- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Cyrus Surfactants Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Central Excise, Jammu
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Order per Justice R.K. Abichandani, President)
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellants challenged the orders of the Commissioner (Appeals) dated 28-04-2006 that dismissed their appeals and upheld the adjudicating authority's rejection of the appellants' refund claim of Education Cess levied under the Finance Act, 2004. The appellants had paid excise and additional duties under three Acts named in Notification No. 56/2002 dated 14-11-2002 (issued under the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 and related statutes) after exhausting their Cenvat credit, and had also paid Education Cess at 2% under Section 93 of the Finance Act, 2004. They claimed refunds of the duties and the Education Cess relying on the exemption mechanics in Notification No. 56/2002. The Revenue accepted refunds of the duties payable under the three Acts but denied refund of the Education Cess on the ground that the Finance Act, 2004 (i.e., Section 93) was not mentioned in the Notification.
The court delivered an order on 12th June 2007, setting aside the impugned orders of the Commissioner (Appeals) and allowing the appeals with consequential reliefs.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Education Cess levied under Section 93 of the Finance Act, 2004 (a "piggy‑back" duty calculated at 2% on the aggregate of excise duties) is refundable to manufacturers when the underlying excise duties (leviable under the three Acts named in Notification No. 56/2002) are held to be exempt under that Notification and its operative procedures (paragraphs 1A, 2 and 2A).
- Whether the absence of an explicit reference to the Finance Act, 2004 (Section 93) in Notification No. 56/2002 precludes refund of Education Cess that was paid in respect of excise duties which are, in substance, exempted by that Notification.
Arguments of the Parties
Revenue / Department (as represented before the court)
- The Commissioner (Appeals) and the Department contended that because the Notification did not specifically mention the Education Cess or the Finance Act, 2004, refund of Education Cess was not admissible under the Notification.
- The Department asserted that the condition in the Notification requiring payment in cash (after exhausting Cenvat credit) for availing the exemption effectively meant such payment should be treated as excise duty "levied and collected." Therefore, Section 93 would apply and Education Cess at 2% would be payable notwithstanding the Notification's reference to the three Acts alone.
- To support this reasoning, the Department referred to various Apex Court decisions (CCE, New Delhi v. Hari Chand Shri Gopal; Eagle Flask Indus. Ltd. v. CCE, Pune; and CCE, Ahmedabad v. Cadila Laboratories (P) Ltd.) as authorities for the legal position advanced.
Appellants
- The appellants contended that Education Cess is a duty of excise calculated on the aggregate of duties leviable under the three Acts named in the Notification, and therefore, when the Notification exempts those duties (subject to its conditions and procedures), the incidental Education Cess that was paid along with those duties is also not leviable and must be refunded.
- They argued that the Notification's mechanism (payment from PLA or cash after Cenvat exhaustion, submission of statements and verification) shows that payments were systemically accepted as part of operationalising the exemption, and the Education Cess paid through PLA in terms of the Notification was therefore refundable.
- The appellants submitted that the Commissioner (Appeals) erred in rejecting the claim solely because the Finance Act, 2004 was not expressly incorporated in the Notification.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| CCE, New Delhi v. Hari Chand Shri Gopal (Supreme Court) | The opinion records that the Department referred to this decision to support its position; the specific rule cited from this decision is not detailed in the provided opinion. | The court noted that this case was relied upon by the Department, but the opinion does not record any detailed reliance on it by the court. The court did not adopt the Department's argument that cash payment makes the amount a duty leviable under Section 93. |
| Eagle Flask Indus. Ltd. v. CCE, Pune (Supreme Court) | The opinion records that the Department referred to this decision to support its position; the specific rule cited from this decision is not detailed in the provided opinion. | Referenced by the Department; the court did not treat this reference as decisive and rejected the Department's interpretation that would make Education Cess non‑refundable in the present context. |
| CCE, Ahmedabad v. Cadila Laboratories (P) Ltd. (Supreme Court) | The opinion records that the Department referred to this decision to support its position; the opinion does not specify the precise principle invoked from this case. | Referred to by the Department to bolster its reasoning. The court examined the statutory and notification scheme and rejected the Department's contention despite these references. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeded in several key steps, grounded in the text of the Notification (No. 56/2002 dated 14-11-2002), the statutory provisions authorising exemption, and the character of Education Cess under Section 93 of the Finance Act, 2004:
-
The Notification: The court described the Notification's exemption scheme and the operative mechanics:
- Paragraph 1A conditions the exemption on the manufacturer first utilising the whole of the Cenvat Credit available on the last day of the month and paying in cash only the balance amount.
