- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Vipor Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner filed a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution challenging the denial of refund of Education Cess. The petitioner had already been granted refund of CENVAT credit on export consignments but was denied refund of Education Cess levied as a surcharge on excise duty. The petitioner contended that since excise duty along with Education Cess was paid and refund of excise duty was granted, refund of Education Cess should logically follow. The matter was taken up for final disposal after the Assistant Solicitor General waived service of rule.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner is entitled to refund of Education Cess paid as a surcharge on excise duty when refund of excise duty has already been granted.
- Whether Education Cess paid from the CENVAT Credit Account is refundable, given that the petitioner did not pay excess duty in cash but from the CENVAT Credit Account.
- Whether the definition of ‘duty’ under the relevant statutory provisions and notifications includes Education Cess for the period prior to 6-9-2004.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- Education Cess is a surcharge on excise duty; hence, refund of excise duty logically entails refund of Education Cess.
- Refund of CENVAT credit on export consignments has been granted, and since Education Cess was also paid from the CENVAT Credit Account, refund of Education Cess should similarly be granted.
- Relied on the Division Bench decision of the Rajasthan High Court in Banswara Syntex Ltd. v. Union of India which held that the definition of ‘duty’ includes Education Cess even prior to 6-9-2004.
- Relied on the Tribunal decision in Sun Pharmaceutical Industries supporting refund of Education Cess paid from CENVAT Credit.
Respondents' Arguments
- The petitioner had not paid excess duty in cash but from the CENVAT Credit Account, and therefore, refund of Education Cess is not permissible.
- The Department's stand was that Education Cess was required to be paid only from the Personal Ledger Account (PLA) and not from the CENVAT Credit Account.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Banswara Syntex Ltd. v. Union of India (Rajasthan High Court) | Definition of ‘duty’ includes Education Cess even prior to 6-9-2004, entitling refund of Education Cess where excise duty refund is granted. | The court relied on this decision to hold that Education Cess paid must be refunded alongside excise duty, even for the period before the notification dated 6-9-2004. |
| Sun Pharmaceutical Industries (Tribunal, Delhi, 2006 (77) Revenue Law Times 824) | Refund of Education Cess paid from CENVAT Credit Account is permissible. | The court accepted this precedent to support the petitioner’s claim that refund of Education Cess paid through CENVAT Credit Account should not be denied. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the statutory provisions, including Section 2A of the Central Excise Act, 1944, which defines ‘duty’ to include CENVAT. It noted that the petitioner had paid both excise duty and Education Cess from the CENVAT Credit Account. The court observed that Notification No. 19 of 2004 explicitly allowed rebate on Education Cess by including it within the definition of ‘duty’ under Rule 18 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002, but the dispute concerned the period prior to this notification.
Relying on the Division Bench decision of the Rajasthan High Court in Banswara Syntex Ltd., the court held that the definition of ‘duty’ for the relevant period includes Education Cess, entitling the petitioner to refund. The court rejected the Department’s argument that Education Cess must be paid only from the PLA Account, reasoning that since the refund is directed to be credited to the same account from which Education Cess was paid, the mode of payment does not bar refund.
The court therefore directed the refund of Education Cess to the petitioner’s CENVAT Credit Account, consistent with the refund of excise duty already granted.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The petition is allowed and the respondent is directed to sanction refund of Education Cess paid by the petitioner from the CENVAT Credit Account in relation to goods on which excise duty refund has already been granted.
Implications: The decision mandates refund of Education Cess as part of excise duty refund where Education Cess was paid, including for periods prior to the 2004 notification explicitly including Education Cess in the definition of duty. The refund must be credited to the same account from which Education Cess was paid. No new precedent beyond the application of existing rulings was established. The Department’s contention regarding mode of payment (PLA vs. CENVAT Credit Account) was not examined, as refund was directed to the same account.
