Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Allianz Steel Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Central Excise, Indore

CESTAT
Jul 31, 2012

[Order per : Justice Ajit Bharihoke, President]. - This is an application seeking waiver of condition of pre-deposit of the duty demand, interest and penalty as a pre-condition of hearing of appeal.

2. The appellant is engaged in manufacture of excisable items. During the financial year 2008, the appellant failed to fully discharge his excise duty liability in respect of the goods cleared for the month of June 2008 and September 2008. On 11-8-2008 Jurisdictional Office wrote a letter to the appellant contending that out of the total duty payable amounting to Rs. 25,43,038/- for the month of June, 2008, the appellant had deposited an amount of Rs. 21,05,967/- through his Cenvat account and Rs. 98,141/- through PLA account and thus he had failed to discharge his duty obligation amounting to Rs. 3,38,930/-. The department noticing another default for payment of excise duty for the month of September, 2008 again intimated the appellants that if he failed to deposit the balance amount of duty for the months of June and September 2008, he would have to clear the goods by paying excise duty through PLA account in cash as per Rule 8(3)(A) of the Central Excise Rules, 2002. The appellant, however, without discharging his duty liability with interest kept on clearing the finished goods through Cenvat credit account. The department was of the view that since the appellant had failed to comply with the provisions of Rule 8(1) of the Central Excise Rules, he was supposed to clear the goods during the disputed period 5-11-2008 to 19-12-2008 on payment of excise duty in cash through PLA account. Accordingly, the appellant was served with a show cause notice raising duty demand of Rs. 30,82,595/- for the period 5-8-2008 to 20-9-2008 and further duty demand of Rs. 12,27,455/- for the clearance of goods during the period 5-11-2008 to 19-12-2008 with interest and the penalty was also proposed to be imposed for contravention of goods. The Adjudicating Authority vide impugned order confirmed the duty demand of Rs. 43,10,050/- to be paid in cash through PLA alongwith interest and also imposed penalty of equal amount under Rule 25.

3. Learned counsel for the appellant while pressing for the waiver of condition of pre-deposit of duty demand, interest and penalty has contended that in the instant case, duty demand has been confirmed against the appellant on technical ground of violation of Rule 8(3)(A) of the Central Excise Rules inasmuch as that the appellant instead of paying excise duty in cash through PLA account has paid the same through his Cenvat credit account. Thus, it is evident that the excise duty liability has been discharged, as such, there is no justification for insisting on the pre-deposit of duty demand, interest and penalty as a pre-condition to hearing of appeal.

4. Learned DR for the respondent on the contrary has referred to Rule 8(3)(A) of the Central Excise Rules and submitted as per the requirement of the aforesaid Rule, once a person has violated the terms of Rule 8(1) of the Rules, he is required to pay the excise duty for subsequent period in cash through PLA account till the amount of excise duty due for the default period is paid alongwith the interest. Learned DR submitted that in the instant case admittedly while the appellant was in default in payment of excise duty he had cleared the goods, in question, on payment of excise duty through Cenvat credit which amounts to clear violation of Rule 8(3)(A) and as such the impugned order cannot be faulted and there is no justification for dispensing with the condition of pre-deposit.

5. We have considered the rival contentions and perused the record.

6. The purpose behind the condition of pre-deposit of the duty demand, interest and penalty by the assessee as a pre-condition of hearing of his appeal is to secure the interest of the Revenue. In the instant case admittedly the excise duty liability has been discharged by the appellant through his Cenvat credit account though as per the Rules, he was required to pay the excise duty in cash but the fact remain that excise duty has been paid. Even if at this stage the appellant is directed to deposit the excise duty confirmed against him with interest in that event obviously corresponding credit entry would be made in the Cenvat credit account of the appellant, which he would be able to utilise against the payment of excise duty for future clearance. Thus, the entire exercise would be revenue neutral. Therefore, taking into account overall facts and circumstances of the case, we find it to be a fit case where the condition of pre-deposit should be waived. Accordingly, the stay application is allowed and the condition of pre-deposit of duty demand, interest and penalty is dispensed with.

7. Appeal be listed in due course.