- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Commissioner Of Central Excise, Hyderabad v. Paris Waves
[Order per : T.K. Jayaraman, Member (T)]. - The Revenue has filed this appeal against the Order-in-Appeal No. 113/2005 (H-III) C.E. dated 29-4-2005, passed by the Commissioner of Customs & Central Excise (Appeals-III), Hyderabad.
2. The Respondent was claiming refund of Cenvat credit which was not utilized because they exported the ready made garments and they were not in a position to utilize the Cenvat credit. Therefore in terms of provisions of Rule 5 of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2002 read with Notification No. 11/2002-C.E. (N.T.) dated 31-3-2002, the Respondent filed a refund claim for an amount of Rs. 16,23,903/-. The sanction order was passed on 12-3-2003. Initially the Basic Excise Duty (BED) was sanctioned and AED amounting to Rs. 5,41,301/- had been rejected. Later based on Board’s order and also in view of the decision of the Tribunal, Bangalore on 13-1-2004, the AED portion was granted by the Assistant Commissioner in his order dated 23-1-2001. The issue involves the granting of interest. The Original Authority in his order sanctioned only the refund claim due to the party. In the order dated 24-8-2004, the Original Authority sanctioned an amount of Rs. 16,23,903/- to the Respondent. But there is no discussion about the refund due to the Respondent. Therefore the Respondent approached the Commissioner (Appeals) and the Commissioner (Appeals) has allowed the appeal of the Respondent and ordered payment of interest in terms of the legal position. While passing the order, the Commissioner (Appeals) has relied on the decision of the Revisional authority, Government of India Order No. 75/2000 dated 7-5-2000 and he has also relied on other decisions of the Tribunal and ordered that interest is payable from the date immediately after the expiry of three months from the date of receipt of refund application. Revenue is aggrieved over the impugned order on the following grounds :-
(i) Though the refund claim was submitted on 13-1-2003 it appears there were some discrepancies and authenticity of the relevant documents were in question.
(ii) A notice was issued on 9-4-2003 i.e. (within 3 months) which can be treated as deficiency memo in the parlance of procedures prescribed in processing refund claims.
(iii) When opportunity under principles of natural justice was given to the assessee, instead of coming up with required documents and proper explanation, he delayed in complying with requirements and acted as per his convenience.
(iv) It can be seen from the events that adjudicating authority disposed off the refund claim within normal time, when the documents etc. were submitted by the assessee and on his appearance of personal hearing.
(v) As it is pronounced in plethora of judgments, the time taken by the assessee in submitting the relevant documents, (enabling the claim to be complete in all respects) should be excluded in calculating the time period for delay.
(vi) In the instant case assessee complied with all requirements only on 14-7-2004, and the refund was sanctioned on 28-8-2004, hence it can be inferred that the sanction of refund is within time and no interest need to be paid.
(vii) Without prejudice to the above discussion it can further be interpreted that :-
This is not a plain case of refund of duty paid under Section 11B of Central Excise Act, 1944, but is refund of unutilized Cenvat credit lying in balance, under Rule 5 of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2002, in respect of inputs used in final products which ultimately got exported.
A similar case was decided in favour of Revenue disallowing the interest on delayed refund of Cenvat credit under Rule 5 of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2002, in case M/s. Ahmedabad Steel Crafts v. CCE, Ahmedabad, (Tri.-Del.). Further since in this case refunded amount/accumulated credit was in the possession of the appellant at his disposal and not the Government exchequer as such any payment of interest on such claim/encashment of sum lying in balance in Cenvat credit account ill be illegal and without authority of law.
(viii) The Commissioner (Appeals) has not taken all the above facts into consideration and proceeded on different grounds and placed reliance on cases whose facts are entirely different.
3. Shri K. Sambi Reddy, learned JDR appeared on behalf of the Revenue and Shri Venkatesh Rao, learned Advocate appeared for the Respondent.
4. On a very careful consideration of the issue, we find that the refund claim was submitted on 13-1-2003. The Department is expected to take a decision either to reject the refund claim or to sanction it within a period of 3 months, if they don’t to saddle the Department with any interest liability. But in this case, only just before the elapse of three months, they issued a Show Cause Notice dated 9-4-2003 asking for certain original documents. This approach is not correct. When three months time has been given, the show cause notice cannot be issued just before the elapse of three months. We are not impressed with the Grounds of Appeal given by the Revenue. The Respondent has stated that all the information which are relevant for sanctioning the claim has been filed along with the original application. Therefore, even if the Department had to verify certain information that should have been got done expeditiously. Moreover the contention of the Revenue that refund in terms of Rule 5 of Cenvat Credit Rules cannot be a refund under Section 11B is not accepted. It has also been urged that the credit was already in the possession of the Respondent at the disposal and it was not with the Government exchequer. Therefore no interest would be payable and it will be without any authority of law. This is not correct. Even though the Respondent had taken credit of the Cenvat, they had not utilized it. In other words, the duty paid to the Government is lying with Government till the credit is utilized. Only when the Respondent utilize the credit there is transfer of first, the amount from the exchequer to the Respondent and later from the Respondent to the Government. In the present case, the Respondent was not in a position to utilize the Cenvat credit accumulated. In that case, it cannot be said that the amount was available with the Respondent and no interest had to be paid. If that was so, there would not be any need for filing the refund claim. The very fact that the refund claim has to be filed in terms of Rule 5 of Cenvat Credit Rules show that only when the competent authority sanctions the refund claim, it will be of any use. When the competent authority delays the sanction of refund for one reason or the other, interest has to be paid in terms of Section 11BB immediately after the expiry of three months from the date of receipt of refund application. We do not find any infirmity in the impugned order of the Commissioner. Therefore the appeal of the Revenue is rejected.
(Pronounced in the open Court on 1-1-2008)
Alert