- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ramakant v. State Of Maharashtra
High Court of Judicature at Bombay, Nagpur Bench — Criminal Appeal (APEAL) No. 253 of 2002
Coram: M. G. Giratkar, J. | Reserve Date: 20 Oct 2018 | Judgment Date: 30 Oct 2018
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant, Ramakant s/o Devidas Solkke, then an Accountant at State Bank of India, Main Branch, Akola, was convicted by the Special Judge, Akola in Special Case No. 01 of 1992 by a judgment dated 12 April 2002. The trial court convicted him under Section 5(1)(d) read with Section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947 and under Sections 420, 467, 483 and 471 of the Indian Penal Code, sentencing him to imprisonment and fines as set out in the trial court order.
The prosecution's case (in short) alleged that a Telegraphic Transfer (TT) for Rs.30,000 was issued by Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited (BPCL) through the State Bank of India, Commercial Branch, Mumbai to the Akola branch for payment to an "Operation Officer" of BPCL. The appellant, as the TT Accountant, received the TT and, according to the prosecution, issued a bankers' cheque dated 03.05.1986 in the name of a fictitious/non-existing person "Champaklal Shah", endorsed identification for that name, and ultimately received Rs.30,000 from the cashier (PW-6 Anjali Pagrut). The prosecution alleged misappropriation and fraudulent conduct; enquiry revealed a double payment of Rs.30,000 and resulted in a charge-sheet and trial.
Charge was framed (Exh.14); the appellant pleaded not guilty. The prosecution examined ten witnesses; the accused's statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C. was recorded. On conviction by the Special Judge, the appellant filed the present appeal challenging the trial court's judgment.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant prepared a false bankers' cheque (Exh.67) in the name of "Champaklal Shah" and thereby committed the offences charged.
- Whether the evidence that the appellant received the Rs.30,000 (payment of Exh.67) is reliable, in particular in light of the material omission in PW-6's (Anjali Pagrut) statement.
- Whether the procedural and evidentiary lacunae (absence of handwriting expert, non-examination of the clerk alleged to have written the cheque, and the manner in which sanction to prosecute was granted) vitiate the prosecution's case.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments (as advanced by Shri Anil Mardikar, Senior Advocate)
- The trial court did not properly consider material omissions in PW-6's evidence; PW-6's testimony that she paid Rs.30,000 to the appellant was an omission from her statement to the Investigating Officer and is a material omission undermining her credibility.
- Bank procedure requires multiple checks: the cheque is prepared by a clerk, passed through officers, and payment is made by the cashier to the cheque-holder after identity verification; there is no direct evidence other than PW-6 that the appellant received the money.
- The appellant did not prepare the cheque: handwriting on the cheque was of Mrs. Ukhalkar (a clerk-typist) and she was not examined; no handwriting expert was called by the prosecution to prove the appellant's handwriting on Exh.67.
- The prosecution failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt that Champaklal Shah did not exist or that the appellant received the payment; therefore, the appellant should be acquitted.
Respondents' Arguments
- Respondent No.2 (CBI counsel Smt. Mugdha Chandurkar) argued that the appellant did not deny material evidence in his Section 313 statement and it was open to him to produce or examine the person Champaklal Shah if he existed; PW-6 specifically stated she had given cash of Rs.30,000 to the appellant — thus the evidence sufficed for conviction.
- The State (represented by Shri H.D. Dubey) supported the trial court's conviction; the submissions recorded in the opinion emphasise that PW-6's evidence implicated the appellant and the prosecution's case should be sustained (the opinion, however, records the court's consideration of these submissions).
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the evidence in detail and proceeded by assessing the provenance and reliability of the material testimony on which the prosecution relied.
First, the Court noted PW-2's evidence confirmed the TT of Rs.30,000 was transferred to the Akola branch and explained the internal bank procedure: bankers' cheques are prepared under the signature of the TT Accountant, the cheque preparatory role is performed by a clerk and cheques pass through multiple officers before reaching the cashier. It was accepted in evidence that the cheque's handwriting (other than the passing/identification endorsements) was that of Mrs. Ukhalkar, Clerk-Typist, who was not examined by the prosecution.
