Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Commissioner of Cus. & C. Ex., Indore v. Deepak Silicate (P) Ltd.

CESTAT
May 6, 2010

[Order (Oral)]. - Appeal No. E/957/08 is by the Department against the order of the Commissioner (Appeals) No. IND-I/31/2008 dated 13-2-2008. Appeal No. E/1542/08 is by the assessee against the very same order of the Commissioner (Appeals).

2. Heard both sides.

3. The relevant facts, in brief, are that the assessee, a manufacturer of silicate of sodium, potassium and sodium hypochlorite was found to have made short-payment of duty during May, 2006 to September 2006 and also not found to have submitted the monthly returns for the period on due dates to the jurisdictional Range Officer. The short paid amount totally amounting to Rs. 72,218/- relating to the period from May, 2006 to September, 2006 was paid on 28-10-06 along with interest of Rs. 2,272/-. Show cause notice dated 5th July, 2007 was issued holding that the duty paid by the party through cenvat credit during the period from 6-7-06 to 27-10-06 amounting to Rs. 4,01,152/- could not be treated as valid payment and accordingly, duty demand was proposed. The original authority confirmed the demand of duty amounting to Rs. 4,73,370/- and after appropriating the sum of Rs. 72,218/- already paid ordered recovery of Rs. 4,01,152/-. He also imposed a penalty of Rs. 4,73,370/- under Section 11AC of the Central Excise Act, 1944. On appeal by the party, the Commissioner (Appeals) held that only a sum of Rs. 2,66,813/- made during the period August, 2006 to October, 2006 by way of debit entry in RG-23A Part II was irregular and accordingly, he ordered recovery of the same in cash and on such payment permitted them to take an equal amount as credit in RG-23A Part II account. He set aside the penalty imposed under Section 11AC but converted the same as penalty of Rs. 40,000/- under Rule 25 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002.

4. The Department is in appeal seeking restoration of the order in original by setting aside the order of the Commissioner (Appeals). The party is in appeal seeking to set aside the demand confirmed and also to set aside the penalty sustained by the Commissioner (Appeals).

5. I have carefully considered the submissions from both sides. The show cause notice has proceeded alleging default in payment of excise duty due from the party during the period from May, 2006 to September, 2006. On careful perusal of the show cause notice, it is noticed that there was only short payment of duty of Rs. 72,218/- during those five months which stood paid by the assessee in October, 2006 along with interest. In other words, the show cause notice only alleged short-levy during these five months. Every case of short-levy cannot be treated as a case of default. The show cause notice does not reveal the circumstances under which short payment has occurred. The deemed non-duty paid clearance will arise only in cases of default of assessed duties and the consequences of treating such clearances as non-duty paid clearance such as seizure and confiscation, the prohibition regarding utilisation of cenvat credit, and the requirement of paying consignment wise will follow. In the present case, it is apparent that there is no allegation of default in payment but only short payment of duty in respect of five months. The reasons for short-payment that has occurred have not been dealt with in the show cause notice, order in original and the order in appeal. Under these circumstances, the finding of the default in payment and consequent liabilities are difficult to sustain. In other words, in the given facts and circumstances of the case, Rule 8(3A) cannot be invoked.

6. Apparently, it was a case of short-payment of Rs. 72,218/- relating to the five months and non-filing of returns by the due dates during these months. Therefore, the order of the Commissioner (Appeals) in demanding differential duty and permitting credit of equal amount in cenvat credit account is set aside. However, considering that there was short-payment of Rs. 72,218/- during five months and non-submission of the returns for 5 months, which is not disputed, some penalty is imposable but taking the entire facts and circumstances into account, the penalty under Rule 25 of the Central Excise Rules is reduced from Rs. 40,000/- to Rs. 10,000/- (rupees ten thousand only).

7. Appeal of the Department is rejected. Appeal of the party is allowed except to the extent of sustaining the penalty of Rs. 10,000/-.