- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Raipur Bright Steel & Wire Weld Industries Ltd. v. Union of India
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, a manufacturer of steel products, was inspected on 3-10-1990 by Excise Authorities who found that certain manufactured goods had been removed without payment of excise duty. A show cause notice was issued and replied to. On 12-12-1991 the Collector, Central Excise passed an order confirming duty demands (including confirmed duty of Rs. 43,909/- on 69.695 MT of CTD Bars removed under certain gate passes and additional confirmed demands of Rs. 1,37,846.62 and Rs. 6,80,207.47 on other quantities) and also ordered confiscation and imposed penalty.
The petitioner appealed to the Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi (Appeal No. E/1730 of 1992). The Tribunal disposed of the appeal by order dated 22-5-1998, reducing the total duty to Rs. 43,909/-. Subsequently, respondents issued a demand notice dated 22-12-2003 (Annexure P-12) requiring the petitioner to pay Rs. 1,69,768/- towards interest for delayed payment of duty under Section 11AA of the Central Excise Act, 1944. The petitioner challenged the validity and correctness of that notice by filing the present petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, for the purpose of liability to pay interest under Section 11AA of the Central Excise Act, 1944, the date of "determination" is the date of the Collector's order (12-12-1991) or the date on which the Tribunal finally determined/reduced the duty (22-5-1998) in view of Explanation 1 to Section 11AA.
- Whether Explanation 2 to Section 11AA is applicable for calculating interest in this case.
- If the Tribunal date governs, what period of delayed payment attracts interest under the proviso to sub-section (1) of Section 11AA?
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The obligation to pay interest under Section 11AA arose only after that provision was inserted w.e.f. 26-5-1995 (by Section 73 of the Finance Act, 1995).
- Explanation 1 to Section 11AA provides that where duty determined to be payable is reduced by an appellate authority (including the Tribunal), the date of such determination shall be the date on which an amount of duty is first determined to be payable; since the Tribunal reduced duty on 22-5-1998, that date is the relevant date of determination.
- Accordingly, liability to pay interest could only arise from 22-5-1998 and, under the three-month period in the proviso, interest could be recovered only from 22-8-1998 onward, not earlier.
Respondent's Arguments (Revenue)
- Determination of duty had already taken place when the Collector passed the order on 12-12-1991; therefore interest liability should be calculated from that earlier date.
- The petitioner had paid only Rs. 5,50,000/- on 28-6-1993 out of total Rs. 8,18,054.09 and paid the balance Rs. 2,68,054.09 only on 24-10-1998, implying a delay of more than five years for which interest should be charged.
- Explanation 1 does not assist the petitioner because duties were demanded and confirmed under different heads and some demands were confirmed by the Tribunal; thus the Explanation should not alter the date for interest calculation.
- Explanation 2 should govern the calculation by treating the date of first determination as relevant in calculating interest.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Central India Spinning and Weaving and Manufacturing Company Limited, the Empress Mills, Nagpur v. Municipal Committee, Wardha - AIR 1958 SC 341 | Where there is ambiguity in statutory interpretation, an interpretation favourable to the assessee should be adopted. | The Court invoked this principle to reject the Revenue's restrictive reading of Explanation 1 and to construe Section 11AA (and its Explanation 1) in a manner favourable to the petitioner, applying the Explanation where an appellate reduction of duty occurred. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined Section 11AA (inserted by the 1995 Amendment Act effective 26-5-1995), its proviso and the two Explanations. The key textual elements considered were:
- The first part of sub-section (1) imposes interest where duty determined under sub-section (2) of Section 11A is not paid within three months from the date of such determination.
- The proviso deals with persons chargeable with duty determined before the Finance Bill, 1995 received Presidential assent, fixing the three-month period from that date.
- Explanation 1: where the duty determined to be payable is reduced by an appellate authority (Commissioner (Appeals), Appellate Tribunal, National Tax Tribunal or the Court), "the date of such determination shall be the date on which an amount of duty is first determined to be payable."
- Explanation 2 deals with increases in duty and is therefore not applicable where the appellate outcome is a reduction.
Applying these provisions to the facts, the Court found:
- Although the Collector's 12-12-1991 order initially confirmed duties, that order was challenged on appeal and ultimately the Tribunal, on 22-5-1998, reduced the duty such that the final determined payable amount was the lesser amount fixed by the Tribunal.
- Explanation 1 therefore applies because the duty determined to be payable was reduced on appeal; under Explanation 1, the relevant "date of such determination" is the date on which an amount of duty is first determined to be payable (interpreted in this case as the Tribunal's order date).
- The Court rejected the Revenue's argument that Explanation 1 did not apply because duties had been determined under different heads; the statute contains no such distinction and accepting the Revenue's reasoning would amount to rewriting the provision.
- Where ambiguity exists, the Court followed the rule favouring the assessee (citing the Empress Mills case) to construe Explanation 1 in favour of the petitioner.
- Explanation 2 was held inapplicable because it is directed at cases of increase or further increases of duty, which is not the situation here.
