- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sabha Shanker Dube v. Divisional Forest Officer
Procedural History:
Appeals were filed against the judgment of the High Court of Allahabad dated 24th September, 2015 in Special Appeal No.1198 of 2006 and others by which the judgment of the learned Single Judge denying relief to the Appellants was affirmed.
Facts:
The Appellants are daily rated workers employed in Group 'D' posts in the Forest Department in the State of Uttar Pradesh. They filed Writ Petitions before the High Court of Allahabad seeking regularization of their services, the minimum of the pay scales available to their counterparts working on regular posts and treating them as being in continued service while condoning the breaks in their service. The Writ Petitions were dismissed by a learned Single Judge by a judgment dated 28th April, 2004. It was held that a direction for regularization cannot be issued. The learned Single Judge rejected the claim of the Appellants regarding the minimum of the pay scales by holding that such a direction cannot be granted under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
Issues:
- Whether the Appellants are entitled to regularization of their services?
- Whether the Appellants are entitled to the minimum of the pay scales available to their counterparts working on regular posts?
Arguments:
The Appellants relied upon a judgment of this Court in State of Punjab & Ors. v. Jagjit Singh & Ors. to submit that they are entitled to the minimum of the pay scales and the judgment of the Division Bench is liable to be set aside. The Advocate General appearing for the State of Uttar Pradesh contended that the Appellants are working in projects after being employed as and when the necessity arises.
Holdings:
In view of the judgment in Jagjit Singh (supra), the Court held that the Appellants are entitled to the minimum of the pay scales applicable to regular employees working on the same posts. The State of Uttar Pradesh is directed to make payment of the minimum of pay scales to the Appellants with effect from 1st December, 2018. Therefore, the Court allowed the Appeals and set aside the judgments of the High Court holding that the Appellants are entitled to be paid the minimum of the pay scales.
Reasoning:
The Court reasoned that the Appellants are entitled to the minimum of the pay scales based on the judgment in State of Punjab & Ors. v. Jagjit Singh & Ors. The Court also held that the Appellants are entitled to the minimum of the pay scales applicable to regular employees working on the same posts.
Disposition:
The Appeals were allowed and the judgments of the High Court holding that the Appellants are entitled to be paid the minimum of the pay scales were set aside. The State of Uttar Pradesh was directed to make payment of the minimum of pay scales to the Appellants with effect from 1st December, 2018.
L. Nageswara Rao, J.— Leave granted. These appeals are filed against the judgment of the High Court of Allahabad dated 24-9-2015 in Ram Pratap Dwivedi v. Conservator of Forest 2015 SCC OnLine All 9088 by which the judgment 2004 SCC OnLine All 2437 of the learned Single Judge denying relief to the appellants was affirmed.
2. The appellants are daily-rated workers employed in Group ‘D’ posts in the Forest Department in the State of Uttar Pradesh. They filed writ petitions before the High Court of Allahabad seeking regularisation of their services, the minimum of the pay scales available to their counterparts working on regular posts and treating them as being in continued service while condoning the breaks in their service. The writ petitions were dismissed by a learned Single Judge by the judgment dated 28-4-2004 2004 SCC OnLine All 2437. Regularisation of daily-wagers was directed to be considered in accordance with the relevant rules by condoning the breaks in service if it is less than 3 months. It was held that a direction for regularisation cannot be issued. The learned Single Judge rejected the claim of the appellants regarding the minimum of the pay scales by holding that such a direction cannot be granted under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The special appeals filed by the appellants were dismissed by a Division Bench of the High Court of Allahabad by a judgment dated 24-9-2015 2015 SCC OnLine All 9088 by relying upon its earlier judgment in State of U.P. v. Chhiddi 2015 SCC OnLine All 9087, (2016) 1 All LJ 226.
