- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Honeyrex Products (P) Ltd. v. Commissioner Of C. Ex., Bangalore
[Order per : T.P. Nambiar, Member (J)]. - This appeal is filed by the appellants against the order passed by the C.C.E., Bangalore in Order No. 57/91, dated 20-10-1991. The facts of the case are that the Preventive Officers of the Central Excise, Bangalore got information that the appellants were manufacturing branded goods i.e. Honeyrex and cleared the same without following the Central Excise procedure, without payment of duty. The officers visited the factory and took statement from Ajaypal Singh, Manager who stated that their product Honeyrex is not an excisable commodity. Show cause notice was issued to the appellants requiring them to show cause as to why Central Excise Duty of Rs. 6,68,003/- should not be demanded from them for the clearances of the goods during the period 1986-87 to 1990-91. The appellants in their reply stated that Honeyrex is nothing but honey added with sucrose and glucose and then additives are added for preserving the honey. Therefore, no new product emerged and the characteristics of the product manufactured by them is also that of honey and longer period of limitation cannot be invoked in their case and that the demand is barred by limitation. The learned adjudicating authority held that a new product has emerged and therefore the department classified the Honeyrex manufactured by the appellants under sub-heading 1702.30 but the appellants sought classification of the product under Heading 2107.91. Since the demand was confirmed, this appeal has been filed.
2. Shri Srinivasa Raghavan, learned Counsel appearing for the appellants contended before us that there is no manufacturing involved in this case. It is stated that there is only mixing of natural honey with sucrose and glucose. It was therefore, contended that mixing of honey with sugar and glucose does not result in a new product and it is only honey before and after the mixing and it has the same characteristics and end-use. It was therefore, stated that addition of sucrose and glucose are only for stabilising and preserving the form of honey. It was further pointed out that if any one were to ask for honey in the retail shop what is made available is Honeyrex and chemical report will also show the same as honey. It was further stated that there is no suppression of material fact. He further pointed out that even if the appellant’s case is not accepted, it will not be possible for them to recover the duty demanded in the order and the same should be treated as cum duty price and as per Section 4 of Central Excise Act, 1944, the value has to be re-determined based on the normal cum duty price as under :
He has pleaded that the Collector merely brushed aside this contention holding that CEGAT decision in this regard is not produced. He pointed out that even if CEGAT decision is not produced, the Collector should have given a reasoned finding in this regard.
3. Shri S. Murugandi, the learned DR on the other hand contended before us that mixing of honey with sucrose and glucose resulted in a new product and the new product cannot be said to be natural honey. He, therefore, pointed out that honey is specified under Heading 1702.30. He pointed that as per Rule 3A for the interpretation of Schedule of heading which provides that the next specified description shall be preferred. So far as the suppression aspect is concerned, no classification list was filed by the appellant. So also no declaration has been filed and no Excise officials visited their factory during the relevant time. The appellants without intimating the department has cleared the goods with an intent to evade payment of duty and the extended period of limitation is invokable in this case. He also contended that re-working of the value is not permissible in the facts and circumstances of this case.
4. We have considered the submissions made by both the sides. The first point to be determined in this case is whether any new product has emerged and whether the process undertaken by the appellants amounted to manufacture. It is now seen that the preparations made by the appellants are by adding various ingredients with natural honey. The same is marketed as Honeyrex. The appellants are getting natural honey for manufacture of the product in question. Sugar is converted by heating process and the same is added to natural honey. Thereafter they are packed in unit containers, sealed and labelled and sold as Honeyrex. The product is not sold as natural honey and it is sold as Honeyrex. Therefore, the process of conversion of natural honey with addition of glucose and sucrose is involved. Preservatives are also added. As a result of these additions to the natural honey a new product is emerged and the same cannot be called as natural honey. Further, the appellants are not marketing the same as natural honey. It is marketed by the name of Honeyrex. Their contention is that by addition of these ingredients the product does not lose its characteristics of natural honey. We are not impressed by this argument. It is seen that because of addition of ingredients like sucrose, glucose and preservatives a new product emerged and the new product is different from natural honey and it has to be classified as artificial honey under Tariff Heading 1702.30. Therefore, we are of the view that the lower authority has rightly come to the conclusion that the item is a preparation of natural honey, since it was manufactured by mixing glucose, and sucrose along preservatives. The HSN notes under Heading 1702.30 also defines what artificial honey is, at page 13 of the Explanatory Note. It applies to mixtures based on sucrose, glucose or invert sugar, generally flavoured or coloured and prepared with natural honey. Artificial honey is also included in this heading. In this view of the matter, we agree with the finding of the lower authority that there is emergence of a new product and the same is rightly classified under Heading 1702.30.
