from 01.09.2008, and on the basis that he was entitled to the said upgradation with effect from 01.01.2006, he approached the tribunal after his representation was rejected. As aforesaid, the tribunal has rejected his claim.
4. The submission of learned counsel for the petitioner, firstly, is that vide resolution dated 29.08.2008 issued by the Ministry of Finance, the 6thCentral Pay Commission (CPC) recommendations were implemented. On the aspect of
2
fixation of pay in the revised pay bands, it was provided that the basic pay drawn as on 01.01.2006 on the existing 5thCPC pay scales will be multiplied by factor of 1.86, and then round off to next multiple of 10. That would be the pay in the revised running pay band. The grade pay as approved by the government, corresponding to the pre revised pay scale was then to be added to the pay in the revised pay band, and the total of pay in the pay band and grade pay was to be the revised basic pay as on 01.01.2006. This mechanism for arriving at the basic pay under the 6thCPC was provided in clause (iv) of the opening paragraph of the aforesaid government resolution dated 29.08.2008. This resolution also provided in para 2 and 3 as follows:
"2. The Commission's recommendations and government decision thereon with regard to revised scales of pay and dearness allowance for civilian employees of the Central Government and personnel of All India Services as detailed in the Part A of the Annex I will be made effective from 1st day of January, 2006.
3. The revised allowances, other than dearness allowance, will be effective from 1st day of September, 2008".
5. The submission of learned counsel for the petitioner is that the revised scales of pay and dearness allowance in respect of civilian employees of the Central Government and personnel of All India Services detailed in Part A of Annexure 1 was made effective from 01.01.2006. However, a distinction was drawn insofar as payment of revision of other allowances (other dearness allowance) are concerned, and the effective date was consciously prescribed as 01.09.2008. Attention is also drawn to Part A of Annexure 1 and to the ACP
3
scheme incorporated in the 6thCPC. The aforesaid government resolution incorporated the modified ACP scheme, which provided that the financial upgradation under the scheme will be available whenever a person has spent 10 years continuously in the same grade. Further, three upgradation after 10, 20 and 30 years of service will be allowed.
6. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that para materia with the revision of pay scales introduced for the civilian employees of the Central Government, the Central Government also notified the revision of pay scales in respect of the personnel of the Armed Forces. In Union of India & Ors. v. Balbir Singh Turn & Anr., in C.A. Diary No.3744/2016, decided on 08.12.2017 along with several other similar cases, the issue that arose before the Supreme Court as to whether the MACP scheme in respect of the defence personnel would be effective from 01.01.2006, or 01.09.2008 - as contended by the Government.
7. The Supreme Court extensively considered the provisions of the 6thCPC report and concluded that the financial upgradation under the MACP scheme would apply from 01.01.2006, and not from 01.09.2008. The relevant extract from this decision reads as follows:
"6. The question that arises for decision is whether the benefit of MACP is applicable from 01.01.2006 or from 01.09.2008.
7. The answer to this question will lie in the interpretation given to the Government Resolution, relevant portion of which has been quoted hereinabove. A bare perusal of Clause(i) of the
4
Resolution clearly indicates that the Central Government decided to implement the revised pay structure of pay bands and grade pay, as well as pension with effect from 01.01.2006. The second part of the Clause lays down that all allowances except the Dearness Allowance/relief will be effective from 01.09.2008. The AFT held, and in our opinion rightly so, that the benefit of MACP is part of the pay structure and will affect the grade pay of the employees and, therefore, it cannot be said that it is a part of allowances. The benefit of MACP if given to the respondents would affect their pension also.
8. We may also point out that along with this Resolution there is Annexure-I. Part-A of Annexure-I deals with the pay structure, grade pay, pay bands etc., and Item 10 reads as follows :-
10 Assured Career Progression Scheme for Three ACP PBORs. upgradation
The Commission recommends that the after 8, 16 and time bound promotion scheme in case of 24 years of PBORs shall allow two financial service has been upgradations on completion of 10 and approved. The 20 years of service as at present. The upgradation will financial upgradations under the take place only scheme shall allow benefit of pay in the hierarchy fixation equal to one increment along of Grade pays, with the higher grade pay. As regards which need not the other suggestions relating to necessarily be residency period for promotion of the hierarchy in PBORs Ministry of Defence may set up that particular an Inter-Services Committee to consider cadre. the matter after the revised scheme of running bands is implemented (Para
2.3.34)
5
Part-B of Annexure-I deals with allowances, concessions & benefits and Conditions of Service of Defence Forces Personnel. It is apparent that the Government itself by placing MACP in Part- A of Annexure-I was considering it to be the part of the pay structure.