3. Special Appeal No. 1530 of 2007 was filed by the State of Uttar Pradesh against the judgment of the learned Single Judge dated 17-10-2005 in Sanjay Kumar Srivastava v. Conservator of Forest 2005 SCC OnLine All 2346. The said writ petitions were filed by daily-wagers working in Group ‘C’ and Group ‘D’ posts in the Forest Department of the State of Uttar Pradesh. Regularisation of services and equal pay for equal work were the reliefs that were sought by the petitioners in those writ petitions. The learned Single Judge allowed the writ petitions by directing the State Government to reconsider the petitioners therein for regularisation of their services, ignoring artificial breaks and by relaxing the minimum educational qualifications and the physical endurance requirements prescribed by the service rules. The Selection Committee was directed to reconsider candidature of all the petitioners therein for regularisation. Such of those persons who were found eligible for regularisation were directed to be regularised in the vacancies that may arise in the future in their respective divisions. There was a further direction that the petitioners therein shall be continued on daily wages till their regularisation and be paid a minimum of the pay scales.
4. In the appeal filed by the State of Uttar Pradesh, a Division Bench of the High Court set aside the directions issued in the writ petitions relating to the relaxation of minimum educational qualifications and physical endurance requirements as also the direction pertaining to the minimum of the pay scales to be paid to the daily-wagers. The directions issued by the learned Single Judge to relax the conditions of the requisite minimum qualifications and physical endurance requirements were found to be unjustified by the Division Bench. Placing reliance on a judgment of this Court in State of Haryana v. Tilak Raj (2003) 6 SCC 123 and State of Punjab v. Surjit Singh (2009) 9 SCC 514, the Division Bench of the High Court held that the daily-wagers are not entitled to the minimum of the pay scales.
5. We have heard Mr B.H. Marlapalle and Mr S.R. Singh, learned Senior Counsel for the appellants and Ms Aishwarya Bhati, learned Addl. Advocate General and Ms Rachna Gupta, learned Advocate-on-Record appearing for the respondents. It was made clear by Mr Marlapalle, learned Senior Advocate that the only point that requires consideration pertains to the entitlement of the appellants to the minimum of the pay scales applicable to the regular employees in the Forest Department. It was submitted on behalf of the appellants that the judgment of this Court in Civil Appeal No. 3634 of 1998 in State of U.P. v. Putti Lal (2006) 9 SCC 337 still holds the field and the Division Bench ought to have granted the relief sought by following the said judgment. The appellants relied upon a judgment of this Court in State of Punjab v. Jagjit Singh (2017) 1 SCC 148 to submit that they are entitled to the minimum of the pay scales and the judgment of the Division Bench is liable to be set aside. The appellants also draw support from the civil appeals Civil Appeals Nos. 879-85 of 2016 that were heard by this Court (2016) 4 SCC 721 against the orders 2010 SCC OnLine All 2975 passed in contempt applications filed for disobedience of the orders 1997 SCC OnLine All 864, (1999) 1 LLN 104 of payment of the minimum of the pay scales to the daily-wage workers in the Forest Department. This Court took notice of an affidavit filed on behalf of the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, State of Uttar Pradesh in which it was stated that the instructions were given to all the officers concerned to implement the directions issued by the High Court regarding payment of the minimum of pay scales to the daily-wagers. A direction (2016) 4 SCC 721 was given by this Court to the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests and the Principal Secretary to the Department of Forests, State of Uttar Pradesh to file separate affidavits in the High Court regarding the implementation of the directions.
6. Mr S.R. Singh, learned Senior Advocate appearing for some of the appellants informed us that all the daily-wagers were paid the minimum of the pay scales from 29-1-2016 to 31-3-2018 @ Rs 18,000 per month. After 31-3-2018, the pay was revised to 7000 per month. He submitted that according to the recommendations of the 7th Pay Commission, the minimum of the pay scale to which the appellants are entitled to is Rs 18,000.
7. Ms Aishwarya Bhati, learned Addl. Advocate General appearing for the State of Uttar Pradesh contended that the appellants are working in projects after being employed as and when the necessity arises. There is no continuity of service and the employment of the appellants is made periodically after long breaks. She submitted that the appellants are not eligible for regularisation in accordance with the rules and they are not working on sanctioned posts. She also submitted that any relief granted in favour of the appellants will result in a heavy burden on the State exchequer.
