Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Abicor And Binzel Technoweld Pvt. Ltd. Petitioner v. The Union Of India And Anr. S

Bombay High Court
Feb 6, 2018
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is a company engaged in manufacturing robotic and automation equipment. Respondent No.1 is the Union of India acting through the Commissioner of Central Goods and Services Tax, Pune, and Respondent No.2 is the State of Maharashtra through the Commissioner of State Goods and Services Tax.

The petitioner was granted provisional registration under the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 and the Maharashtra Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 but was unable to access its online profile on the Goods and Services Tax Network (GSTN). The petitioner alleged that lack of online access prevented generation of E-way bills (the Electronic Way Bills Rules had not yet come into force), filing of returns (specifically GSTR-3B), payment of tax, other statutory compliances, obtaining final registration, and claiming input tax credit. The petitioner filed the writ petition; notice was issued. Initially only the learned AGP (for the State GST Commissioner) appeared. Mr. Mishra later appeared for Respondent No.1.

After filing, on 25 January 2018 the petitioner was given access to its online profile and final registration number, but access was incomplete: the petitioner still could not file GSTR-3B and could not make tax payment without filing that return; the return was being rejected unless late fees for the period from October 2017 were paid. The petitioner filed further affidavit describing additional difficulties.

The Court questioned the respondent's representative (Mr. Mishra) about remedial measures. Mr. Mishra sought two weeks to obtain instructions and file an affidavit. The Court observed that it is for the implementing authorities to set up operational mechanisms and a grievance redressal system and expressed dissatisfaction with the inability of the respondents to provide a concrete remedy. The Court noted a similar order of the Allahabad High Court in Writ (Tax) No. 67 of 2018 dated 24 January 2018 which directed reopening of the portal or manual processing after verification of claimed credits. The matter was posted to 16 February 2018 with direction that Respondent No.1 file an affidavit in reply by that date and serve an advance copy to the petitioner's advocate.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether and how a taxpayer who has been granted provisional (and subsequently final) GST registration but lacks functional access to the GSTN portal can be afforded relief to file returns, make payments, generate E-way bills and claim input tax credit.
  2. Whether the Court should require administrative authorities to make the GST portal operational for affected taxpayers or to provide alternate/manual mechanisms or a grievance redressal procedure to address access and compliance failures.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner (a manufacturer of robotic and automation equipment) was granted provisional registration but could not access its online GST profile on the GSTN, through no fault of its own.
  • Because Electronic Way Bills Rules were not yet in force and the petitioner lacked portal access, it could not generate E-way bills, thus obstructing movement of goods and paralysing business operations.
  • Inability to access the portal prevented filing returns (notably GSTR-3B), payment of tax, obtaining final registration, and claiming input tax credit; the petitioner faced exposure to interest liability and potential penal consequences.
  • After filing the petition, limited access was granted (final registration and an operational profile) but the petitioner still could not file GSTR-3B; the return was not being accepted without payment of late fees dating from October 2017.
  • The petitioner filed a further affidavit alleging numerous other operational difficulties with the online system.

Respondents' Position and Submissions

  • At hearing, the State's counsel (AGP) appeared earlier; Mr. Mishra subsequently appeared for Respondent No.1 (Central GST). Mr. Mishra indicated he required two weeks to obtain instructions and file an affidavit in reply.
  • Mr. Mishra could not provide a definite assurance as to when issues would be taken up before the GST Council or whether the petitioner's grievance would be projected there.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Allahabad High Court in Writ (Tax) No. 67 of 2018 (order of the Division Bench dated 24th January, 2018) The Division Bench directed the respondents before it to reopen the portal and, if not done, to entertain the petitioner's application manually and pass orders after due verification of claimed credits. The Court referenced this order as a precedent and recorded that it would be constrained to pass a similar direction (reopening portal / manual processing) not limited to the petitioner before it if respondents did not provide an adequate remedy.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the petitioner's factual materials: provisional registration, inability to access the GSTN portal, practical consequences including inability to generate E-way bills, file GSTR-3B, pay tax, obtain final registration, and claim input tax credit. The Court noted that after the petition was filed limited access had been granted but the petitioner still could not file its returns because the portal required late fee payment for earlier periods.

The Court questioned the respondent's representative on remedial measures and governance of the portal. It observed that while the judiciary cannot itself provide the operational access sought by the petitioner, the implementing authorities are duty-bound to set up a functioning mechanism and a grievance redressal system so that taxpayers can perform statutorily mandated compliance. The Court rejected the notion that deferring the problem to the GST Council's next meeting is an adequate response in the absence of any timeline or assurance, finding that reliance on future Council meetings without concrete steps is unsatisfactory.

The Court relied on the existence of a recent direction by the Allahabad High Court (Writ (Tax) No. 67 of 2018) requiring reopening of portals or manual processing as a relevant administrative remedy and signalled that similar directions might be made if the respondents do not act. The Court thus balanced the institutional limitation (it cannot itself create the technical system) against the responsibility of the administration to ensure a functioning compliance mechanism and protect taxpayers from practical prejudice.