9. The MACP Scheme was initially notified vide Special Army Instructions dated 11.10.2008. The Scheme was called the Modified Assured Career Progression Scheme for Personnel Below Officer Rank in the Indian Army. After the Resolution was passed by the Central Government on 30.08.2008 Special Army Instructions were issued on 11.10.2008 dealing with revision of pay structure. As far as ACP is concerned Para 15 of the said letter reads as follows:-
"15. Assured Career Progression. In pursuance with the Government Resolution of Assured Career Progression (ACP), a directly recruited PBOR as a Sepoy, Havildar or JCO will be entitled to minimum three financial upgradations after 8, 16 and 24 years of service. At the time of each financial upgradation under ACP, the PBOR would get an additional increment and next higher grade pay in hierarchy. xx xx xx"
Thereafter, another letter was issued by the Adjutant General Branch on 03.08.2009. Relevant portion of which reads as follows:-
"…….The new ACP (3 ACP at 8, 16 and 24 years of service) should be applicable w.e.f. 1 Jan 2006, and the old provns (operative w.e.f. the Vth Pay Commission) would be applicable till 31 Dec. 05. Regular service for the purpose of ACP shall commence from the date of joining of a post in direct entry grade.
xx xx xx"
6
Finally, on 30.05.2011 another letter was issued by the Ministry of Defence, relevant portion of which reads as follows:-
"5. The Scheme would be operational w.e.f. 1st Sep. 2008. In other words, financial up-gradations as per the provisions of the, earlier ACP scheme (of August 2003) would be granted till 31.08.2008." Therefore, even as per the understanding of the Army and other authorities up till the issuance of the letter dated 30.05.2011 the benefit of MACP was available from 01.01.2006.
10. As already held by us above, there can be no dispute that grant of ACP is part of the pay structure. It affects the pay of the employee and he gets a higher grade pay even though it may be in the same pay band. It has been strenuously urged by Col. R. Balasubramanian, learned counsel for the UOI that the Government took the decision to make the Scheme applicable from 01.09.2008 because many employees would have lost out in case the MACP was made applicable from 01.01.2006 and they would have had to refund the excess amount, if any, paid to them. His argument is that under the old Scheme if somebody got the benefit of the ACP he was put in the higher scale of pay. After merger of pay scales into pay bands an employee is only entitled to higher grade pay which may be lower than the next pay band. Therefore, there may be many employees who may suffer.
11. We are only concerned with the interpretation of the Resolution of the Government which clearly states that the recommendations of 6th CPC as modified and accepted by the Central Government in so far as they relate to pay structure, pay scales, grade pay etc. will apply from 01.01.2006. There may be some gainers and some losers but the intention of the Government was clear that this Scheme which is part of the pay structure would
7
apply from 01.01.2006. We may also point out that the Resolution dated 30.08.2008 whereby the recommendation of the Pay Commission has been accepted with modifications and recommendations with regard to pay structure, pay scales, grade pay etc. have been made applicable from 01.01.2006. This is a decision of the Cabinet. This decision could not have been modified by issuing executive instruction. The letter dated 30.05.2011 flies in the face of the Cabinet decision reflected in the Resolution dated 30.08.2008. Thus, administrative instruction dated 30.05.2011 is totally ultra vires the Resolution of the Government." (emphasis supplied)
8. On the other hand, the submission of learned counsel for the respondent is that the conscious decision taken by the Central Government is to grant the financial upgradation under the MACP scheme only from 01.09.2008. The petitioner cannot claim the implementation of the MACP scheme from
01.01.2006.
9. Having heard learned counsels and perused the record as well as the judgment of the Supreme Court in Balbir Singh Turn (supra), we are of the view that the petitioner is entitled to the grant of the second financial upgradation under the MACP scheme, provided he is found fit under the relevant rules and schemes, with effect from 01.01.2006.
10. In Balbir Singh Turn (supra), the Supreme Court has held that MACP is a part of the pay structure and would affect the grade pay of the employees and it could not be stated that it is a part of the allowances. The benefit of MACP if given to the employee, would affect his pension also. The Supreme Court has also held that the stand taken by the government that the MACP scheme was
8
made applicable from 01.09.2008 through a conscious decision was ultra vires the resolution of the government, founded upon a cabinet decision.
11. The ratio of the decision in Balbir Singh Turn (supra) is squarely attracted even in the present case, since the 6thCPC implemented in respect of the civilian employees of the Central Government is para materia with the scheme implemented in respect of the defence personnel.
12. Accordingly, we allow the present petition to the aforesaid extent. The respondent is directed to grant the second financial upgradation to the petitioner under the MACP scheme with effect from 01.01.2006, provided he was entitled to the said benefit from the said date in all other respects. The respondent shall take steps and pass appropriate orders within the next four weeks. The petitioner shall be entitled to costs of Rs.5,000/-.
13. The petition stands disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
VIPIN SANGHI, J
A. K. CHAWLA, J
NOVEMBER 13, 2018
sr
9
Alert