Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Commissioner of Service Tax v. Manan Motors Pvt. Ltd.

Gujarat High Court
Sep 3, 2012
Smart Summary (Beta)

Legal Opinion Summary (Judgment per: V.M. Sahai, J. (Oral))

Factual and Procedural Background

The assessee is M/s. Manan Motors Private Limited, Ahmedabad, an authorized service station providing services categorized as "service of motor vehicles" and "business auxiliary service." The assessee permitted financial institutions (specifically ICICI and HDFC) to maintain counters/desks at its premises and, in return, received amounts described as commission/incentive/remuneration from those institutions. The assessee treated that commission as liable to service tax under "business auxiliary service."

For the period 1-7-2003 to 31-12-2005 the assessee paid service tax and interest at various dates (payments and dates are recorded in the opinion). Thereafter, on 22-10-2008 the Joint Commissioner, Service Tax, Ahmedabad issued a show cause notice proposing recovery of service tax of Rs. 7,68,602 on a value of Rs. 86,19,305 for the said period under the proviso to Section 73(1) of the Finance Act, 1994, together with interest, and indicating an intention to adjust amounts already paid by the assessee. The show cause notice also queried penalty under Sections 75A, 76, 77 and 78.

Pursuant to the show cause notice the Joint Commissioner passed an order dated 12-11-2009 confirming a demand of Rs. 7,68,602 along with interest under Section 75 and imposing penalty under Section 76 (Rs. 200 per day or 2% per month) and under Section 78 (Rs. 7,68,602) with an option to pay 25% if paid within thirty days. No penalties were imposed under Sections 75A and 77.

The assessee appealed to the Commissioner (Appeals), who by order dated 16-3-2010 rejected the appeal. The assessee then appealed to the CESTAT (Tribunal). The Tribunal, by judgment dated 22-2-2012 (Tribunal-Ahmedabad), allowed the assessee's appeal relying on Board Circular No. 137/167/2006-CX dated 3-10-2007 and held that Section 73(1A) applied because the entire service tax and interest had been paid before issuance of the show cause notice, and set aside penalties in excess of 25%.

The present opinion records that the Tax Appeal by the revenue challenged the Tribunal's reliance on Section 73(1A) and the Tribunal's decision to set aside penalty in excess of 25%. The court heard counsel for the appellant and ultimately dismissed the Tax Appeal, agreeing with the Tribunal's view.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the CESTAT was right in invoking the provisions of Section 73(1A) of the Finance Act, 1994 even though those provisions were not applicable to the facts of the case; and whether the CESTAT was right in ignoring certain conditions provided for in the provisions of Section 73(1A) of the said Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Counsel for the appellant (revenue) argued that once a show cause notice has been issued under Section 73 read with sub-section (1A), the assessee is required to make payment of penalty. The implication was that issuance of a notice triggers an obligation with respect to penalty.
  • It was further contended that even if service tax and interest were deposited before issuance of the show cause notice, the assessee would nevertheless have known the likely penalty and therefore should have deposited at least 25% of the penalty amount within thirty days.

The opinion does not set out a detailed, separately labelled statement of the Revenue's full arguments beyond the submissions summarized above.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court expressly agreed with the Tribunal's approach. The reasoning followed these explicit steps as recorded in the opinion:

  1. The court considered the Board's Circular No. 137/167/2006-CX dated 3-10-2007, and in particular paragraph 3.1 of that circular, which addresses the proviso to Section 73: where a person has paid service tax in full together with interest and penalty under sub-section (1A), proceedings in respect of such person to whom notices are served under sub-section (1) shall be deemed to be concluded.
  2. Applying that administrative instruction to the facts, the court observed that the assessee had deposited the entire service tax and interest well before the issuance of the show cause notice. The opinion records that the assessee "discharged 25% of the amount of service tax liability" at that time and that there was no contemporaneous imposition of penalty nor any fixed quantum of penalty when those payments were made.
  3. The court rejected the revenue's contention that the issuance of the show cause notice obliged the assessee to deposit penalty (or at least 25% of the penalty) because the circular and the statutory proviso, as interpreted by the Tribunal, operate to conclude proceedings where tax and interest have been paid in full before notice, such that the assessee's failure to deposit any separately-demarcated penalty amount before issuance of the notice did not amount to illegality.
  4. On that basis the court concluded that the Tribunal was correct in holding that penalties imposed in excess of 25% under Sections 76 and 78 were not sustainable.

The court's analysis is grounded on the Board circular's interpretation of the proviso to Section 73 and on the undisputed sequence of payments; the opinion does not elaborate other statutory or case-law sources beyond the circular cited.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Tax Appeal is DISMISSED.

Implications and direct effects:

  • The Tribunal's order dated 22-2-2012 setting aside penalties levied in excess of 25% under Sections 76 and 78 of the Finance Act, 1994 was affirmed by the court. In short, penalties in excess of 25% were rightly set aside.
  • The court found no illegality in the Tribunal's decision and held that the question raised did not constitute a substantial question of law.
  • The opinion does not announce any broader legal doctrine beyond affirming the Tribunal's application of the Board circular to the facts; it explicitly indicates that no substantial question of law arises, and it does not purport to lay down a new precedent.