- Paragraph 2 prescribes the procedure — submit a statement of duty paid in cash by the 7th of the next month; the Assistant/Deputy Commissioner to verify and refund the amount of duty paid in cash by the 15th day of that month (provisionally if necessary).
- Paragraph 2A gives the manufacturer an option to take credit in his account current in lieu of refund and sets out consequences for excess or irregular credit.
- Nature of Education Cess (Section 93, Finance Act, 2004): The court characterised the Education Cess as a "piggy‑back" duty — calculated at 2% on the aggregate of excise duties levied and collected by the Ministry of Finance under the Central Excise Act, 1944 and any other law. Section 93 does not provide for a separate scheme of exemption.
-
Interaction between the Notification and Section 93:
- The court reasoned that if the underlying excise duty (leviable under the three Acts named in the Notification) is exempted in accordance with the Notification's mechanism, then there is no levy or collection on that component of duty — and consequently no base on which Section 93 could operate to impose Education Cess.
- Hence there was no requirement to specifically mention the Finance Act, 2004 (Section 93) in the Notification: if the excise duty is exempted, the piggy‑back cess cannot be levied because there is no excise duty in existence on which to calculate it.
-
Rejection of the Revenue's core contention:
- The Revenue argued that payments required by the Notification to be made in cash or PLA (after exhausting Cenvat) should be treated as "excise duty levied and collected" — bringing them within Section 93. The court found this contention unsustainable on close reading of paragraph 2 of the Notification.
- The court explained that paragraph 2's procedures are a methodology to ascertain the extent of the exemption and to operationalise refund or account credit; they are not a declaration that such sums are properly treated as duties levied and collected for the purposes of attracting the piggy‑back cess.
- The court relied on a CBEC Circular (No. 682/73/2002-CX dated 19-12-2002) quoted in the opinion to emphasise that the "refund" under such Notifications is designed to give effect to the exemption and is not a refund of excess duty in the ordinary Section 11B sense.
- The court also noted a Ministry of Finance clarification (letter dated 10-08-2004) that where goods are fully exempted and chargeable to nil duty, there is no collection of duty and therefore no Education Cess would be leviable on such clearances.
- Anomalous consequences of including Section 93 in the Notification: The court observed that expressly incorporating Section 93 into the Notification would have produced unintended and anomalous results by exempting Education Cess even in contexts where the Notification was not meant to affect other excise levies (for example, cesses under other statutes such as the Sugar Cess Act, Oil Industries Development Act, Jute Manufacturers Cess Act). This reinforced the court's view that exclusion of an explicit mention of Section 93 did not imply the Revenue's position.
- Conclusion from the foregoing analysis: When the Notification's procedures resulted in an exempted amount of excise duty, that exempted amount was not leviable and, therefore, any Education Cess calculated on that amount was also not leviable and was refundable. The Commissioner (Appeals)'s rejection based on absence of a specific mention of Finance Act, 2004 in the Notification was held to be erroneous.
Holding and Implications
Holding: APPEALS ALLOWED; the impugned orders of the Commissioner (Appeals) are set aside and the appellants are entitled to consequential reliefs (including refund of the Education Cess paid on exempted excise duties).
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The appellants' claims for refund of Education Cess (levied at 2% under Section 93 of the Finance Act, 2004) in respect of excise duties exempted under Notification No. 56/2002 (and determined by following the Notification's procedures) were allowed and the impugned administrative orders rejecting those refunds were set aside.
