Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Vam Organic Chemicals Ltd. v. Collector Of Customs, Meerut

CESTAT
Mar 4, 1997
Smart Summary (Beta)

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from an Order dated 12-9-1988 of the Collector (Appeals) confirming a departmental demand of Rs. 62,920.18 raised by a show cause notice dated 10-11-1983. The show cause notice required M/s. Vam Organic Chemicals Ltd. to explain why auxiliary duty of Rs. 62,920.18 should not be demanded under Section 28 of the Customs Act in respect of stainless steel plates imported and warehoused under Bond Nos. 1853/1980 and 2001/1980. The goods had been rewarehoused, cleared from the bonded warehouse and duties were deposited and later (according to the importer) finally assessed on 24-25 February 1982.

The Assistant Collector issued an Order-in-Original rejecting the importer’s plea of limitation because he treated the assessment as provisional under Notification No. 150/81-Cus. (22-5-1981) and held that final assessment was to be made only after production and acceptance of an end-use certificate. The Assistant Collector also relied on the date of release/discharge of the bond and bank guarantee (letter dated 11-8-1983) as the relevant date for computing the six-month period; the show cause notice was served in November 1983. The importer appealed, contending primarily that the assessment was not provisional under Section 18 of the Customs Act and that the demand was time-barred.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the assessment of the imported goods was a provisional assessment under Section 18 of the Customs Act such that the "relevant date" for computing limitation under Section 28(3)(b) is the date of adjustment of duty after final assessment (or discharge of the bond), thereby rendering the show cause notice dated 10-11-1983 within time.
  2. Whether the proviso to Section 28 (extension of limitation where there is wilful mis-statement or suppression) could be invoked, given the Assistant Collector’s reference to mis-declaration or suppression by the importer.
  3. Whether the bond executed under Notification No. 150/81-Cus. operated as a bond for provisional assessment (under Section 18) or merely as a warehousing bond (Section 59), with consequences for the computation of limitation under Section 28.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (M/s. Vam Organic Chemicals Ltd.)

  • The importer did not dispute the department's substantive claim that auxiliary duty was payable; the challenge was confined to limitation and characterization of the assessment.
  • The assessment was not a provisional assessment under Section 18 of the Customs Act; rather the bills were ex-bond for warehousing under Section 59, and therefore Section 28 could not be invoked as the department asserted.
  • The Assistant Collector’s finding that there was mis-declaration, mis-statement or suppression (to attract the larger extended period under Section 28) was not pleaded in the show cause notice; hence the extended period cannot be invoked.
  • Because the bond had been discharged and bank guarantees cancelled, the rate/date of payment of duty should be the basis for computing limitation (i.e., the show cause was time-barred if measured from the date duty was finally assessed/paid in February 1982).
  • Relied on precedents: Vikas Watch Manufacturing Industries v. Collector of Central Excise and International Computers Indian Manufacturers Ltd. v. Union of India.

Respondent's Arguments (Revenue / Learned DR)