If any specific amounts, dates of payment, or the full text of the circular are required for further analysis, those items should be consulted directly in the underlying opinion text reproduced by the court.

Show all summary ...

[Judgment per : V.M. Sahai, J. (Oral)]. - This appeal has been filed on the following proposed substantial question of law:

“Whether the CESTAT was right in invoking the provisions of Section 73(1A) of the Finance Act, 1994 even though these provisions were not applicable to the facts of the case and whether the CESTAT was right in ignoring certain conditions provided for in the provisions of Section 73(1A) of the said Act?”

2. We have heard Mr. Darshan M. Parikh, learned counsel appearing for the appellant in this Tax Appeal. The facts in brief are that M/s. Manan Motors Private Limited, Ahmedabad, (hereinafter referred to as ‘the assessee’ for short), is engaged in providing Services as Authorized Service Station, falling under the category of ‘service of motor vehicles’ and ‘business auxiliary service’. The assessee has allowed financial institutions like ICICI and HDFC to keep their counters/desks for providing the suitable environment to them to boost up their business. In response the said financial companies were giving them a substantial amount under head ‘commission/incentive/remuneration, etc. therefore, the assessee was liable to pay service tax on the commission received from the financial institutions under ‘business auxiliary service’. The assessee had paid the amount of service tax and interest within time whenever it was due for the period between 1-7-2003 and 31-12-2005. The following chart will demonstrate the details of payments made against the Service Tax and interest liability of the assessee :

S.T. + Cess Interest Date of Payment
83940 0 15-2-2006
200000 0 7-2-2006
200000 0 10-3-2006
116388 3127 28-3-2006
7332 28914 13-3-2006
11204 68120 14-3-2006
149738 16324 28-3-2006
768602 116485 28-3-2006

3. The Joint Commissioner, Service Tax, Ahmedabad, issued a show cause notice on 22-10-2008 proposing to recover service tax of Rs. 7,68,602/- on the value of Rs. 86,19,305/- during the period 1-7-2003 to 31-12-2005 under the proviso to Section 73(1) of the Finance Act, 1994 (for short ‘the Act’) along with interest, and also proposed to adjust service tax amount of Rs. 7,68,602/- and interest amount of Rs. 1,16,485/- paid by the assessee against the demand of service tax and interest. The show cause notice also mentioned that the assessee should explain as to why penalty under Sections 75A, 76, 77 and 78 of the Act be not imposed.

3. In pursuance of the show cause notice dated 22-10-2008, the Joint Commissioner, Service Tax, passed an order on 12-11-2009 wherein demand of Rs. 7,68,602/- was confirmed along with interest in terms of Section 75 of the Act and penalty of Rs. 200/- per day or at the rate of 2% of the Service Tax amount per month under Section 76 of the Act was imposed. Penalty of Rs. 7,68,602/- was imposed under Section 78 of the Act. An option was given to them to pay penalty of 25% if it is paid within thirty days. However, no penalty was imposed under Sections 75A and 77 of the Act.

4. The assessee challenged the order dated 12-11-2009 passed by Joint Commissioner, Service Tax, by way of appeal before the Commissioner (Appeals), who by his order dated 16-3-2010 rejected the appeal.

5. The assessee thereafter filed an appeal before the CESTAT. The Tribunal by its judgment dated 22-2-2012 [ (Tri.-Ahmd.)] has allowed the assessee’s appeal by placing reliance on Circular No. 137/167/2006-CX., dated 3-Oct.-2007. The Tribunal held that the provisions of Section 73(1A) of the Act, will apply in full force as the entire amount of Service Tax has been paid along with interest, before the issuance of show cause notice. Therefore, the proceedings initiated against the assessee for imposition of penalty in excess of 25% was liable to be set aside.

6. We are in agreement with the view taken by the Tribunal, though Mr. Darshan M. Parikh, learned counsel for the appellant has vehemently urged that under Section 73 read with sub-section (1A) of the Finance Act, once show cause notice has been issued then the assessee is required to make payment of penalty. He has further argued that even before the issuance of show cause notice if the Service Tax and interest has been deposited by the assessee, still he would require to deposit the penalty as he would have known as to what penalty would be levied on the assessee, therefore, atleast he should have deposited the 25% of the penalty amount within thirty days. We do not agree with the argument of learned counsel for the appellant as the Board’s Circular dated 3-10-2007 in paragraph No. 3.1 has considered the proviso to Section 73 that where a person has paid service tax in full together with interest and penalty under sub-section (1A), the proceedings in respect of such person to whom notices are served under sub-section (1) shall be deemed to be concluded. In the instant case was not contesting the Service Tax liability and had deposited the entire service tax and interest much before the issuance of show cause notice and discharged 25% of the amount of service tax liability, and at that time, neither any penalty was levied by the appellant nor any quantum of penalty was fixed. Therefore, the assessee has not committed any illegality in not depositing any penalty amount.

7. For the aforesaid reasons, the penalty levied against the assessee in excess of 25% under Sections 76 and 78 of the Finance Act, 1994, has rightly been set aside by the Tribunal. We do not find any illegality in the order of the Tribunal. The question raised by the assessee in our opinion does not raise any substantial question of law. We do not find any merit in this Tax Appeal. This Tax Appeal is accordingly dismissed.