The Court focused on PW-6 (Anjali Pagrut), the cashier, as the "material witness" for the allegation that the appellant actually received the Rs.30,000. In her examination-in-chief she stated the appellant had passed the cheque for payment, had endorsed identification that the person (Champaklal Shah) was known to him, and that she paid the Rs.30,000 to the appellant. However, in cross-examination PW-6 admitted that she had not mentioned payment to the appellant in her statement to the Investigating Officer; this omission was specifically pointed out and the Investigating Officer (Shri Nene) corroborated that PW-6 had not stated to him that she paid the cheque amount to the appellant. The Court treated this as a material omission and concluded that the incriminating portion of PW-6's evidence regarding payment to the appellant had to be excluded.
The Court also observed that bank officers stated the cashier must pay only to the holder of the cheque and not to a bank employee — and that no employee is authorised to receive payment in the name of a customer. Evidence showed that the cheque bore passing remarks and identification by the appellant but did not establish that the appellant had written the cheque itself. The appellant denied the handwriting on the cheque in his Section 313 statement; the prosecution did not examine any handwriting expert to establish authorship of the disputed handwriting or call Mrs. Ukhalkar (the clerk whose handwriting was said to appear on the cheque).
Additionally, the Court noted that the Disciplinary Authority had not applied his mind properly when granting sanction to prosecute the appellant (as emerged from his evidence), which further affected the strength of the prosecution's procedural foundation.
Taking these strands together — the material omission in PW-6's evidence (leading to exclusion of her incriminating statement about payment), absence of direct evidence that the appellant wrote the cheque, non-examination of the clerk and lack of handwriting expert evidence, plus questions regarding sanction — the Court concluded that there remained no evidence to show the appellant accepted the Rs.30,000. On that basis the prosecution had not proved the appellant's guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL ALLOWED; CONVICTION QUASHED; ACCUSED ACQUITTED
Direct effects on the parties:
- The Criminal Appeal is allowed.
- The impugned judgment in Special Case No. 01 of 1992 dated 12 April 2002 passed by the Special Judge, Akola is quashed and set aside.
- The accused/appellant is acquitted of the offences charged with.
Broader implications: The opinion does not discuss or state any new legal principle or broader precedent; the decision's effect, as recorded in the text, is limited to the acquittal of the appellant in this case.
1 apeal253.02
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY,
NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR.
CRIMINAL APPEAL (APEAL) NO. 253 OF 2002
Ramakant s/o Devidas Solkke, aged about 58 years, Accountant, State Bank of India, Branch Malkapur, District Buldana. (Under suspension) at present r/o C/o Miss R.R. Solke, S.B.I. Colony, Quarter No.21, Shegaon, District Buldana, Maharashtra (accused). ... APPELLANT
VERSUS
1. State of Maharashtra through P.S.O. Police Station, Civil Lines, Akola.
2. The Central Bureau of Investigation, Nagpur Region, Nagpur. ... RESPONDENTS
....
Shri Anil Mardikar, Senior Advocate with Shri Akshay M. Kshirsagar, Advocate for the appellant.
Shri H.D. Dubey, Additional Public Prosecutor for respondent No.1/State.
Smt. Mugdha Chandurkar, Advocate for respondent No.2.
....
CORAM : M.G. GIRATKAR, J.
DATE OF RESERVING THE JUDGMENT : 20TH OCTOBER, 2018.
DATE OF PRONOUNCING THE JUDGMENT : 30TH OCTOBER, 2018.
JUDGMENT :
1
By way of present appeal, the appellant has assailed the judgment of conviction in Special Case No. 01 of 1992, dated 12th April, 2002 passed by Special Judge, Akola, thereby convicting the appellant for the offence punishable under Section 5(1)(d) read with Section 5(2) of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947 and sentenced him to suffer RI for one year and to pay a fine of Rs.500/-, in default, to further suffer RI for two months. The appellant is further convicted for the offence punishable under Sections 420, 467, 483 and 471 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced him to suffer RI for one year and to pay fine of Rs.500/-, in default, to further suffer RI for two months.