- Broader implications: The opinion explains the legal principle that a piggy‑back duty (Education Cess under Section 93) cannot be levied when the underlying excise duty is exempted in accordance with the operative machinery of a Notification. The court expressly noted that there was no need to include Section 93 in the Notification to achieve the result of non‑levy of the cess where the underlying duty is exempted. The opinion did not purport to articulate or overrule any broader, novel precedent beyond the resolution of the appeals; no new, separate exemption scheme for Section 93 was created by the court.
Order pronounced in open court on 12 June 2007.
[Order per : Justice R.K. Abichandani, President]. - The appellants have challenged the orders of the Commissioner (Appeals) dated 28-4-2006 dismissing the appeals and upholding the order of the adjudicating authority rejecting the refund claim of the appellants on account of Education Cess levied under the Finance Act, 2004.
2. The claim of the appellants for refund of Education Cess was based on the Notification bearing No. 56/2002 dated 14-11-2002, which provided for exemption to the goods specified in the First Schedule and the Second Schedule to the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 (other than the goods specified in Annexure I to the Notification), from so much of the duty of excise or additional duty of excise, as the case may be, leviable thereon under any of the three Acts, namely, The Central Excise Act, 1944; The Additional Duties of Excise (Goods of Special Importance) Act, 1957; and The Additional Duties of Excise (Textiles and Textile Articles) Act, 1978, as was equivalent to the amount of duty paid by the manufacturer of goods, other than the amount of duty paid by utilization of Cenvat Credit. Under this Notification, it was, inter alia, provided by paragraph 1A that the exemption contained therein shall be available subject to the condition that the manufacturer first utilizes whole of the Cenvat Credit available to him on the last day of the month under consideration for payment of duty on goods cleared during such months and paid only the balance amount in cash. Paragraph 2 of the said Notification laid down the manner in which the said exemption was to be given effect to. Accordingly, a manufacturer was required to submit a statement of the duty paid, other than the amount of duty paid by utilization of Cenvat Credit, to the Assistant Commissioner by the 7th of the next month, in which the duty had been paid. This obviously means that the statement of only the duty paid in cash (or from the PLA) was to be submitted. Thereupon, it was to be verified by the Assistant Commissioner or the Deputy Commissioner, and the amount of duty paid in cash was to be refunded to the manufacturer by the 15th day of the said next month. In the event of likelihood of delay in the verification of the statement, refund was to be made on a provisional basis by 15th day of the next month to the month under consideration. Paragraph 2A of the Notification gave an option to the manufacturer to take credit of the amount of duty paid during the month under consideration, other than by way of utilization of Cenvat Credit, in his account current, maintained in terms of Part V of the Excise Manual. When such option was exercised by the manufacturer, the credit of duty paid in cash during the month under consideration, could be given by the manufacturer in his account current by the 7th day of the next month to the month under consideration, who upon verification was required to determine the amount correctly refundable to the manufacturer and intimate the same to the manufacturer by 15th day of the next month to the month under consideration. Any excess credit taken, was required to be reversed within 5 days of the intimation to the manufacturer. If the credit was irregularly taken or excess credit is availed and not reversed, it became recoverable as if it was a recovery of duty of excise erroneously refunded.
3. It is not disputed that the appellants paid the excise and additional duties under the said three Acts in cash after having exhausted payments made from the Cenvat account, in respect of which the exemption did not extend. The appellants having paid the duties under the said three Acts and also the Education Cess payable at 2% in respect thereof under Section 93 of the Finance Act, 2004, claimed refunds of the duties and the Education Cess, which was also in the nature of excise duty, as provided by Section 93 of the Finance Act, 2004. As noticed above, since the Finance Act, 2004 was not mentioned in the exemption Notification and only the aforesaid three Acts were referred, the Revenue, while upholding the claim for the refund of duties paid in cash under the said three Acts, denied the refund of the Education Cess, which was also in the nature of the excise duty, paid at 2% of the aggregate of the duties which were paid under the said three Acts, on the ground that the Finance Act, 2004 was not specified in the Notification.