5. On the contrary the plea of the appellants is that Heading 2101.01 applies is not sound. This tariff heading applies only when an item is otherwise not specified or included. Besides, this heading applies to the various products described under sub-heading 21.07. Therefore, the lower authority has rightly rejected the classification under the above heading.
6. As regards their plea that longer period of limitation is not invokable in this case, we find that the appellants have not shown any facts leading to hold that they bona fide believed that the product is not excisable. In case of doubt they could have sought clarification from the department instead of seeking such clarification, the appellants proceeded to manufacture and clear the goods without payment of duty. The department was not aware of the manufacturing activities of the appellants. In the circumstances, it cannot be said that there was bona fide belief on their part in this behalf. We are therefore of the view that they have suppressed material fact with intent to evade payment of duty and therefore, longer period of limitation is invokable in this case.
7. As regards imposition of penalty is concerned, the appellants had made a plea before the adjudicating authority that the value should be re-worked, but the adjudicating authority has not given any finding in this regard. The appellants pleaded before the lower authority that there is a CEGAT decision in this case. But that decision of CEGAT was not placed before him. In para 16 of the impugned order, the lower authority has held as under :
“The next argument put forth is that the value needs to be redetermined by adopting the formula. According to the assessee, such a view is taken by CEGAT. In the absence of citing specific case law where the CEGAT has taken such a view, it is not possible to consider such a plea”.
Therefore, it is seen that no finding has been given by the lower authority in this regard. On the contrary we find that the decision of the Tribunal in the case of Pawan Tyres reported in is on the point. Therefore, since the adjudicating authority has not given any finding in this regard on this point of re-determination of the value, the matter is required to be remanded to the adjudicating authority for de novo decision in this regard in the light of the decision of the Tribunal in the case of Pawan Tyres, para of which is reproduced below :
2. Department has no case that besides price collected, any amount has been collected as excise duty. Therefore, whatever amount was collected must be treated as amount collected on the basis of cum-duty price. That being so, the amount of Rs. 30,389.25 which was the duty calculated on the wholesale price amount should be treated as part of the wholesale price and assessable value and duty calculated accordingly. This is supported by the observations of the Supreme Court in Assistant Collector of Central Excise v. Bata India Limited - = 1996 (14) RLT 613 (S.C.). It was observed therein that unless it is shown by the manufacturer that the price of the goods includes an amount of excise duty payable by him no question of exclusion of the duty element from the price for determination of value under Section 4(4)(d)(ii) will arise. In other words, if duty is payable by the manufacturer that will be eligible for deduction from the price. As has come out in the facts of this case, the price realised by the respondent was cum-duty price, and as duty was leviable on the goods and had, in fact, paid pursuant to the impugned order passed by the Additional Collector of Central Excise, the deduction of the duty element claimed for arriving at the assessable value was justified. It will make no difference whether the duty amount has been paid by the assessee at the time of clearance of the goods or it was paid subsequently. What is material is that the excise duty was payable on the goods. The impugned order in this behalf is, therefore, correct. We are told that there is an appeal against the imposition of penalty filed by the respondent which is pending in another Bench.
8. The appellants have also claimed benefit of Modvat credit. 17 para of the impugned order, the lower authority has held as under :
“Traversing to the next contention that they would be eligible for Modvat credit, if the duty demanded is confirmed, it would not be out of place to mention that the eligibility of Modvat credit or not would be determined by the competent authority and the issue of whether the Modvat credit is eligible or not is not for consideration in the present case”.
9. It is seen that the adjudicating authority in para 17 has not given any finding in this regard. Since duty is now demanded the appellants are entitled to the benefit of Modvat credit notwithstanding the fact that they have not filed declaration under Rule 57G provided that all other ingredients necessary for taking Modvat credit are satisfied in this regard. This plea of the appellants is therefore required to be looked into by the adjudicating authority. In this view of the matter we hold that the finding of the lower authority that the Honeyrex produced by the appellants fall under Heading 1702.30 is legal and we confirm the same. We also hold that the longer period of limitation is invokable in this case.
10. As far as the re-calculation of the value is concerned, the matter is remanded to the adjudicating authority for de novo decision in the matter in the light of the decision of the Tribunal in the case of Pawan Tyres cited supra. The appellants will be entitled to the benefit of Modvat credit despite non-filing of the declaration provided other conditions in this regard are satisfied.
11. As regards imposition of penalty is concerned, the same will depend on the outcome of the de novo adjudicating proceedings. The appeal is thus decided in the above terms.
Alert