- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Desh Raj v. Commissioner Of C. Ex. & Cus., Chandigarh
[Order per : S.S. Kang, Member (J)]. - Appellant filed this appeal against the order passed by the Commissioner of Customs, Chandigarh vide which penalty of Rs. One lakh under Section 112(b) of Customs Act, 1962 is imposed upon the appellant.
2. Brief facts of the case are that on the intervening night of 12/13th July, 1990, a joint naka was laid by the Customs officers and Border Security Force personnels near village Agro Chak on Indo-Pak Border. At about 3 A.M. two persons were seen by the naka party and on challenged the person managed to escape under the cover of darkness. But they left behind two gunny bags. On search 58 Kgs of Heroin was found in 58 packets in the gunny bags. The Heroin was taken into possession under Section 110 of the Customs Act, 1962. Subsequently on 23-7-1990, 18 Kgs. of Heroin was recovered from a defence bunker of village Agra Chak. This Heroin was also taken, into possession under Section 110 of the Customs Act, 1962. During investigation all the recovered Heroin was found to be of one consignment.
3. In follow up action the Customs officers summoned three persons namely Som Nath, Naresh Kumar and Rajesh Kumar and their statements under Section 108 of the Customs Act, 1962 were recorded. Som Nath in his statement under Section 108 of the Customs Act, admitted that he was carrying 58 Kgs. of Heroin along with Swaran Lal and on seeing the Naka party they escaped leaving behind the Heroin. He further disclosed that the whole consignment of heroin was brought by Des Raj, appellant and Swaran Lal from Pakistan along with two Pakistani nationals Hyder and Herif Beg. There after the consignment was handed over to him and he carried it to the house of Des Raj appellant situated near the Indo-Pak border and from there the consignment was further taken to the house of one Darshan Singh. He further disclosed that on instruction of Swaran Lal he took the heroin from the house of Darshan Singh to the shop of Naresh Kumar. Naresh Kumar kept three packets and remaining packets were concealed in the defence bunker near village Agra Chak.
4. Naresh Kumar in his statement under Section 108 of the Customs Act, 1962 disclosed that Som Nath and Swaran Lal came to his shop and told him that Des Raj appellant had been detained under Public Safety Act in Central Jail and they have two bags of Heroin belonging to Des Raj appellant, who had smuggled the heroin from Pakistan. Thereafter he directed his assistant Rajesh Kumar to assist Som Nath and Swaran Lal in bringing the Heroin to his shop. Two bags of Heroin were brought to his shop. He sold two packets to one Sudesh Kumar. The bags were kept in room of Rajesh Kumar. After about one month the bags were returned to Som Nath and Swaran Lal.
5. Rajesh Kumar in his statement under Section 108 of Customs Act corroborated the statement given by Naresh Kumar.
6. Darshan Singh who is brother of Swaran Lal in his statement under Section 108 of the Customs Act admitted that he knew Som Nath and he admitted that four packets of heroin recovered from his house were given to him by Des Raj appellant for sale.
7. Des Raj appellant who was under detention under the Public Safety Act at that time in his statement under Section 108 of the Customs Act, 1962 denied the link with recovered heroin.
8. After adjudication impugned order is passed.
9. The ld. Advocate appearing on behalf of the appellant submitted that there is absolutely no evidence on record to link the appellant with the recovered heroin. He is being named by co-accused. It is settled law that on the basis of confession made by an co-accused, one cannot be held guilty. There is no independent evidence on record to corraborate the facts given in statements of co-accused. The appellant in his statement under Section 108 of the Customs Act stated that he does not know any of these persons except Swaran Lal as he resides near his village. He further stated in his statement that he never crossed the border.
10. The ld. Advocate further submitted that appellant was under custody much before the said recovery of heroin. He further submitted that the appellant was discharged in the criminal case relating to recovery of heroin. He submitted that from the order of discharge it is clear that the counsel for the Customs Department had conceded that there is no evidence against the appellant.
11. We have heard Shri Jangir Singh ld. JDR.
12. In this case, admittedly the appellant was in custody under the Public Safety Act much before the recovery of Heroin. Som Nath and Swaran Lal named the appellant in their statements under Section 108 of Customs Act. In their statements they disclosed that appellant brought the heroin from Pakistan. Som Nath in his statement stated that the recovered heroin was brought from Pakistan by Des Raj and Swaran Lal. Appellant in his statement admitted that he knew Swaran Lal. Further Darshan Singh in his statement stated that four packets recovered from his house were given by Des Raj appellant for sale on commission basis.
13. Regarding discharge of the appellant from the criminal case, in that case, Counsel for Customs might have conceded that there was not sufficient evidence against the appellant for his prosecution in criminal case. The criminal proceedings and departmental adjudication are based on different principle. Hon’ble Supreme Court in case Naresh J. Sukhawani v. Union of India reported in (S.C.) held that “the statement made before the Customs officials is not a statement recorded under Section 161 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973. Therefore it is a material piece of evidence collected by Customs officials under Section 108 of the Customs Act. That material incriminates the petitioner inculpating him in the contravention of the provisions of the Customs Act. The material can certainly be used to connect the petitioner.”
14. In the present case, the co-noticee in their statements under Section 108 of the Customs Act implicated themselves and also the appellant. There is no ill-will or enmity of the appellant with co-noticee. In these circumstances, we do not find any infirmity in the impugned order. Appeal is dismissed.
Alert