Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sanskriti Jayantilal Salia v. State Of Maharashtra

Bombay High Court
Oct 1, 2018
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

On 19th December 2016, Ms. Sanskriti Jayantilal Salia deposited Rs.40,500/- in old currency notes at Saraswat Co-operative Bank Ltd., Vikhroli branch. The bank cashier, Smt. Dipika Prakash Amin, detected Rs.4,000/- worth of notes as counterfeit using a Fake Note/Counterfeit Money Detector Machine. Ms. Sanskriti informed the bank that the notes were her savings deposited in light of the demonetization announced by the Government of India on 8th November 2016, which allowed deposit of demonetized notes until 30th December 2016. She had previously deposited Rs.32,000/- and Rs.20,000/- on 10th November and 4th December 2016 respectively without any issues.

Following the detection of counterfeit notes, a complaint was lodged on 7th January 2017 at Parksite Police Station, Vikhroli, and a case was registered under Section 489(B) of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). Ms. Sanskriti cooperated with the investigation, obtained anticipatory bail, and the charge-sheet was filed on 17th June 2017. The Sessions Case No.699 of 2017 was registered against her in the Court of Sessions, Greater Bombay.

The petitioner approached the High Court seeking quashing of the charge-sheet and setting aside the Sessions Case, contending absence of mens rea and knowledge regarding the counterfeit nature of the notes.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the prosecution has established the essential mens rea element under Section 489(B) IPC, that is, whether the petitioner knew or had reason to believe that the currency notes deposited were forged or counterfeit?
  2. Whether mere possession or deposit of counterfeit currency notes without knowledge or reason to believe their counterfeit nature attracts penal liability under Section 489(B) IPC?
  3. Whether continuation of the trial against the petitioner is justified in absence of evidence indicating her knowledge of the counterfeit nature of the currency notes?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The prosecution must prove that the petitioner had knowledge or reason to believe the currency notes were counterfeit, as mens rea is an essential ingredient under Section 489(B) IPC.
  • The charge-sheet does not attribute any knowledge of counterfeit currency to the petitioner; she is in fact a victim and scapegoat.
  • Mere possession or deposit of counterfeit notes is insufficient to sustain charges without proof of mens rea.
  • The counterfeit notes were high quality and not distinguishable by an ordinary person, negating any presumption of knowledge.
  • Continuation of trial would be an abuse of process of law and the case should be quashed in exercise of inherent jurisdiction.
  • Relied on authoritative judgments, including the Apex Court decision in Umashankar vs. State of Chattisgrah, to support the requirement of mens rea for offences under Section 489(B) IPC.

Respondent's Position

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent's legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Umashankar vs. State of Chattisgrah, (2001) 9 SCC 642 Mens rea is essential under Sections 489(B) and 489(C) IPC; mere possession without knowledge does not constitute offence. The court relied on this to hold that the petitioner’s knowledge or reason to believe the notes were counterfeit was not established.
Shashikant s/o. Gulabchand Bora vs. State of Maharashtra, (2010) ALL MR (Cri) 3883 Requirement of mens rea for offences involving counterfeit currency. Followed the principle that knowledge or reason to believe is necessary for conviction under Section 489(B).
Abdul Majeet Abdul Reheman Sarkhot vs. State of Maharashtra, (2001) ALL MR (Cri) 1311 Mens rea as an essential element for offences under Section 489(B) IPC. Supported the petitioner’s argument on the necessity of proving knowledge of counterfeit currency.
Abdul Fakirsaheb Mamtule vs. State of Maharashtra, (2001) ALL MR (Cri) 2264 Mens rea requirement for offences involving counterfeit currency. Reinforced the principle that mere possession without knowledge is insufficient for conviction.
Noor Islam s/o. Sadik Ali vs. The State of Maharashtra, (2016) ALL MR (Cri) 3480 Mens rea essential for Section 489(B) offences. Used to affirm that knowledge or reason to believe counterfeit nature is necessary for criminal liability.
M. Mammutti vs. State of Karnataka, (1979) 4 SCC 72 No presumption of knowledge if counterfeit notes are not obviously fake; prosecution must prove mens rea. Quoted extensively to emphasize that mere possession does not imply knowledge; conviction set aside where mens rea not proved.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court carefully examined the charge-sheet and the expert opinion obtained from the General Manager, Currency Note Press, Nashik Road, which classified the seized notes as "High Quality Counterfeit Notes." The report detailed various discrepancies in security features, printing quality, watermark, and optical responses that indicated the notes were counterfeit. However, these high-quality counterfeit notes were such that an ordinary person, including the young petitioner, could not have reasonably distinguished them from genuine currency.