2. The case of the prosecution against the appellant, in short, is as under :-
The appellant was working as an Accountant in State Bank of India, Main Branch, Akola. One Mukund Govind Saraf was the Manager in the State Bank of India, Commercial Branch at Mumbai. On 30.04.1986, Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited (BPCL) gave a list of various amounts to State Bank of India, Commercial Branch, Mumbai for transfer of various amounts to the branches mentioned in
2
the list by Telegraphic Transfer (TT). Mukund Saraf received the lists of BPCL and requested the State Bank of India, Commercial Branch, Mumbai to transfer the amount of Rs.30,000/- by TT to State Bank of India, Main Branch, Akola for payment of Operation Officer, BPCL. Accused, who was an Accountant, received the TT on 02.05.1986. He issued bankers' cheque (Exh.67) dated 03.05.1986 for Rs.30,000/- in the name of fictitious and non existing person namely Champaklal Shah. He certified the identity of the said person as known to him and sent cheque for encashment. Anjali Pagrut, Cashier of the Akola branch received the said cheque for payment. She had given the said amount of Rs.30,000/- to the accused. It is further the case of prosecution that Champaklal Shah was not in existence. Accused prepared false cheque in the name of Champaklal Shah. He himself passed the said cheque and made remarks about the identification of the said person and received the amount of Rs.30,000/- from Cashier Anjali. The appellant thereby misappropriated the said amount. During enquiry, it was revealed about the double payment of Rs.30,000/- and report was lodged. Investigating Officer recorded the statements of witnesses and filed the charge-sheet before the Court.
3
3. Charge was framed by the Special Judge at Exh.14. The same was read over and explained to the appellant/accused to which he pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried. The prosecution has examined ten witnesses. Statement of accused came to be recorded under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. After hearing both the sides, the appellant/accused is convicted as stated above.
4. Heard Shri Mardikar, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant/accused. He has submitted that the trial Court has not considered material omissions brought on record in the evidence of PW-6. The evidence of other witnesses shows that TT of Rs.30,000/- was received from BPCL. The bankers' cheque was issued in the name of Champaklal Shah for Rs.30,000/-. As per the procedure, cheque is to be verified by various Officers of the bank. Cashier, who pays the amount, has to pay the amount of cheque to the concerned person. There is no evidence to show that Champaklal Shah was not in existence. It is the specific contention of the appellant that the said amount was received by Champaklal Shah.
4
5. Learned Senior Counsel has pointed out the evidence of witnesses and submitted that it is the procedure of the bank that the cheque has to go from one table to other and after passing the said cheque, it goes to the counter of Cashier. Cashier, after verifying the identity of the person, uses to pay the amount of cheque. Except the evidence of PW-6, there is no evidence to show that accused received the amount of cheque.
6. Shri Mardikar, learned Senior Counsel has further pointed out the evidence of PW-6 Anjali Pagrut and submitted that what she has stated incriminating against the appellant is a material omission brought on record in her cross-examination. She has stated in para 8 of her cross-examination that, she has not stated in her statement recorded by Investigating Officer about the payment of Rs.30,000/- to the accused. Investigating Officer Shri Kudkar has stated in his cross- examination that accused was competent authority to issue bankers' cheque. He had not collected any information about the existence of Champaklal Shah. Learned Senior Counsel has submitted that prosecution has failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt that Champaklal Shah was not in existence. The prosecution has failed to
5
prove that the appellant prepared false cheque and received the amount of cheque of Rs.30,000/-. Learned trial Court has not considered the material in its proper perspective and convicted the appellant. At last, learned Senior Counsel prays to allow the appeal and acquit the appellant.
7. Heard Smt. Mugdha Chandurkar, learned Counsel appearing on behalf of respondent No.2 and Shri Dubey, learned Additional Public Prosecutor on behalf of respondent No.1/State.
8. Smt. Chandurkar, learned Counsel for respondent No.2 has pointed out statement of accused under Section 313 and submitted that he has not denied the material evidence. She has further submitted that it was for the appellant to examine/produce Champaklal Shah before the Court. The appellant himself prepared a cheque, passed for payment and received the amount of cheque. PW-6 Anjali has specifically stated that she had given cash of Rs.30,000/- to the appellant. At last, she has submitted that the evidence is sufficient for convicting the appellant, therefore, appeal is liable to be dismissed.