- Consequently, the date for reckoning the petitioner's liability for interest is 22-5-1998 (the Tribunal order date). Under the proviso to sub-section (1) the petitioner had three months from that date (i.e., until 22-8-1998) to pay the reduced duty without incurring interest; because the petitioner paid the remaining balance only on 24-10-1998, interest is payable only for the period from 22-8-1998 to 24-10-1998 (a little less than two months).
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court allowed the petition and made these specific determinations:
- The impugned demand notice dated 22-12-2003 (Annexure P-12) is held illegal and set aside.
- The petitioner is liable to make payment of interest on delayed payment of duty only for the period from 22-8-1998 (three months after the Tribunal's determination on 22-5-1998) until the actual date of payment of the balance duty (24-10-1998).
- The petition is accordingly allowed. No order as to costs.
Implications: The direct effect is that the Revenue's demand for interest beyond the period from 22-8-1998 to 24-10-1998 was quashed; the petitioner remains liable only for interest for the limited period identified by the Court. The opinion does not purport to announce a broader precedent beyond its statutory interpretation applied to these facts.
[Order (Oral)]. - By this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the petitioner has assailed correctness and validity of notice dated 18-12-2003, by which, the petitioner has been required to pay Rs. 1,69,768/- towards interest of delayed payment of duty under Section 11AA of the Central Excise Act, 1944.
2. The petitioner is the manufacturer of steel products. When the premises of the petitioner was inspected on 3-10-1990, the Excise Authorities found that the petitioner had removed certain manufactured goods without payment of excise duty as required under the law. This led to issuance of show cause notice to the petitioner which was replied. Thereafter, the Collector, Central Excise passed an order on 12-12-1991 confirming duty payment of Rs. 43,909/- on 69.695 MT of CTD Bars removed under Gate Passes No. 511 to 517 of dated 1-10-1991 as also confirming a duty demand of Rs. 1,37,846.62 and Rs. 6,80,207.47 on 218.720 MT of CTD bars/channels/flats and angles and 1504.765 MT of CTD bars/rounds/angles and 96.240 MT of M.S. Flats, said to be cleared by the petitioner without issue of gate pass without payment of duty. In addition, confiscation also took place and penalty was also imposed.
3. Aggrieved by the order, the petitioner preferred an appeal before the Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi, registered as Appeal No. E/1730 of 1992. The appeal of the petitioner was finally decided vide order dated 22-5-1998 (Annexure P-1) [ (Tri.-Del.)]. By this order, the total duty payment was reduced to Rs. 43,909/- as indicated in Para 4 of the appellate order. Thereafter, the respondents initiated proceedings for recovery of interest on delayed payment and demand notice was issued to the petitioner vide Annexure P-12. Aggrieved by this demand notice, the petitioner has approached this Court.
4. Submission of learned counsel for the petitioner is that the liability to make payment of interest on delayed payment of duty was imposed under Section 11AA of the Act which was inserted vide Section 73 of the Finance Act of 1995 (22 of 1995) w.e.f. 26-5-1995. Under this provision, the petitioner, in whose case, determination had already taken place, was required to pay the duty within a period of three months from the date, on which, Finance Bill, 1995 receives the assent of the President. However, by virtue of Explanation-1 appended to Section 11AA of the Act, in the present case, as duty was reduced by the Tribunal, the date of such determination shall be treated as date on which amount of duty is first determined to be payable. Therefore, the liability for payment of interest on delayed payment of duty under Section 11AA of the Act arose only on 22-5-1998 and not before that. Therefore, the respondents had authority to recover interest on delayed payment, only for the period from 22-8-1998 and not earlier.
5. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent No. 1 submitted that determination had already taken place by the Collector when he passed the order on 12-12-1991. Out of total amount of Rs. 8,18,054.09, the petitioner had paid only Rs. 5,50,000/- on 28-6-1993 and the balance amount of Rs. 2,68,054.09 was paid as late as on 24-10-1998. Therefore, the delay occurred in paying the balance amount for a period of more than five years. He further submits that the petitioner is not entitled to benefit of Explanation-1 because as far as duty demand of Rs. 1,37,846.62 and Rs. 6,80,207.47 is concerned, that was confirmed by the Tribunal. In respect of another demand of Rs. 43,909/-, relief was granted to the petitioner. Therefore, the said explanation would not come to the aid of the petitioner. Second submission of learned counsel for respondent No. 1 is that in view of Explanation-2, for the purpose of calculating interest, the date of first determination would be relevant.