4. The controversy before us centres around the interpretation of the provisions of Section 93 of Chapter VI of the Finance Act, 2004, which provides for levy and collection of Education Cess on excisable goods which was in the nature of excise duty, at the rate of 2% calculated on the aggregate of all duties of excise including special duty of excise or any other duty of excise, which are levied and collected under the provisions of the Central Excise Act, 1944 or under any other law for the time being in force, by the Central Government in the Ministry of Finance.
4.1 The Commissioner (Appeals) in all these matters took the view that in the absence of specific mention of the Education Cess in the nature of excise duty in the said Notification No. 56/2002, refund of Education Cess was not admissible to all these appellants in terms of the said Notification. Referring to the Notification No. 40/2001 dated 26-6-2002 which related to rebate of duty on excisable goods, which Notification was superceded by Notification No. 19/2004 dated 6-9-2004, and noticing that Education Cess on excisable goods under clause 83 of the Finance Bill, 2004 was included in the Explanation (1) of the Notification dated 6-9-2004, the Appellate Commissioner concluded that, if it would have been the intention of the Government to also extend the benefit of refund in respect of Education Cess, the Finance Act, 2004 would have been specifically included in the said Notification as was done under the Notification dated 6-9-2004 in the context of rebates. This line of reasoning has been adopted by the learned authorized representatives appearing for the Department in all these appeals. They have supported this reasoning by referring to the decisions of the Apex Court in CCE, New Delhi v. Hari Chand Shri Gopal, reported in (S.C.), Eagle Flask Indus. Ltd. v. CCE, Pune, reported in (S.C.); and CCE, Ahmedabad v. Cadila Laboratories (P) Ltd., reported in (S.C.). According to the learned authorized representatives for the Department, since there was a condition for payment of cash for availing the benefit of the said Notification, that should be treated as excise duty levied and collected, which would obviously result in attracting the provisions of Section 93 of the Finance Act, 2004, and Education Cess in the nature of excise duty at the rate of 2% became payable notwithstanding the fact that the duties named in the Notification were to be “refunded”.
5. The learned counsel appearing in these appeals have contended on behalf of the appellants that since Education Cess was a duty of excise which was paid on the aggregate of duties of excise leviable under the aforesaid three Acts, which were named in the Notification, it should be treated to have been levied under those Acts and, therefore, along with the refund, which was admissible in respect of the duties paid under the said three Acts, even the Education Cess in the nature of excise duty paid at the rate of 2% thereof, was required to be refunded. It was submitted that, the Education Cess was clearly accepted as excise duty, which was paid by the appellants through PLA account in terms of the said Notification. It was submitted that the Appellate Commissioner has committed an error in rejecting the appellants’ claim for refund of the Education Cess paid under Section 93 of the Act on the ground that the provisions of the Finance Act, 2004 relating to levy of Education Cess which was in the nature of excise duty was not incorporated in the said Notification which exempted duties only in respect of the three Acts named therein. It was also argued that, in view of the exemption under the said Notification in respect of the duties payable under the three Acts named thereunder, no Education Cess was payable under the provisions of Section 93. It was, therefore, submitted that, Education Cess would not have been recoverable in connection with the duties which were exempted under the said Notification on its conditions being satisfied.
6. Levy and collection of excise duty is provided for in Chapter II of the Central Excise Act, 1944. The expressions “Duty, Duties, Duty of Excise and Duties of Excise” are required to be construed by including a reference to Central Value Added Tax, as provided in Section 2A of the said Act. A duty of excise, which is to be called as Central Value Added Tax (Cenvat), on all excisable goods which are produced and manufactured in India, is to be levied and collected in such manner as may be prescribed under the Rules on all the excisable goods in the First Schedule to the Tariff Act. Similarly a special duty of excise in addition to Cenvat is required to be levied and collected in the prescribed manner at the rates set forth in the Second Schedule to the Tariff Act on excisable goods specified in the Second Schedule.
6.1 The scheme of exemption is reflected in the provisions of Section 5A of the Act which empowers the Central Government to exempt excisable goods of any specified description from the whole or any part of the duty of excise leviable thereon. Similar exemption is also provided for in Sections 3(3) of the Additional Duties of Excise (Goods of Special Importance) Act, 1957 and subsection (3) of Section 3 of the Additional Duties of Excise (Textiles and Textile Articles) Act, 1978, which provisions have been resorted to while issuing the said exemption Notification.