Holding and Implications

The Court directed that the matter be posted to 16th February, 2018 and ordered Respondent No.1 to file an affidavit in reply on or before that date, with an advance copy to the advocate for the petitioner.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: Respondent No.1 must file an affidavit in reply by 16 February 2018 and provide an advance copy to the petitioner, thereby requiring the respondents to state what remedial steps (if any) they will take.
  • The Court warned that if respondents fail to act or the portal is not properly reopened/operationalised, the Court may be constrained to pass orders similar to those of the Allahabad High Court (including directions to reopen the portal and/or entertain applications manually after verification of claimed credits). Thus the order preserves the Court's willingness to compel administrative action if required.
  • No new legal precedent was authoritatively established by this short order beyond reliance on the Allahabad High Court decision; the order primarily directs procedural compliance by the respondents and reserves further directions pending the affidavit.
Show all summary ...

[Order]. - P.C. : The petitioner has brought before this Court his grievance and it is little peculiar.

2. The petitioner says that it is a company engaged in manufacturing of robotic and automation equipment. The 1st respondent is the Union of India through the Commissioner of Central Goods and Services Tax, Pune and the 2nd respondent is the State of Maharashtra through the Commissioner of State Goods and Services Tax.

3. The purpose of filing this petition is because the petitioner having been granted a provisional registration number under the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 and the Maharashtra Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, is not able to access its online profile on the Goods and Service Tax Network. There is no fault or negligence on the part of the petitioner. The petitioner says that it is the respondents who have decided to put in place an automated and electronic system of accepting tax returns based on self-assessment.

4. The petitioner says that the Electronic Way Bills Rules have yet to come into force. Therefore, without access to the online profile, the petitioner cannot generate E-way bills. Without such E-way bills, the petitioner will not be allowed to move the goods anywhere and that will paralyse its business. Lack of access would mean that the petitioner is unable to file return or pay tax or undertake any other compliances required by the statute. Such lack of access to the online profile also inhibits the petitioner from securing the final registration number. In the absence thereof, the petitioner is exposed to interest liability and may have to face even penal consequences. Importantly, the petitioner as well as its customers are unable to avail input tax credit mechanism.

5. The writ petition was filed in this Court and after its filing, notice was issued. On the earlier occasion, only the learned AGP representing the State Goods and Services Tax Commissioner appeared before us. After notice, Mr. Mishra is instructed to appear for Respondent No. 1.

6. The petitioner says that after filing of this petition, on 25th January, 2018, it has been allowed access to the online profile. However, even this access is not complete. The petitioner was granted the final registration number and the profile was made operational, but the petitioner could not file the necessary return, and particularly the Return GSTR-3B, and the payment of tax is not possible without this return. This return is not being accepted without payment of late fee for the period from October, 2017 onwards.

7. The petitioner also faces innumerable other difficulties as highlighted in the further affidavit filed by the petitioner before us.

8. On all these materials, we inquired from Mr. Mishra in the pre-recess and post-recess sessions as to how this Court could redress the grievance of the parties like the petitioner and make the system operational and functional for them. It is not the business of this Court to grant such access as is claimed by the petitioner. It is for the authorities to work out the necessary mechanism and set that in place. It must also set up and establish a grievance redressal mechanism. It is no answer that such issues, as are projected in the petition, would be taken up before the Goods and Services Tax Council at its next meeting.

9. When we inquired from Mr. Mishra as to when is the next meeting of this Council, he has no instructions. Whether the grievance of the petitioner would be projected and raised before the Council or not, Mr. Mishra could not give us a definite answer. All that Mr. Mishra says is that he may be granted two weeks’ time to take instructions and file affidavit.

10. We do not think that these are satisfactory state of affairs. A tax like Goods and Services Tax was highly publicised and termed as popular. We had yet not seen a celebration of New Tax regime, but that has followed with great hue and cry. These celebrations mean nothing. The special sessions of Parliament or special or extraordinary meetings of Council would mean nothing to the assessees unless they obtain easy access to the website and portals. The regime is not tax friendly. We hope and trust that those in charge of implementation and administration of this law will at least now wake up and put in place the requisite mechanism. This is necessary to preserve the image, prestige and reputation of this country, particularly when we are inviting and welcoming foreign investment in the State and the country. We hope and trust that such petitions are rarity and the Court will not be called upon to administer the implementation of the law, leave alone monitoring and supervising the working of the individual officials, howsoever high ranking he may be.

11. We would record that similar grievances have been raised before the Allahabad High Court in Writ (Tax) No. 67 of 2018 and the order of the Division Bench of that Court dated 24th January, 2018 directs the respondents before it to reopen the portal and in the event it is not done, there is further direction to entertain the application of the petitioner before the Allahabad High Court manually and pass orders on it after due verification of the credits as claimed by the petitioner before the Allahabad High Court. We would also be constrained to pass such order and that would not be restricted to the petitioner before us alone.

12. We post this matter, at the request of Mr. Mishra, on 16th February, 2018, with a direction that on or before 16th February, 2018 an affidavit in reply shall be filed in this Court by Respondent No. 1 with advance copy to the advocate for the petitioner.