Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sri Shy Am Iron Udyog Pvt. Ltd. v. C.C.E, C. & S.T, Bhubaneswar-Ii

CESTAT
Aug 26, 2009
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Appellant filed an appeal against an order of the Commissioner (Appeals), who had remanded the matter to the Adjudicating Authority for quantification of the demand related to credit entitlement for electric transmission cables. The Commissioner (Appeals) held that the cables used to transmit power from the main grid to the factory and distribute it within the factory, including to the office building, warranted credit entitlement: full credit for cables used inside the factory and deemed credit for those used outside for supplying the office building.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the electric transmission cables used to transmit power from the main grid to the factory qualify as capital goods eligible for credit.
  2. Whether credit can be allowed for cables used outside the factory premises, particularly for supplying power to the office building where no manufacturing activity occurs.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The cable is used to draw electricity from the main grid to the factory and is further used within the factory; hence, the Appellant claims entitlement to credit.
  • Relied on Tribunal decisions including CCE, Chennai v. Pepsico India Holdings Ltd., Jaypee Bela Plant v. CCE, and Indorama Cement Ltd. v. CCE, which supported credit entitlement for similar situations involving infrastructure extending outside the factory.
  • Fairly conceded that cables used solely for supplying power to office premises are not entitled to credit.

Revenue's Arguments

  • The cable falls under Heading 76.10 of the Tariff and is not a specified capital good; credit is only allowed for cables used within the factory as components of specified goods.
  • The definition of 'capital goods' includes components, spares, and accessories used within the factory for manufacture but excludes equipment used in office premises.
  • Relied on the definition of 'factory' under the Central Excise Act, emphasizing that only cables used within premises where manufacturing occurs qualify for credit.
  • Cables supplying power to office buildings and other non-production areas are not entitled to credit.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
CCE, Chennai v. Pepsico India Holdings Ltd. (Tri.-Chennai) Credit entitlement for cables used to transmit power related to factory operations. Supported the Appellant's claim for credit on cables transmitting power to the factory.
Jaypee Bela Plant v. CCE (Tri.-Del.) Credit allowed for pipeline drawing water from a reservoir located several kilometers away for use in factory manufacturing. Used as precedent to allow credit for cables transmitting power from outside the factory to the factory.
Indorama Cement Ltd. v. CCE, Mumbai-II (2007 (83) RLT 655) (CESTAT-Mum.) Credit allowed for conveyor belt installed between appellant’s factory and input supplier’s factory for transporting inputs. Supported the principle that infrastructure extending beyond factory premises may qualify for credit if integrally linked to manufacturing.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court identified the remaining issue as whether cables used to transmit power from the main grid to the factory qualify as capital goods eligible for credit. The denial of credit was based on the fact that the cables were used outside the factory premises. The court noted the Appellant’s reliance on Tribunal decisions that allowed credit for similar infrastructure extending beyond factory boundaries, such as pipelines and conveyor belts used in manufacturing processes.

Given these precedents, the court concluded that the matter requires fresh consideration by the Adjudicating Authority. The Authority must re-quantify the credit entitlement for the cables transmitting power from the main grid to the factory, after providing the Appellant an opportunity to be heard. This approach reflects the court’s intent to align the credit entitlement with established principles recognized in prior decisions.

Holding and Implications

The appeal was disposed of by modifying the impugned order to the extent that the matter is remanded to the Adjudicating Authority for fresh consideration of the credit entitlement regarding cables transmitting power from the main grid to the factory.

The direct effect is that the Adjudicating Authority must re-examine and quantify the credit after hearing the Appellant. No new precedent was established; rather, the court directed adherence to existing Tribunal decisions. The decision clarifies that cables used outside the factory may be eligible for credit if integrally connected to manufacturing operations, subject to quantification and verification.

Show all summary ...

[Order]. - Heard both sides.

2. The Appellant filed this Appeal against the impugned Order whereby the Commissioner (Appeals) remanded the matter to the Adjudicating Authority for quantification of the demand. The Commissioner (Appeals) held that the Electric Transmission Cables were used to transmit power from the main grid to the factory and then to distribute to various points within the factory, part of which was supplied to the office building. The Commissioner (Appeals) held that the Appellants are entitled for credit in respect of the cables used within the factory and for deemed credit in respect of the cables used outside the factory for supply of power for the office building.

3. Contention of the Appellant is that the cable is used to draw electricity from the main grid to the factory, which is further used within the factory. Therefore, the Appellant is entitled for the credit. The Appellant relied on the following decisions of the Tribunal :-

(i)      (Tri.-Chennai) - CCE, Chennai v. Pepsico India Holdings Ltd.;
(ii)    (Tri.-Del.) - Jaypee Bela Plant v. CCE, Bhopal;
(iii)   2007 (83) RLT 655 (CESTAT-Mum.) - Indorama Cement Ltd. v. CCE, Mumbai-II.

4. Contention of the Revenue is that the cable is classifiable under Heading 76.10 of the Tariff and is not specified goods under the definition of ‘capital goods’. Accordingly, credit is allowed only in respect of the cables used within the factory being components of the specified goods. The definition of ‘capital goods’ includes components, spares and accessories of the specified goods used in the factory for the manufacture of final products, but does not include any equipment or appliance used in the office. Contention is that the cable is used outside the factory and is also used for supply of electricity to the office premises and other areas where no production is being carried on. Revenue relied on the definition of ‘factory’ as provided under the Central Excise Act, to submit that ‘factory’ means any premises, including the precincts thereof, wherein or in any part of which excisable goods other than salt are manufactured, or wherein or in any part of which any manufacturing process connected with the production of these goods is being carried on or is ordinarily carried on. Contention is that the cables which are used for power-supply to the office building and some other areas where no production activity or any activity in relation to production of the final product is carried on, are not entitled for credit.

5. In reply, the Appellant fairly submitted that the cables which are used for supply of power for office purposes are not entitled for the credit.

6. I find in this case now that the only issue remains to be decided is whether the cable which is used to transmit power from the main grid to the factory is entitled for the credit as capital goods. The credit is being denied on the ground that the cable was used outside the factory and the matter was remanded to the Adjudicating Authority to re-quantify the amount of credit. The Appellant relied on the decisions of the Tribunal, as noted above. In the case of Jaypee Bela Plant (supra), credit was allowed in respect of the pipeline used for drawing water from reservoir situated 5-6 kms. away from factory for manufacture of finished goods within factory. In the case of Indorama Cement Ltd. (supra), credit was allowed on the ground that conveyor belt was installed between appellant’s factory and input supplier’s factory for transporting inputs.

7. In view of the above decisions, I find that the matter is to be re­considered by the Adjudicating Authority afresh, for entitlement of credit in respect of the cables, which are used from the main grid to the factory after affording an opportunity of hearing to the Appellant. The impugned Order is modified to that extent. The Appeal is disposed of, as indicated above.

(Pronounced and dictated in the open Court)