6.2 It will be noticed that, Chapter VI of Finance Act, 2004, which provided for levy and collection of Education Cess in the nature of duty of excise in Section 93 did not provide for any such exemption; obviously so, because, as my esteemed learned brother very aptly described, it was a “piggy back duty”. The levy and collection of excise duty under Section 93 of the Finance Act, 2004 was at the rate of 2% of the aggregate of all the duties of excise which are levied and collected by the Ministry of Finance under the provisions of not only the Central Excise Act, 1944, but under any other law for the time being in force. Therefore, unless there is excise duty levied and collected under such law, there can arise no question of levy and collection of Education Cess under Section 93 of the said Finance Act, 2004. Levy and collection of Education Cess under Section 93 cannot stand on its own independent of levy and collection of excise duties under the Central Excise Act, 1944 and other laws for the time being in force. In other words, if there is no levy and collection by virtue of any exemption of the excise duties which otherwise would be payable under the Central Excise Act, 1944 or under any other law which could be levied and collected by the Ministry of Finance, there would be no occasion to calculate Education Cess in the nature of excise duty under Section 93 of the Finance Act, 2004. There is no need to provide any scheme of exemption from Education Cess in the nature of excise duty, because if the excise duty in respect of which it is reguired to be calculated is itself exempted, automatically, no question of levy of the said Education Cess in the nature of excise duty can ever arise. There was, therefore, no need to incorporate the provisions of Chapter VI of Finance Act, 2004 in the said Notification. The reasoning of the Commissioner (Appeals) that because Education Cess in the nature of excise duty which can be levied and collected under Section 93 did not find place in the said Notification which referred to only the aforesaid three Acts proceeds on an erroneous footing, in view of the fact that there is no separate scheme of exemption from Education Cess in the nature of excise duty contemplated in the provisions of Chapter VI of the Finance Act, 2004 nor does such requirement flow from any of the three Acts in respect of which duty exemption has been granted under the said Notification.
7. The contention raised on behalf of the Revenue that, since for availing the benefit of the said Notification, the manufacturer was required to pay duty on goods cleared, after having exhausted the Cenvat Credit, in cash or through PLA, it should be treated as duty levied and collected, though at first blush attractive, is devoid of any substance, on a closure scrutiny of paragraph 2 of the said Notification. The opening part of paragraph 2 clearly declares that, the exemption contained in the said Notification shall be given effect to in the manner laid down thereunder. In the scheme of the exemption of the nature granted under this Notification, it appears that no exemption is available until the manufacturer utilizes all the Cenvat Credit. It is only in respect of the balance amount which is paid thereafter in cash or through PLA, that the question of availing benefit of exemption can arise. The method devised in paragraph 2 requiring the manufacturer to furnish a statement of duty paid in cash by the 7th of the next month, or the option given to him to take credit of such amount in his account current, and the verification thereafter which is required to be done by the Assistant Commissioner by 15 day of the next month, is only a methodology for working out the extent of exemption and for ascertaining whether any excess was paid, which was required to be refunded along with the duties paid in cash or which could be taken credit of by the manufacturer himself where he exercises option, as contemplated by paragraph 2A of the said Notification. At the end of this exercise, which is aimed at working out the exemption to which the manufacturer is entitled, it would be incongruous to say that such extent of exemption should be treated as duty levied and collected. In this context, even the Central Board of Excise & Customs (CBEC), had issued clarification by its Circular No. 682/73/2002-CX., dated 19-12-2002 from which the relevant portion contained in paragraph 3 thereof is extracted hereunder :
“3. In this context, it may be pointed that the ‘Refund’ envisaged in the Notifications is not on account of any excess payment of excise duty by the manufacturers, but is basically designed to give effect to exemption. In other words, the mechanism has been adopted to operationalise the exemption envisaged in these two notifications. In view of this aspect of the matter, the provisions of Section 11-B of the Central Excise Act, 1944 would not apply in the case of these Notifications.”