  • The bond was executed under Notification No. 150/81-Cus. and non-compliance with the notification's end-use requirements disentitles the importer from the benefit of the notification.
  • The "relevant date" for computing the six-month limitation runs from the date of discharge of the bond or from the date of adjustment of duty after final assessment, in terms of sub-section (3)(b) of Section 28 of the Customs Act.
  • The bond executed under the Notification should be treated as constituting provisional assessment under Section 18 (proviso to Section 18), not merely a warehousing bond under Section 59; therefore the extended timeline under Section 28 operates from the date of final adjustment/discharge of the bond.
  • Relied on precedent including Castrol Ltd. v. Collector of Central Excise and Collector of Customs v. Indian Potash Ltd. (Tribunal) = 1987 (13) ECR 1114.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Collector of Customs v. Indian Potash Ltd. (Tribunal) = 1987 (13) ECR 1114 Holds that the terms of a notification and the terms of the bond may amount to a provisional assessment under Section 18; clause (b) of sub-section (3) of Section 28 makes the relevant date the date of adjustment of duty after final assessment. The court found the ratio identical to the facts before it and relied on Indian Potash Ltd. to conclude that the bond under Notification No. 150/81 created a provisional assessment and that the relevant date was the bond discharge (11-8-1983), making the show cause notice timely.
International Computers Indian Manufacturers Ltd. v. Union of India States that provisional assessment of duty is possible only when the provisions of Section 18 of the Customs Act are satisfied. The court distinguished this Delhi High Court authority: it accepted the principle but held that, on the present facts, a provisional assessment under Section 18 had indeed occurred, so the International Computers ratio was distinguishable.
Vikas Watch Manufacturing Industries v. Collector of Central Excise Observes that concessional rates are conditional and that authorities could have made provisional assessment under Section 18; also indicates Section 28(1)(b) may be applicable when demands are within six months from the relevant date. The court treated this precedent as supportive of the Revenue’s position and observed that it did not undermine the conclusion that a provisional assessment could be made and that demands raised within the relevant six-month period are valid.
Castrol Ltd. v. Collector of Central Excise The Learned DR relied on the ratio (as applied in submissions) relating to the computation of limitation and provisional assessment principles. The opinion records that the DR relied on Castrol Ltd. However, the court’s analysis focuses principally on Indian Potash Ltd. and other reasoning; no extended independent application of Castrol is set out in the text provided.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in two discrete analytical steps addressing (A) the Assistant Collector’s invocation of the proviso to Section 28 (extension for wilful mis-statement or suppression) and (B) whether the assessment was provisional such that the relevant date for limitation is the date of discharge/adjustment under Section 28(3)(b).

(A) On invocation of the extended period under Section 28 (mis-statement/suppression)

  • The Assistant Collector had relied in part on the proviso to Section 28 to extend the limitation period on the ground of wilful mis-statement or suppression by the importer.
  • The court examined the show cause notice and the pleadings and noted that the show cause notice did not allege mis-statement or suppression with the necessary particularity to invoke the extended period under the proviso to Section 28.
  • Conclusion: The court was not satisfied with the Assistant Collector’s finding on this ground and held that there was no justification in this case to invoke the larger extended period under the proviso to Section 28.

(B) On whether the assessment was provisional and computation of the "relevant date"

  • The Assistant Collector had held that the assessment was provisional because the importer had executed a bond under Notification No. 150/81-Cus., and final assessment would follow production and acceptance of an end-use certificate; consequently, the six-month period under Section 28(3)(b) should be computed from the date of discharge of the bond (11-8-1983).
  • The appellants contended the bond related to warehousing (Section 59) and not to provisional assessment under Section 18; therefore the date for limitation should be earlier (when duties were deposited/assessed in February 1982).
  • The court carefully examined the bond and the notification and relied on the Tribunal’s decision in Collector of Customs v. Indian Potash Ltd., where similar notification provisions and bond terms were held to constitute provisional assessment under Section 18 and to make the "relevant date" the date of adjustment after final assessment.
  • The court found the language of proviso (e) to Notification No. 150/81 (reproduced in the opinion) created an obligation on the importer to pay on demand the difference between duty leviable but for the exemption and that already paid, for quantities not proved to the satisfaction of the Assistant Collector to have been used as required under the notification.
  • On this basis, and noting the bond’s preamble and undertakings, the court concluded that the bond did operate in the manner contemplated by Section 18 provisional assessments and that the relevant date for computing limitation was therefore the date of discharge/adjustment of the bond (as held by the Assistant Collector), making the show cause notice within six months.
  • The court distinguished International Computers on the basis that, while it establishes that provisional assessment requires satisfaction of Section 18’s conditions, the present facts satisfied those conditions and therefore the International Computers ratio did not aid the appellants.
  • Vikas Watch was regarded as supportive to the Revenue because it acknowledged that provisional assessment was open to authorities in analogous situations.