6
9. Perused the evidence on record. The evidence of PW-2 shows that he has transferred TT of Rs.30,000/- to State Bank of India, Akola Branch. PW-2 has stated that cheque (Article-A) bears the signature of the appellant. Handwriting on the cheque was of Mrs. Ukhalkar, Clerk-Typist, State Bank of India, Akola. Cheque marked as S-2 shown to him. He could not identify the signature of the cheque. He has stated the procedure in respect of payment of cheque. In his cross-examination, he has stated that all cheques are issued under the signature of TT Accountant. Accused was TT Accountant and voucher is to be sent by TT Accountant for preparation of cheque. TT Accountant signs the bankers' cheques prepared by his Clerk. In the evening, payment and passing receipts are tallied. If the cashier has a doubt about the cheque, he can get it cleared from the passing Officer. If the payment is made to a person having no account in the bank then identification of the person is asked for, either from the bank employees or the persons having bank accounts. It is a rule of prudence to ascertain that the payment is made to a proper person. Other witnesses also stated in respect of procedure of payment of cheque.
7
10. PW-6 Anjali Pagrut is the material witness. She has stated in her examination-in-chief that accused prepared a cheque (Exh.67). Said cheque was received by her through transit book of appellant. It was brought by messenger of the bank. On receiving the cheque, she saw that the appellant has passed the cheque for payment and signed it for passing. She has further stated that the appellant has identified the person Champaklal Shah whose name is mentioned in the cheque (Exh.67). Appellant had made endorsement on the cheque that the person known to him and had signed the endorsement. The identification endorsement was in the handwriting of the appellant and bears his signature. She made the payment of cheque (Exh.67) to the accused. This material evidence is brought on record in her cross- examination as an omission. In para 8 of her cross-examination, she stated that, the CBI Officers made enquiry with her. She had disclosed to police at the time of statement that she made the payment of this cheque (Exh.67) to accused. This fact was not mentioned in her statement before police. The statement was read by her and this fact was not mentioned in her statement before police. She could not say why it was not mentioned in her statement. This material omission is proved by Investigating Officer Shri Nene. He has stated in his cross-
8
examination that PW-6 Anjali not stated before him that she made payment of cheque (Exh.67) to accused. Except this evidence of Anjali (PW-6), there is no evidence to show that amount of cheque (Exh.67) was received by the appellant. Whatever Anjali had stated in respect of payment of cheque (Exh.67) is the material omission brought on record in her cross-examination and proved by Investigation Officer Shri Nene.
11. The evidence of Disciplinary Authority shows that he has not applied his mind properly while granting sanction to prosecute the appellant. In his cross-examination, he has stated that as per rule of the bank, the payment needs to be made to the holder of cheque. No employee of the bank is authorized to receive the payment in the name of customer. Therefore, it is clear that Anjali (PW-6) was not authorized to give the payment to the appellant. Handwriting of cheque (Exh.67) is denied by the appellant in his statement under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. There is nothing on record to show that cheque was written in the handwriting of appellant except the endorsement of passing and identification. The prosecution failed to examine any Handwriting Expert to prove the
9
handwriting on the cheque (Exh.67).
12. As stated by the Bank Officers, it is clear that the cheque was to be prepared by the Clerk of TT Accountant. As per the evidence of PW-3, a cheque was in the handwriting of Mrs. Ukhalkar, Clerk- Typist, State Bank of India, Akola. Mrs. Ukhalkar was not examined by the prosecution. As per the procedure, cheque uses to pass from one table to other and ultimately to the counter of Cashier. As per the rule, Cashier has to pay the amount to the holder of the cheque and not any other employee of the bank. This fact is stated by PW-9. Other bank officers also stated that Cashier has to pay the amount to the holder of the cheque after verifying the identity.
13. Disputed cheque (Exh.67) only shows the passing remarks and identification by the appellant. There is no evidence to show that accused prepared the said cheque in his handwriting. Evidence of PW-
6 Anjali about the payment of Rs.30,000/- to the appellant is nothing but material omission proved by Investigating Officer Shri Nene. This evidence, therefore, has to be excluded from her deposition. If this evidence is excluded then there is no evidence to show that accused
10
accepted the amount of Rs.30,000/- of disputed cheque (Exh.67). The prosecution has miserably failed to prove the guilt of accused beyond reasonable doubt. Hence, the following order.
(i) Criminal Appeal is allowed.
(ii) Impugned judgment in Special Case No. 01 of 1992 dated 12thApril, 2002 passed by the Special Judge, Akola is hereby quashed and set aside.
(iii) Accused/appellant is acquitted of the offences charged with.
JUDGE
*rrg.
11
Alert