The court emphasized that Section 489(B) IPC requires the prosecution to prove that the accused "knowing or having reason to believe" the notes to be counterfeit, trafficked or used them as genuine. The mens rea element is central and indispensable. Mere possession or use of counterfeit notes without such knowledge or reason to believe does not constitute an offence under this provision.

The court noted the absence of any material in the charge-sheet indicating that the petitioner had the requisite knowledge or reason to believe the notes were counterfeit. This absence was not disputed by the learned APP. The court also referred to authoritative Supreme Court judgments, particularly M. Mammutti vs. State of Karnataka and Umashankar vs. State of Chattisgrah, which reinforce that mens rea is essential and that mere possession without knowledge is insufficient for conviction.

Accordingly, the court concluded that continuation of the trial would amount to an abuse of the process of law as the charge could not be proved even on culmination of the trial.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is allowed and the Sessions Case No.699 of 2017 arising out of CR No.22 of 2017 registered at Parksite Police Station, Vikhroli, Mumbai, under Section 489(B) IPC is quashed and set aside.

The direct effect of this decision is the termination of criminal proceedings against the petitioner on the ground of absence of mens rea required under Section 489(B) IPC. No broader precedent beyond the facts of this case is established, but the ruling reiterates the essentiality of proving knowledge or reason to believe the counterfeit nature of currency notes to sustain charges under this provision.

Show all summary ...

judgment-wp3027-18-stm.doc

SSK

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

(The judgment is corrected pursuant to speaking to the minutes order dtd.08.10.18)

CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. 3027 OF 2018

1. Sanskriti Jayantilal Salia age : 25 years, Occu.: Service, Indian inhabitant having her permanent place of address and residing at 13/202 Kannamwar Nagar - I, Vikhroli (E), Mumbai - 400 083 …Petitioner

(Ori. Accused)

Versus

1. The State of Maharashtra

2. The Senior Inspector of Police at the instance of Parksite Police Station, Vikhroli, Mumbai

3. Mrs. Dipika Prakash Amin Employed with Saraswat Co-operative Bank Ltd., Vikhroli (W), Mumbai Branch as Bank Cashier and residing at Flat No.11, Sankalp Siddhi Housing Society, Kamarl Sagar, Bhandup (E), Mumbai - 400 042. …Respondents

(First Informant) Mr. Jatin P. Shah, a/w Ms. Snehankita Munj and Zarna K. Shah, for the Petitioner.

Mrs. Aruna S. Pai, APP for the State/Respondent.

CORAM : RANJIT MORE &

SMT. BHARATI H. DANGRE, JJ.

DATED : 1st October, 2018

JUDGMENT :- (Per Smt. Bharati H. Dangre, J.)

1. Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. Heard by consent of the parties.

1/15

2. On 7th January, 2017 one Smt. Dipika Prakash Amin working as Bank Cashier with the Saraswat Co-operative Bank Ltd. Vikhroli, lodged complaint stating therein that on 19.12.2016 while she was discharging her duties as cashier one Ms. Sanskriti Salia with A/c No.055203100000285 deposited old currency notes to the tune of Rs.40,500/-. When these notes tendered by the customer, were placed in the Fake Note/Counterfeit Money Detector Machine, three notes of denomination of Rs.1,000/- and two notes of denomination of Rs.500/- i.e. total amount of Rs.4,000/- were found to be counterfeit. On inquiry from Ms. Sanskriti Salia, she informed that the said notes were her saving and in the wake of demonetization she had deposited the said amount. Ms. Sanskriti complied with the directions issued by the Bank authorities and the complaint filed by Smt. Dipika was registered as CR No.22 of 2017 and offences under Section 489(B) of Indian Penal Code ("IPC", for short) came to be registered against Ms. Sanskriti Jayant Salia, who has approached this court praying for quashing of the said charge- sheet.

3. The petitioner before us is well educated and has

2/15

completed post-graduation in commerce. According to the petition, her father is a businessman and she while pursuing her studies, she started working with a company "Enlightned Minds" - National English Language Testing & Assessment System at Mulund, in the capacity of Senior Back Office Executive. According to the Petitioner, on 8thNovember, 2016, the Government of India announced demonetization of old bank notes of Mahatma Gandhi series in the demonetization of Rs.500/- and Rs.1,000/-. It is the case of the Petitioner that the Government of India issued a notification post demonetization, and the demonetized notes were permitted to be deposited by the concerned holders of the said notes, in their bank account before the deadline, which was stipulated on or before 30thDecember, 2016. It is specific case of the petitioner that she had saved an amount of Rs.92,500/- in cash and this was in form of currency of Rs.500/- and Rs.1,000/-.

