Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Pearl Drinks Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Central Excise, New Delhi

CESTAT
Mar 2, 2001

[Order per : C.N.B. Nair, Member (T)]. - The appellants are manufacturers of soft drinks. The present appeal is directed against Order-in-Original No. CCE(ADJ.) VLS/13/2000, dated 23-6-2000 of the Commissioner of Central Excise (Adj.), Delhi. The impugned order confirmed duty demand of Rs. 34,78,301/- upon the appellants. It also imposed a penalty of Rs. 2,000/- under Rule 52A and a penalty of Rs. 10 lakhs under Rule 173Q(1) of the Central Excise Rules. The appellant is aggrieved by the duty demand and the penalties.

2. The dispute under adjudication in the impugned order related to valuation of the aerated waters manufactured and cleared by the appellant during the period March, 1994 to March, 1995. The show cause notice was issued on 28-7-1995.

3. The facts of the case are that the appellants were removing the goods from their factory to an adjacent godown and distributing the goods from there. There was no sale at the factory gate. From their sale price, the appellants claimed deductions towards “excise, sales tax, Trptn. chgs., containers service and other service charges including trade discount” in the price-list filed by them w.e.f. 3-3-1994. The price-list was approved by the Central Excise Authorities. The show cause notice was issued alleging that part of the deduction claimed was not permissible inasmuch as they related to items of expenditure which are to be included in the assessable value of goods. The notice also invoked extended period of time as contemplated in proviso to Section 11A(1) of the Central Excise Act. Eventhough the show cause notice demanded differential duty of above Rs. 51 lakhs, the impugned order confirmed the duty amount at a lower amount of over Rs. 34 lakhs as already indicated. The impugned order held that costs such as advertisement and publicity, cost of maintenance of Depot including the salary of employees at the Depot are not eligible for exclusion from assessable value.

4. The learned Counsel representing the appellants have submitted that the demand raised in the show cause notice was not legally justifiable at all, since that related to costs towards transport and distribution activities and not manufacturing activity. The learned Counsel also submitted that the findings in the order are contrary to facts of the case. He submitted that the order has held that addition is required to be made towards rent of the Godown, despite the appellants’ submission in the adjudication proceeding that no separate rent was being paid for the Godown and the rent for the Godown is included in the rent for the factory premises. The learned Counsel also submitted that in any case, inclusion of about Rs. 31 lakhs was illegal as that amount related to depreciation for bottles. The learned Counsel submitted that the bottles being durable containers, their cost is not includible in the assessment value of the aerated water in view of the provisions contained in the Section 4(d)(i) of Central Excise Act, 1944. He also submitted that the order is not right in holding that the cost of the employees at Godown should be included in the assessable value of the goods. He stated that the employees are engaged in loading and unloading and handling of goods in the Godown. The cost of such operations are not liable to be included in the assessable value as those costs related to post manufacture, distribution activities. The learned Counsel also submitted that the issue of demand for the extended period by taking resort to proviso to Section 11A(1) was also not justifiable in the present case as the assessment had taken place in terms of an approved price-list and the appellants had not suppressed any facts with intent to evade payment of duty from the Central Excise Authorities. He also submitted that all the relevant facts were in the knowledge of jurisdictional Central Excise Authorities.

5. The learned DR contested the submissions made by the learned Counsel for the appellants and stated that the impugned order was legally and factually correct. He submitted that there was no sale of the goods at the factory gate. The goods were being sold from the appellants’ Depot. He submitted that it is settled law (Bombay Tyre International case) that maintenance of Depot by a manufacturer is part of the manufacturing activity and its costs are liable to be included in the assessable value of the goods. In the instant case, goods were distributed from the Depot and all the costs incurred by the appellant at the Depot for such distribution including rent cost, electricity, water etc., and cost of employees were rightly includible in the assessable value. He also submitted that the appellants submission regarding time bar is also not supported by facts. Even though the appellant had filed a price-list and had indicated the deductions, the price-list never indicated that the goods were not being sold ex-factory. The appellants also suppressed the fact that costs of maintaining the Godown such as employee cost, cost of electricity and water etc., at the Godown were being claimed as permissible deduction.

6. It is settled law in view of the judgments of the Supreme Court in the cases of Bombay Tyre International and MRF that all costs incurred by the manufacturer including the cost of maintenance of depots form part of manufacturing cost and no deduction from the sale price is required to be made on account of such costs for reaching the assessable value of excisable goods. Therefore, no objection could validly be taken to the inclusion of such costs in the assessable value. However, with regard to depreciation towards bottles (about Rs. 31 lakhs) the appellants are right in their contention that this cost being part of the cost of packing in durable containers, is not to be included in the assessable value. The impugned order has rejected the appellants’ contention by holding that the appellant had in their books of account not claimed depreciation against this amount. Such an approach cannot be upheld. If the appellants’ claim is borne out by facts, it is not to be rejected merely on account of the fact that the appellant had not claimed depreciation for this item. Claim of depreciation and claim for exclusion from assessable value are entirely different subjects and one is not dependent on the other. Therefore, this issue is required to be reconsidered by the adjudicating authority after verifying factual position from the relevant account books. Similarly, the appellants had been maintaining that they were not paying any separate rent for the godown and that the rent for the godown forms part of the rent of the factory building. However, this objection of the appellants has been rejected without verifying the factual position. This matter also is required to be reconsidered.

7. The appellants’ submission regarding time bar cannot find acceptance, inasmuch as, while claiming the deductions, the appellants never informed the Central Excise authorities that the deductions included cost of maintenance of depot, the cost of the staff at the depot etc. Nor did they intimate the Central Excise authorities that there was no ex-factory sale of the goods. There is also no substance in the appellants’ claim that full facts about the appellants’ manufacturing and markets costs were known to the Central Excise authorities through previous proceedings. Aerated water became liable to ad valorem duty only w.e.f. 1st March, 1994. During the previous period goods were subject to duty at specific rate. The question of valuation under Section 4 of the Central Excise Act did not arise, prior to 1-3-1994 and the price list filed by the appellant did not mention that cost of godown was being excluded. Therefore, we hold that proviso to Section 11A is attracted in the present case.

8. In view of what has been stated above the appeal is partially allowed and is ordered by way of remand. The Commissioner shall reconsider the issue relating to includability of depreciation for bottles and rent. The rest of the demand is confirmed. The case is remitted back to the Commissioner for re-consideration of the above mentioned two items and recomputation of the demand. The quantum of penalty shall also be re-considered in the remand proceedings.