Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

South India Paper Mills Ltd. v. Commr. Of Cus. & C. Ex., Tuticorin

CESTAT
Oct 15, 2008

[Order]. - M/s. South India Paper Mills Ltd., imported seven consignment of waste paper and cleared the same on payment of duty in the year 2004-05. Later on, they noticed that vide Notification No. 21/02-Cus., dated 1-3-2002, imported waste paper was exempt from CVD when the waste paper was used in the manufacture of newsprint falling under Chapter Heading 4801 of Central Excise Tariff. They approached the Commissioner (A) who ordered that the impugned imports were eligible for the exemption claimed and that the assessee was eligible for a refund of Rs. 8,44,187/- paid towards CVD. Accordingly, they claimed refund of the erroneously paid duty. The Assistant Commissioner sanctioned the refund of Rs. 8,44,187/- and credited the same to the Consumer Welfare Fund. The impugned order was passed sustaining the above order of the original authority when the importer filed an appeal before the Commissioner (A).

2. Before the Commissioner (A), the appellants had canvassed their case that refund would not entail unjust enrichment and reiterated the claim for interest on the amount of refund from the date of refund claim in terms of Section 27A of the Customs Act (the Act). They furnished a certificate obtained from a Cost Accountant to the effect that the amount of CVD in question had not been taken into account for costing of the newsprint manufactured using the impugned waste paper. It was also certified that an amount of Rs. 11,25,043/- being erroneously paid CVD in respect of nine consignments (including Rs. 8,44,187/-involved in impugned seven consignments) had been shown under the heading ‘Loans & Advances’ as duty refund receivable from customs. The Cenvat account register was also produced to show that the credit of CVD initially availed was subsequently reversed. In the circumstances, the appellants had claimed, that there was no unjust enrichment in granting refund of the erroneously paid CVD to them. The appellants relied on various case law in support of this claim. The Commissioner (A) rejected the appeal filed on the ground that the appellants had not established that the amount claimed as refund had not been passed on to its customers. The Cost Accountant’s certificate furnished was not adequate evidence to support the claim that the duty incidence had not been passed on.

3. The ld. Counsel for the appellants reiterated the grounds taken before the lower authorities. He also submits a copy of judgment of the Apex Court dated 30-9-08 in Civil Appeal No. 959/2003 in the case of CC, New Delhi v. M/s. Organan (I) Ltd. - (S.C.). In the above judgment, in a case of similar facts where the assessee had received refund of erroneously paid customs duty and had furnished evidence for not passing on the same to its customers in the form of an auditor’s certificate, their lordships had held that the refund of the excess duty paid would not involve unjust enrichment. In that case the assessee’s invoices had shown that the sale price did not include the customs duty and the price of the assessee’s product had remained constant before and after they had cleared the imported goods on payment of duty. The Apex Court found that the majority view of the Tribunal, in the order impugned before that court, that the refund of the erroneously paid duty would not entail unjust enrichment was a finding of fact. Another decision relied upon by the appellant is a decision of the Tribunal in Kudremukh Iron & Steel Co. Ltd. v. CC, Bangalore reported in 2007 (217) E.L.T 286 (Tri.). In that case, the appellants therein had claimed refund of special additional duty erroneously paid on import of Low Ash Metallurgical (LAM) Coke. The assessee had accounted the SAD paid in a separate account called “Amounts Recoverable - Others”. The Tribunal held that in the facts of the case, the SAD claimed as refund had not been treated as revenue expenditure as part of raw material cost. Therefore, duty burden had not been passed on.

4. The ld. SDR defends the impugned order and reiterates the findings contained therein.

5. I have carefully considered the facts of the case and submissions by both sides. There is no dispute that the Cost Accountant had certified that the amount of refund claimed had been accounted as receivables from customs in the balance sheet of the appellants for the relevant financial year. In addition, the Cost Accountant also certified that the amount incurred by the appellants towards CVD had not been taken into account for costing of the final product manufactured and sold by the appellants. They had reversed the corresponding CVD credit in their cenvat account. These evidence abundantly establish that the appellants are eligible for cash refund of the erroneously paid CVD and that the vice of unjust enrichment would not be attracted in granting refund to the appellants. In the judgment of the Apex Count relied upon by the appellants, their Lordships had held that the finding of the Tribunal that grant of refund to the appellant in that case would not involve unjust enrichment was found by the Tribunal relying on a Chartered Accountant’s Certificate that the duty burden had not been passed on. The Apex Court did not interfere with the finding of the Tribunal. In the Kuremukh Iron Ore case (supra), cited by the appellants, in a case of similar facts where the importer had accounted excess duty paid as receivables from customs and had not treated the same as revenue expenditure forming cost of production of their final products in their balance sheet, the Tribunal held that refund of the said duty amount would not involve unjust enrichment. The above case law supports the finding that in the facts of the subject case refund of the amount of duty claimed would not involve unjust enrichment. As regards the appellant’s claim for interest for delay in grant of refund, it is ordered that the appellants shall be entitled to interest in terms of Section 27A of the Customs Act, for the period beyond three months of filing of claim for refund with the Assistant Commissioner of Customs. The appeal filed by M/s. South India Paper Mills Ltd. is allowed.

(Order dictated and pronounced in the open Court)