4. It is the case of the Petitioner that on 10thNovember, 2016, she deposited an amount of Rs.32,000/- in her account and thereafter on 4thDecember, 2016 she deposited further amount of Rs.20,000/- in her saving bank account in Saraswat Co-operative Bank Ltd., Vikhroli. As per the bank, on both

3/15

dates, the amount deposited by her was verified by the cashier by putting the notes in Fake Note/Counterfeit Note Detector Machine and nothing abnormal was noted. On 19thDecember, 2016 she again visited the bank to deposit balance sum of Rs.40,500/- in her saving bank account and on this date, the cashier found that currency amounting to Rs.4,000/- (three notes of Rs.1,000/- and two notes of Rs.500/-) were counterfeit. Based on which an offence was registered against the Petitioner under Section 489(B) of the Act on 7th January, 2017 at Parksite Police Station Vikhroli. The Petitioner co- operated with the investigation and got her statement recorded. The Petitioner also obtained anticipatory bail from the Sessions Court of Greater Bombay, Mumbai, anticipating her arrest. On completion of investigation, charge-sheet was filed against the Petitioner on 17thJune, 2017 in the Metropolitan Magistrate, 31stCourt, at Vikhroli and the case was committed to the Court of Sessions, Greater Bombay, Mumbai and registered as Sessions Case No.699 of 2017.

5. The Petitioner has approached this Court praying for quashing and setting aside of the said Sessions Case arising out of the CR No.22 of 2017 registered against her, for the

4/15

offences punishable under Section 489(B) of IPC. In support of the Petitioner, we have heard the learned Counsel Mr. Shah and the learned APP Mrs. Pai. The learned Counsel for the Petitioner would submit that for invoking the provisions of Section 489(B) of IPC, it is necessary for the prosecution to establish that the Petitioner had either

"knowledge" or that she had "reason to believe" that the currency notes were forged or counterfeit. He would submit that mens rea is an essential ingredients of Section 489(B) and without the presence of the same, the Petitioner could not have been charged with Section 489(B). The learned Counsel would submit that even if the charge-sheet is perused and construed the way it stands, it do not reflect any knowledge being attributed to the Petitioner and, in fact, she herself is a victim of the counterfeit menace and has been made an scapegoat of entire incident. Thus, according to the Petitioner, perusal of the entire charge-sheet and the material collected by the prosecution both, fall short of establishing the charge even prima facie, since it fails to establish knowledge on her part that the notes which she had deposited were forged or fake. His specific submission is that mere possession of the currency

5/15

notes by her, is not sufficient to foist the charges on her and according to him perusal of the charge-sheet would reveal that there is no iota of any evidence to show that the counterfeit notes were of such nature or description that a mere look at them would convey any person of average intelligence that they were counterfeit notes. He would thus submit that continuation of trial and the Petitioner being made to go through the rigmarole of trial would nothing but an abuse of process of law and this Court should intervene and quash the Sessions Case pending against her.

6. The learned Counsel for the Petitioner would rely upon judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of

Umashankar vs. State of Chattisgrah1to support hs argument that the Section 489(B) would involve an element of mens rea and is is an essential ingredient to constitute an offence under the said Section. According to the learned Counsel the Hon'ble Apex Court has held that possessing or even intending to use any forged or counterfeit currency notes or bank notes is not sufficient to make out a case under Section 489 - C of IPC in absence of mens rea. He also place reliance on the following judgments of this Court, which lay down a similar

1 (2001 ) 9 Supreme Court Cases 642

6/15

proposition of law, following the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court.

(i) Shashikant s/o. Gulabchand Bora vs. State of Maharashtra, (2010) ALL MR (Cri) 3883.

(ii) Abdul Majeet Abdul Reheman Sarkhot vs. State of Maharashtra, (2001) ALL MR (Cri) 1311.

(iii) Abdul Fakirsaheb Mamtule vs. State of Maharashtra, (2001) ALL MR (Cri) 2264.

(iv) Noor Islam s/o. Sadik Ali vs. The State of Maharashtra, (2016) ALL MR (Cri) 3480. He would also place the reliance on the judgments of the other High Courts taking a similar view.