In sum, the court rejected the Assistant Collector’s invocation of the extended period under the proviso (for wilful suppression) because no such allegation appeared in the show cause notice, but accepted the second and dispositive ground that the assessment was provisional under the notification and bond terms and that the six-month limitation period computed from the date of bond discharge made the departmental demand timely.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is REJECTED. The Collector (Appeals) order confirming the demand of Rs. 62,920.18 (raised by the department by show cause notice dated 10-11-1983) was upheld.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The departmental demand for Rs. 62,920.18 was confirmed and the appeal by the importer was dismissed. The court accepted that the bond executed under Notification No. 150/81 operated in the manner of a provisional assessment obligation, and the relevant date for limitation was the date of discharge/adjustment of the bond (11-8-1983), rendering the show cause notice of 10-11-1983 within the six-month limitation period.
  • The court did not set out a novel legal principle; instead it followed and applied existing precedents (notably Collector of Customs v. Indian Potash Ltd.) to the facts. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond applying established authorities to the present facts.

Note: This summary is strictly limited to the factual statements, arguments, reasoning and citations contained in the provided opinion. No additional facts or inferences beyond those expressed in the opinion have been added.

Show all summary ...

[Order per : S.L. Peeran, Member (J)]. - This appeal arises from the Order dated 12-9-1988, passed by the Collector (Appeals), confirming the demand of Rs. 62,920.18 raised by the department by issue of show cause notice dated 10-11-1983 under Section 18 of the Customs Act. Before the Collector, the importer had raised the plea that there was no provisional assessment under Section 18 of the Customs Act and that the ex bond Bills of Entry executed under Notification No. 150/81-Cus., dated 22-5-1981 would not make the assessment provisional was rejected by the Learned Collector. The Learned Collector has held that final assessment was to be made only after the production of end-use certificate and its acceptance by the competent authority.

2. The details of the show cause notice issued to the importer are reproduced herein below :

NOTICE TO SHOW CAUSE

``To
M/s. Vam Organic Chemicals Ltd.

Gajraula District Moradabad

M/s. Vam Organic Chemicals Ltd., Gajraula have imported the Stainless Steel Plates from Japan of the description as mentioned below : -
1. Vessel Name -RAMO NEVERETT - Invoice No. NMM033/3 dated 2-5-1980-Bill of Lading No. Y2/C dated 28-4-1980 Bill of Entry No. 388/80 dated 11-6-1980-Bond No. 1853 of 1980.
I. Stainless Steel Plates, Hot Rolled - Annealed and Prickled No. 1 Finish (Alloy Steel containing more than 0.5% Chrom.)
(i) Grade AISI-304

8.0X1500X3500 mm = 30 Pcs. weighing 10.303 M.T.

(ii) Grade AISI-316

6.0X1500X3500 mm = 32 Pcs. weighing 8.265 M.T.

Value Rs. 4,20,272.97
2. Stainless Steel Plates, Hot Rolled, Annealed and Prickled No. 1 Finish (Cold rolled)
Grade AISI-316

5.0X1500X3500 mm = 70 Pcs. weighing 15.266 M.T.

Value Rs. 4,52,212.56
II. [Vessel] Name-RAMOVERERETT - Invoice No. NMMO33(8) dated 19-5-1980Bill of Lading No. Y-8-C dated 17-5-1980-Bill of Entry No. 423/80 dated 23-6-1980-Bond No. 2001 of 1980.
Stainless Steel Plates Hot Rolled, annealed and pickled No. 1 Finish, AISI-316.
5.0Xl500X3500 mm-60 Pcs. weighing 13.028 M.T.
Rs. 3,85,918.07.
Total value of both Bond Rs. 12,58,403.70
Duty Auxiliary @ 5% Rs. 62,920.18.
The aforementioned imported goods were rewarehoused at Customs Public Bonded Warehouse, Mohan Nagar, Ghaziabad vide Receipt Nos. 9/81 and 10/81 respectively.
And whereas M/s. Vam Organic Chemicals Ltd., Gajraula appears to have cleared the quantities of imported goods as aforementioned without payment of Auxiliary duty of Customs as provided under Notification No. 161-Cus., dated 20-6-1981. The Auxiliary duty @ 5% on assessable value of Rs. 12,58,403.70 comes to Rs. 62,920.18.
The said M/s. Vam Organic Chemicals Ltd., Gajraula are hereby required to show cause to the Assistant Collector of Customs & Central Excise, Division II Ghaziabad as to why Auxiliary duty of Customs amounting to Rs. 62,920.18 should not be demanded from them under Section 28 of the Customs Act, 1962.
The said M/s. Vam Organic Chemicals Ltd. are further directed to produce at the time of showing cause, all the evidence upon which they intend to rely in support of their defence.
The said M/s. Vam Organic Chemicals Ltd. should also indicate in their written explanation, whether they wish to be heard in person before the demand is confirmed.
If no cause is shown against the action proposed to be taken within ONE MONTH OF THE RECEIPT OF THIS NOTICE or they do not appear before the adjudicating officer when the case is posted for hearing, the case will be decided ex parte.“

