- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Debabrata Tiwari v. State Of West Bengal And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion arises from an appeal before the High Court at Calcutta involving Sri Debabrata Tiwari and the State of West Bengal along with others, including Burdwan Municipality. The appellant's counsel referred to certain notifications issued by the Labour Department, Government of West Bengal, which allegedly provide for a compassionate appointment scheme. The appellant contends that these notifications have been the basis for compassionate appointments granted by Burdwan Municipality in other cases. The municipality, however, denies the existence of any such scheme in force. The court is engaged in determining the factual matrix regarding the existence and application of a compassionate appointment scheme by Burdwan Municipality.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the notifications issued by the Labour Department, Government of West Bengal, dated 21st August 2002, and bearing Nos. 302-EMP/1M-10/2000 and 303-EMP/1M-10/2000, constitute a scheme for compassionate appointment applicable to Burdwan Municipality.
- Whether Burdwan Municipality has granted compassionate appointments under the died-in-harness category based on these notifications despite the absence of a formal scheme.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellant's counsel highlighted a notification dated 21st August 2002 issued by the Labour Department, which, under the authority of sub-section (a) of section 3 of the West Bengal Regulation of Recruitment Act, 1999, allows formulation of schemes by municipalities for compassionate appointments.
- He also referred to two other notifications issued on the same date, asserting that these collectively form the basis for compassionate appointments granted by Burdwan Municipality in other cases.
Respondent's Arguments
- The advocate for Burdwan Municipality stated that no scheme for compassionate appointment is currently in force for the municipality.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the notifications referred to by the appellant and noted that they were issued under the powers conferred by sub-section (a) of section 3 of the West Bengal Regulation of Recruitment in State Government Establishments and related bodies Act, 1999. The court observed that, upon perusal, these notifications do not explicitly reveal the existence of any compassionate appointment scheme enforced by Burdwan Municipality. Given the conflicting positions of the parties, the court directed Burdwan Municipality to file an affidavit clarifying whether compassionate appointments under the died-in-harness category have been granted based on these notifications in the absence of a formal scheme. This procedural step aims to ascertain the factual basis before further adjudication.
Holding and Implications
The court's order directs Burdwan Municipality to submit a report clarifying the application of the notifications concerning compassionate appointments.
DISPOSED OF in terms of the directions issued.
The decision primarily affects the procedural posture of the case by mandating factual clarification from the municipality. No new legal precedent or broader implication beyond the immediate parties is established by this order.
1 03.10.2018 IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA (PP) CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION APPELLATE SIDE CAN 6137 of 2018 MAT 859 of 2018 Sri Debabrata Tiwari The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Indradeep Pal, Mr. M. F. Rahaman, Mrs. S Pal (Das) for the applicant/appellant.
Mr. Subhasis Bandopadhyay .for Burdwan Municipality.
Let the affidavit of service filed in Court today be taken on record.
At the time of hearing of the instant appeal, the learned advocate for the appellant invites our attention to a notification dated 21st August, 2002, issued by the Labour Department, Government of West Bengal. He submits that this notification, in effect, provides for a scheme to be formulated by the concerned municipality for appointment on compassionate ground.
Perusing the said notification, it appears that the same has been issued by the Labour Department, Government of West Bengal, in exercise of the powers conferred under sub-section (a) of section 3 of the West Bengal Regulation of Recruitment in State Government Establishments and Establishments of Public Undertakings, Statutory 2Bodies, Government Companies and Local Authorities Act, 1999 (West Bengal Act XIV of 1999), for the purpose of declaring that certain categories of persons come within the purview of exempted categories.
He has also referred to two other notifications, both issued on the same date, bearing No.302-EMP/1M-10/2000 and No.303-EMP/1M- 10/2000, by the Labour Department, Government of West Bengal.
A bare perusal of the three notifications, however, do not reveal the existence of any scheme for compassionate appointment brought into force by the concerned municipality.
Learned advocate appearing on behalf of the concerned municipality submits that there is no scheme for compassionate appointment in force so far as Burdwan Municipality is concerned.
At this stage, the learned advocate representing the appellant submits that the notifications he has referred to and relied upon were, in fact, the very basis on which compassionate appointment has been granted by the same municipality in the case of others.
We, therefore, direct the concerned municipality, namely, Burdwan Municipality, to file a report in the form of an affidavit on or before the next date stating therein specifically as to whether it has granted compassionate appointment under the died-in-harness category to others on the basis of the notifications referred to and also relied upon by the learned advocate for the appellant and in the absence of a scheme.
3List this matter one week after the long vacation under the same heading.
(Biswanath Somadder, J.) (Arindam Mukherjee, J.)
Alert