7. With the assistance of the learned Counsel for the parties, we have carefully perused the charge-sheet in the subject crime. The case of the prosecution is that the Petitioner had deposited an amount of Rs.40,500/- on 19thDecember, 2016 out of which an amount of Rs.4,000/- has been found to be counterfeit currency. The denomination of the said counterfeit currency was three notes of Rs.1,000/- and two notes of Rs.500/- and in terms of the circular issues by the Reserve Bank of India vide Circular No.RBI/2015-16/162, since more than five notes were found to be counterfeited, an offence came to be registered against the Petitioner. The Investigating Officer

7/15

during the course of investigation has sought an opinion from the General Manager, Currency Note Press, Nashik Road, Nashik vide letter dated 10thJanuary, 2017. The seized currency notes were sent for examination to the addressee and he was requested to give his opinion on the following points:

(i) Whether seized currency notes are counterfeit note or genuine notes.

(ii) Whether seized notes are printed/produced from Security press of Government of India.

(iii) What are the security features in genuine currency notes of denomination of Rs.1000/- (having silver colored thread) and Rs.500/- (having green colored thread).

(iv) In which respect (regarding security features) the seized currency notes differ from that in genuine currency notes.

(v) Any other opinion than above points. In response, the Assistant Manager (Tech and Per) on behalf of General Manager, forwarded an opinion report on examination of the suspected forged currency notes to the Investigating Officer. The said report reveals that the opinion was expressed after comparing the alleged counterfeit notes with genuine notes of respective parties with the help of modern scientific instrument, and the observation is reproduced below:

8/15

1. Cut size of the note (s)

(i) Length :- Correct

(ii) Width :- Correct

2. Size of printed design :- Varies from genuine note

3. Paper

(i) Thickness :- Same as that of Genuine note paper

(ii) texture :- Not as per genuine note.

4. Watermarks

(i) Main Watermark :- Created during paper making process but imitated

(ii) Hidden Watermark :- Created during paper making process but imitated

(iii) Deno. Number :- Created during paper making process but imitated

5. Security Thread

(i) Continuity of the thread:- Partly embedded on front & fully embedded on Back.

Inserted during paper

making but imitated.

6. Optical response under U.V. light :-

(i) Paper - optically active / Optically inactive inactive :-

(ii) Fluorescent Fibers :- Only single colour fibers are present & are imitated.

(iii) Fluorescent Tint Band:- Present

(iv) Security Thread :- The thread is not glowing.

The text is over printed with invisible fluorescent links.

(v) Numbering Present.

7. See though registration :- Correct

9/15

8. Printing quality of straight Good lines arranged in Different angles on front side of

watermark window :-

9. Latent image of Imitated without intaglio denomination :- printing.

10. Intagilo Printed micro Un sharp without intagilo lettering :- printing

11. Printing Inks :- Not matching with the genuine notes

12. Optically variable ink :- Imitated without distinct color shift effect.

13. Printing Process used :- Offset

14. Presence of Intaglio Not present Printing:-

15. Numbering

(i) Color Shade :- Slightly varies.

(ii) Size of Numerals & Not as per genuine note. alphabets :-

16. "M" Feature Not present.

17. Whether the FICN(s) is/ Yes. are of High Quality or not:

The opinion expressed conclusively read thus:

"All the referred suspected notes of Rs.500/- & Rs.1000/- deno are HIGH QUALITY COUNTERFEIT NOTES as it is imitation of security features as specified in the third schedule of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Amendment Act 2012 (3 of 2013)."

8. On the basis of the opinion received from the Currency Press Note, Nashik Road, Nashik, it is apposite to note that the notes which were referred to as suspected notes are classified

10/15

as High Quality Counterfeit Notes and perusal of the report would reveal that there was no means by which a young girl like the Petitioner could have distinguished the said notes as being counterfeit. It was only on careful scrutiny of the expert like General Manager of the Currency Press Note, the alleged notes are concluded to be high quality counterfeit notes. Apart from this material, the charge-sheet do not in any manner discloses that the Petitioner had any knowledge about the notes seized from her to be counterfeit. This submission of the learned Counsel for the Petitioner is not disputed by the learned APP Mrs. Pai.

9. In such circumstances, we will have to examine whether on the basis of the material collected by the investigating agency and on the basis of which charge-sheet has been filed, whether invocation and application of Section 489(B) of IPC against the Petitioner is justified. Section 489(B) reads thus:

"489B. Using as genuine, forged or counterfeit currency-notes or bank-notes.—Whoever sells to, or buys or receives from, any other person, or otherwise traffics in or uses as genuine, any forged or counterfeit currency-note or bank-note, knowing or having reason to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit, shall be punished with 2[imprisonment for life], or with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine."