3. The importer replied vide his letter dated 11-12-1983 to the said show cause notice. In the said reply they have admitted that the stainless steel plates imported by them were warehoused in the Customs bounded warehouse at Mohan Nagar, Ghaziabad under Bond No. 1853 of 1980 and No. 2001 of 1980. The goods were cleared on payment of customs duty from the bonded warehouse at Mohan Nagar, Ghaziabad under 2 bills of entry on 26-2-1982. The duty payable on the said 2 bills of entry were finally assessed on 25-2-1982 by the Superintendent of Customs Incharge of the Customs Public Bonded Warehouse Mohan Nagar, Ghaziabad-II. Duty in respect of Bond No. 1853 of 1980 and bond 2001 of 1980 had been deposited by them on 24-2-1982. They stated that the duty payable in respect of the aforesaid 2 Bonds had been finally assessed by the customs authorities on 25-2-1982. Therefore, the show cause notice had been issued under Section 28 of the Customs Act, 1962. Section 28 provides that a show cause notice should be issued within 6 months from the date on which the duty had been paid or short levied. It is stated by them that as the duty had been finally determined by the Superintendent of Customs on 24-2-1982, therefore, the demands are barred by time. The Assistant Collector in the Order-in-Original had rejected the plea of time bar on the ground that the goods had been cleared on Ex-bond bills of entry as per the provisions of Notification No. 150/81-Cus., dated 22-5-1981 on execution of Bond and furnishing Bank Guarantee for the differential amount of duty, if any. He has held that in the instant case the assessment cannot be regarded as final assessment. The assessment could have been finally made only after the end use certificate is furnished by the importer and is accepted by the Assistant Collector and the Bond and Bank Guarantee released to the party. He has noted that the bank Guarantee were released by the Assistant Collector of Central Excise, Division II Ghaziabad vide his letter C. No. V(30) 52-Bond/82/8373 dated 11-8-1983 while the show cause notice was issued and was served on the party on 15-11-1983 by the Superintendent, Central Excise, Gajraula, hence the show cause notice had been served on the party within six months from the date of released of security and the same cannot be termed as time barred. He has also held that it was duty of the importer to submit correct Bills of Entry and that the party had failed to submit the correct Bills of Entry and they did not incorporate the Auxiliary duty chargeable therein in the light of Notification as mentioned earlier and thus wilfully made mis-statement, suppression of facts with an intention to evade payment of duty and hence the demands raised under Section 28 of the Act were within time.

4. Arguing for the appellants, the Learned Advocate Shri T. Vishwanathan did not dispute the merit of the claim made by the department inasmuch as that the duty is liable to be paid for the reasons stated in the show cause notice. He has only confined to the ground that there was no provisional assessment under Section 18 of the Customs Act and that Section 28 of the Act does not get attracted. He has also pointed out to the Assistant Collector’s finding that there has been mis-declaration, mis-statement and suppression, so as to attract larger period was never alleged in the show cause notice and therefore, extended period of limitation can be invoked in the present case, and argued that there is no such allegation in the show cause notice. He submitted that admittedly Bond had been discharged and Bank Guarantee cancelled, therefore, the rate of payment of duty is required to be taken into consideration for the purpose of computing the limitation in the present case. The Learned Advocate relied on the ratio of the following judgments : -

i. Vikas Watch Manufacturing Industries v. Collector of Central Excise, []
ii International Computers Indian Manufacturers Ltd. v. Union of India []

