- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Commissioner Of Central Excise, Raipur v. Anil Agrawal
[Order]. - Being aggrieved with the order of Commissioner of Central Excise, revenue has filed the present appeal.
I have heard Ms. Shweta Bector, Advocate for the Revenue and Ms. Sukriti Das, Advocate for the respondent. As per the fact on record M/s. Agrawal Structure Mills Pvt. Ltd is engaged in the manufacture of MS Ingots, Angles Channels and Joist and Sh. Anil Agrawal, Director of M/s. Agrasen Ispat Udyog is a Registered Dealer, dealing in the said goods under the Proprietorship of Sh. Anil Agrawal, Director.
2. On the basis of intelligence received by the revenue, a case was made out against M/s. Agrawal Structure Mills Pvt. Ltd., having cleared their goods without payment of duty to M/s. Agrasen Ispat Udyog, under their trading bills, who further raised the bills to their customers passing on Cenvat credit to them. The above allegation was based upon the bills raised by M/s. Agrasen Ispat Udyog and the inculpatory statement of M/s. Agrawal Structure Mills Pvt. Ltd.
3. Proceedings were initiated against all the three respondents by way of issuance of Show Cause Notice dated 27-10-2008 proposing confirmation of demand of Rs. 2,71,483/- along with interest against the manufacturing unit and imposition of penalties. On various notices the said Show Cause Notice culminated into an order passed by the original Adjudicating Authority confirming the demand against the manufacturing unit along with imposition of penalty of identical amount. Further penalty of Rs. 80,000/- each was imposed on the trading unit as also on the Director, under Rule 29 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002.
4. On appeal, Commissioner (Appeals) set aside the impugned order and allowed the appeal. Hence, the present appeal by the Revenue.
5. After hearing both the sides, I find that Commissioner (Appeals) has allowed the appeal by observing as under :-
“In this context, I find that the allegation of clandestine removal is based on photocopies of invoices of trading unit and also the copies of lorry receipt, without disclosing the source from where these documents have been recovered/sourced. Admittedly these invoices show sales of goods from the trading units and corresponding lorry receipt indicates about removal of goods from the factory premises of the Appellant. Thus, these documents create a legitimate suspicion about clandestine removal of goods by the Appellant. However, it is settled principle of law that the suspicion however, grave cannot be an evidence as held by Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of J.A. Naidu v. State of Maharashtra - 1983 (13) E.L.T. 161 (S.C.) and the same was followed by Hon’ble Tribunal in series of cases. Some of these cases are
(i) Usha Amorphous Metal Ltd. v. CCE, New Delhi - .
(ii) Lloyds Steel Ind. v. CCE - .
(iii) D.P. Industries v. CCE - .
Here I would also like to mention that photocopies are never treated by the Department as a genuine documents as is evident from the facts that even availment of credit on the strength of photocopies of bills is not admissible as in such cases there is every possibility of misuse of photocopies of bills/invoices, which may also be available in the instant case though in a vice versa manner.
It is also consistent view of Hon’ble Tribunal that clandestine removal is a positive act and burden to prove the same is on department. In the present case as stated above source of recovery of the documents i.e. invoice/Lorry receipt which are the basis for allegation of clandestine remove, is not disclosed. Therefore, unless veracity/genuineness of these documents is established, the same cannot be accepted as a piece of evidence. Having these documents in hand the investigation should have established the veracity of documents by making enquires at the end of customer and transport. Though the invoices are of the period 2003 and Show Cause Notice issued in 2008 and thus Department had sufficient time, if not 5 years, available in case of suppression of facts to probe the entire case in details and fortifying their case from each and every angle which could have been easily done by co-relating the entire links from the raw material stage till the end i.e. flowback of money by sale of alleged clandestinely removal of goods needless to say the intermediate link of transportation also. But, the Department even after availability of such a long period had never taken any step to collect clinching evidence whether corroboratory or tried to initiate any action in any manner to verify the genuineness of these documents available with them in the nature of photocopies of bills.
Hon’ble Tribunal in its decision in the case of M/s. Sqaure Chemicals v. CCE - (T) have held that demand based on recovered sale bills and recorded statement without any other evidence is not sustainable. Further in the case of Tejwal Dyestuff Industries v. CCE - (T) Hon’ble Tribunal have corroborative evidence is not sustainable. In the case under consideration the department has created liability on the documents procured from undisclosed source and the statement. However, having paid duty liability during investigation under protest, it was on the part of investigation to support allegation supported by tangible and clinching evidence which is absent. There is also nothing on record to evidence purchase of unaccounted raw material its use in production and removal of such goods in surreptitious manner. Since, the allegation of clandestine removal which is grave charge is not supported by any other independent, corroborative evidence the order passed by the Adjudicating Authority deserves to be set aside. I hold accordingly.
In view of above appeals are allowed and impugned order dated 2-3-2009 against the Appellant No. 1 & others the Appellant No. 2 & 3 is set aside.”
6. On going through the Grounds of Appeal raised by the Revenue, I find that they have placed reliance on the Supreme Court’s Judgment in the case of Commissioner of Customs, Madras v. Bhoormul - (S.C.) to support their argument that the demand should have been confirmed on the basis of such degree of possibilities. They have also referred to some other decisions of the Tribunal upholding the demand of clandestine removal.
7. I find that the charges against the Respondent are clandestine removal of their final products without payment of duty. Admittedly such charges made by the revenue are required to be proved by the way of sufficient evidences. In the present case the Revenue has solely relied upon the recovery of certain photocopies of the bills from the trading unit as also on the statement of the Director, accepting the clandestine removal. Apart from the above, there is no other evidence showing clandestine manufacture and removal of the final products.
8. The Hon’ble Delhi High Court in a latest decision in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax v. Dhingra Metal Works - 2010 (101) 603 (Del.) has held that though a confessional statement is important piece evidence but it cannot be held to be conclusive. As such the sole reliance of the revenue on the statement of Sh. Agarwal without any other evidence to reflect upon the clandestine activities of the respondent is not proper and just. Even for applying the ratio of decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of D. Bhoormull, there has to be some evidence for assessment and then the degree of evidence has to be adjudged. In the present case, I note that there is virtually no evidence on record to reflect upon the clandestine activities of manufacturer-respondent. In view of the above I find no infirmity in the views of the Commissioner (Appeals) all the three appeals filed by the revenue are rejected.
(Pronounce in the open Court)
Alert