6. Provision requiring payment of interest on delayed payment of duty was inserted as Section 11AA in the Act of 1944 by way of Section 73 of the Amendment Act of 1995 with effect from 26-5-1995. The relevant provision reads as under :-
11AA. Interest on delayed payment of duty. - (1) [Subject to the provisions contained in Section 11AB, where a person, chargeable with duty determined under sub-section (2) of Section 11A, fails to pay such duty within three months from the date of such determination, he shall pay, in addition to the duty, interest at such rate not below ten per cent. and not exceeding thirty-six per cent. per annum, as is for the time being fixed by the Central Government, by notification in the Official Gazette, on such duty from the date immediately after the expiry of the said period of three months till the date of payment of such duty :
Provided that where a person chargeable with duty determined under sub-section (2) of Section 11A before the date on which the Finance Bill, 1995 receives the assent of the President, fails to pay such duty within three months from such date, then, such person shall be liable to pay interest under this section from the date immediately after three months from such date, till the date of payment of such duty.
Explanation 1. - Where the duty determined to be payable is reduced by the Commissioner (Appeals), Appellate Tribunal, National Tax Tribunal or, as the case may be, the court, the date of such determination shall be the date on which an amount of duty is first determined to be payable.
Explanation 2. - Where the duty determined to be payable is increased or further increased by the Commissioner (Appeals), Appellate Tribunal, National Tax Tribunal or, as the case may be, the court, the date of such determination shall be,-
(a) for the amount of duty first determined to be payable, the date on which the duty is so determined;
(b) for the amount of increased duty, the date of order by which the increased amount of duty is first determined to be payable;
(c) for the amount of further increase of duty, the date of order on which the duty is so further increased.
(2) The provisions of sub-section (1) shall not apply to cases where the duty becomes payable on and after the date on which the Finance Bill, 2001 receives the assent of the President.
7. A close reading of the aforesaid provision shows that in first part, liability for payment of interest on delayed payment of duty has been imposed where a person chargeable with duty determined under sub-section (2) of Section 11A, fails to pay such duty within three months from the date of such determination. The proviso, however, makes such provision in case of those, who are chargeable with duty determined under sub-section (2) of Section 11A before the date on which Finance Bill, 1995, receives the assent of the President, failed to pay such duty within three months from such date. The Explanation 1, however, stipulates that where the duty determined to be payable is reduced by the Commissioner (Appeals), Appellate Tribunal, National Tax Tribunal or, as the case may be, the court, the date of such determination shall be the date on which an amount of duty is first determined to be payable.
Applying the aforesaid provision in the manner as indicated above, this Court finds that though at the first instance, the Collector passed order on 12-12-1991, confirming the duty, the order was assailed in appeal. Finally, the Tribunal vide its order dated 22-5-1998 allowed the appeal partly, by which the duty was reduced by an amount of Rs. 43,909/- as indicated in Para 4 of the appellate order. Therefore, in the present case, provisions contained in Explanation 1 would be attracted, according to which, the date of such determination shall be the date on which amount of duty is first determined to be payable. The legislative intention is clear that in cases, where payment of duty is subjected to challenge before appellate authorities or the Court, resulting in reduction of duty by taking recourse to the remedy of appeal before the appellate authorities or the Tribunal or the Court as the case may be, as a result of which, duty is reduced, the date of such final determination shall have to be reckoned for the purposes of imposing interest.
Though learned counsel for the respondents/Revenue strenuously urged that the provision in Explanation 1 will not apply because duty was demanded and confirmed under different heads, the contention is liable to be rejected, because liability to pay duty arose on the basis of order dated 12-12-1991 passed by the Collector. Merely because, the duty was determined under different heads, the sweep of provision contained in Explanation 1 cannot be excluded from its operation. The provision does not make any such distinction. If the contention of learned counsel for the respondents/Revenue were to be accepted, this would amount to re-writing the provision. In case of any ambiguity, an interpretation which favours the assessee has to be adopted. Please see Central India Spinning and Weaving and Manufacturing Company Limited, the Empress Mills, Nagpur v. Municipal Committee, Wardha-AIR 1958 SC 341.
8. Explanation 2 will have no application at all. That provision will apply in a case, where the appellate authority or the Tribunal or the Court passes an order resulting in increase or further increase in the duty.
9. In view of above analysis, the date with reference to which petitioner’s liability for payment of interest on delayed payment of duty has to be reckoned would be the date on which the appellate Tribunal passed the order reducing the duty i.e. on 22-5-1998 and not the 12-12-1991.
10. If that be so, proviso to sub-section (1) of Section 11AA of the Act of 1944 on its application shows that the petitioner failed to pay duty within three months from the date of determination by the Tribunal. The order of the Tribunal passed on 22-5-1998. The petitioner was, therefore, under an obligation to pay the amount of duty within a period of three months thereof. However, the petitioner admittedly paid the remaining amount of duty only on 24-10-1998 whereas period of three months expired on 22-8-1998. Thus, there was a delay in payment of duty by a period of a little less than two months. For this period i.e. from 22-8-1998 to 24-10-1998, the petitioner is liable to make payment of interest on delayed payment of duty as required under Section 11AA of the Act of 1944.
11. In the result, the impugned demand notice dated 22-12-2003 (Annexure P-12) is held illegal and set aside. The petitioner shall, however, be liable to make payment of interest only for the period with effect from 22-8-1998 till the actual date of payment of balance amount of duty. The petition is accordingly allowed. No order as to costs.
Alert