[Judgment per : M.S. Shah, J. (Oral)]. - Rule : Mr. Harin P. Raval, learned Assistant Solicitor General waives service of rule. In the facts and circumstances of the case, the petition is taken up for final disposal.
2. In this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution, the petitioner has challenged denial of refund of Education Cess under the provisions of the Notification under clause 40 of 2001-C.E., dated 26-6-2001 issued under Rule 18 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002, even though refund of CENVAT credit on the export consignments has already been granted to the petitioner. It is submitted that Education Cess is levied in the nature of surcharge on excise duty. Therefore, when the petitioner is compelled to pay excise duty with Education Cess and ultimately, it is held that the petitioner is entitled to refund of excise duty as a necessary and logical corollary, the petitioner must also be held to be entitled to refund of Education Cess. Our attention is invited to the decision of a Division Bench of the Rajasthan High Court in Banswara Syntex Ltd. v. Union of India, (Raj.).
3. There is no dispute about the fact that by Notification No. 19 of 2004 dated 6-9-2004, rebate on Education Cess is allowed in terms of Rule 18 of Central Excise Rules, 2002; by providing that the expression, ‘duty’ also includes Education Cess on excisable goods as levied under clause 81 read with clause 83 of the Finance Bill 2/2004. The dispute, therefore, is only for the period prior to 6-9-2004. After considering all the relevant statutory provisions and the notifications, a Division Bench of the Rajasthan High Court has held that even for the period prior to 6-9-2004, the definition of ‘duty’ would include Education Cess on excisable goods and that therefore, an assessee, who is entitled to refund of excise duty would also be entitled to refund of Education Cess paid in the nature of surcharge on excise duty.
4. The other objection raised on behalf of the respondents is that the petitioner had not paid excess duty in cash, but had paid duty from his CENVAT Credit Account and therefore, while the amount of excess duty paid from CENVAT Credit Account may have been refunded, the petitioner is not entitled to refund of the Education Cess as such, to which Mr. Dave, learned advocate for the petitioner submitted that just as excise duty amount was paid from CENVAT Credit Account, so also Education Cess was also paid from the same CENVAT Credit Account. Therefore, when the petitioner is found entitled to get refund of the excess duty amount, there is no reason to deny refund of the Education Cess. Mr. Dave also relied on the decision of the Tribunal in Sun Pharmaceutical Industries, (T) = (T) = 2006 (77) Revenue Law Times 824 (Tri.-Delhi).
5. We find in the provisions of Section 2A of the Central Excise Act, 1944 that :-
‘In this Act, save as otherwise expressly provided and unless the context otherwise requires, references to the expressions ‘duty’, ‘duties, ‘duty of excise’ and ‘duties of excise’ shall be construed to include a reference to ‘Central Value Added Tax (CENVAT)’.
Having regard to the above statutory provisions and also having regard to the fact that the petitioner had paid excise duty as well as Education Cess thereon from out of the petitioner’s CENVAT Account, when the petitioner is found entitled to refund of excise duty and the actual refund of the excise duty amount is also given to the petitioner, agreeing with the decision of the Rajasthan High Court in Banswara Syntex Ltd. reported in (Raj.), we see no reason why the amount on education cess paid from out of the CENVAT Credit Account should not be refunded to the petitioner and credited in the same account. The stand of the Department that education cess was required to be paid only from PLA Account and not from the CENVAT Credit Account, is not required to be examined in the facts of the present case, because the refund of education cess is being direeted to be made to the same account from which the education cess was paid by the petitioner.
6. We accordingly allow this petition. Respondent No. 2-Assistant Commissioner of Central Excise, Makarpura Division, Vadodara-II is directed to sanction rebate of Education Cess of Rs. 7,225/- collected from the petitioner in relation to the goods on which excise duty has already been refunded to the petitioner, within one month from the date of receipt of this judgment, by crediting the refund in the same account from which the Education Cess was paid by the petitioner.
7. Rule is made absolute in the aforesaid terms with no order as to costs. Direct service is permitted.
Alert