8. It is necessary for us to refer to the judgment of the Division Bench of the High Court of Allahabad in State of U.P. v. Chhiddi 2015 SCC OnLine All 9087, (2016) 1 All LJ 226 as all the impugned special appeals were dismissed 2015 SCC OnLine All 9088 by following the said judgment. The directions issued by the learned Single Judge to reconsider the writ petitioners for regularisation of their services by ignoring the minimum educational qualifications and the physical endurance requirements as well as continuance of the writ petitioners on a daily-wage basis with the minimum of the pay scales were set aside by the Division Bench.
9. The daily-wagers relied upon a judgment of this Court in Putti Lal (2006) 9 SCC 337 and submitted that the same relief may be extended to them. It is relevant to note that the judgment in Putti Lal (2006) 9 SCC 337 relates to a dispute similar to that involved in this case. Daily-rated wage earners in the Forest Department in the State of Uttar Pradesh approached the High Court for regularisation of their services. The Division Bench of the High Court of Allahabad directed the State Government to constitute the Committee as directed in order to frame the scheme for regularisation. The judgment of the High Court that the daily-rated wage workers shall be paid at the minimum of the pay scales was affirmed by this Court on the principle of equal pay for equal work. The Division Bench of the High Court while deciding State of U.P. v. Chhiddi 2015 SCC OnLine All 9087, (2016) 1 All LJ 226 referred to the judgment in Putti Lal (2006) 9 SCC 337 but placed reliance on a later judgment of this Court in Tilak Raj (2003) 6 SCC 123. The Division Bench of the High Court also cited Surjit Singh (2009) 9 SCC 514 to hold that the daily-wagers cannot seek the benefit of the judgment of Putti Lal case (2006) 9 SCC 337 in view of the subsequent decisions of this Court wherein, according to the High Court, it was held that daily-wage employees were not entitled to the minimum of the pay scales.
10. On a comprehensive consideration of the entire law on the subject of parity of pay scales on the principle of equal pay for equal work, this Court in Jagjit Singh (2017) 1 SCC 148 held as follows:
“58. In our considered view, it is fallacious to determine artificial parameters to deny fruits of labour. An employee engaged for the same work cannot be paid less than another who performs the same duties and responsibilities. Certainly not, in a welfare State. Such an action besides being demeaning, strikes at the very foundation of human dignity. Anyone, who is compelled to work at a lesser wage does not do so voluntarily. He does so to provide food and shelter to his family, at the cost of his self-respect and dignity, at the cost of his self-worth, and at the cost of his integrity. For he knows that his dependants would suffer immensely, if he does not accept the lesser wage. Any act of paying less wages as compared to others similarly situate constitutes an act of exploitative enslavement, emerging out of a domineering position. Undoubtedly, the action is oppressive, suppressive and coercive, as it compels involuntary subjugation.”
11. The issue that was considered by this Court in Jagjit Singh (2017) 1 SCC 148 is whether temporary employees (daily-wage employees, ad hoc appointees, employees appointed on casual basis, contractual employees and likewise) are entitled to the minimum of the regular pay scales on account of their performing the same duties which are discharged by those engaged on regular basis against the sanctioned posts. After considering several judgments including the judgments of this Court in Tilak Raj (2003) 6 SCC 123 and Surjit Singh (2009) 9 SCC 514, this Court held that temporary employees are entitled to draw wages at the minimum of the pay scales which are applicable to the regular employees holding the same post.
12*. In view of the judgment in Jagjit Singh (2017) 1 SCC 148, we are unable to uphold the view of the High Court that the appellants herein are not entitled to be paid the minimum of the pay scales. We are not called upon to adjudicate on the rights of the appellants relating to the regularisation of their services. We are concerned only with the principle laid down by this Court initially in Putti Lal (2006) 9 SCC 337 relating to persons who are similarly situated to the appellants and later affirmed in Jagjit Singh (2017) 1 SCC 148 that temporary employees are entitled to minimum of the pay scales as long as they continue in service.
13. We express no opinion on the contention of the State Government that the appellants are not entitled to the reliefs as they are not working on Group ‘D’ posts and that some of them worked for short periods in projects.
14. For the aforementioned reasons, we allow these appeals and set aside the judgments of the High Court holding that the appellants are entitled to be paid the minimum of the pay scales applicable to regular employees working on the same posts. The State of Uttar Pradesh is directed to make payment of the minimum of pay scales to the appellants with effect from 1-12-2018.
Alert