11/15

10. Perusal of the said Section would reveal that mens rea is an essential ingredient of the said Section and use of the term

"knowing or having reason to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit" is the sine qua non for inviting penalty under the said provision. When mens rea is conspicuously absent, mere use of any forged or counterfeit currency notes or bank notes cannot attract the provisions of Section 489(B). The essential ingredient of the said offence being that the person, who receives the notes has reason to believe that the said notes are forged or counterfeit. The burden to prove beyond all reasonable doubt, that the accused had knowledge or reason to believe that the currency notes which were put to use / possessed by him were counterfeit or fake currency note is on the prosecution.

The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of M. Mammutti vs. State of Karnataka2has observed thus:

"Mr. Neitar submitted that once the appellant is found in possession of counterfeit notes, he must be presumed to know that the notes ate counterfeit. If the notes were of such a nature that mere look at them would convince anybody that it was counterfeit such a presumption could reasonable be drawn. But the difficulty is that the prosecution has not put any specific question to the appellant in order to find out whether the accused knew that the notes were of such a nature. No such

2 (1979) 4 SCC 72 3

12/15

evidence has been led by the prosecution to prove the nature of the notes also, In these circumstances, it is impossible for us to sustain the conviction of the appellant. For these reasons, therefore, the appeal is allowed, conviction and sentences passed on the appellant are set aside, and the appellant is acquitted of the charges framed against him."

The Hob'ble Apex Court in case of Umashankar vs. State of Chattisgrah (supra) has observed thus:

"7. Sections 489-A to 489-E deal with various economic offences in respect of forged or counterfeit currency-note or bank-notes. The object of Legislature in enacting these provisions is not only to protect the economy of the country but also to provide adequate protection to currency-notes and bank-notes. The currency-notes are, inspite of growing accustomedness to the credit cards system, still the backbone of the commercial transactions by multitudes in our country. But these provisions are not meant to punish unwary possessors or users.

8. A perusal of the provisions, extracted above, shows that mens rea of offences under Sections 489B and 489C is, "knowing or having reason to believe the currency-notes or bank-notes are forged or counterfeit". Without the afore-mentioned mens rea selling, buying or receiving from another person or otherwise trafficking in or using as genuine forged or counterfeit currency-notes or bank-notes, is not enough to constitute offence under Section 489B of I.P.C. So also possessing or even intending to use any forged or counterfeit currency-notes or bank- notes is not sufficient to make out a case under Section 489C in the absence of the mens rea, noted above. No material is brought on record by the prosecution to show that the appellant had the requisite mens rea. The High Court, however, completely missed this aspect The learned trial judge on the basis of the evidence of P.W. 2, P.W. 4 and P.W. 7 that they were able to make out that currency note alleged to have been given to P.W. 4,

13/15

was fake "presumed" such a mens rea. On the date of the incident the appellant was said to be 18 years old student. On the facts of this case the presumption drawn by the trial court is not warranted under Section 4 of the Evidence Act. Further it is also not shown that any specific question with regard to the currency-noted being fake on counterfeit was put to the appellant in his examination under Section 313 of Criminal Procedure Code. On these facts we have no option but to hold that the charges framed under Sections 489B and 489C are not proved. We, therefore, set aside the conviction and sentence passed on the appellant under Sections 489B and 489C of I.P.C. and acquit him of the said charges [see: M. Mammutti Vs. State of Karnataka ]."

11. In light of aforesaid authoritative pronouncements wherein has been categorically held that mere possession of the counterfeit notes is not punishable under law and it must be established by prosecution that possession was with a knowledge that the said currency notes are fake or counterfeit. In such circumstances, in absence of any evidence brought on record by the prosecution as a part of charge-sheet to demonstrate that possession of the Petitioner of the alleged currency notes which were deposited by her in the bank on 19th December, 2016 was with a knowledge that the same were counterfeit, Petitioner cannot tried for an offence under Section 489(B) in absence of any material to attribute such a knowledge on her part.

14/15

Continuation of the proceedings against the Petitioner would be nothing but would amount to abuse of process of law and in such circumstances we are of the opinion that this is a fit case where we should exercise our inherent jurisdiction under Section 482 of Code of Criminal Procedure and in any contingency even on culmination of a trial, the charge leveled against the Petitioner cannot be proved and would result into an acquittal. In such circumstances, we are inclined to invoke our inherent power and we allow the Writ Petition and quash and set aside the Sessions Case No.699 of 2017, pending before the Additional Sessions Judge, Greater Bombay, Mumbai, arising out of CR No.22 of 2017 registered with Parksite Police Station, Vikhroli, Mumbai, for the offence punishable under Section 489(B) of IPC.

12. Rule made absolute in terms of prayer clause (a). No costs.

[SMT. BHARATI H. DANGRE, J.] [RANJIT MORE, J.]

The judgment is corrected pursuant to speaking to the minutes order dated 8th October, 2018.

15/15