5. On the other hand, the Learned DR forcibly submitted that the bond had been executed under the Notification and the non-compliance of the end use requirement of the Notification would disentitle them from the benefit of the said Notification. It is his contention that the time limit would, in any case, begin from the date on which the Bond had been discharged in terms of the definition `relevant date’ as per sub-section 3(b) of Section 28 of the Customs Act. It is his contention that the Bond executed under the Notification is not the same as the one executed under Section 51 for the warehouse purpose, which have been entered for warehousing and assessed to duty under Section 17 or Section 18 of the Act. The Learned DR submitted that this assessment was in terms of the Section 18 of the Act and the Bond was in terms of proviso of the Section 18, by which the importer had undertaken to produce the end use certificate in terms of Notification and therefore, failure to produce the said certificate in terms of the Bond, disentitles the importer from the benefit of the Notification. He contends that the `relevant date’ should be reckoned from the date of discharge of the Bond or from the date of adjustment of the duty after final assessment in terms of sub-section 3(b) of the Section 28 of the Act. The Learned DR relied on the ratio of the judgment rendered in the case of Castrol Ltd. v. Collector of Central Excise, as reported in .

6. We have carefully considered the submissions made by both the sides and have perused the orders. The original authorities have held that the proviso to Section 28 is attracted to extend larger period in view of the assessee’s wilfully making mis-statement or suppression of facts with an intent to evade payment of duty. On this ground, we are not satisfied with the finding of the Assistant Collector inasmuch as the show cause notice does not allege the grounds of mis-statement or suppression to invoke larger period under Section 28 of the Act and therefore, we have to hold that there was no justification to invoke larger period in the present case.

7. The second ground on which the demands have been confirmed are that the assessments were provisional inasmuch as that the importer had executed a Bond and that the date for reckoning the 6 months period under Section 28 of the Act is in terms of sub-section 3(b) of Section 28 which defines the `relevant date’. The Assistant Collector has therefore, computed 6 months from the date of discharge of Bond dated 11-8-1983 and the notice had been issued on 10-11-1983 and therefore, the demands are held to be within a period of 6 months. The Counsel has contested this plea on the ground that the demands were not provisional in terms of Section 28 of the Act and the Bond executed was in terms of Section 59 of the Act for warehousing purpose only and not for provisional assessments under Section 18 of the Act. We have considered this plea. We are not impressed with this arguments, in view of the ratio laid down in a similar case arising in the case of Collector of Customs v. Indian Potash Ltd. as reported in (Tribunal) = 1987 (13) ECR 1114. In this case also the department had raised demands under Section 28 of the Customs Act. The importer had imported two consignments of Di-Ammonium Phosphate and cleared from customs without payment of duty on the strength of Notification No. 144/80 dated 19-7-1980. Out of this quantity a shortage of 728.900 MT approximately of Di-Ammonium Phosphate was detected and report of the same lodged with Malia-Miyana Police. The Customs then issued show cause notice dated 22-3-1983 calling upon the respondents to show cause why duty amounting to Rs. 17,83,287.38 on the quantity of 728.900 MT of Di-Ammonium Phosphate be not realised from the importer. Among other pleas the importer had raised the ground of time bar. This was considered by the Tribunal and noted the conditions of Notification 144/80 dated 19-7-1980 which had a proviso that the importer shall by the execution of a bond in such form and for such sum as may be specified by the Assistant Collector of Customs, bind himself to pay, on demand, in respect of such quantity of Di-Ammonium Phosphate or Ammonium Nitro Phosphate in question as is not proved to the satisfaction of the Assistant Collector of Customs to have been used for the aforesaid purpose, an amount equal to the duty of customs leviable thereon under the said First Schedule on such quantity, but for this exemption. The Tribunal also noted the terms of the Bond executed by the importers which had stated : -

“We agree to pay on demand in respect of such quantity of Di Ammonium Phosphate as is not proved to be satisfaction of the Asst. Collector of Customs, to have since been used for the said purpose an amount equal to the duty of customs leviable thereon under the first Schedule of Customs Tariff Act, 1975 on such quantity.”