[Emphasis added]
7.1 We may also incidentally refer to the clarification issued by letter dated 10th August, 2004 by the Ministry of Finance on the question, whether the goods that are fully exempted from excise duty/customs duty, would be subjected to Education Cess. It was clarified in answer to issue no. 2 that if the goods are fully exempted from excise duty and are chargeable to NIL duty, there is no collection of duty and, therefore, no Education Cess would be leviable on such clearances.
7.2 Therefore, once the entitlement to exemption of the duty of excise or additional duty of excise, which would otherwise be payable under the three Acts named in the Notification, is established by following the manner indicated in paragraph 2 for ascertaining the extent exemption, there cannot arise any question of imposing Education Cess in the nature of excise duty under Section 93.
8. The ground for rejecting the claim for refund of Education Cess in the nature of excise duty paid at the rate of 2% on the portion of excise duties which were exempted, given by the Commissioner (Appeals) and adopted by the Learned Authorized Representatives for the Department, that there was no mention of the provisions of Education Cess in the nature of excise duty leviable under Section 93 in the said Notification, would be self-defeating and counter-productive, as will be seen hereafter.
8.1 If the provisions of Chapter VI of the Finance Act, 2004 relating to levy and collection of Education Cess in the nature of excise duty were included along with the three Acts in the said Notification, unintended adverse consequences would follow for the Revenue. It is clear from the wordings of Section 93 that the Education Cess in the nature of excise duty which is required to be levied and collected at the rate of 2% of the aggregate of all duties of excise would be applicable not only in respect of the excise duties that can be levied and collected under the Central Excise Act, 1944, Additional Duties of Excise (Goods of Special Importance) Act, 1957 and Additional Duties of Excise (Textiles and Textile Articles) Act, 1978, but also in respect of all other excise duties which are levied and collected by the Union Finance Ministry under any other law for the time being in force. Inclusion of the provisions of Section 93 of the Finance Act, 2004 in the Notification would have created an exemption from levy of Education Cess even in the context of excise duties payable under the other laws in respect of which no excise duty exemption was intended under the said Notification. To illustrate, if the provisions of Finance Act, 2004 were also mentioned in the said Notification along with the said three Acts, then even the Education Cess in the nature of excise duty leviable on Cess in the nature of excise duties under Section 3 of the Sugar Cess Act, 1982, Section 15 of the Oil Industries Development Act, 1974, and Section 3 of the Jute Manufacturers Cess Act, 1983, in respect of which no exemption is granted, would stand exempted.
8.2 In our opinion, there was no need for including the provisions relating to Education Cess in the nature of excise duty required to be levied and collected under Section 93 of the Act in the said Notification, because the Education Cess was in the nature of piggy back duty, which would not operate in respect of the excise duty exempted under the relevant law. Moreover, inclusion of the said provisions of Section 93 of the Finance Act, 2004 in the said Notification would have led to an anomalous situation as indicated above. It would also to be noticed that the “refund” contemplated in paragraph 2 of the Notification in the context of statement of duty paid in cash, has no relevance with any Education Cess in the nature of excise duty, because the provisions of the Notification, including the manner of giving effect to the exemption contained thereunder, were devised only in the context of the excise duties which otherwise would have been payable under the said three Acts, but for such exemption. It cannot, therefore, be said that Education Cess cannot be refunded because there was no provision for its refund in paragraph 2 of the said Notification. It became refundable because the exemption became operative.
9. For the foregoing reasons, it is evident that when the exempted amount of duty was required to be refunded for operationalising the exemption, Education Cess, which was in the nature of piggy back duty on the excise duties under the said three Acts, was also required to be refunded, because it was not at all leviable, in view of the entitlement to exemption worked out under paragraph 2 of the said Notification. The impugned orders of the Commissioner (Appeals) cannot, therefore, be sustained and are hereby set-aside with consequential reliefs. These appeals are accordingly allowed.
(Dictated & pronounced in the open court on 12th day of June, 2007)
Alert