8. After noting this provisions the Tribunal held that the above portion of the terms of the bond and the Notification reproduced in the order, left no manner of doubt that the assessment in the respondents’ case was provisional assessment of duty under Section 18 of the Customs Act, 1962 and as per clause (b) of Sub-section (3) of Section 28 it is clear that relevant date for computing limitation is the date of adjustment of duty after the final assessment thereof. The said finding is reproduced herein below : -

“The portion of the bond and the notification reproduced above leave no manner of doubt that the assessment in the respondent’s case was provisional assessment of duty under Section 18 of the Customs Act, 1962 and clause (b) of Sub-section (3) of Section 28 is clear that relevant date for computing limitation is the date of adjustment of duty after the final assessment thereof. It is nobody’s case that final assessment in the present case had been made. Therefore, the plea that the demands was barred by limitation cannot be accepted. The Assistant Collector of Customs in terms of the bond executed by the importer-respondent was justified in enquiring of the respondent-importer as to use of the material and the respondent-importer in terms of the notification was to prove to the satisfaction of the Assistant Collector of Customs that the imported goods had been used for the purpose set out in the notification (use as manure or in the production of complex fertilizer). That the respondent-importer failed to do. The argument that whoever may have stolen or pilferred the material would have used the same as manure because the goods have no other use is too remote and fanciful an argument to be acceptable. In any case, it does not fulfil the requirement as proof to the satisfaction of the Assistant Collector of Customs stipulated in the notification. This argument cannot be accepted.”

9. After dealing with other aspects of the matter raised before the Tribunal, the Tribunal rejected the pleas of the importer and allowed the Revenue appeal.

10. In the present case also we notice that the appellants had executed a bond under the Notification No. 150/81-Cus., dated 22-5-1981. The Notification also had a similar proviso (e) which is reproduced herein below : -

“(e) bind himself by execution of a bond in such form and for such sum as may be specified by the Assistant Collector of Customs, undertaking to pay, on demand, in respect of such quantity of imported goods as is not proved to the satisfaction of the Assistant Collector of Customs to have been used for such manufacture without fulfilling the provisions in clauses (a) to (d), an amount equal to the difference between the duty leviable on such quantity but for the exemption contained herein and that already paid at the time of importation. ”

11. In terms of the said proviso (e) of the Notification, the importer executed the bond and in the bond they have undertaken to pay the amount on becoming due on them under the bond. It was contended before us that this bond had not been executed in terms of the Notification and proviso (3)(b) of Section 28 of the Act. We are not impressed with this submissions because we notice from the bond that importer had bound themselves and the Preamble stated that they had applied to Assistant Collector of Customs & Central Excise, Division II, Ghaziabad for obtaining permission for manufacture under bond at Gajraula for the goods, which details are stated in detail at page 2 of the bond, which has been extracted in the show cause notice and already reproduced in the order. In sum the ratio of the citation in the case of Indian Potash Ltd. is identical and we do not find any reason to differ with the same. We have to hold that the demands have been raised within 6 months from the relevant date for computing limitation and it is the date of adjustment of duty after the final assessment thereof, which is the date of discharge of the Bond dated 11-8-1983 as stated in the show cause notice dated 10-11-1983 and held by the Assistant Collector in the order-in-original and hence the demands are within time.

12. The Learned Advocate relied on the ratio of the Delhi High Court’s judgment rendered in the case of International Computers Indian Manufacturers Ltd. (supra). This judgment also clearly laid down that the provisional assessment of duty is possible only when the provision of Section 18 of the Customs Act, 1962 are satisfied. We are satisfied that there has been a provisional assessment and Section 28 has been invoked for the purpose of computing the relevant date in terms of sub-section (3)(b) of the Section 28 and therefore, the said ratio of the Delhi High Courts’ judgment is clearly distinguishable.

13. The judgment cited by the Learned Advocate in the case of Vikas Watch Manufacturing Industries (supra) is, in fact, supportive to the Revenue because it has been held in para 10 of the citation that concessional rate of duty is available only on fulfilment of certain conditions. It has been held that it was open to the authorities to have made provisional assessment of duty under Section 28 of the Customs Act. It has been further held that although it was not done. However, the show cause notice served on the appellants inter alia relied on Section 28 of the Customs Act, 1962. Section 28(1)(b) would be applicable to the facts of the case inasmuch as the demands had been raised within 6 months from the relevant date, therefore, the demands were confirmed for 6 months.

14. For the reasons stated above, we do not find any merit in this case and hence the appeal is rejected.